Check out the full episode 1663 here: Video - https://youtu.be/ESeP6y0BD7s “HMB Supplement Review" LIKE this video if you learned something new! COMMENT your thoughts on this topic. SUBSCRIBE for more valuable fitness content
Next question is from Rui Marquez Insta.
Is HMB worth it?
HMB.
You guys remember that supplement got all crazy
and it was like all over the ads and stuff?
Yeah, this was actually not one that I really got into.
Really? So, okay, so hydroxymethylbutyrate,
you could call it, right?
That's what HMB stands for.
It's a metabolite, an active metabolite of leucine,
the amino acid that is really closely tied to
the anabolic effects of protein.
So the more leucine protein has,
the more anabolic it has.
Now, I will say this,
if your protein intake's high, it doesn't matter as much.
It's if your protein intake is below that,
you know, what studies will show to be the upper limit
of where you'll get benefit from high protein.
Now, I remember when HMB first came out,
it was EAS that was really pushing it.
EAS at the time also sold creatine.
Now, creatine is just, it's the best natural supplement
just hands down that you can find.
It's good for you, it works, it builds muscle,
improves recovery, it's got heart health benefits
and cognitive benefits,
and it's just a great supplement all the way around.
And EAS tried to kind of follow on the heels of creatine
with HMB.
And I remember reading an article,
and this will haunt,
I think it'll haunt Bill Phillips till forever.
Literally, the article said,
creatine is like D-ball and HMB is like Deca.
Like he was trying to say,
you'll get explosive gains with creatine
and you'll get slow and consistent gains with HMB.
I, and by the way,
studies show HMB to be great for presenting,
excuse me, preventing muscle breakdown.
In certain populations,
it helps with muscle building and strength.
So there are studies to show and support it.
In fact, you know those Ensure drinks
that they give to old people or whatever?
They now will have HMB in them
to help with old people to prevent muscle loss.
Now I've tried HMB at least a hundred times
because of the studies.
And I've taken monster doses of it
to make it work or whatever.
Here's why it doesn't do ----,
because my protein intake's high.
It didn't do anything for me when I would supplement it
because it didn't do much.
The value with HMB might be the similar value
you'd find with branched amino acids,
which is if your protein is low,
then you may get some benefit from taking HMB.
Let's say you're vegan
and you're not hitting your 0.8 grams of protein
per pound of body weight
because it's harder to do with plant sources.
HMB might be beneficial to you.
Other than that,
it's one of those supplements
that didn't even come close to meeting the hype.
Have either of you heard Lane speak on this before?
He's someone who I'd love to hear talk about HMB.
He says leucine.
Just do leucine
because leucine has been shown to do the same thing,
which is true.
His thesis was on that,
so I imagine that he would have a really intelligent answer.
If you compare leucine to HMB in similar studies,
you find that it doesn't make a difference,
except for HMB is way more expensive.
HMB is a much more expensive supplement.
I can see benefit in some populations.
Like I said, low protein.
Yeah, but even then, why not just take leucine then?
Exactly.
Why not just give them leucine?
So it's really worthless
because even where it has some value,
there's a product that's cheaper
and would do as good of a job, if not better.
So to me, that's enough to just cancel.
The one time I saw some benefit,
I was taking, I don't remember the dose,
it was like three grams three times a day,
which is way higher than you're supposed to,
so I'm not advocating for this.
I do like to experiment on myself with supplements.
And it was during a period
where I was cutting really aggressively
and my protein intake even wasn't high enough
because my calories were so low.
And then I felt like I got a little bit of a benefit,
but it never added up to the cost
of buying all this freaking HMB that I took.
So it's one of those supplements that I just say,
you know, look, here's the deal.
If your protein intake's low
and you want to take amino acids
to help preserve your muscle,
buy branched chain amino acids.
Way cheaper.
They're high in leucine, right?
One of the branched chain amino acids is leucine.
Typically, a good branched chain amino acid supplement
will have like a 2-1-1 ratio.
So, you know, the highest amino acid is leucine
and isoleucine and valine, so 2-1-1.
And that'll do what the HMB is going to do
and it's much cheaper.
Or your better option is increase your protein intake.
Take a protein powder,
which gives you all the amino acids
and has all the benefits of preserving muscle.
But yeah, this is one of those supplements
that the marketing was so heavy behind it
in the 90s and the early 2000s.
Like they spent so much money marketing it
and it absolutely never lived up.
Like I've heard of it, but also I got it confused.
What's the other one called that's like a muscle relaxer?
It's like a drug.
It's something like that.
It sounds like HMB, but you guys.
Come on, you guys.
You're the drug guys.
Yeah, yeah.
And it's supposed to be like a muscle relaxer?
Yeah.
I don't know.
I have no idea.
Is it a prescription drug or is it like a natural supplement?
No, no, it's illegal, I think.
Yeah.
It's legal?
Illegal.
Oh, it's illegal.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
Oh, I don't know.
Everybody's looking at Adam.
Adam, what are the illegal drugs for relaxers?
Well, ----.
I'll never know.
I mean, how do you measure it?
In grams and ounces or pounds?
Okay, now I can't remember it.
Wasn't there a drug that used to be sold?
Yeah, I know this for a fact.
I just don't remember the name.
It used to be sold in supplement stores
because it raised growth hormone
and then people would take it before going to bed
and it would help them sleep.
Methoxybolic?
No, no, no, no.
It's not...
Bro, people used to take it to party.
Oh, to party.
Oh, you're talking about...
Here we go.
So, I have some of that somewhere.
No, you don't.
Allegedly, bro.
GH.
No, not GH.
That's growth hormone.
No, no, no.
It's called...
The acronym is still GH.
GMB or GMB.
GHB.
That's what it is.
GHB.
That's what it is.
There it is.
That's what we're talking about.
My crazy brain.
Not the same.
Give me the chemical.
HMB, GH.
I remember...
God, I remember my first experience
trying that stuff, dude.
It was like...
That stuff's gnarly.
It's like...
Not at all like HMB.
Yeah, not at all.
Totally different.
Yeah, it's totally different.
No, GH...
Okay, so GHB...
So, that's supposed to help you
get into your...
REM sleep.
Yeah, your REM sleep faster.
Like, you instantly go into it.
My new bodybuilders were taking it, so...
And I remember my first experience.
I'll never forget the first time.
Please don't do it.
Yeah, we're not...
Just because I'm telling somebody
a drug story...
Gamma-hydroxybutyrate.
There you go.
Yeah, GHB, right?
So, I mean, what...
Okay, that's the...
What exactly is it derived from?
And like, what is it used for?
Is it used for anything right now?
Like, the...
I know what it is on the black market used for,
but what is it used for?
Oh, yeah.
I heard it was used for like
cleaning computers and ----.
Oh, really?
Interesting.
Yeah.
It's a central nervous system depressant
that is commonly referred to
as a club drug or date rape.
Bodybuilders would use it
to get into their REM sleep as fast as you could.
And I remember the first time that I tried this,
I was at my house.
I remember I was scared to death to try it,
and I had a buddy that was peer-pressuring me to do it,
and I'm easily peer-pressured to try drugs.
And so I go, okay, I'll try this out
because it's just me and you and it's safe, right?
So I take it...
Oh, no, it was a date rape drug, bro.
Yeah, it is.
He pressured you?
Yes, yes.
I'm sure it was a friend.
We used to be friends.
No, it's just...
So...
Where's my pants?
What happened was I passed out on the couch afterwards.
I just fell asleep.
And he came back.
He went to the bathroom or something.
We were watching TV.
It was late at night,
and he went to the bathroom.
He comes back,
and him coming back into the living room
startled me enough to wake up.
And I woke up,
and I thought I slept through the whole night.
I went, oh, my God.
And I just felt so rested.
It literally felt like a full night's sleep,
and I thought it was early in the morning,
like five or six in the morning.
And it had only been like 20 minutes.
And I was like, how long have you been gone for?
He's like, I just went to the bathroom.
I came back.
And I'm like, what?
That's what it felt like.
Bro, they used to sell this at supplement stores
in the 90s,
I believe the early 90s,
and it would...
Because it raised growth hormone,
and they sold it as something to help you sleep.
By the way, this will kill you.
You take too much.
Very, very dangerous.
You take too much,
you go to sleep,
you don't wake up.
Yeah, and it was...
I mean, I was...
I experimented with like a little tiny cat foot.
So small.
Yeah, and then people are like,
oh, this is fun to take at the club
because you feel like you're drunk.
That's what I heard.
It's kind of fun.
It's no alcohol.
My friend told me.
Yeah, I don't know.
I've never used it before,
but anyway,
that's crazy.
So sell it as a supplement
and now it's one of these,
you know, whatever.
But it's not HMB.
Not even close.
Justin, a little side note.