Energy Expert Explains How CA Penalizing Big Oil Will Cause Gas Prices to Increase | Mike Umbro

California Insider Show
1.9K followers
Siyamak sits down with Mike Umbro, an energy entrepreneur from California. Today he will explain why California’s gas prices will likely keep increasing despite the state’s recent action on penalize the big oil. #bigoil #california #gasprices
There's a reason why our gas prices are a lot higher here.
Gavin Newsom has really pushed this notion that the big oil operators are gouging the consumers.
People don't know why things are happening. They're just told they need to be angry.
The idea is that they will have a committee that's going to watch these companies, right?
They will penalize the refineries. As you remove local supply from the market,
we become prone to price shocks. It doesn't solve anything.
My guest today is Mike Umbro, an energy entrepreneur from California.
Today he'll explain why California's gas prices will likely keep increasing,
despite the state's recent actions to penalize the big oil.
Californians don't exactly know who to be upset with. It's very frustrating to hear politicians
present it and frame it as, you know, the people versus big oil.
I'm Siamak Urami. Welcome to California Insider.
It's great to have you on. Welcome back, Mike.
Thank you. Thank you for having me. Appreciate it.
Governor Newsom just passed this law to penalize oil companies.
The idea was that they're making a lot of money off us Californians.
That's why our gas prices are high. Can you tell us what happened?
You know, to take a step back and look at what happened requires us to look at
where these refineries are getting their feedstock into the refineries
and how they're running their refineries over time. And Gavin Newsom in Sacramento
has really pushed this notion that the big oil operators are gouging the consumers.
But they typically look at windows of time where they make high profits. And so the case for
price gouging really emerged in spring of last year, 2022, when oil prices jumped to $120 a barrel
as the Russian-Ukrainian war emerged and disruption on the global market became real,
a reality. And so during that window, that quarter, Gavin Newsom has cited,
the industry made $60 billion in profits, but that's a short window in time.
And so I think it's important for policymakers and for us inside or related to the industry to
take a step back and maybe look at how these refineries have worked and operated in California
over the past several years, not just windows where a high commodity price might lend itself
towards high profits. And the idea is that they will have a committee that's going to watch these
companies, right? How does the law work? Right. So my understanding is they're starting a committee
under the California Energy Commission to investigate and to monitor the way refiners
are contracting for crude oil feedstock into the refineries, the way those contracts are set up,
the price points in those contracts, the gross margins of those contracts, the refining and
the maintenance procedures in these refineries. So in the industry, that's called a turnaround.
And so they will turn around and maintain refineries based on different blends of product
coming into those refineries. That is impacted by policies. So we have special blends of gasoline
that are required in the summer months, in the winter months to reduce smog. So there are a host
of characteristics at play. And this committee to monitor price gouging is intended to distill
all of that information in the refinery complex and identify whether or not these refineries are
unfairly gouging Californians. What was shocking to me was that the committee is not clear. They're
back to the consumer, but somehow the money is not going back to the consumer if there is price
gouging. Right. Well, the way it's being presented to us is, well, the committee is going to
potentially identify price gouging. If there are gouging events or triggers or whatever they deem
price gouging, they will penalize the refineries and then they will redistribute that money back to
the people of California, I guess, presumably in a rebate or some sort of a program that
offers those price gouging penalties back to the people of California. But I think they removed
that part. They actually, when they passed the law, they actually don't have that anymore.
Right. They talked about it. They wanted to do it this way. That's how we were promised. But then
after the law was passed, it's kind of vague what they would do with that.
And there are still some uncertainties with the law. So, for example, in reading the bill,
they talk about measuring the amount of natural gas or fuel used to produce oil in California,
so unrelated to refining. And industry trade groups have said, well, Senator, I think it's
Senator Skinner who authored the bill, promised to take that language out. So there are still
some moving pieces of this piece of legislation that's been signed that still could eliminate
themselves from the final draft. There's a reason why our gas prices are a lot higher here.
Right. Several reasons. 30, 40 percent higher. Yes. Can you tell us why is it higher? Yes. Yes.
So the California Energy Commission already tracks the amount of taxes we pay per gallon
at the pump. The last reporting I've seen showed about a dollar and 19 cents that we pay in the
form of state excise tax. So California's state excise tax is the highest in the country. We pay
cap and trade and low carbon fuel standard taxes at the pump. So those are called climate programs
in the California Energy Commission breakdown. We pay storage taxes, several other taxes. When you
add them all up, it amounts to about one dollar and 20 cents per every gallon that you or I or
any Californian is filling up in their gas tank. To put that in perspective, other states might have
state excise taxes of 20 cents on average. So we're paying a full dollar more than any other
state just in tax revenue that is then sent to Sacramento. And our blend is different as well,
right? That's why it's more expensive. Is that it? That's one of the characteristics that will
be at play and is always at play. That blend of summer or winter feedstock using ethanol,
effectively growing crops as a source of feedstock to these refineries to
lower the carbon intensity of the product or lower the smog forming pollutants of these products
comes at a cost. So that will also impact. We saw that in the fall when we were switching
prematurely to a winter blend. It took a few weeks, but the price elevated 10 or 15 cents
and then dropped back down when they fully switched to that feedstock for the wintertime.
So that is always at play. So California's gas is cleaner than other countries like essentially or
the rest of the country. Allegedly. Allegedly. So there's debate about the cleanliness of growing
corn in Iowa for a feedstock for a refinery setting in California and what are the water
impacts, the fuel usage of that farming, the full spectrum of emissions from bringing that
feedstock into a refinery versus let's say producing it in the hills of the San Joaquin
Valley on the west side where it's going to go from an oil well to a pipeline to a refinery
with very few midstream or transportation emissions. So it is sold to the consumers
that it is better for the environment to blend ethanol and different feedstocks into our gasoline,
but there's nothing that conclusively says we have a better environment as a result.
It definitely costs more money, but it's hotly debated in the industry.
The old country soaps are handcrafted and long-lasting soap bars made on a farm in South
Dakota with soothing natural ingredients without harsh chemicals that can dry out your skin. They
can produce a creamy lather unlike anything you've tried before. Just a great American-made product
that will leave your skin feeling soft and smooth all day long. The soap is multi-purpose. You can
also use it for your hair. It's great for shaving and safe for pets. Every order comes with an
exfoliating soap bag. It can hold smaller pieces of soap and can prevent soap bars from slipping
out of hand. After each use, just leave the soap bar inside and hang dry. It will last a very long time.
This company does not sell on Amazon, so go to oldcountrysoap.com and reward yourself and your
loved ones. Use promo code INSIDER and get an exclusive 20% off your order. Let's support a
company that's bringing back traditional American values and American manufacturing. Now, let's go
back to the interview. Now, do you think this type of regulation will, because the industry, your
industry said that this is going to increase the cost. Do you think this is going to become
something like cap and trade where there is a committee, they're going to find these oil
companies, they're going to take the money, not give it back to the consumer and just do something
else with it? I think it could, I think it could become an ongoing situation where they're
redistributing profits to consumers. Although, I'm thinking as they get this rolled out, Governor
Newsom said it will take 9 to 12 months just to set this committee up. So, I think we're probably
24 months down the road before we really have some tangible results to review. What they're going to
find is the fact that Californians have consumed virtually the same amount of oil every year for
the past 40 years. We've consumed 600 million barrels a year in California, dating back 40
years. Despite the fact of this population growth we've had and all these more cars? Yes, so there's
more vehicles, but engines have become more efficient and then there's more EVs coming online,
but then you're charging those EVs at night potentially and you're using natural gas to do
that. So, there's still a significant amount of fossil fuels in the world's fourth or fifth
largest economy that is California. So, when you look at the California Energy Commission data,
it shows 600 million barrels a year have been consumed in California. We're the number one
state in terms of jet and aviation fuel usage. About 15 percent of the entire country's jet fuel
is consumed in California. We're the number two consumer in terms of the whole country in
gasoline. As you say, we have 20 million vehicles. We have close to 40 million people here. We drive
and we drive far distances. We drive a lot and we're always in traffic too. We're always in traffic and
it's very important to recognize those fundamental facts to the energy complex in California because
demand is inelastic and we learned that in Economics 101 that gasoline demand is one of
those things if you have to take your children to practice or if you want to go on vacation,
you're going to pay for the gasoline because you want to get to where you're going.
So, I think what the commission will find is that demand has maintained at a constant level.
However, we're taking local supply out of the economics of the equation and as you remove
local supply from the market, we become prone to price shocks and availability of these resources
can come into supply shocks. So, those things happen. Now, do you think the price of gasoline
will keep going up? I think if we're being very honest about the situation with the people of
California, the people of California are beholden to OPEC and we saw that last week. OPEC and Saudi
Arabia announced production cuts and this week we're up about 10 to 15 cents a gallon. It takes
a week or two and sometimes longer depending on how long the refinery has contracted for those
barrels, but when your supply source is 60% foreign crude as it is in California, you're going to be
beholden to the production cuts of the foreign producers and OPEC is the largest cartel in the
world. It controls the global oil trade and the only competition for the California refineries
to an international barrel traded on Brent pricing subject to OPEC production is a California barrel
and we've seen 65 million barrels lost on an annual basis in California since Governor Newsom
took office and that is a huge number. That is 180,000 barrels per day that California is no
longer producing for its people. So when you say lost, where do we get this now? So now every
barrel almost that we are shutting down in California is being replaced by South American
heavy oil barrels. So California produces what's called a heavy oil. It's about a 12 to 20 gravity
crude. It looks like thick syrup coming out of the ground. So all of these refineries in California
are manufactured and built and designed to take that oil, that heavy oil feedstock and refine it.
So California Air Resources Board recognizes this in their scoping plan released in December. They say
as we shut down California oil production, it will be replaced by South American production because
it's similarly heavy in nature. So you have to replace the barrels with something that
works in the refineries that we have and that's South America. That happens to be Ecuador, Brazil,
Guyana, effectively the rainforest that are the lungs of the earth. We're taking crude out of
the rainforest now instead of California because it's allegedly better for the environment.
But it's better for our environment than theirs, right? It's better for the local environment,
but it does nothing for the global environment. In fact, it does the opposite. We're losing
biodiversity and the ecosystems of the rainforest in Ecuador, the most biodiverse ecosystem on the
planet. We're sacrificing that and then we're taking that crude oil produced in the Amazon
rainforest. We're putting it on a tanker that burns bunker fuel, the dirtiest form of
transportation and the dirtiest way you can move. Probably not regulated at all. Totally unregulated,
not subject to CEQA, the California Environmental Quality Act, not subject to the Global Warming
Solutions Act of 2006. We're suffering extreme leakage into those environments and then we're
bringing it back into our ports on tankers, which is spewing pollution into the cities of Los
Angeles and Long Beach. The very disadvantaged communities that Sacramento is allegedly
protecting are now receiving more tanker traffic as a result of these policies, more pollution
into their communities versus a local barrel that is brought on a pipeline that runs under the city
that emits nothing straight to the refinery. And it's very disingenuous to tell the people
of California that we are transitioning to an all-electric future, because it's not happening
today. Why are we doing this? It's really about control. It's really about controlling the
outcomes of how we move as a society. When you really look at it from a holistic perspective,
you can identify the leakage in these other foreign countries, you can identify the
environmental damages, but you can't identify the benefits to the people of California, other than
the government is telling us that they need to be in control of where our liquid fuels come from
and where our electricity comes from. Do you think these leaders not understand or not see
what you just explained, that we're getting them from these rainforest areas, we're transporting
them, their emissions are probably a lot more? And I'm not an expert in this field, just hearing
this, it makes common sense. Do you think our leaders don't understand this point? I think they
understand that the people in California don't exactly know how all of this works. It's a
very complicated system. It's hard even just explaining it to you, and I'm in the industry.
So I think they're counting on the fact that Californians don't exactly know who to be upset
with. So they can say, big oil, and that'll make somebody mad. That makes someone angry that big
oil is ripping me off somehow. When in all actuality, it's the lack of competitiveness
in California, and that's pervasive throughout industries in California. You see Tesla relocating
to Texas. You see biotech moving out to Texas. You see a whole host of industries moving out because
these massive environmental policies and the lack of permitting that is taking place at the local
level really favors the major corporate players, no matter what industry it is. So it's really
tamping down competition in California, and that hurts our communities. That hurts
service companies and companies in oil and gas in Bakersfield and Los Angeles,
wherever it is throughout the state. Those 65 million barrels a year that we've lost under
the Newsom administration, that's $6.5 billion every year at $100 a barrel oil. So just every
year, we're now losing and trading that $6.5 billion to petrostate dictators in these Amazon
countries or in Iraq and Saudi Arabia, where we get most of our oil from. We're entrusting those
political regimes to safeguard the environment, to pay people living wages in their countries,
and we're not expecting the Californian consumer to put all of this together. So I think it's
political cover for them to be able to say, well, hey, it's big oil doing it to you. We're not doing
it, but we're going to look into the price gouging. I'll promise you that next November.
It's kind of that whole political rhetoric to the next election season.
And it does look green, right? It looks like you're shutting this down. It does look...
Well, that's the thing. If you physically, like yesterday, I was in Bakersfield and Taft and the
west side of the San Joaquin Valley. So when you drive through these established oil fields,
they've been there since 1900. They've been there. They've been developed over 125 years.
So that infrastructure is there. There is a lot of iron. There's pumping units, there's pipelines,
there's tank settings. All of that infrastructure is there. It's not going away. It's not going
anywhere. So we're not actually transitioning anything. We're shutting it down. And what we
risk doing when we shut it down is the total loss of that economic impact. So that's where it relates
back to political campaigning to say, oh, well, we can shut it down. It's cleaner for California
if we shut down the Central Valley or if we shut down urban drilling in Los Angeles in the
Englewood oil field. But if we don't recognize that the port of L.A. and Long Beach is the number
one source of pollution in Southern California, what are we really accomplishing? Because they're
telling us, well, we're going to transition all of our vehicles. It doesn't matter if the
top source of pollution is still pumping away without any oversight. Now, how does all this
make you feel? You've been in this field. You're seeing this. You're talking to the leaders.
It's aggravating. It's hard. I have to pause because I don't want to
say something I can't say on camera. It's really frustrating because my neighbors are asking about
it. My friends are asking about it. I'm sure yours are. People don't know why things are happening.
They're just told they need to be angry. And I don't think that's fair to a state of 40 million
people to tell them just to be angry at a big oil company, to be angry at Chevron.
It doesn't solve anything. But what I think people want to know is how Chevron is in other states,
too. Because all these companies are in other states and the price is lower.
Exactly. No, you're exactly right. And I'm not for big oil because I don't know. They might be
doing some shady things, too. I don't know. Exactly. Well, I think those are the questions
that need to be asked to the policymakers. Why is Chevron price gouging Californians but
they're not price gouging Oklahomans who are paying $3.15 for their gasoline today?
All of these programs and taxes add up. Yes, there might still be quote unquote mystery
surcharges in California. But as I mentioned, we trade on an international market. So when
a Saudi Arabia cuts production and the price of Brent crude goes up $5 overnight, there's no
competition for that barrel. And so the Californians are going to be stuck paying for that higher
priced barrel of oil because we are not fostering competition in our state when we can, when the
resource is there. And so it's very frustrating to hear politicians present it and frame it as
the people versus big oil. And why are you being vocal about it? And this is a tough topic to talk
about. Yeah, I think it's a tough topic to talk about. But I also think it's one that's worth
talking about. I think everyday people are struggling with their bills and affordability.
And this factors into literally everything we're touching and buying, whether it's groceries at
the store that are brought by a diesel refrigerated truck, whether it's someone redoing their front
yard and the landscaper coming and needing to drive their truck to the job. Whatever it is,
it's impacting all of our lives. And that's why we all need to talk about it as an industry,
as folks that are experts. And sadly, the big oil companies do not want to talk about it. It does not
benefit them to talk about it because they have a captive market. And that goes back to the demand
side being constant at 600 million barrels. We still need them anyways. They know we need them.
And I think there's going to be a reckoning even within the industry where you have
small independents and operators that are going to break away from the major corporations because
they realize that a Chevron could go develop oil in another part of the world and bring it here.
And they lose nothing. Now they might have to comply with some sort of a committee.
And there's paperwork involved with that. But there's also a huge shadow market emerging
in crude oil as a result of this war. And so there's a lot of murkiness that does need to
be investigated. But I think the Sacramento committees and the oil operators are going to
all get to the same point in all of this where none of this looks good for the people of California.
So it requires people like me to start talking about the issues that are not being discussed.
And you grew up here, right? In California.
I grew up here. Born and raised in San Diego. I knew nothing about
where gasoline came from. I go to the gas station and I fill up and that's it. But
yeah, I'm from here and it's a concerning topic. Just yesterday, I see gas stations posting gas
all the way from $5.50 down to $4.70 throughout Southern California and Bakersfield. So right
there is an example of not only is there a refining market, but there's a service station
market. And they have a role to play in how these prices are set at the pump. So I think there's so
many factors involved here that one committee is not going to solve anything. What's really
going to solve the problem is fostering competition in California, allowing the free
market and the people of California to produce the resources under our feet. And let's see how
competitive we can make it to drive down the influence of big oil. And that takes a nuanced
conversation that I don't see political extreme party, either whether it's Democrat or Republican,
they don't want to talk about what's in the middle and the moderate issues.
Mike Umbro, Energy Entrepreneur, it was great to have you on California Insider.
Thank you for having me. Always love it.
If you like the show and our content, you should go to InsiderCA.com and sign up to our newsletter
because we never know what can happen with social media and other platforms in terms of
distributing our content. If you'd like to come on the show and be an insider, you can reach out
to us at cainsideratepochtimesca.com. Again, it's cainsideratepochtimesca.com. We would love
to have you on the show to tell us what's going on in your field in California. Thank you for
watching. Please click the icon on the left to subscribe to our channel. We bring you the most
pressing issues California is facing with straightforward and in-depth interviews.
See you in the next video.
