1780's Dutch Oven Pot Roast with Bacon, Sour Cream (?), and Carrots!

Cooking Traditional
465 followers
161 Video Views·Apr 18, 2023
So today's main ingredients are sirloin and bacon. What could possibly go wrong?
Thanks for joining us today. So we've been working through this series. We're trying to understand
North American food today and we're going back into history and we're looking at these other
cultures that influence our cooking today. This recipe is from 1787. It's from a German cookbook,
the kind of cookbook that possibly German immigrants would have brought with them and
you can definitely tell it's related to our cooking today. Let me read to you this recipe.
Now this is translated. It's translated by the folks down at Winston-Salem, at the old Salem
site. They've done a tremendous job. They've got a couple of these cookbooks and they're kind of
translating through them. I'm not sure if this is published yet, but we've got one of these pre
works here. So let me read to you. This one's actually called roast sirloin in a sauce.
And I'll just read you the top part. We'll get to the sauce later on.
You will thickly cut some bacon and ham. In a dish, lay the pieces of bacon out and lay the
meat on top of it. Add some salt and pepper. Use a whole onion and some root vegetables,
bay leaves, some wine. Cover it up and set it on a small amount of embers. Be sure to turn it often
when it is cooked and yellow. Make some little flour yellow and put it in the broth.
Okay. So obviously these directions certainly need some interpretation after the interpretation.
It's one of those tricky things. We're trying to look at sort of difficult to understand German
writing from the 18th century and then, you know, twist it into English. And we also have
the historical way that they would have written out recipes. So you got to do some interpretation
here. So today the cut of beef we're using here, we're using a, this one was listed as a London
broil. We want something that would be a pot roast type of piece of meat that we're going to be. We
need a nice big thick chunk. And of course I've got some nicely thick cut bacon. We're going to
use a Dutch oven for this baking. This is the perfect sort of dish to use a Dutch oven with.
It didn't get really specific, but obviously when they called for something that had a close
fitting lid, that's the important part of this dish. We need something that has a nice
close fitting lid to keep this moisture and juices in. So let's start to assemble this.
We've got our Dutch oven here. Kind of pick a size that's going to work for the cut of meat
that you've got. First thing that goes in here is the bacon. We're going to take our big thick
slices of bacon. We're going to place and sort of make a bed of bacon in the bottom of this.
So we've got our bacon bed laid down there. Now we're going to put in our cut of beef here and
we'll just lay it right on top of that bacon. And now we have, let's see, it calls for some salt and
pepper. So we've got some salt here and obviously you get to choose about how much you'd like.
I enjoy my pepper, so we're going to pepper that nicely. If you really want, you could add some
other spices in here that you think would go well with the meat. Something that might be common in
the English cookbook would be even nutmeg in a dish like this. I'm not going to put in nutmeg
this time. Now it's time for the root vegetables. We've got some common ones here. I've got some
carrots, we've got some turnips and parsnips. I cut those up into, you know, medium-ish small pieces
here so that they're going to cook well. And I'm just going to sprinkle those around the outside
edges here, getting them spread out nicely. After the root vegetables, we have our onion. We're just
going to leave that whole. That's just in here for flavor and then we'll take it out. And we're going
to pour in some wine to kind of fill this up and about a cup or so of wine in here. I'm using
a sherry, which in the time period they would have called a sack wine. Very common in cooking.
They didn't specify the wine in this particular recipe, so I'm just going to a classic for the
18th century, which is a sack. This is ready to go on the fire. We're going to make sure our lid fits
on well and take this and put it over our coals. So we need a small bed of coals. I've got some
coals already cooking along here. We're going to separate out some coals, kind of make a ring
of coals that we're going to set this on. We don't want the center bottom to get too hot.
And this is a slow cook and so we're not going to have a whole bunch of coals underneath here.
We're going to have to play around with this. This is, I mean, if we're cooking in a Dutch oven.
If you're doing this in a regular oven in your modern home, hey, you're just going to place your
Dutch oven in the oven, set the temperature at about 325 and let it go for a couple hours,
depending on the thickness of your cut of meat. But this one, we're going to have to
take care of it a little bit more and watch it. So I've got a smallish bed of coals going here.
Okay, now we have to go ahead and put a few coals around the top here to keep this heat coming in
from the top as well as the bottom. Probably want to have a few more on the top than we actually
had on the bottom. Even in our Dutch oven, in our fireplace or out in the field, this can easily be
cooked out in the field. We need to continue to watch this. It's going to take another, you know,
approximately two to three hours, depending on the thickness. And there's the other direction there
that it said to make sure to continue to turn it. That was right there in the directions.
That's one of the classic things. You can kind of tell what kind of pot they intended you to
cook this in. Because of the type of cooking, low and slow with the coals, you have to occasionally
pick up your pot and turn it sort of 90 degrees, say once every five or 10 minutes, so that it gets
a very even heating underneath. And we can even do that with the top, where we can turn the bottom
one direction, turn the top the other direction, so it continues to get very even heat. Of course,
if you're using a modern oven, you don't have any problems like that at all.
We're making the sauce now. And this is a little bit different than the ones we've done in the
past. The base of this sauce is sour cream. So it says a few spoonfuls of sour cream. Let me get
some sour cream going on here. We don't, again, no, no measurements whatsoever here. So we've got
a few spoonfuls of sour cream. It says to also add some lemon juice. So I've got the juice of one
lemon here. And it also says this a few lemon slices. I'm not sure whether in the in the
original language, it actually meant the zest of a lemon or the peel of a lemon. Or I'm just going
to go ahead and go with the directions here and just put a couple of slices of lemon in it. I
know it seems a little strange. And then, again, oddly, certainly not what we would do in a modern
recipe. It says sugar to taste. Again, okay, let's add some sugar. Of course, sugar to taste means
however much we think is appropriate. I'm going to put about a teaspoon, maybe two teaspoons full
in here. Let me take this over to the fire, put it on the very gentle heat and bring this up to
a very low simmer. That should be about right. After two and a half or three hours, this meat
should be nice and tender. Let's remove the meat and the vegetables from our pot. Add a little bit
of water or beer and then sprinkle a little bit of flour in that. We're making a nice gravy. Leave
this on the fire just a very short amount of time. When it thickens up, we can go ahead and put that
on our meat to keep it nice and moist. Well, this smells tremendous. And this sauce that they had us
make up, this white sauce, very, very interesting. Certainly nothing like I've done before. I can't
wait to try this. I mean, really, smells good. These vegetables look so rich and the meat looks
great. So let's give it a try. Wow. That white sauce, very, very interesting because it's got
that lemon juice comes in there and gives us a little bit different flavor, almost like a vinegar
would do in this. Along with this white sauce, it makes it very, very rich.
And of course, we've got these wonderful soft vegetables that have been infused with this
meat flavor. And of course, we had that gravy that they had us make in the bottom of the pot
to pour over the top. So it's like really two sauces in one or sharing it so we can switch
from one to the other. Tremendous flavor. And doesn't hurt having a little bacon in the bottom
of the pot, right? So this recipe was tremendous. If you'd like to learn more about Dutch oven
cookery, this video is tremendous. And I'll see you over there.
