Does the world of tennis have something against Asian players right now?
Or is it just a coincidence that this seems to keep happening?
Yeah, this went viral in the tennis world, Andrew.
And of course, Andrew, silly to serious.
It started out silly.
It even got a little geopolitical.
Make sure you like, subscribe, turn on your notifications, Andrew.
Let's run the viral clip circulating right now,
involving Zhuang Shuai and Amarisa Toth.
It was good.
Amarisa Toth isn't sure.
Normally, when you kind of linger...
Oh, no, it is wide.
Can you believe this?
She has retired from this match.
I mean, we saw the doctor there.
Clearly, nothing is wrong with her.
She was in floods of tears at the sit down there.
Long story short, Andrew, Zhuang Shuai hits it.
It's actually in, according to the video,
the umpire and the supervisor call it out.
You know, she wants to protest.
It turns into a whole thing.
Toth is taunting her.
The crowd starts taunting her.
And Zhuang Shuai is just like, you know what?
I give up.
I'm going to retire from this match.
Toth throws her hands up.
The tennis world went against Toth and supported Zhuang Shuai.
Right, and then Toth sends out an apology
that doesn't seem super genuine,
but probably just because she had to.
I guess right here, David,
and we're going to go into the comment section
because there's a lot of different comments
and perspective on it.
But I guess like, for me, not being a natural tennis player,
I was surprised to find out some things
about the game of tennis
and how much etiquette and sportsmanship is part of it.
Right, so you're saying this is why this is going viral.
Yeah, it's a little bit different,
but I don't think a lot of people understand this about tennis, right?
It's like the respect that the tennis players
are supposed to have for each other.
It's not a trash talking sport like basketball,
where you're saying mean things at each other
at the free throw line and stuff like that
to get into their head.
Like this is, it's not as much of the sport.
No, this is a country club sport.
This is a sport that has been typically played
by the upper middle class
and wealthy people of the world, right?
Yeah, and while I think that umpires of any sport
and any referee can make a missed call,
there's bad calls in basketball.
There's this, that.
We all, even with replay,
they can still make a bad call
because to overturn it,
you have to have like more than reasonable doubt
and all this stuff.
But I guess like, yeah,
I guess her stepping and erasing the mark
was really disrespectful.
I guess it wasn't illegal,
maybe not a violation quite,
but her stepping to show where the ball had landed,
that the ball had landed on the line,
to step on it.
I think it was extra disrespectful
because while she's doing it,
Zhang Shuai is asking her to not do it
because she still wants somebody to come examine it.
Yeah, so it kind of like,
don't do it, don't do it, don't do it.
And then she's like, I'm doing it.
Yeah, people are like, oh, wow.
And coupled with the recent disqualification of Kato
for accidentally hitting the ball towards the ball girl
and hitting the ball girl in France,
Andrew, everybody's looking at Hungarian Grand Prix
like, yo, what's going on?
Is there a conspiracy against Asian women in pro tennis?
All right, well, we're going to talk about it
because there is a theory,
but I don't know if it's true or not.
So, hey, guys, make sure you like, subscribe,
turn on your notifications.
Let's get into the comments section.
Somebody said literally every single one of their peers
agreed that Toth was disrespectful
and they supported Zhang Shuai.
So what does that show you?
I mean, does that show you, Andrew,
the fact that the tennis world went with Zhang
because she has a good reputation?
She's been a pro for a number of years.
This was Toth, I think Toth, by the way,
she's half Thai and half Hungarian, looks more Asian,
but people was more going with Zhang Shuai.
I think it was bad because Toth already got the point
and that she didn't have to step on it out of spite.
You know what I mean?
She did it to punk her.
She said, oh, you don't want me to erase it.
Bam, even though she could have just left it
because the call already happened.
Right.
Do you think she was also yelling at her?
You are creating problem.
Like, do you think she was doing that
because she was on her home turf in Hungary
and she's Hungarian?
Yeah, I mean, I also, you know,
maybe there is some anti-China thing.
I don't want to call Toth racist
because she is half Asian.
So maybe I will give her the benefit of the doubt for that.
But it could be anti-China.
What if she tried to justify and go?
No, no, no, no, no.
The fact I don't like Zhang Shuai is from my Thai side.
Yes, from the Thai side.
It's not my Hungarian side.
But Thai people, I don't think they hate Chinese people either.
That's not.
I think the older ones.
But anyway, yeah, the Hungarian GP entered
the Grand Prix official account,
came out and said,
China is releasing manipulative video
trying to manipulate the world.
And this is where it got geopolitical.
So long story short, Andrew,
they were saying that the clip got taken out of context
because it is missing the fact
that there was a point right after the bad read,
the bad call before she wiped it.
So does that show that the video we showed earlier
was manipulative?
It was edited.
It cut out some part in between.
But does that change that her behavior was unsportsmanlike?
Because you can clearly see she did everything,
even if there's like a point missed in between.
Right.
You're saying that there was a play in between.
It didn't happen right out.
Yeah.
I don't know if that changes anything.
But yes, yes.
Yeah, I could see from the video.
If you think that she's wiping it wild
before the umpires coming to look at it,
that would be really horrible.
Yeah.
But the umpire had actually made the call already.
Right.
And that's why a lot of people are accusing the umpire
of potentially being anti-Asian or anti-Chinese,
because you can see that it's in when she marks it out.
So people are saying potentially that the umpire,
aka the officials and the referee,
and the player were both being kind of like disrespectful.
Yeah, that's what everybody's saying, guys.
Listen, the tennis world is the tennis world, man.
I can only tell you what I see.
Somebody said, I noticed the institution of tennis
seems to be against any Asian female player.
Why does this pattern happen over and over again?
Amarisa Toth has the worst PR ever now.
This is white privilege.
And someone said, what do you mean white privilege?
They're both Asian.
Someone said, no, one of them's half white,
whether she looks at it or not.
Obviously, Amarisa Toth, more Asian passing.
Hungarian, I guess if Hungarian is white in this case.
Yeah, more white for sure.
Even though, yeah.
Yeah.
What do you think, man?
Do you think that there's any enough evidence to prove?
Or is this a result of there's just a lot more
pro Asian female tennis players nowadays?
Like there's a lot more pro Asian female golfers.
They make up a much larger proportion of that pie
and growing every year.
I think it's tough to tie the Kato situation
and the Shui situation together as far as a geopolitical thing.
Because what, people hate Japan too?
Because then you can't use the whole like,
oh, they're hating on Chinese players argument.
Right.
You're saying that.
But you could say that they don't like East Asian players.
Yeah.
I think the only theory that has any sort of validity,
and I'm not sure if it does, is the one where people feel like
since Asian female players are on the rise,
they want to hold them back or punish them
for possibly replacing a lot of European
or white female tennis players.
Right.
This is replacement theory.
You mean how, for example,
a lot of Asian female pro golfers have replaced
a lot of European women on the pro LGBT.
LPGA.
Yeah.
LPGA.
Yeah.
It's hard to say.
But yeah.
So I would say that I think that's the only theory that I can see.
You know what I mean?
And I'm not sure if that's true.
I don't want to necessarily throw the whole tennis federation under the bus,
but I can't say no.
Right.
It's an old world society, man.
They might not like people messing with the old world order.
Somebody said the sign of phobia was loud AF.
Wow.
And somebody said, yeah, it's well-deserved.
The sign of phobia is well-deserved.
Of course, Andrew, this is where the whole geopolitical thing comes into play.
Right.
Let me ask you this, David.
Do you think the sign of phobia might be worse
and harsher in the tennis world?
Because tennis is more of a richer sport.
As in, if you saw a bunch of Asian basketball players that were super good
and could play in the NBA, that they might just let them play.
I definitely know some Asians said that Jeremy Lin didn't get the calls at the rim,
though, with the contact.
So you did hear that theory, too.
That could have been because he's not a superstar either, though.
I don't know.
That's what we're saying, guys.
Hey, I'm not here to oversubscribe to anyone.
I'm just here to ask the questions.
I think we need to see a larger sample size.
But this pattern is in my tennis mind.
To a pattern.
I need to see if they do that to the guys.
I don't know if there's enough Asian men
that are competitive on that level in the tennis world yet.
But I think I'm Arisa Toth being half Asian.
It clearly goes to show you that Asian women are clearly making their way into tennis.
Yeah.
I forgot how to say her name.
And also Naomi Osaka, half Asian.
Right, right.
I guess maybe there's just enough Asian women that are playing tennis
that more of these bad calls are going to happen.
There's such a volume of interactions with Asian women now in the pro tennis world.
Somebody said her apology just felt so forced because of the backlash she received.
You can look at her eyes.
There's not a single ounce of regret.
Let's play Toth's apology.
Three, two, one.
Andrew, long story short, man.
What's going on in the tennis world?
Is it racist?
Is it not?
I mean, a lot of people are just saying that, you know.
Three, three, two, one.
Just end it off with your take away.
All right, three, two, one.
All right, long story short.
Three, two, one.
All right, just getting into our takeaways.
I do think that racism looks different in tennis
than it does in a very more violent sport like football or basketball.
I do think, like you said, there's so much stuff that is subjective
about, like, line in, line out.
They don't necessarily, especially on clay, they're not using the robot sensors.
You know, like you said, there's a lot more about decorum.
Yeah, in tennis.
Yeah, so I think, like, there's such a focus on sportsmanship.
Like, if this was any other sport, almost, I feel like it's not that big of a deal.
And also, I do think, let's be honest,
that there might be a different expectation for women to be, like, more nicer to each other.
Right, because they don't have the John McEnroes and things like that.
Right, like, yeah, John McEnroe is known to be an a-hole, right?
But I'm saying, like, you don't really want to see an a-hole
women-female tennis player, because female tennis players are supposed to be, like,
more, you know, like, womenly, like women, like, is what they would want.
No, it's true.
The ones that are really popular, they generally look really good in a dress.
Yeah, and they're more sweet.
And Shwy has a very good, long reputation of being sweet.
She's also been playing tennis for many years.
And then everybody's, like, so weird.
It's almost like people don't like Toph bringing the nastiness to tennis, right?
Yeah, it just got a little dirty and catty.
And I think that's when people are, like, oh, we might be losing the tennis world.
And the tennis decorum is falling apart.
Because, listen, we have women, women's tennis players fighting each other.
Listen, I don't want to lend anything to this replacement theory of, like,
European players in tennis, Andrew.
But if we look at the hierarchy of how big the balls get in sports, it goes squash,
badminton, golf, tennis, cricket, baseball, volleyball, soccer ball, basketballs.
That's, like, and football is somewhere that they didn't rank it,
because it's not spherical, right?
But, like, I'm saying this is, like, it seems like Asians are getting better and better
each level, you know what I mean?
They started at the small sports, squash, golf, and they're just moving up the list.
You mean they're being really good at the sports with small balls?
Yeah, because those are probably, what, less power, less power sports, less height-related.
More technical, yeah, maybe, you know, smaller movements.
I do think that, like I said, I don't know how much Europeans are scared or trying to
be racist about, like, getting replaced in the median.
But I do think that when you see a dominant player in a sport, Andrew,
that's from a different place, like Shohei Otani or Ichiro when they were dominating the MLB,
it's different than when you feel like all the players in the middle,
the median average player, is becoming a foreign face.
I think more people are okay with, like, even, let's just say basketball,
Jokic and Luka are starting to dominate the NBA, and Giannis, he's from Greece,
even though he's Nigerian.
Like, it's, like, that's, it's okay, because the median player is still American.
Right, right, right.
Interesting.
Yeah, I don't know, guys.
You let me know in the comments down below.
Personally, I'm not, I don't want to say I'm convinced
that there is a conspiracy against Asian players yet,
but definitely this raises some questions.
And I do think that, yeah, people in the tennis world, I don't know,
maybe they're feeling the heat of all these Asian tennis players coming up.
Anytime there's a 50-50, go against the Asian player.
No, I'm just kidding, guys.
I don't know, guys.
I don't think it would happen in America, to be honest, all these things.
I think these are old-world countries with old-world rules that, that,
that's my honest opinion.
I think they do things different in Europe than in America,
because it's, that's the old world.
Yeah, possibly.
All right, guys, let me know in the comments down below.
Hit that like button.
Check out other episodes of the Hot Pop Boys.
And until next time, we out.
Peace.