How to Modify a 151 Spokeshave to Pare Leather for Bookbinding // Adventures in Bookbinding

Sparky Deal
161 followers
1 Video View·Jun 11, 2023
A common tool used by bookbinders to pare or thin leather is a spokeshave.
Now, spokeshaves are tools designed for woodworkers.
There are many different types of spokeshaves, but the one most commonly used by bookbinders is in the style of the
Stanley 151, which has the adjustment screws to adjust the depth of the blade.
It's become common practice to make some modifications to these spokeshaves, specifically for paring leather, for
bookbinding. And that's what we're going to look at today.
This is my favorite woodworking spokeshave, and then this one's my favorite paring or leather paring spokeshave.
Now, this red one, now they're not always red, but this is one for doing inside curves.
They can't be modified for paring leather.
And this one is the one that we're going to tune up in this video.
Now, by the magic of a time machine, that's what it's going to look like at the end of the video.
Now, before we get into the modifications, I just want to show you this.
This is my woodworking spokeshave.
It has no modifications for leather paring.
It does have a very sharp blade.
I've had it for probably 20 plus years, so I've really tuned that blade well.
But it is at an angle of 25 degrees and it planes leather quite well.
I haven't opened the mouth at all.
It is just a woodworking spokeshave.
So if you want to use a woodworking spokeshave, I think it's perfectly acceptable.
Now, to see one of the major differences is that angle, the bedding angle, is 45 degrees on a standard 151
spokeshave. But you can see that on the right, that angle is much lower.
It's closer to 35 degrees.
And the other main modification is the bevel angle on the blade.
And I'll compare the two.
And you can see the my modified blade has a much shallower angle on the bevel.
How are we going to lower that bedding angle?
We're going to use metalworking files to file material away towards the adjusting screws.
You can see how much further back the sole reaches towards the adjusting screws, compared to the woodworking
spokeshave at the top.
So we'll start by pulling the spokeshave apart.
Now, notice that the bevel on these spokeshaves goes down, and that's true for woodworking and for leather
paring. There's a misconception about this, and I might talk about it later.
But for now, let's just pull it apart, take it completely apart.
So I just want to demonstrate this again, what we're trying to do is lower the angle of the bed that the blade
sits in. And we're going to do that by taking metal away towards where the number 151 is.
Now, how we're going to do that is we're going to clamp this body of the spokeshave to the bench, just like that.
And you can see how that the back of the sole is higher than the front.
So we can clamp it and then, using metal files kept horizontally, we'll just file across that sole and until
it's completely flat all the way across.
And it will have lowered the angle almost exactly to what we want, which is probably 35 degrees.
So I'll just start filing away, trying to keep the file horizontal.
Now, metal working files come in a bewildering range.
However, there are a couple of key parameters that you should know about.
So the coarseness of the teeth come in three broad categories.
The coarsest is called bastard cut, the medium is called second cut, and the finest is called smooth cut.
Now, the next characteristic is whether it's a single cut or a double cut file.
So a single cut, the teeth are cut all in the same direction once across the file.
A double cut file has a second row of cuts across the face of the file.
Now, do you use a double cut or a single cut?
There's a lot of art, I guess, to using files and people have rules of thumb.
I'm actually swapping between a single cut and a double cut file here just because they happen to be the two that I
grab off my wall.
One of them's a bastard cut and one's a second cut.
So it's probably a second cut double cut.
So the rule of thumb that I use, whether it's true or not, is that a double cut file removes more material faster,
but leaves a rougher surface.
You can see the lines that this one's leaving now, and that a single cut file leaves a smoother surface.
If you don't have some files lying around and you're going to buy one and only one, the one I'd recommend is an 8
inch single cut second cut file.
So it's sort of medium coarseness and it should produce a smoother surface.
If you're going to get a second file, I'd get something that's going to remove material faster.
So it would be a 12 inch double cut bastard cut file.
So I'm just going to keep at this and work my way down, trying to keep the sole flat from side to side.
And if everything goes well, just as the number 151 disappears, I'll hit the roughly the front of the plane.
So it'll be flat all the way across.
Now, I was just using a thing called a card file, which is used to clean the filings out of the teeth of the file.
It's a worthwhile thing to have.
Now I'm just checking to see how flat I've got it, making sure that I'm keeping that file nice and flat as I'm working.
Now I'm almost there.
The number 151 is almost gone, and I'm going to start putting a nice, smooth, round curve to the front of the
spoke shave. I want it to glide nicely over leather, so I'm just going to put a nice, smooth, rounded edge at the
front. Now it's going to be a bit rough from the plane, and we'll fix that up later with some fine emery paper.
I'm also going to take the edges off on the sides and even a little bit at the back, just to reduce the sole size so
there's less friction on the leather.
Now, from the big pile of iron filings, you can see we've removed quite a lot of metal, which is something you normally
don't like doing with an old tool.
Now we'll start refining the sole with our sharpening station.
Start with 240 grit emery paper.
So after a bit of an effort, I'm going to realize that it's a bit hollow towards the center, so I'm going to go back to
using a file to take a bit of material off on either side.
So we're going to see that that's a significant improvement, and it's now flat across the front of the spoke shave with
just a bit of a hollow behind the blade.
But I'm going to put a bit of an effort in, and I'm going to take that hollow out.
Now, it's a bit rounded on the corners, and I actually did that on purpose.
It'll just help it glide over the leather nicely.
So I'm just going to check the angle.
I think I got it pretty close to 35 degrees.
35 to 37, something like that.
Now I'm going to put it in my metal vice too.
Now, I'm going to be gentle with it because you could crack one of these easily in a metal vice.
I've got a piece of block of wood in there, and I'm just going to fix that leading edge.
I'm going to try and get that nice and rounded and smooth.
So there's still a lot more fine tuning to do, but before I do that, I want to clean it up and paint it.
So I'm going to start scraping off the rust and the little bit of remaining paint, and then I'll put it on a wire
wheel to really clean it up.
This is just a Stanley box cutter knife put into a piece of wood.
It was a little trick that I've been taught in the past, which I really like, by a guy by the name of Keith
Banfield. Here's one of my favorite toys.
It has some minor modifications so that I can run it in both directions.
That's because the wire bristles on the brush will start to all lean in one direction.
And then when you go in the other direction, it'll clean better for a while, and then you go back in the other
direction. So this device was designed to have a grinding wheel on it, and that would only go in one direction,
and it would be in the direction where the nut on the auger would tighten up.
So I had to put an extra locking nut on it to stop it undoing when I went in the opposite direction.
Starting to look pretty good.
I'll start doing the little pieces in a moment, and I'll use a pair of vise grips to hold those.
Jeff Peachey sells these spokeshaves modified with even more modifications that I'm going to demonstrate.
He's also written a lot about modifying spokeshaves and has done a type study of the Stanley 151.
So I'll put some links to his information in the description for this video.
The next step is to flatten the bed of the plane.
The bed is what the blade sits on.
Now, again, I got this from Jeff Peachey, but in Jeff Peachey's articles, he says that he got it from the
woodworker Brian Boggs.
And I have gone back to the his original article, which is called Soup Up Your Spokeshave, and it's available to
subscribers from one of the woodworking magazines.
And this technique is to put some epoxy down in the bed, put a layer of paper over it, and then use the blade to
squeeze it flat.
This is the first time I've used this approach.
In the past, what I've done is put a layer of epoxy down and then filed it flat.
It turns out this approach works much better.
So I'm cutting a piece of paper to fit snugly into the bed.
It's larger than I need, so it extends through the mouth and up towards the adjustment screws.
I will cut those corners out of the way so they don't interfere with the adjustment screws.
So there's a common problem with these in that the adjustment screws, the screw that is cast into the body, leans up
and then the adjustment nuts ride or the blade rides on those adjustment nuts.
Now that stops the blade sitting flat on the bed.
Now, that can be fixed in this process by shimming up the blade with a bit of masking tape.
And when we put the epoxy in, it will take the right shape for the blade being slightly higher.
And then once the tape is taken away, it won't ride on the nut any longer.
So it only happens on one side.
On this spoke shape, so I'll put a bit of bit of tape on the side that it was binding on.
The other side turns freely.
Now, all the articles and Jeff's website, they talk about using two part epoxy, but I just happen to have this metal
filler from another project.
And I know it's worked for me in the past, so I'm going to use it again.
I'm going to put a thin layer down.
I'm going to fill in those two divots and then put a thin layer down.
I don't want to put too much material in because I don't want it to squeeze out.
Just going to clean the grease off with a bit of acetone first.
Now, you don't want to epoxy the screw in, so I try not to leave a bit of a gap around the screw, though it will squeeze
out towards the screw.
And something I forgot to show was that I put some furniture polish on the screw so that it wouldn't get stuck in by
the epoxy.
So I'll put the paper in place and then the blade on top.
Now, I'm going to put the blade with the bevel up and I want it to extend past the mouth, the opening of the
spokeshave. And I'll put the lever cap in without the lever screw.
So I'm just the central screw is all that I'm going to put in.
And I'll do up that snugly.
I want to push the epoxy flat, but I don't want to squeeze it all out.
I want a nice layer of epoxy, but I do want it squeezed nice and flat.
I don't want any holes under the paper or voids under the paper.
So that looks pretty good.
There's a nice small amount of squeeze out along the whole mouth.
So I let that set up for a couple of days.
I guess you just follow the instructions of whatever epoxy you're using.
Now, trim along the opening of the mouth and at the back as well.
I'll just clean that up.
Now, taking that tape off the nut, adjustment nut, I can just check that it's not binding any longer and it's working
perfectly. There's a small amount of clearance there.
So now it's time to do all the final fine tuning before we do the painting.
So I'm just going to round off and reduce the surface area of the sole, which hopefully minimizes the drag on the
leather and get that front, the front edge of the spoke shape, nice and rounded and smooth.
So I'll just start with the file and then I'll do a progression with emery cloth, starting at 240 down to 1200.
And then once I've done the edges, I'll put it back on the sharpening station and work my way up to 1200 emery cloth.
I'm going to take that lip off the back there, but it's going to be sharp again after I put it on the sharpening station.
So I'll probably leave that to the very last moment to round off the edge behind the blade.
So I'll work through the brick progression to get that nice and smooth.
Now, how long did this job take?
Over about, I think it took me 4 or 5 days.
I filmed almost 7 hours of work.
I did miss a few things where I forgot to hit the record button.
I think I missed two coats of paint.
So I probably missed maybe 10 or 15 minutes of work, but otherwise I recorded the whole process.
So it took me about 7 hours of work spread out over a week.
So I'll finish the sole off with 800 grit and then 1200 grit.
In preparation for painting, I'll strip it all down again and mask off the areas that I don't want painted.
Take all the grease off again with acetone.
I'm going to put a screw in the back of the hole to stop that getting filled with paint.
Now, I'm not going to use the screw from the plane, and it is a funky thread.
So I'm going to use a screw that's a bit loose, but it's going to be tight enough to stop paint getting in.
You don't want to force a screw in there and wreck that thread.
Now, I want to mask off the bed, but I don't want to wreck that piece of paper.
So I'm going to put a piece of paper over it.
I'm going to glue it in place just with a bit of glue stick, but it's only on the exposed bit of metal.
I'm not putting it on the paper.
That paper is nice and smooth and the blade slides on it beautifully.
Now, I do a bit of woodworking and I love using old tools, and restoring old tools is a huge hobby.
There's lots and lots of YouTube videos out there.
My favorites used to be by this guy called Keith Banfield, but something happened and all these videos have
disappeared, unfortunately, because they were great.
Now, it's really common in that community to use this engine paint to replace japanning on planes.
It works really well.
It looks pretty good.
It's maybe not as good as genuine japanning, but that's what I'm going to use for this plane.
I forgot to hit the record button for the first coat, unfortunately.
So it's simply a matter of following the instructions.
It is a bit tricky to stop getting drips.
The trick is the first two coats want to be very light, and then you start giving thicker coats to get a nice glossy
surface. I did four coats, and in hindsight, I probably wish I'd gone a fifth coat.
It's a good idea to cut around the masking tape so that when you remove it, you don't pull the paint off the areas
you want the paint to stay on.
So at least the plane body is getting close to finished.
The next job is to flatten the front of the lever cap.
Now, this only touches the blade at the front.
So you just lift it up slightly and make sure that it's flat across the full width.
And also just smooth off the front edge so that the leather pairing, when it comes up off the blade, is traveling
over a nice, smooth surface.
Probably getting a bit ahead of myself, putting everything back together at this point.
There is one thing that I probably should have done first, but it's a good feeling to put everything together.
And now we'll take the blade out and get working on the blade.
So the first step, as usual, is to flatten the back of the blade.
Doesn't look too bad.
I'll start with a better piece of emery cloth or a less used one.
It's got a bit of a hollow there.
It's taking too long for my liking, so I'm going to swap to my diamond stone to speed up the process.
Once I have the back flat on my coarse stone, I'm going to move to changing the bevel angle.
So most woodworking planes or this, this blade had a 25 degree bevel angle, and I want to get it down to
something close to 15 degrees.
Now I've got another toy.
I've got a hand cranked grinder.
And it has a really nice tool rest and a nice holder for short blades.
Now, making a significant change to the bevel angle on a blade like this is going to really require some mechanical
help. You really couldn't, I couldn't do it by hand.
It would just would be too much work for me.
And I think that means too much work for everyone.
So if you don't have a nice tool like this, you may have to seek out some help to change the bevel angle.
Now, this setup does come with this little tool to help try and determine the angle.
But in reality, what I do is I try and get it close to where I think it should be.
And then I'll just monitor it and iterate in to the angle that I want.
So how do I know I'm getting close to the 15 degrees that I want?
So I've gone and measured the thickness of this blade, and it's one and a half millimeters.
With some basic trigonometry, the width of the bevel should be 1.5 divided by tan 15, which is about 5.6
millimeters. So once it's getting close to grinding all the way across the bevel, I'll keep an eye on the width
with a pair of calipers, and I'll try and get it close to five and a half millimeters.
Another common modification on these spoke shaves is to replace the blade with a high end woodworking blade.
There's a particular maker called Hock, which is very popular.
The only thing is, their blades are very thick and you have to do a number of other modifications.
You do have to open up the mouth of the spoke shave, and that's a modification I just don't actually like doing.
So for leather, I just think these blades, the standard blade, is rigid enough.
It works pretty well.
I haven't tried the thicker blades to compare.
Maybe one day I'll do a comparison and I'll find it so much better that I'll wonder why I've never done it before.
But for now, I haven't gone with the thicker blade.
The other thing with those high end blades is they are harder steel, so they are harder to modify the bevel angle on.
So I'm just taking off the corners here.
Of course, that's not great for your, for the stone, but it's got to be done.
I guess you could do it on the side of the stone, but I don't like messing with the side of my stone either.
I can always dress it up if I'm, if I put a bit of a groove in my stone.
And getting back to those aftermarket blades, they're expensive as well.
And I do have one that I picked up.
It's new old stock, a Hawk blade, the, not the A2 steel, but the bicarbon steel.
And I'm sort of saving that for woodworking.
So I'm almost there.
So I've just put it on to the lapping station, and there's just a spot that is not ground as much as the rest of it.
And I'm just going to touch that up on the grinding stone before finishing the lapping.
Now, a bevel ground on a circular wheel like that, or a circular grinding stone, is called hollow ground.
So I'm going to lap that across the hollow grind.
So I'm going to let it sit on either side of the hollow grind.
So you can see where it's touching on either side.
It's such a shallow grind that I almost grind out the hollow, which is fine.
I'm just going to check the angle, and I think it's pretty close to 15 degrees, somewhere between 15 and 17 degrees, I
think. Now I'm just going to go through my grit progression up to my finest stone.
So I just go side to side, back, then the bevel, then back again to take off any burr.
One last modification to the body of the plane, the back of the mouth is really sharp.
And I think that the leather, when it springs back up after the blade's gone across, it can catch on that.
So I like to round that off.
So I'll just use a small file to just take that sharp edge off, just to touch it up with the finest emery cloth I've
got. So it's sort of rounded off like the leading edge.
So that it runs smoothly across the leather.
I'm just going to use my rag in a can, thanks to the woodworker Paul Sellers for the idea of that.
Put a bit of oil on it to stop it rusting and put everything back together.
I think my camera is even starting to get bored of this job.
It's starting to lose focus.
Something I forgot to do was to strop the blade.
Just using my strop that I use for my other knives, I'll just strop the blade, same way, maybe 30 strokes on either
side of the blade.
For the initial depth adjustment, look along the plane of the sole and adjust it till you just see the blade.
And this is the first go with it.
And I'm pretty happy with that.
It's certainly not perfect.
I've used it a bit now and it will wear in.
I think it'll improve with a bit of use as the blade gets sharper and sharper.
I don't know what was causing that mark there on the right.
It must be something was catching.
It's usually a piece of leather that gets caught under the blade that causes that.
So here I'll do an actual job.
This is the piece of leather that I'm going to use for the mini springback that I bound.
So I end up pairing this too thin.
So I think I took it down to about 0.4 of a millimeter.
And if it had been, of course, for a large springback binding, you want relatively thick leather.
But this springback's less than 4 inches tall and quite small by springback standards.
So I wanted, I thought I'd need very thin leather for it.
It turns out that it's probably too thin for the job.
And the next one, I won't pair the leather down as much.
That's it. Job done.
Now you want to protect your investment.
So just get a bit of scrap leather and make a cover for it.
So I think I've shown you how to prepare all the tools that you'll need for some basic leather binding.
So I think the next videos I'm going to do is going to be some leather binding.
I think I'm going to start with a 19th century library binding because it doesn't involve a lot of pairing.
I think it's a good spot to start.
So I hope you've enjoyed this rather long video and I hope you've got something out of it.
If you have, please hit the like button and provide any comments about your experience with modifying a Stanley
151. If you want to be notified about my future videos, please hit the subscribe button.
And until next time, thanks for watching.
