The Rice Wars of Southeast Asia.
How did a Singaporean comedian making a joke
at New York City's Comedy Cellar
become an international outrage?
David, let's talk about it.
Yeah, I mean, people are internationally
protesting this clip right now.
I'll let you guys decide for yourselves.
Run the clip.
Country Singapore, after we gained independence
from the British, we were a struggling little nation.
In order to survive, we formed a union
with a larger, more powerful country, Malaysia.
Where are you from, Malaysia or Singapore?
Malaysia, okay, yeah.
You assholes.
When my Prime Minister went on TV to announce
that you guys had dumped us, he cried
because he thought we're not gonna survive without you.
But then, four years later,
we became a first world country.
And you guys, Malaysia, what are you now?
Still a developing country.
Oh, boo.
You, Malaysia.
Isn't that the best breakup revenge?
Now, Malaysia, y'all trying to come around like,
eh, Singapore, you're looking good lah.
And we're like, I know,
but why haven't you visited me in 40 years?
And you're like, yeah, I tried,
but you know, my airplanes cannot fly.
Malaysian airlines going missing, not funny, huh?
Some jokes don't land.
This joke kills in Singapore.
I gotta pack y'all for me from the Malaysia side.
It's okay, they don't have internet.
Long story short, Andrew, Jocelyn Chia
is a comedian from Singapore.
She lives in New York City now.
We actually know her.
She did our Asianology show.
She is a funny comedian.
She made an edgy joke about MH370.
I mean, some people would say she was even being
a little bit mean to the Malaysian audience members
at the comedy cellar, but certainly, to be honest,
it doesn't seem anything too far outside of the range.
However, Andrew, the response from Malaysia
and Singapore was crazy.
We're talking about diplomats, party opposition leaders,
protests at the U.S. embassy.
Singapore issued a statement being like,
hey guys, she was no longer a Singaporean citizen
when she made this joke.
She was an American citizen.
Why do you think this went so crazy?
Because a lot of Americans, Andrew, cannot understand it.
All right, everybody, we're gonna answer this question.
We're gonna go through the comment section
because the world is weighing in on this,
not just fans of comedy.
So please hit that like button.
Check out other episodes of the Hot Pot.
David, number one, I think a lot of people
who heard her joke initially in America
because she has done the joke many, many times before
and it's gotten a lot of laughs,
I don't think a lot of people understand the relationship
or the tension between Singapore and Malaysia.
Well, most Americans, let's just say,
I'm gonna go ahead and say 96 to 97%,
have no clue where Singapore and Malaysia are
and they just don't even know much
other than they cane people in Singapore.
That's probably what they know.
Yeah, and I think the outrage is really coming
from the fact that within the confines of a comedy club
and the context of a comedy club,
this joke, although it was edgy
and some people could say offensive,
was still very much a joke.
Honestly, I'd give it a 7.8, maybe 8.2 out of 10.
There was still two more notches of intensity
that you hear at the comedy club
in a two-hour set on a Wednesday.
People make jokes about 9-11 in New York City
where that happened, right?
Now, I will also say this, though.
Because you post a clip on the internet
for the whole world to see,
the whole world gets to judge it.
Right?
No, they get to judge it like they were there
sitting in the comedy club without all the context,
but they were right there.
No, they don't.
Yeah, I don't even think they're judging it
like they're in a comedy club.
They're just judging it while they're eating breakfast
with their kaya toast or nasi lemak,
and they're just like, oh my, this is offensive.
This pisses me off.
You know what I'm saying?
So I guess it's really tough
because nowadays a joke can be funny within a context,
but if you bring that out of the context onto the internet,
it can get a lot of views,
and a lot of people will think it's funny
if they've been to a comedy show,
but if you haven't, then it's probably pretty offensive.
Yeah, I mean, I think that that's why
there was such a widespread of opinions, guys.
I looked this up.
I had to stop doing research on this
because literally we're talking about
50 hyperactive threads on various platforms,
maybe like 500 comments each.
I'm not gonna read 25,000 comments
about Jocelyn Chia's airplane joke, to be honest.
But there is some serious takeaways to have from this,
so make sure you like, subscribe,
turn on your notifications, Andrew.
Let's get into the very first comment.
Somebody said,
wah, Asians are just not ready for stand-up comedy, man.
Man, I think that a lot of Asians
don't put themselves in comedy club environments.
Well, it's not a Asian thing, right?
A lot of Asian Americans
have never even seen stand-up comedy live,
even though they've watched it online.
Would you agree with that?
Yeah, but I also think that if you watch
a lot of comedy, for the most part,
probably I would say 90% of people
who watch a lot of comedy think this joke was edgy
and was kind of offensive
because her style is a little bit more brash,
but ultimately it was still a joke.
Yeah, I would say-
And it doesn't do anything to the geopolitics behind it.
It's not that Singapore and Malaysia
are on the brink of war, although there is tension.
It's like, you know what I mean?
I think she was just playing
on pre-existing power dynamics.
Singapore is way more economically developed
than Malaysia.
It's more, there's different racial compositions.
Somebody was saying,
everything in the West is just harsher.
The comedy's harsher, it's more blunt,
it's more sarcastic, it's mean.
Look at our version of hip-hop
versus the type of hip-hop
that comes out of Malaysia or Singapore.
Our version of hip-hop would be way more intense
and just extreme as well, right?
Everything is more extreme, right?
America is an extreme place, that is true.
Somebody said, do you think it's true
that most Asians just are too soft
or too easily quote-unquote butt-hurt
for Western comedy?
That's why she intended this joke for an American audience.
Yeah, yeah, I think a lot of her fans are American
and I think that, I don't know.
I mean, honestly, Asians just,
you can generalize and say people from Asia
or people from a traditional Asian background
do not have the same Western comedy sensibilities
or context or tolerance.
It's true.
Despite being relatively fluent in English
in Singapore and Malaysia.
In America, we want to roast each other,
we roast our politicians
while they're trying to win a campaign.
Right, like in a lot of other countries,
traditional societies,
like the Washington DC Correspondents Dinner,
that comedian possibly would be executed, right?
Like at the most extreme end.
Yeah, I mean, listen,
I think that there's pros and cons
to each society, all right?
Somebody said, as an American,
how is this even newsworthy at all?
Why did the governments get involved?
This is weird.
This was a joke in America.
By the way, I'm white,
so maybe I don't get it.
Yeah, so here's the thing,
that there is, not that I do not think
Jocelyn Chia meant anything racial by this,
but I think some people who are offended
are taking it somewhat racially
because Malaysia is 70% Malay, right?
And that's a different ethnicity
than the 70% of Singapore,
which is ethnically Chinese.
For sure, there's a racial element here.
There's definitely a racial element.
That's the unspoken, guys.
Andrew, not-
Andrew, you're talking about
♪ Race wars of Asia ♪
♪ The race wars of Southeast Asia ♪
♪ They go on and you know we ain't playin' ♪
And I think that this is the truth
that we will speak on,
but even a lot of internet comments,
Andrew, we're afraid to speak on.
Andrew, it's clearly a very sensitive issue,
and somebody said it stirred up
a lot of stuff that had settled
at the bottom of the glass
that was clearly still there,
and her joke was like a little stir
in a cup of Milo
that just a little stirred up.
You know what it is?
It's because Uncle Roger Nigel Ng, right,
who is funny,
he actually got his social media banned in China
for a joke he made about Xi Jinping, right?
Right, right.
And it wasn't even that harsh.
It really wasn't.
It was not that.
I was actually surprised he got banned.
But obviously, I think a lot of people
expect that type of thing from China.
It's like, oh, well, China's extra sensitive
about that stuff,
so of course they're gonna ban him,
but Malaysia, whoa, I don't get this.
Somebody said, but yeah,
it still doesn't make sense.
Even if what she said did stir up some bad blood,
the government still seemed like she was overreacting,
still seemed like they're overreacting.
She wasn't a diplomat.
She became an American citizen,
and she's literally telling jokes.
She has no power to make any decisions whatsoever.
You know what's different, though,
is because she still kinda has a Singaporean accent,
so it appears as if she is from there
and being the representative.
Here's the issue here,
and I love Jocelyn,
but I guess how people are viewing it
is that they're viewing her
as the one representative of that country
or that region.
You know what it is?
People may tacitly, deep down without vocalizing it,
internally feel that a heavy volume of Singaporeans
feel that way towards them.
Right, they agree,
and I think that's because it's kinda played
into the stereotypes that a lot of people believe in,
so I think that's why.
Somebody said, I'm a white woman,
and I was offended.
Jokes about tragedy are not cool.
Bad taste joke.
And somebody said, let me guess,
you also got mad at Chappelle's last special, too,
and then somebody came through and said,
well, you're a white woman and offended?
I'm a white man,
and this is pretty tame compared to other things.
It's just morbid humor.
I would say that if you are offended,
I think that's fine.
I think everybody has the right
to be offended about anything.
It's true, right?
You can say, you know what?
I didn't like that joke,
or yo, that joke hit too home,
because there are some people who commented and say,
hey, I actually lost a relative on that plane,
so of course I'm not gonna find it funny.
It's true, but I guess,
for example, if a Singaporean comedian,
which Singapore is a country that's well off, right?
If they were making 9-11 jokes about America
and trying to downplay America,
obviously, because America,
the way we think and our tolerance for comedy,
I don't think a lot of Americans
are gonna get offended by this.
Some would.
Honestly, like, listen,
jokes that work in New York City at the Comedy Cellar
might hit completely different
at a Republican comedy venue in like Dallas, Texas.
That's true.
Right? Yeah.
Like, depending on how much you wanna diss
or not diss America,
different parts of England, for example,
you go to London, you tell British jokes,
the crowd is so international,
maybe they're not even from London, they laugh.
If you go outside of London in the UK,
I heard they're very nativist.
That's what I heard.
David, are you trying to say that context matters?
That context matters a lot.
And like you said,
internet does not allow for things that are hyperlocal
to stay hyperlocal in that club,
even though there was a white person in there that night
that Jocelyn Chia was performing
that was like, ooh,
you're gonna get a lot of one-star Yelp reviews,
because they were almost feeling the heat
between her and Malaysians.
They knew, they knew, yeah.
Like I said, who knows?
Maybe she wished she could have that one back,
or maybe not.
Somebody said, you know,
why are you mad at her joke
when you should be mad at the Malaysian government
for messing that whole situation up?
This is an internet comment by the way, guys,
not my words.
Somebody said, there shouldn't be any limits.
There's freedom of speech.
However, there's also freedom of consequences.
The consequences are the consequences,
just like you can say whatever you want to say.
Yeah, and I think Jocelyn is standing her ground.
She's saying, hey, it was a joke.
I've performed it hundreds of times.
I'm going to keep performing it.
I am not canceled.
In fact, some people want to see me even more
because I'm now controversial.
Right, that's probably true.
Ultimately, there's probably pros and cons though,
like the internet profile's gonna take a hit,
but the, you know, in person,
people are gonna wanna see more edgy comedians
that say just wild things, right?
Somebody said, it wasn't the joke for me that offended me.
It was her being rude to the Malaysians
and not wanting to give them any sort of compliment
to make up for it because at the end of her set,
she said, F you, Malaysia,
and it felt like she was saying it to the Malaysians
in the audience's face.
Listen, I think that there's a point of the joke
where it did get even more harsh.
Like, it got continually more harsh.
You're talking about as the joke escalated?
Yeah, it's still a joke.
She's still a comedian on stage,
and I think if you talk to her off stage,
she's still gonna be very nice to you.
Yeah, she was nice to me all the conversation.
She's a very sweet woman,
but I could see, again, out of context,
you're living in Penang or Kuala Lumpur,
and you open that up in the morning
and someone sends you that video,
you could be offended.
So it's easy.
By the way, I'm not telling anybody
who's offended to lighten up either
because obviously, guys,
we all live different lives on this earth.
We all have different cultural positioning
within different plots on this game map of this earth.
Of course, we're all gonna feel differently
about different things, right?
Think about it.
You're sipping on your kopitiam in the morning
and you're just like, you know.
Somebody said, if you have the skills,
you can jujitsu anything
and people will laugh at anything.
She just had poor delivery on this particular joke.
Yeah.
Yeah, she didn't stick the landing.
Would you agree or disagree or?
Oh, that's a pun right there.
No, I'm just kidding.
But yeah, I mean, she could have said something
about how good Malaysian food is
and how she wants a Malaysian chef,
but not a Malaysian pilot or something.
You know what I mean?
That could have been a little compliment first,
but I'm not telling her how to do her comedy,
but of course, you know what?
I think Jocelyn's gonna live with that.
I think she's gonna be fine.
I don't think that although there's online death threats,
usually that stuff doesn't really mean anything
to be honest in real life,
but you know, I'm sure she took note
of how people feel about it.
I'm sure.
Somebody said that, you know,
they had a Patrice O'Neill quote,
good jokes and bad jokes come from the same place.
When you don't allow people in the room to make bad jokes,
you're killing off the good jokes and humor.
Basically saying that bad jokes are all part of the process
and you know, sometimes you tell the joke this way,
it's a bad joke.
You tell the joke this way with a different tone,
even just a few different words, it's a good joke.
Humor is very, in a way, it's very subjective.
It's not like singing, right, Andrew?
Nobody can deny Celine Dion, Mariah Carey,
Christina Aguilera's range, right?
But like jokes are subjective.
Yeah, for sure.
A hundred percent, man.
All right.
One of my biggest takeaways is this, I guess.
Moving forward for a lot of comedians
who want to post clips on the internet,
even including ourselves, including myself, right?
I post some of the clips of our comedy,
of my comedy on the internet for the world to see
because you want a lot of views.
You want more viewership, but guess what?
You don't control how those people view your comedy.
How they take it, what lives they've lived,
how they perceive it,
doing whatever situations they've been through, right?
What context they see it in.
So then they have every right to comment back.
Now, they could probably be wrong
because at the end of the day,
if it's a comedy clip, it's a comedy clip.
It's supposed to be comedy.
But yeah, people are going to get offended
and the whole world can get offended.
Yeah.
I mean, I do think, and I don't know,
I don't want to say, you know, as an American,
I could still try to put my Asian hat on.
I've been to Malaysia and Singapore multiple times each.
I would say this, it did,
it surprised me the level of seriousness that diplomats
and like politicians had to issue statements, right?
But if they see, like they themselves might get it,
but if they see their bases energized by it,
they have to address it because their basis
is still their career too, if they get voted in.
I do believe it was suboptimal delivery
and execution of a volatile subject joke.
Volatile subjects in comedy are the most fun to play with,
Andrew, because they're like explosive elements
on the periodic table,
but they can go downside as well, right?
But they can also go upside and people love the comedians.
They can talk about these very explosive subjects.
That's why Chappelle, Patrice O'Neill, Bill Burr,
you know what I mean, are so lauded.
If you look at her delivery versus like a Mark Norman,
who is a white guy, but his delivery is very like smug
and hey, hey guys, like I'm going to talk about race,
you know, and then like almost nothing he says
almost feels offensive.
But obviously if your delivery is kind of like yelling
and that's her style, that's her character,
then it is going to even be perceived
a different way to outside people.
Yeah, but let's be honest, like you said,
I mean, as much as the joke could have been told
a little bit better, smoother, more refined here or there,
there may be some, you know, religious, racial demographic,
socioeconomic, you know, rivalries at play
that those go way deeper than whatever joke she made.
I think ultimately jokes like this,
I think that in a way in the long term can do some good
because it brings up something that was under the rug, right?
Right, you're saying stirring up the Milo
that's at the bottom of the cup.
Yeah, now some people are kind of like,
well, now why she do that?
Like, we don't want to talk about that.
Like, we just try to live our life.
We're like, what is she doing?
You know, trying to rock the boat, you know?
But, you know, in America, we like to rock the boat.
Yeah. We like to shake things off.
We will try to shake off the dust.
That's what we like to do here.
I don't know. For me, I've always been a fan
of the American style, but yeah, understanding Asia
and just like how different they are,
how they approach everything musically.
And even when we're playing on the basketball court
with a bunch of kids from China,
if a kid like goes 0 for 7,
it's considered rude for you to tell him to stop shooting.
Even if he's bricking threes
and he's going to brick another three threes
and he's going to lose the game for the team.
It's just weird.
I don't know why that is,
but that's just a difference in culture.
All right, everybody, we're going to wrap it up there.
Let us know what you thought about Jocelyn's joke.
Was it funny?
And could you see why so many people are offended?
Or do you think that's like stepping over the line
and that, I guess, people are being too sensitive?
Can you just chalk it up to a wildly
different culture despite, you know,
I'll tell you this, Andrew, not everybody who speaks English
at a fluent level necessarily
is culturally English in their mind.
That's true. All right, everybody.
Thank you so much for watching. We are the Hot Pop Boys.
And until next time, we out. Peace.
Malaysia, you want to know the truth about Singapore?