Check out the full episode 1676 here: Video - https://youtu.be/ZIuhNkVDI14 “How Much Sugar Is Too Much?" LIKE this video if you learned something new! COMMENT your thoughts on this topic. SUBSCRIBE for more valuable fitness content
Next question is from Billy B3.
How much sugar a day is too much?
Anything over 27.25.
You know what's funny about this?
Actually, that's close to a number I used to try and keep my clients under.
25 was the number.
It depends on the person, but I will say this.
Here's what the studies will actually show.
The amount of sugar that you eat doesn't really matter as much as when your
calories are low, especially if you're in a deficit.
If you're in a deficit, sugar doesn't have like this crazy negative effect.
It's when you're in this calorie surplus that you start to see
problems with lots of sugar.
Now that being said, I will say this.
Sugar in my experience with clients does stimulate the appetite in a
particular, in a very interesting way.
So if I have a client that's like, Hey, I read the studies.
It's funny because Lane likes to actually counter that argument all the time.
He does, but my experience is not like that.
Now I know it's usually sugar in combination with fat.
That causes the, the, you know, the palatability and all that stuff.
But in my experience, I've had clients who've done this.
They're like, Hey, look, these were, these were like doctors who read the studies.
I'm like, so in this study, it showed that high sugar, low calorie
blood markers improved.
There was no difference between that and a diet that was low in sugar.
And I said, okay, give it a shot and let me know how you feel.
And sure enough, they came back and like, yeah, my appetite is all over the place.
And it's harder for me to eat lower calories than when I eat more complex
carbohydrates and more fats and proteins.
So that's the one thing I will say, but you know, sugar.
In a high calorie, in the context of a high calorie diet can have some pretty
inflammatory effects, uh, in, in a lot of people and cause maybe potential
issues with insulin, uh, resistance.
Do you guys have any experience?
My experience with my clients with this is that if I'm, if I'm, um, coaching a
competitor who's weighing and measuring and tracking their food, um, so long as
we stay within their parameters and the guidelines I give them, then allowing
them to have sugar in the diet is no big deal, but so long as they're following
their parameters and they're, and they're sticking to that.
If I am trying to teach a client to kind of intuitively, intuitively eat or just
change some behaviors, one of the first go-to things I do is actually cut back
almost all sugar intake because I find that when I don't do that, clients do
tend to overeat what, what, what the mechanism that does that.
I can't tell you, I can't tell you exactly what's happening that
causes people to do that.
It's just, I've experienced that with so many behavior things and myself enough
times that I just like, if I allow a little bit of sugar in my, in my diet,
will it be just like, oh, I decided, let's say, um, you know, yesterday I was moving
around a lot and I could totally afford to have that, you know, 300 calories of,
of sour patch candy.
And I haven't had something like that in forever.
And I have that something that I can guarantee happens is that night, all of a
sudden I want ice cream or the next day, all of a sudden I want a soda.
I like it.
I, my cravings changed the minute I introduced it into, into my diet.
Now I start to crave that.
And it just, and it doesn't mean that I can't, it doesn't mean I can't get buff
still or get shredded and still insert those things in the diet.
It just makes it harder for me.
It's like, now I have this other thing that I have to do.
It's already hard enough to restrict calories and stay in this, this calorie
intake and exercise on a regular basis.
Oh, now when I allow sugar to occasionally come in there, now I'm also battling this
craving thing that I know versus when I eliminate it and I stick to all whole
foods and I don't have any, the only sugar I'm getting is from, from natural
sources like fruit, whole fruit.
Yes.
Not fruit juice.
If I'm only getting there, I don't battle these things.
And the moment that I allowed in there, even if my calories are low and it's not
going to affect me and put fat on my body, now I'm battling that craving again.
And so for me, that's enough to coach clients when I'm teaching them, Hey,
let's, if that's not something you have to have in the diet, let's get rid of that.
Yeah.
For me, I mean, it's, it's just a behavior thing.
It's, it's something that, you know, evolutionarily we've been hardwired to be
rewarded like that, that signal is, is a massive loud signal of reward.
And it's, it's like, you know, once you introduce that signal you know, it's just
a natural response of like wanting to introduce that back and like keep that
into the routine because it's, it's something that just hardwired wise, like
it's, we're going to be fighting that a lot, that, that response.
And so it's, it's a very strong signal.
And regardless of this, like this nuanced talk that, you know, a lot of people get
in this debate on whether or not it's bad for you or it's toxic or, you know, it, it
leads to all these diseases, whatever, all that stuff, like granted, like calories are
a big proponent of this in terms of like it having more weight, you know, if you're
over your calorie limit and having sugar in there, it's probably more, you know, of
a problem than, you know, if you're under calories and it's in there.
But at the end of the day, behaviorally, like this is just something that you're
just going to continually fight and it could, you know, like take over a majority
of what you're consuming.
The other thing it, it changes the way fruits and vegetables taste for me.
That's the other thing I don't like about it.
So if I allow, let's say I always kept my calories under my, you know, my
maintenance.
Um, so I'm losing body fat, but I, every day I eat Sour Patch Kids in there.
My apple and my vegetables taste different.
They do not have the same taste as if I were to have no added sugar into my diet
and then I eat those things.
So part of why I don't like it either was I remember the first time that I cut sugar
out for an extended period of time and then actually bit into an apple, you know, or
had some asparagus.
The food, the food actually tastes richer to me when I'm not adding any sugar.
If I'm letting sugar in the diet on a regular basis, it changes my palate.
Yeah, the sweet, the perception of sweet is very powerful and it, it can
definitely, you definitely build a tolerance to it, don't you?
Um, and everybody experiences this again.
If you eat lots of sugar, you'll find that sweet.
In fact, uh, artificial sweeteners are several hundred or thousands of times
sweeter than sugar.
And I've worked with enough clients who have lots of artificial sweeteners and
prefer the flavor of them to sugar because it's actually sweeter.
I've actually had people tell me that when they drink a soda with sugar, it
doesn't taste as good as the diet Coke.
And I think it has to do with my personal opinions that have to do with that
perception of, uh, of sweetness.
I mean, evolutionarily speaking, Justin, you know, sugar in its natural forms was
probably pretty rare.
Okay.
So finding lots of fruit, not that you actually planted in, I'm talking about
before agriculture, when for most of the time humans were on earth, pretty rare
that you'd walk around and find a apple growing or some berries.
And by the way, the apples and berries and fruit that we have today has been
modified and bred to be much higher in sugar.
Apples were full of seeds.
There was very little meat, you know, strawberries looked very different size
too, by the way.
Yeah.
And it weren't nearly as sweet.
We, I mean, carrots near, not nearly as sweet.
Like everything was not nearly as sweet.
So it was one of those things that was, we just didn't get a lot of, I mean, honey,
maybe, but honey, you had to go kill, like battle a bunch of bees in order to get to
it.
And if you look at, you know, modern hunter gatherers, it's a big deal to get
honey.
It's just not something you see quite common.
And, but it's, but it's a very quick source of energy.
So it makes sense that it would trigger these behaviors in us or these feelings
that we were going to go seek it out because it's a very quick source of
energy.
So that's, that's for me.
I see that it changes people's behaviors, but the studies do show that all the
negative effects that come from sugar, if your calories are low and you're getting
adequate protein and fat, not nearly as big of a difference when your calories are
high, though.
High sugar plus high calorie is problematic.
That starts to look like it causes lots of problems.
And the people I find that are most staunch about defending sugar are addicted to
it.
That's I swear to God.
Yeah.
It's like you have products they're trying to sell that have a lot.
Well, like what I see, I late lane always talks about this stuff, right?
So he, he's, he defends sugar a lot because of how many people have demonized it.
Right.
Which I'm not pro that either.
Right.
I'm not pro demonizing sugar either, but making people aware of its addictive
properties or how it could change the cravings or change your palate, I think
it's very important.
And the people that get behind them, like, yeah, **** those guys.
And then you click on their thing and it's like videos of them doing sour patch
kids and deadlifts.
And like, dude, you're so funny.
You know, or donuts every single day.
It's like you, people want to, it's like the whole squatting thing, like
telling people not to squat.
I hate that.
I don't like that messaging.
And I remember when we first met lane, that was one of the things that we would
challenge him a lot on is that it's not that I think he's wrong.
I actually, he's right.
What he's saying is right.
But I also come from the place of training a lot of people, regular people
that are trying to create better behaviors in their life.
And could you do it with having sugar added sugar and candy every once in a
while?
Absolutely.
Is it going to be more difficult?
Fuck.
Yes, it will.
Yeah.
Usually the people eat a lot of sugar are not getting it from whole fruit.
Are they?
Yeah.
They're getting it from, from other things.
And I tell you what, it definitely feels different to eat 70 grams of processed
sugar in candy or in a soda than having a, you know, starch, 70 grams of starchy
carbohydrates.
It feels different on the body.
I think most people would agree with that.
It gives you totally different feeling.
Yeah.
You like the information in this clip.
You guys are going to love the information in this full episode.
Make sure you subscribe and check it out.