Why don't broadcasters value our World Cup?

Sports Zone
361 followers
2 Video Views·May 3, 2023
While Australian audiences are salivating at the prospect of a home World Cup, global broadcasters aren't as convinced.
FIFA says they're being low-balled by TV organisations in major European markets and have threatened to boycott networks rather than undersell.
Is it a reflection of market interest or a failure of broadcasters to invest in the women's game? Is it a problem entirely of FIFA's own making?
Today, Sam Lewis joins Patrick Stack to explain why the Women's World Cup is struggling to rake in the TV dollars.
That's US soccer fans after their team won the last Women's World Cup.
In some ways, they got what they wanted too.
The men's and women's teams are now paid equally by their federation.
Globally, there are clearly issues remaining.
We are two months out from the next Women's World Cup.
Australia is hosting it.
The biggest European markets still don't have TV broadcast deals.
FIFA says the offers are so poor, they won't entertain them.
They'd rather a blackout than undersell.
The story is more than a little ironic on a number of fronts.
Will FIFA follow through on its threat?
What moral obligation do broadcasters have to spend up?
How could it impact Australian football's big moments?
I'm Patrick Stack.
This is ABC Sport Daily.
Sam Lewis writes on football and other things for ABC Sports.
Sam, we are closing in on the Women's World Cup.
While we're very excited here in Australia,
broadcasters in some big European markets aren't so fired up.
What can you tell us about their interest in the tournament
from a broadcast rights perspective?
The past six months have been quite interesting in terms of this discussion.
FIFA President Gianni Infantino has regularly spoken publicly
about the fact that a number of major European broadcasters
are either reluctant to or are really not offering very much money at all
for the rights to broadcast the Women's World Cup.
The reason why this is kind of all happening for context
is that this is the first time that the men's and women's tournaments
are actually being sold separately.
Historically, both of them tended to be bundled in together.
So when a broadcaster would come to FIFA and say,
we're interested in broadcasting this tournament,
FIFA would throw them the men's and then just bundle in the women's on the side.
So there was never really any true way of measuring
what value each of those tournaments had.
So the 2023 edition is going to be the first time
that we actually get a sense of what the Women's World Cup
as a standalone product is actually worth.
But the issue is that for a lot of European broadcasters,
this tournament is operating in a very different kind of time zone.
It's going to be outside of primetime hours,
which is not going to be good for viewership
and it's not going to be good for advertisers.
So that coupled with the sort of just general apathy towards the women's game,
which continues to perpetuate across the sport,
they have been offering what Giardi Infantino claims
is anywhere from 10 to 100 times less money
for the Women's World Cup broadcast rights compared to the men's.
And Infantino has been increasingly furious about this.
He recently came out and has basically threatened
to block the broadcasts from a number of European countries.
They should help us because otherwise we'll simply not sell these rights
at these undervalued prices to them.
And the European public will not be able to watch the Women's World Cup,
which after the success of the last tournament in France,
after the success of the Euro, would be really, really a pity.
If they continue to lowball their offers,
because he believes that the time is right and ripe
for all of these organisations to finally be valuing the women's game
in the way that he believes that it should,
which as we'll get into is absolutely dripping in irony.
So it's a really interesting time.
Sam, that feels like a blunt instrument, you know,
real sort of cutting off your nose to spite your face areas from Infantino, no?
Yeah, absolutely.
This is a problem largely of FIFA's own creation.
And as I've written for the ABC Sport website today,
there are so many layers of hypocrisy that are kind of threaded throughout this.
Like the first and probably the most important is the fact that over time,
FIFA's own undervaluing of women's football has permeated
throughout all the rest of the ecosystem from media rights
to broadcasting to clubs to federations.
Every single aspect of football has taken FIFA's lead when it comes
to how we value and how we monetise and how we commercialise women's football.
One of the first things that we did was to create in FIFA,
it did not exist, a women's football division.
It did not exist.
It took us over 100 years to do it.
And now he's turning around and pointing to these organisations
and saying they're the problem,
when actually they've just been following the rules that FIFA
has effectively set for them in terms of the culture
and the economy of the game.
And it also seems like such a counterproductive measure
to threaten broadcast blackouts in some of the biggest markets
for women's football in Europe when you claim that your ultimate goal
is to grow the game.
That just doesn't make any logical sense to me.
It is just this blunt instrument.
It feels like a game of poker, like he's trying to just draw them out
and to get them to commit to something when he actually doesn't see
the bigger picture of the potential consequences of that.
What's really going to be quite interesting, I think,
is what happens now?
What happens in the next three months before the women's tournament
if these broadcasters don't stump up the amount of money
that he believes they ought to?
Which we don't really know how he bases that logic
or what metrics he draws upon.
But he says that the Women's World Cup often draws half the number
of viewers, at the very least, as what the Men's World Cup does.
Very successful Women's World Cup in France in 2019
with 1.2 billion viewers all over the world,
more than one million in the stadiums.
This shows the magnitude of this event, that the next World Cup
in Australia and New Zealand will be even bigger than that
with two billion viewers.
So by virtue of that metric, there should be hundreds of millions
of dollars involved in the broadcast offers from these European nations.
But that's not what we're seeing.
So is there a potential benchmark that needs to be met for FIFA
to say, yep, you're allowed to have these rights?
Or alternatively, FIFA have their own broadcast platform
called FIFA Plus where they can very readily broadcast
all the games themselves and go direct to the consumer
rather than going through the third party of a broadcaster.
But the other irony with all of that, of course,
is that FIFA themselves want to make money.
They're a profit-driven machine, just like all of these broadcasters are.
So there's an incredible hypocrisy to pointing to these organisations
and saying, you have a moral obligation to support women's football.
You have the moral imperative and responsibility to grow
this product in the same way that we are.
Broadcasters, especially public broadcasters funded
by taxpayers' money, should put their action behind their words
because they rightfully criticise football organisations
or other sports organisations for not paying equally women.
When this whole tussle between FIFA and the broadcasters
in the first place is because FIFA wants their money.
So it's just an absolutely bonkers scenario
and it's going to be really fascinating to see what happens.
The capitalists out there would argue this is a simple case
of the market not valuing the product.
We heard from the broadcasters at all about their position.
Why is it their responsibility to bid against themselves?
That's a great question.
No, we haven't heard from the broadcasters
and it would be really interesting to see what their rationale is for this.
You would assume that they will lean on old arguments
about viewership figures, about sponsorship deals,
about the fact that just not as many people give a crap
about women's football as what they do men's.
And so the way that FIFA could potentially respond to that
in terms of presenting viewership figures, consumption,
social media engagement, all those figures that are often relied upon
when it comes to this kind of argument is going to be fascinating.
But I think what both of those positions will ultimately leave out
is context and history.
People forget that women's football was banned for 50 years.
And in that time, men's football had absolutely clean air
in order to flourish, in order to embed itself in culture
and in the economy and in the traditions
and in the language of people around the world.
That's the reason why football is where it is now on the men's sides,
why it is this behemoth financially and culturally.
So women's football is starting from a lot further back.
It's trying to make up so much ground so much faster.
And as we've seen, even just in the last four to five years,
it really is accelerating beyond the speed
that I think anyone really anticipated that it would.
We had 172 countries participating in the qualifiers
of this World Cup in Australia and New Zealand.
The last World Cup in France had only 143 countries participating.
Now it was 172.
And today we have 188 countries ranked in the FIFA ranking.
So it is moving. It is getting bigger.
It is getting more impactful.
So you have to really take that history into consideration
when you talk about how we value this particular product now.
In addition to all of these attitudes,
these outdated beliefs that no one cares about women's football,
when all of the data shows that year on year,
increasingly more and more people are coming to watch it.
Ultimately, as it has always done,
women's football is going to continue to flourish.
And if these broadcasters aren't going to get on board,
then that's going to be their problem going forward.
What you're saying here, it sounds as though the women's game,
as it continues to seek pay parity,
is really going to take some pain from this overall conversation
as it seeks to achieve that objective.
I also wonder what this might mean for the future of World Cups
in men's and women's and even just generally events
across the football calendar.
Are we less likely to see big ticket items like this in markets
that don't align with big broadcasting nations as a consequence?
Yeah, that's another really good question.
Again, we need to think about the global economy of football
like a visual map where you see the conglomeration of economies
in Europe, in the Americas, but you don't really see that much
in Africa, Asia, the Pacific, these continents where football
has been chronically underdeveloped and under-resourced by FIFA
and by their own respective federations.
And yet those are the continents that have this incredible potential,
particularly in Asia.
Asia is the most populous continent on the planet
and one of the most untapped footballing communities
in the world.
I don't know why FIFA hasn't tried harder to really capitalize
on that.
You know, we're hosting a Women's World Cup in Asia.
We have some of the biggest populations in some
of these countries in our time zone.
What are they doing to capitalize on that?
How are they starting to shift the power from Europe
and the Americas, and particularly South America,
towards these other population bases that haven't really
been given that spotlight or that financial opportunity
in the past?
So I'm really curious to see how these kinds of ebbs
and flows affect these big ticket items, as you say,
but FIFA needs to really start to think about where
its priorities are moving forward.
If it cares about growth in football,
it's pretty much already hit its ceiling in certain markets.
It can't really get much bigger than what it already is
in Europe.
So where's the next opportunity?
Where is the next untapped market?
To me, it seems pretty obvious, but maybe it's not
so obvious to them.
Sam Lewis, thanks for your time.
Thanks, Pat.
Headlines.
Staying with football a moment, and not sure if you saw it,
but Liverpool manager Jurgen Klopp pinged his hamstring
while celebrating the Reds' win over Tottenham
in the Premier League this week.
He did so while trying to stick it to a bemused
fourth official, as Klopp has been bickering
with referees of late.
Aside from a pinged string, there's been other punishments.
The English FA has charged him with improper conduct
over the incident.
Here's Klopp on the matter.
Bad enough, so how is that?
Fair punishment for behaving not in the right way.
That's it.
I have pain for a few days, Mr Tierney not.
I will be ready to do what I always do,
and the celebrations, if we have something to celebrate,
will be much calmer.
The Lakers have opened their playoff series
with a five-point victory over the Warriors.
As we touched on in yesterday's podcast,
this series is also very much a study on Steph Curry
versus LeBron James.
Both shone in game one with Curry managing 27 points.
King James had 22, but both outshone by LA's Anthony Davis,
who had 30 and 23 rebounds.
Elsewhere, Philadelphia's Joel Embiid was crowned league MVP.
His 76ers will be hoping there's more trophies to come
for the Cameroon native as they chase an elusive NBA title.
New South Wales forward Jake Trebojevic
will be unavailable for the Origin opener.
He has suffered a calf injury a month out from game one
of the series, which is taking part in known rugby league
heartland of Adelaide.
Go Rams.
It's been unofficial for weeks.
Now it's official.
AFL CEO, the outgoing one Gil McLaughlin,
has announced Tassie has an AFL team license.
Now begins the fun discussion of what that might be named.
I'm Patrick Stack.
This is ABC Sport Daily produced by Poppy Penny.
Thanks to the World Trade Organization
for the extra audio used in this episode.
