A Beginners Guide to Coffee Tasting

James Hoffmann
3 followers
3 Video Views·May 4, 2023
Today, we're gonna talk about how to taste coffee,
how to break apart those sensations of taste,
to understand what it is you like, what you don't like,
and to begin to learn to describe
what it is that we're tasting.
Now, this is a sort of second part,
and the first part was how to set up
a simple cupping at home.
If you haven't watched that video yet,
go and watch that video
because setting up some sort of comparative tasting
is absolutely essential to be able
to develop your sense of taste
and really progress quite quickly.
Here, I've got two different coffees.
That's enough, but having three or four or five
would be even better.
Now, today's video is gonna be a lot of talking.
I'm gonna have to talk through
a bunch of different taste characteristics.
There's gonna be a bunch of opinion in there too,
but it's not a very practical video.
I'm gonna taste some coffee,
but I'm mostly, I'm gonna talk to you.
So the first thing I want you to do
is check the description of this video.
The first link is a link to a PDF,
and that's a PDF that is a kind of cupping form
that I think is really helpful.
Now, this form was developed by Sarah Larson
at Proofrock Training with a little help
from Evelina at Proofrock
and a tiny little bit of help from me too.
There are loads of different cupping forms in our industry,
but lots of them are focused on really specific things
that aren't particularly relevant
to what we're doing here.
You can look at, say, the Cup of Excellence cupping form
that is a complicated sheet
that's really designed to help you rank
an enormous number of raw coffees.
A roaster may have a different form
that they use to assess their roasts
because they're not really looking
at the raw coffee anymore,
they're looking at the success of the roast.
Here, this is a guide to help us sort of take notes
and record what we like, what we don't,
to better understand whether we like a coffee in front of us
or whether we dislike it.
What it is that we like, what it is that we don't like,
that can help us choose better in the future,
buy coffee better in the future,
communicate with others what we like and what we don't like,
and it's fun to develop your sense of taste.
So what I'm gonna do is guide you
through each of the sections,
each of the categories of taste on the score sheet.
And the first one is aroma, smell.
How good does this coffee smell?
Now, it's not really a key part of tasting,
but it is a part of why we love coffee.
When you grind a coffee, when you brew a coffee,
there'll be a whole host of aromas that are delightful.
Now, one of the key things about this sheet
is the use of two individual scales,
one for intensity and one for quality.
You can have a coffee that smells incredibly strong
and smells fantastic, that would score high on both fronts.
You can have a coffee that doesn't smell that intense,
but it does smell pleasant.
Or you could have something that smells intensely awful.
You'd wanna be able to record that on two different scales.
So that's why it's like that.
A lot of coffee sheets just use one scale
that I find a little bit confusing.
Am I supposed to rate intensity or quality?
Here, you've got two scales, use them both.
Now, aroma isn't the most important thing,
but it is a huge part of why coffee's enjoyable.
And if there are specific aromas that you catch,
it's a good place to note them down.
But don't worry too much
if you can't put your finger on an exact aroma.
Let's talk about acidity.
Acidity is by far the most complicated, controversial,
difficult, problematic aspect of coffee.
Coffee professionals love acidity in coffee.
And it happens for a whole host of reasons.
And often it ends up being a little bit of a disconnect
between them and a wider audience
who maybe finds the idea of sour coffee to be unpleasant.
Now, acidity is just one of the best parts
of the food that we eat and drink.
It provides that kind of freshness, that crispness to fruit.
It gives that beautiful contrast to rich fattiness.
It's a wonderful thing,
but we don't think about it that much most of the time.
Now, you'll perceive acidity
around the sort of sides of your tongue.
It's actually detected all over your tongue,
but you sort of feel it along the sides there.
And in coffee, it can be a really good thing
or it can sometimes be a really bad thing
because acidity, well, in English, we have two words for it.
We have acidity and we have sourness.
And sourness has a kind of negative connotation.
Acidity can be bad.
Not many people enjoy drinking lemon juice.
It's too sour.
It's too acidic, but lemonade's fantastic.
A good sort of fresh, crisp green apple
is fantastic acidity.
If you like sour candy, you love acidity.
It's a wonderful thing,
but you want it to be a positive acidity, a fresh acidity.
You want it to feel bright and crisp and fresh
and not harsh and sour.
So when you're assessing acidity,
the easiest way to do that is back to comparative tasting.
Does coffee A feel more acidic than coffee B, right?
Just a quantity assessment first.
And then secondly, well, which acidity do I enjoy more?
Which one feels nicer?
Which one leaves my tongue feeling good?
Which one maybe leaves it feeling a little sort of
a dried out, which one's making me salivate?
These are kind of nice ways to begin to assess acidity.
One quick note, there is quite a common phenomenon
in the general population,
which is called bitter-sour confusion,
where a lot of people, especially when tasting sour coffee,
will describe it as bitter because it's unusual
to most people to describe a coffee as sour.
So sour-bitter confusion is pretty normal.
Again, if you're perceiving it strongly
down the sides of the tongue,
if it's causing a little bit of salivation,
it's likely to be acidity.
Now, I've come across sour-bitter confusion quite a lot
in my professional life.
Typically, it happens somewhere like a restaurant
where a diner will send back an espresso
for being too bitter.
And that shot was definitely not over-extracted.
The machine is nice and clean.
The roast is not dark.
How is that a bitter shot?
You kind of tear your hair out.
Chances are, it was just a very sour shot
and there's bitter-sour confusion at play.
And that's the language that someone will reach for
to describe what they don't like.
Let's talk about sweetness.
Now, generally, in our day-to-day lives,
when we talk about sweetness,
we're probably referring to a simple sugar
or a sweetener designed to replicate the sweetness
of a simple sugar.
Something like sucrose, which is table sugar,
or fructose, found in a fruit,
that kind of very obvious, very sweet sweetness.
Now, there is no simple sugar in coffee.
Coffee is not naturally sweet in that way at any point.
You can tell this because if you take a cup of coffee
and you add even the tiniest amount
of just table sugar to it,
you can immediately tell that coffee is sweet
in a whole other way.
So here, when we talk about sweetness in coffee,
it's actually a much more complicated,
more complex kind of definition of sweetness.
You know what sweetness tastes like.
I know what sweetness tastes like.
And so for many people,
when they taste coffee for the first time,
they're like, well, that's not, that's not at all sweet.
But sweetness in coffee tends to be
this kind of slightly complicated composite
of a whole host of different things.
Acidity can add to sweetness in a funny way.
It can kind of highlight that.
It'll be about the kind of flavors
and aromas that the coffee conjures.
It'll be also about the kind of texture
that the coffee gives.
Sweetness generally comes from ripe fruit
when the coffee was grown and harvested.
It comes from good processing and good roasting,
and ideally good brewing as well.
So there's no doubt that some coffees
definitely feel sweeter than others,
but don't go looking for a traditional obvious sweetness.
It's a different kind of thing,
and it is much harder to quantify.
But as you go back and forwards between coffees
and you think about them, which one feels sweeter to you?
Which one feels more complex, more whole?
So the next key characteristic of coffee
that I want you to assess is body, right?
And this is a kind of a funny word
that we could use, texture or mouthfeel.
None of them are fantastic.
And it's a really key characteristic of coffee
that I feel is not really been embraced
by the kind of modern specialty coffee movement.
It feels like a classic kind of second wave thing
to talk about texture,
whereas we really just want to talk about flavor.
But the texture, the mouthfeel, the body of a coffee,
how it feels in your mouth is so important.
You obviously could tell the difference
between skim milk and whole milk, right?
That there's a huge textural difference there.
One feels thin, one feels rich and full.
That's the kind of thing I want you to think about here.
Is this coffee light and almost like tea,
or is it kind of heavy and full and rich and almost chewy?
Like, it's a very nice point
to compare two different coffees.
Like which one feels bigger, richer, fuller?
Now you can have coffees that have a lot of mouthfeel,
but you may not like that mouthfeel.
At the most extreme end, Robusta as a species,
if you taste that, that will have a ton of body and texture,
but it's not a particularly enjoyable one to me anyway.
Some people certainly like it more than I do,
and that's okay, but it's certainly one to consider.
Now, when it comes to assessing the sort of texture
or the mouthfeel of a coffee,
it's where I actually really prefer
to use cupping as a brew method.
If you say use a paper filter,
that tends to sort of homogenize mouthfeel
in quite a frustrating way.
It's much harder to discern
between small differences in mouthfeel
with paper-filtered coffee.
With a cupping where there's no filtration,
light, delicate coffees still feel very light and delicate.
Heavier, richer, fuller coffees
definitely feel that way too.
So that's why I'm a big fan of the cupping method
to help develop language around coffee tasting.
So the last category to talk about
on this section is finish.
And that's really, what are you left with
after swallowing that coffee, right?
Like, does that feel good?
Does that feel bad?
Is it a harsh and pleasant finish?
Do a whole bunch of pleasant flavors
slowly develop and sort of build over time?
What are you left with?
Is it a nice taste or a bad taste?
Do you like the aftertaste or not, right?
Some coffees will almost disappear, right?
You'll swallow and you'll be left
with really kind of nothing there.
That would be scoring low on both quantity
and for me on quality as well.
There might be a brief finish
where it's lovely for a second, but then goes away.
It's quite a tricky thing to do
if you're tasting multiple coffees.
It needs a little bit of patience
because you constantly want to go back
and compare and contrast.
So take your time here.
You can taste coffees all the way down
until they're pretty much room temperature.
So there's no rush here.
You've got at least 30 minutes to do so,
but don't keep bouncing backwards and forwards
when you want to score this.
Taste it, let it sit 30 seconds a minute
and really decide how you feel.
There's one more category left
that I want to talk about, which is flavor.
But before that, I just need to tell you
about this video's sponsor.
Skillshare is an online community
full of thousands of classes
covering all sorts of different entrepreneurial
and creative skills.
Now I'm a Skillshare premium member,
which costs me $10 a month
and it means I have unlimited access
to all of the classes they have to offer.
For me, that's hugely useful.
I want to learn about things that are relevant to my career,
relevant to YouTube, to making better videos
and there's tons of information on filmmaking on there.
At the same time, there's lots of other things
that really just interest me
that are just fun to learn about.
I love being able to dip in to say a quick night skills class
and pick up one or two things
to take into my everyday cooking.
I think Skillshare is incredibly affordable,
but if you want to try it out,
then use the link in my description down below.
You can get two months of free Skillshare premium
unlimited access to all the courses that they offer.
Imagine what new skills you could acquire
in the next 60 days.
Now flavor is undeniably the category
that gets people the most excited
because being able to accurately describe
the flavors of coffee makes you feel like a pro.
The description of flavor amongst professionals
can easily get frustratingly competitive.
People are trying to call out
the most specific descriptor they can
and I don't think that's particularly helpful.
I would say that there's a few key kind of groups
of flavors that are worth paying attention to
that will help you understand what you like
and what you don't like.
Now there are flavor wheels out there
to help you narrow down your descriptors
to something quite precise,
but I don't want you to feel like you have to use
a precise descriptor for it to be accurate.
I get quite frustrated by our industry's obsession
with very specific descriptors
that are reliant on whoever's tasting that coffee
having the same water, brewing the same way
from the same batch that they tasted.
Coffee is a moving target
and I think very specific descriptors
are probably intimidating to some people,
frustrating to others, pretentious to others still.
So let's just talk about some broad characteristics.
So let's talk about a kind of the fruity category
of flavor descriptors that people use.
Now this is just a personal theory thing,
but I would say there are broadly speaking
three categories of kind of fruit descriptors
that you'll see in coffee.
At one end, you might see those kind of fresh fruit
descriptors that cover things like berries,
things like stone fruits, things like apples or pears.
And then in the middle, you might have what I might call
the kind of cooked fruit characteristics,
things that are like jammy,
things that are like kind of baked kind of pies
or that kind of stuff.
You'll see people refer to sort of cooked fruits sometimes.
And then on the other end,
there are those kind of tropical
through to kind of fermented fruit flavors
that are really quite different to all of the others
that we've talked about beforehand.
For me, these are kind of tied to acidity.
If you have a sort of medium to high level of acidity
in a coffee, you're probably gonna wanna start
hunting around for a fresh fruit descriptor.
That's the time in the real world where we get
high sweetness, high acidity is in fresh fruits.
And that's what your brain is probably thinking
about something in that category.
Is it berry-like?
Is it grape-like?
Is it kind of appley and fresh and crisp that way?
Or is it maybe more like a plum or a peach or something
that kind of sweet acidic combo there?
If the coffee has a little bit lower acidity,
then yeah, I would generally look for more
of a kind of cooked fruit descriptor.
I think those are really helpful sometimes.
Generally, when you cook fruits down,
you do diminish their acidity,
which is why if you're getting that kind of aroma
and flavor of fruit, but you wanna describe it well,
I think cooked fruits are a good place to go.
On the other end, you've then got categories
like kind of tropical fruits
or sort of slightly fermented wild kind of things there.
It can cover things like strawberries,
even though that really should sit right in this end,
but that kind of aroma of strawberries
is often common in things like naturally processed coffees.
Or you might have coffees that have had
a much longer fermentation that's kind of skirted,
things getting a little too wild,
and you might use descriptors like mango or pineapple
for those kind of coffees.
Generally speaking, this category of flavor
is a little bit of a love-hate thing
with both consumers and professionals.
Some people really love naturally processed coffees
that have these kind of characteristics.
Some people really, really, really hate them.
Now, there is one category of flavor
that if I was being fancy,
I would call the kind of Maillard
and caramelization family of flavors.
If I'm being less fancy,
I would say it's the things that have gone brown
and are now delicious category.
This would include things like kind of caramels
or chocolate or toast or biscuits
or things that have got baked,
things that have been roasted
in a delicious and kind of sweet way.
Coffee undergoes a whole host of very similar reactions
to other things that are roasted or baked.
And so using those kinds of words,
I think are very good descriptions of coffee.
Typically, you might wanna be trying to describe
the particular kind of sweetness that a coffee has, right?
Is it more like a kind of maple syrup?
Is it more like a caramel?
Is it more like a toffee?
Do people know the difference
between toffee and caramel anyway?
Who knows?
I don't want you to be really specific in this stuff.
It isn't helpful because you'll end up chasing a thing.
If one specific word pops into the back of your brain,
write it down, keep it, grab it.
It's really useful when that happens,
but don't feel you have to get that specific
for every single thing.
Now, it's perfectly acceptable to write down descriptors
for things that you don't like here as well.
If there is a bitterness that you don't like,
if there's a burntness that you don't like,
if there's a kind of rubbery flavor that you don't like,
if it tastes like earth or wood or mushrooms or vinegar,
or it's just something unpleasant,
it's okay to pay attention to the things that you don't like
as much as the things that you do like.
Now, on this little score sheet,
there is, at the end, a place for a score.
Now, I'm not a huge fan of scores in general,
but it is a nice place to kind of summarize
how you feel about a particular coffee, right?
Like, just give it an emotional score.
I think that's okay.
In coffee, we score in a much more structured way
where there's lots of different categories
contribute scores to a final score.
Those are useful for some people.
They're a little problematic for others.
Here, I just want you to have somewhere
to try to make a note of your favorites
for the things you didn't really care for
and for the things in between.
So I did just want to touch on one final characteristic
that isn't really discussed in typical coffee tastings
or all coffee scoring sheets.
That's bitterness.
Now, as an industry,
we're not very comfortable talking about bitterness
because to us, bitterness is failure.
We think that one of the key sort of selling points
of specialty coffee is that it is much, much, much less bitter
than commodity coffee, than commercial coffee.
But there's still some bitterness there, right?
There are undeniably bitter compounds
in every single cup of coffee,
and it's okay if you want to talk about that.
It's okay if you like that.
For us, bitterness is kind of a failure.
It's a failure of roasting.
It's a failure of brewing.
We don't really want to talk about it, even if you like it.
And I'll be honest, it's true for me.
If I'm doing a public tasting,
I really won't talk about bitterness
until someone raises the question.
But it's okay if you like it.
It's okay if you want to take notes about it.
I just wanted to explain why, as an industry,
we don't really talk about it.
So go, go and taste.
Go and compare and contrast.
Take a bunch of notes.
Don't settle on anything
until you've had a chance to taste it
right the way down until it's cool.
You're gonna change your mind
about how you feel several times
in the course of one tasting.
That's totally normal.
Now, I don't say this very much,
but do please make sure you're subscribed
because there is something very fun,
very silly, very big, very cool coming very soon,
and I don't want you to miss out.
So if you can, please subscribe.
I'll just say thank you so much for watching,
and I hope you have a great day.
