A Beginner's Guide To Buying Great Coffee

James Hoffmann
3 followers
10 Video Views·Apr 15, 2023
Welcome to today's video
and the beginning of a series of sorts,
a beginner's guide to coffee.
And this video is a beginner's guide to coffee buying.
Now, I know you know how to buy coffee,
but what today's video is all about
is helping you explore the world of coffee
more easily, more enjoyably, with less mistakes.
Here's the thing, if you have found a coffee that you love,
be it a coffee roaster or a coffee brand, that's great.
I don't want to stop you drinking that thing.
I'm not gonna tell you what to drink today.
But part of the joy of coffee is the diversity of flavor.
And whatever you're enjoying now,
there's something, something out there
that I think you could enjoy even more.
But what I don't want you to do is experiment, gamble,
buy something that kind of looks good and then hate it.
That's the goal today.
Help you buy stuff that you're likely to really enjoy
and avoid stuff that you're likely to really dislike.
We're gonna break this down into three sections.
Part one is gonna be the kind of golden rules
of buying coffee.
Part two will be where to buy coffee
and the pros and cons of each.
And then part three will be about kind of decoding
a bag of coffee, decoding the label on a bag of coffee.
What are they trying to tell you?
And how do you match that and marry that up
to what you want?
Before we begin, I should disclose a couple
of very important ways in which I am biased.
Firstly, I have a strong preference
and I'm a big advocate for specialty coffee.
If you're watching this and you don't like specialty coffee,
that's okay.
This is still a useful video for you,
but just know that I have a very strong preference
towards it.
Secondly, I also co-own a coffee company.
Now, none of our products are in the video today.
There are no links to our products
in the description down below,
but you should know and I should disclose this
right at the start.
So let's begin.
The golden rules for buying coffee.
And the first one, you probably know.
Buy fresh.
But what does fresh mean?
Now, coffee after roasting declines
in a pretty steady way over time.
It loses its aromatics.
They kind of float off into the atmosphere and escape.
And you also develop some unpleasant flavors,
things go stale and they begin to oxidize.
And so a combination of those things
is what happens when coffee stales and goes off.
It's food safe for a really, really long time.
Some of you might have seen,
I've drunk coffee from the 1950s
and while I wouldn't necessarily recommend it,
yeah, coffee lasts a really, really long time,
but it's not at its best.
Now, typically coffee will be dated
in one of two different ways.
Specialty coffee typically will offer you a roast date,
the day on which it was roasted.
And that's pretty useful.
You know how old the coffee is exactly.
However, if you're selling a product through a supermarket,
supermarkets don't want you to put a roast date on there.
They hate roast dates.
They want a best before date.
This is often 12, even 18,
sometimes 24 months after the roasting date.
So you don't really know when the coffee was roasted.
This is not a choice that the roasters get to make.
Really, this is a choice from supermarkets.
In fact, here on the table, I've got the same coffee,
one from a supermarket and this has a best before date
and the same roaster, same coffee bought directly from them
has a roasted on date.
So understand this is a little bit confusing.
Where you buy it will impact the information that you have.
More on that a little bit later on.
Today, we're gonna cover coffees
for both filter coffee drinking and for espresso.
And what gets confusing about the messaging of fresh
is that fresh isn't always the best.
Now, when you roast coffee, a lot of CO2 comes out.
That's why any bag of coffee will have a little valve on it
that you can squeeze the gas out of.
Now, when it comes to espresso in particular,
fresher isn't always better.
Because there's a lot of CO2 in very fresh coffee beans,
when you try and brew them as espresso,
a lot of gas comes out in this pressurized environment
and it can make for a disrupted brewing process.
It's harder to brew really, really fresh coffee.
And many people rest the coffee for seven to 10 days,
sometimes two weeks, if not sometimes longer
to make it a little easier to brew for espresso.
With filter coffee, it's less of a concern.
A day or two, fine.
You know, it's pretty easy to brew from that point onwards.
It gets a little bit easier the older it is.
And you're trying to hit a kind of window
of anywhere from a week to six weeks
in which it's gonna be at its best.
And speaking of at its best,
we need to talk also about ground coffee versus whole bean.
I will always, always, always advocate for whole bean coffee
for a couple of reasons.
Firstly, it's better value for money.
With ground coffee,
they'll often pack it in a protective atmosphere,
but once you open that bag and air gets in,
the clock's ticking and you might have one or two days
to enjoy it at its best.
Yes, it's still drinkable.
Yeah, it's probably okay for a little while more,
but you're not getting what you paid for.
Whole beans last much longer.
And when you grind them, they begin to degrade,
but if you grind before you use them,
you're just gonna have a better time.
It's better value for money to buy whole beans.
And secondly, grinding coffee
is one of the great pleasures of life.
You know, I don't want people to miss out
on having their morning be that little bit more
aromatic and enjoyable.
As final guidance, for whole bean coffee,
anything that's a kind of light and medium roast,
I think is generally fine four to six to eight weeks
after roasting, depending on how you're storing it.
If it's pre-ground, it's not gonna be that case.
And if it's a darker roast,
I would say maybe four to six weeks maximum,
because darker roasts go stale a little bit quicker.
The second rule I'm gonna give you
is to buy traceable coffee.
Buy coffee from as distinct a place as you can.
That might be a single farm.
That might be a cooperative of growers.
That might be a region in some cases.
But historically, coffee was just sold by country of origin.
And you'd be skeptical if the wine you bought on the shelf
just said France.
That's not enough, right?
You would want more.
Which region is this from at the very least?
Same with coffee.
Just because a coffee is from Guatemala or Colombia,
well, it doesn't really tell you that much
about how it's going to taste.
There's huge variation within
just about every single producing origin
of flavor, of styles.
So knowing what country it's from isn't that useful to you.
It's a little useful, but it's not that useful.
If you can't tell where in a country a coffee is from,
it's not particularly traceable.
Now, the secret sort of shortcut of traceable coffees
is that adding traceability to a coffee,
keeping it separate all the way from a farm or a co-op
to you, the consumer, costs money.
It adds cost to that product.
And that will only be done in situations
where that coffee is good enough
in terms of its taste and its quality
to merit a premium price.
There's no point keeping a coffee
that doesn't taste very good traceable all the way through
because it doesn't have the value necessary
to kind of return on that investment.
So that's why traceability, I think,
is a nice little shortcut to quality.
I don't want to tell you how much to spend on coffee,
but I would say that spending more
buys you generally better quality, better tasting coffee,
and more of that money is likely to go back to the producer.
So I'd obviously encourage you to invest a little bit
in the coffee that you drink.
This last tip, it's not really optional,
but it's a kind of complicated tip,
and that's to buy seasonally.
Here's the deal.
Different countries around the world
harvest coffee at different times.
This means that the raw coffees are arriving
into kind of consuming countries
at different times of year.
Raw coffee lasts longer generally than roasted coffee,
and a roaster may carry a coffee
from anywhere from a few weeks to six to eight months.
Classically, roasters would carry a coffee all year round.
They would have a Guatemalan offering 12 months of the year,
even though for three, four, sometimes five months,
that coffee wasn't very good
because the raw coffee was a little bit old.
Specialty has embraced seasonality,
which means that you may only see coffees
from certain origins for six months of the year.
I'm not gonna ask you to pay attention
to which country is harvesting when
or understand shipping dates or that kind of stuff,
but do look to buy from places
where the offering changes reasonably regularly.
If they're doing that,
if they have different products on the shelf quite often,
while that can be initially frustrating,
it's actually a good thing.
It means that the raw coffees are nice and fresh
and you're gonna get the best possible experience.
Now let's talk about where to buy coffee.
For this, I'm gonna say there are three
kind of places to buy coffee.
One is the supermarket.
Two would be a cafe or coffee shop
or a shop on the high street, let's say,
or in your neighborhood.
And the third place would be online.
We need to talk about each of these
because they impact the offering and your options
and the way you should approach buying in those places.
So let's start with the supermarket, right?
It has a couple of big advantages.
Firstly, for most people, it's incredibly convenient.
They're often visiting or buying for the supermarket online
or it's a part of your week,
it's a part of your kind of routine day-to-day.
And secondly, things there are generally cheaper.
Supermarkets compete with each other.
They're happy to use their size and their scale
to diminish their profits.
And so typically, products in the supermarket
are as cheap as they're likely to be anywhere.
That's the good news.
Here's the bad news.
Supermarkets do not treat coffee like fresh food.
As I said before, they don't want you to think
about when that coffee was roasted
because you might pick up a bag and think,
oh, this is two months old.
But if they give you a best before date,
well, you might think,
oh, I've got 10 months left to use this product.
Now, the way supermarkets work
is that they may buy from a single supplier
that goes into a centralized distribution center
that eventually goes to the individual supermarket,
goes onto the shelf,
works its way slowly forwards to the front of the shelf,
and it can take months from it being produced
to it being sold.
So freshness is really, really, really difficult.
You can buy good quality, traceable coffees there,
well-roasted coffees that I would say are good coffees,
definitely worth drinking,
but know that the trade-off is freshness.
So now let's talk about coffee shops.
And right now, as coffee shops around the world
begin to reopen in many places,
this is a great way to support them.
I just wanna put that out there now.
Now, coffee shops have some advantages.
One, you often go to them,
so there's a convenience factor there.
Two, there's the opportunity for a conversation.
You can talk to someone and say,
I like this kind of coffee,
this is a brand I like,
or this is an experience I had that I liked.
What can you recommend?
And a good coffee shop should be able to help you.
Now, in terms of freshness,
their product typically will be actually pretty fresh.
It may not be as fresh as buying online,
and we'll come to that in a second,
but if you need coffee to use right now,
coffee shops are perfect.
Chances are that coffee is five, six, seven days old,
and they certainly will have something
that old that you can buy.
It's beautifully fresh, perfectly ready to brew,
and you can take it home
and have a delicious cup of coffee.
Oh, one more thing.
Don't forget that coffee shops
are often serving the coffee they retail.
You know, there may be an opportunity
to try before you buy, taste something,
or buy something, drink it, really enjoy it,
go back and take a bag of that home
to enjoy in the morning.
Big fan of buying from coffee shops.
Now, let's talk about online.
Now, online gives you probably the most variety.
It's often competitive in price.
You're buying directly from a roaster,
and that means in many cases, though not all,
but in many cases, they will roast your coffee
once they receive your order.
They'll ship it often of the same day,
and it will come to you a day or two after being roasted.
Incredibly fresh, but like we said,
fresher isn't always better.
If you're kind of managing the freshness,
and you know you've got like a week left on this bag,
great time to buy online.
You know, like that's a good decision.
It'll come, it'll be nicely rested.
You can go into that bag next.
Life is easy, but it requires a touch more organization.
Now, often, roasters will offer things
like subscription services.
I think those are generally a great way to go.
It sort of takes away having to remember to do something.
Coffee just arrives through your door.
That, I think, is a great thing to do,
and often, for many people,
they'll go through more than one bag a month,
and so a great way to set up life
is to have one bag come on a subscription from a roaster,
and then buy one bag on top of it from a different place,
or from a cafe, or from wherever,
because the whole point that I keep coming back to
is that coffee is really, really fun,
and tasting different stuff is really, really fun.
So those are my recommendations,
and those are the impacts of buying
on each of those different places.
Now, before we move into the third section
where we decode a bag of coffee,
there's a short ad from this video's sponsor,
which is Skillshare.
Skillshare is an online learning community
full of thousands of classes
for creative and curious people like you and me.
It's a great place to explore new skills
or deepen existing passions.
Now, recently, I've been enjoying two classes
from Zach Mulligan.
I've been wanting to refresh my cinematography skills,
and both of his classes have been fantastic.
Now, with an annual subscription,
Skillshare is incredibly affordable.
It's less than $10 a month,
and that's unlimited access to all of the classes,
and there's new ones being added all the time.
But, even better, the first 1,000 of you
to click the link down below
can get 30% off an annual Skillshare membership,
making it superb value.
So go, click the link in the description,
and enjoy a year of learning and creativity.
Thank you to Skillshare for sponsoring this video.
So let's talk about all of these bags of coffee here
and work out what they're trying to tell us
about how they taste.
Now, to kind of get a wide coverage of coffee
for the video today,
it required a trip to the supermarket,
which was always good for me to go back
and look at that enormous wall of choice
and try and work out what I wanted to buy.
And that's kind of what we're thinking about here, right?
You walk up to that big wall of coffee,
you pick up a bag, and you're like, will I like this?
So the first thing we're gonna talk about
is gonna be roast degree, how darkly a coffee is roasted.
Generally, we talk about either light or medium or dark,
and in the case of supermarket coffees,
often they don't use that language.
Often they use strength.
They'll say strength five, strength three.
Now, they don't generally put anything down
as strength one or two because no one wants weak coffee.
So their functional range is generally three through five,
which is kind of absurd, but it is what it is.
Now, specialty coffee gets very angry
about the use of the word strength on the front of a bag
because strength means something else.
Strength is how much coffee to how much water.
You know what I mean?
The more coffee you use to brew a cup,
the stronger that's going to be.
That's the correct usage of strength.
But in the defense of the supermarket coffees,
at least they're trying to properly communicate
roasted degree to some extent for people.
Specialty coffee often does not describe roast degree.
Now it does occasionally.
There's a bag here that has along the bottom here,
medium roast, right?
That's nice, but that's not common in specialty coffee.
The most common thing to see is a description
about whether it might be used as a filter coffee
or as an espresso coffee.
Now, when it comes to the term roasted for espresso,
that tells you a little bit regarding the coffee
from that particular roaster, right?
Most roasters will roast their espresso
sort of focused products a little bit darker,
a little bit deeper than they would do
their filter coffee roasted products.
However, some people in specialty
use what's called an omni-roast
where they're kind of roasting for both at the same time.
It's a kind of philosophy thing for many roasters,
their approach to espresso, to filter coffee,
to roasting as a whole.
But if you are buying specialty coffee
and it does not have any indication of roast on it,
it is a light to medium roast.
That's the default.
On the occasions that they don't roast that way,
they tend to signify that.
If there's a description of roast,
be it a country description,
which doesn't really mean anything like French roast,
or just dark roast, then you know it's different.
But otherwise, you can presume it
to be light to medium roasted.
With the supermarket stuff,
the higher the strength, the darker the roast.
And generally speaking, the lighter the roast of coffee,
the more acidity it will have.
The darker the roast, the more bitterness it will have,
and the less acidity it will have.
And specialty feels that light to medium
gives you nice sweetness, a little bit of acidity,
not too much bitterness, and tons and tons of flavor
of where the coffee comes from,
which is why that's such a popular roasting style choice
for specialty companies.
Now we need to talk about the descriptors.
And generally, specialty companies,
and in fact, more and more commercial companies,
will offer you maybe three,
sometimes more descriptive words.
Now these are doing two different jobs,
and I think people can forget about this.
Firstly, they are trying to describe in some way
the taste of the coffee.
And secondly, they're trying to entice you, the buyer,
to buy that bag of coffee.
It's half use and it's half sales.
And it's important to remember that.
In some cases, descriptions can be so odd or unusual
or kind of contrary and clashing
that that really doesn't work.
But in many cases, it does,
and things sound completely delicious.
Those words promise a great deal.
If you tell me my coffee is going to taste of caramel,
well, I expect it to taste almost
as if you've put caramel in the bag.
And it leads to further confusion with the consumer
who thinks, oh, is this like a flavored coffee?
Is this like a caramel flavored coffee?
Because those exist, but often, no, it's not.
They're trying to communicate something
about the coffee's taste to you with that word.
And we'll come to that a bit more very soon.
One other quick tip.
Specialty coffee is a little bit like wine
except for one thing.
The very highest priced wines are often the most elegant,
the most kind of classic, the most beautiful wines,
but they would be familiar and enjoyable to most people.
The highest priced coffees tend to be the most unusual,
the least kind of coffee-tasting coffees.
So it's just one to bear in mind.
If you're looking at a more expensive coffee,
have a look at those words.
Are they promising you a very unusual experience?
And is that what you want?
And in some cases, yes, it is.
And in other cases, no, it's not.
One other thing to bear in mind
is that often these roasters come up
with their descriptions for coffees
through comparative tasting.
They're not just tasting that one coffee on its own.
They're comparing it to other coffees
that they're also roasting and serving.
Now we've talked a lot on this channel
about learning to taste.
There's some information up here
if you wanna develop your tasting skills,
but comparative tasting is really useful
for kind of breaking apart the flavors of coffee.
But if you, the consumer,
don't have that comparative tasting experience
when you drink it,
it can feel harder to pull out
the berry qualities of a coffee
or the kind of ripe pear promised by the roaster.
But if you were comparing it to something else,
oh, the differences would be more obvious.
And yeah, this is kind of more pear-like in its way,
in its flavor compared to coffee B or C or D.
So know that there is an element of frustration
that's almost inevitable
because you won't have had the same comparative experience
as a coffee roaster.
But generally they're doing their best
to broadcast some key information to you
to help you really find out
if you're gonna enjoy that coffee or not.
Now, what I can't do
is know what your personal preferences are
around what you really, really like.
What I can do, however,
is understand some things that you really, really dislike
and give you some guidance there.
There are three categories of kind of coffee experience
that really trigger dislike for people.
I'll explain.
Some people cannot stand it
when a coffee is quite light bodied,
quite delicate, quite tea-like almost.
It doesn't taste like coffee to them.
And I wanna help you avoid buying coffees like that
if you feel that way.
Now, generally specialty coffee
is often of a certain roast degree.
As we said, it's a kind of light to medium roast.
And the kinds of coffees
that are typically bought by specialty companies
are often, as a default, kind of medium-bodied.
Generally, they'll use language
to highlight the texture of the coffee
if it is not a kind of medium-bodied coffee.
If it's quite light-bodied,
look for words they'll use like delicate or elegant
or often explicitly tea-like.
Look for descriptors of things being quite floral.
Those kind of words suggest lightness to you
and that's what they're trying to say.
And if they use kind of creamy or rich
or those kind of words,
then they're suggesting it
as a fuller-bodied coffee in that way.
But if there's no texture words,
I would say, as a kind of vaguely useful rule,
it's a medium-bodied coffee.
Now, the second one, I think,
is a much easier one to kind of decode.
And it's a much bigger love-hate aspect
for a lot of people with the coffee they drink.
And that is the sensation of acidity.
Some people do not want any acidity in their coffee.
The idea of an acidic coffee
is genuinely repulsive to them,
and that's completely okay.
There are other people
who want all the acidity in their coffee.
They want it to be bright and juicy and vibrant.
How do we help you there?
Well, it's gonna be fruit words.
If you see fresh fruit words in the descriptors,
there may be berries, there might be apple, right?
Those kind of fruit descriptors,
if they are referring to fresh fruits,
that coffee is gonna have a reasonable amount of acidity.
If you see berry fruits, I'd expect a lot of acidity.
If you see citrus fruits, I'd expect a lot of acidity.
If you see things like apple or pear,
yeah, I would expect a good amount of acidity.
If the words are fruit words,
but they're kind of transformed,
if they're cooked fruit words,
if it's described as jammy or candied orange, for example,
then I would expect a little acidity, but not a lot.
If a description has no fruit words,
then I would expect very low acidity from it.
If they're using other words like caramel or treacle
or nuts or chocolate, those are non-fruit words
and they are suggesting low acidity in that regard.
So that will help you kind of decode
how much acidity do I generally expect.
The third kind of key aspect around
sort of love-hate with coffee
is what I would call fermented fruit flavors.
That sounds a bit odd, but there are styles of coffee,
they're often dry or natural process coffees
where the whole cherry was dried in the sun
instead of the seeds being squeezed out
and sort of washed and kind of cleaned of their fruit
before being dried.
If it's been dried inside the fruit,
then a little fermentation can go on
and you can get these kind of funky, very unusual flavors
that are often described on bags of coffee
as tropical fruit.
If you see pineapple, if you see mango,
if you see strawberry even, chances are
there's gonna be some fermented fruit qualities
to the coffee in the bag.
If it says dry process or natural process on the bag,
expect those flavors.
Now, some people love those flavors.
They are fascinating.
They are unlike any other coffee flavors.
They are easily identifiable.
They're just kind of fun.
Other people are completely disgusted by them
and they hate them.
For that reason, it's really important to me
that people understand how to not buy those
or to buy those on purpose and never make a mistake.
If you don't like fermented fruit flavors,
and that in my experience is around 40% of people,
then I would strongly avoid dry or natural process coffees
unless they're making a lot of promises
around how clean it tastes.
There's no weird fruit flavors on the bag.
If they're saying it's just like clean or sweet
or chocolate or nuts, maybe.
But if there's any kind of fruit on there,
chances are that's not going to be to your tastes
and it's just a bit of a gamble, which I want you to avoid.
Now, I've talked a lot about the sort of theory side.
The reason I bought a bunch of coffee
is to use some sort of practical examples here, right?
Let's take what we've discussed so far
and apply it to some real world examples.
This is a Kenyan coffee.
It's from the supermarket, strength three.
So it's gonna be the lighter roast
that you would get at a supermarket
because two and one don't really exist.
It's saying zesty, citrus, and blackberry.
They are broadcasting to you
that this is gonna be a light to medium bodied coffee.
It's going to have, for them, a lot of acidity,
but those fruits are kind of clean fruit tastes.
It's not kind of funky fruit.
That's what they're telling you about this coffee.
And from that perspective,
you may love or loathe the experience that is coming.
Now, this, Lavazza Rosso,
very popular with a lot of people.
Description, rich and full bodied with chocolate notes.
So they are saying to you,
this is a heavy bodied coffee, right?
There's gonna be very little acidity.
There's no fruit words in here whatsoever.
So they're saying no to low acidity,
lots and lots of body, lots of texture.
They're saying intensity, five out of 10, roasting medium.
So you're not expecting a ton of kind of bitterness
or kind of harsher, more kind of developed roast flavors,
but it's still gonna be a big
kind of heavy bodied experience.
Back to this bag, which I picked up before.
It's a coffee from China, which is interesting.
Now, this is described as kind of nutty and sweet here.
They say cherry, almond, candied orange, and caramel, right?
It's a medium roast.
So what I'm expecting is reasonable texture actually,
like some nice body.
It's a washed coffee,
but I wouldn't expect it to be light bodied.
In addition, it has some fruit,
but they're pushing towards kind of cooked fruit,
candied fruit in a way.
So I would expect some acidity, but not that much.
And I wouldn't expect any fermented flavors in this
from their particular description.
So, you know, I can kind of understand,
am I likely to enjoy this or am I not?
So this one is really interesting to me
because this is a very big coffee company
called Taylors of Harrogate, very large UK company,
one of the biggest roasters in the UK,
doing specialty coffee.
Now this is listed right at the front as a natural.
So straight away, we know we're in for some funky flavors.
If you look at the back of the bag,
yeah, it says pineapple, coconut, and whiskey.
This is going to be a strongly fermented tasting coffee,
right?
It says natural process.
It's roasted for filter, it tells us that,
and it also says it's a light roast.
So we've got a lot of information.
Natural process coffees don't often have the same acidity
as washed coffees,
but still, if you don't like acidity,
they're saying probably avoid this coffee.
And if you don't like fermented flavors,
then probably avoid this coffee.
But if you like those two things,
this might be a pretty safe bet,
you know, if you're buying it off the shelf,
especially if you're spending a little bit of money.
Now, in some cases,
you may not have any descriptors on a bag,
but generally speaking,
specialty roasters are wise enough
to the whole fermented flavors thing
that they will say if it's a natural or not.
And so here, we know that it is a natural process coffee.
So from that word alone,
you can make a pretty informed decision
around your preferences around those styles of flavors.
And then one more, one more.
So here, it's an espresso roast.
So we'd expect it to be darker,
and it is strength four,
so they're suggesting it's gonna be pretty darkly roasted,
not all the way to very darkly roasted, but pretty dark.
Descriptors of rich chocolate, spice, and toffee.
So no fruit words there whatsoever.
We're gonna expect really pretty low acidity.
They're offering, you know, by the description,
some kind of sweetness there,
but ultimately, it's not gonna be a, you know,
a fruity or in any way acidic espresso.
I think it's gonna be more kind of medium bodied,
but relatively high bitterness and low acid.
That's the sort of subtext of this whole thing.
So that I hope is a really useful guide
to help you buy better coffees.
But now I wanna hear from you down in the comments below.
What did I miss out on?
What more information would be useful to you
when it comes to buying a bag of coffee
and feeling confident that you're really going to enjoy it?
Let me know down in the comments below.
But for now, I'll say thank you so much for watching
and I hope you have a great day.
