Special thank you to Trace Dominguez for all his help on this video. Please go check out his channel for some neat science videos! https://www.youtube.com/user/TravellinTrace
In the field of psychology, the Dunning–Kruger effect is a cognitive bias in which people mistakenly assess their cognitive ability as greater than it is. It is related to the cognitive bias of illusory superiority and comes from the inability of people to recognize their lack of ability. Without the self-awareness of metacognition, people cannot objectively evaluate their competence or incompetence.
Socrates said, the only true wisdom
is knowing when you know nothing.
But that's not actually easy for humans
to do because our brains want us to think that we are awesome.
In 1995, MacArthur Wheeler walked
into a bank in Pittsburgh ready to rob it.
He didn't wear a mask.
He didn't have like a fake mustache.
He was just there robbing a bank in full view of everyone.
He even smiled at the security cameras
before leaving and going to a second bank to rob that one
too.
Later that night, the security footage
allowed the police to pick him up and take him off to jail,
which shocked him.
He was shook.
I wore the juice, he famously exclaimed.
Wheeler believed that rubbing lemon juice on his skin
would render him invisible to videotape cameras.
This is a cognitive bias at work.
And it inspired two psychologists
to create some experiments to understand it better.
Cognitive biases are everywhere.
Have you ever met someone who has one,
like perhaps during a group project at school
or during an argument with a stubborn uncle
or when you had to toil alongside that coworker?
You know the one I'm talking about.
Somebody who believed they knew things, but really they didn't.
Believing you know something you don't
is called the Dunning-Kruger effect.
It's named for the two psychologists
who, upon hearing about Wheeler's bank robberies,
formulated a set of experiments to determine
if Wheeler's juice beliefs were due
to some kind of cognitive bias.
Cognitive biases allow us to convince ourselves
that something is true, even if the reality is different.
Cognitive biases protect us from reality.
They let us process information more quickly,
and they help us make decisions more quickly.
But that doesn't mean that they are good.
Cognitive biases are essentially a subjective social reality.
The Dunning-Kruger effect is, in a nutshell,
a way for everyone to feel good and above average internally
because most of us are actually completely average.
Dunning-Kruger can help explain why
people feel that they're experts,
even though they know very little about something,
a problem sometimes described by this graph.
The vertical axis is confidence, and the horizontal
is experience.
Imagine someone spent an hour reading the Wikipedia
page about global warming, then took to Twitter
to try and school some climate scientists who have literally
spent their lives studying it.
You don't have to imagine this because you know it.
It happens all the time.
This cognitive bias is extremely common.
For example, a 1992 survey of the engineers at one company
found that 42% of them, 42%, believed
they were in the top 5% of all the engineers at the company.
But that's not actually possible.
42 cannot be 5.
Another example is driving.
One study found most people believe
that they are above average at driving.
But most people cannot be above the average.
Another survey of people aged 77 years and older
jived with that as well, most assuming they
were average or above average.
But again, that's not actually possible.
Most people have to be average because that's
how statistics work.
The psychologists who first realized
this bias was part of the human fabric
did so in four studies, humor, logic and reasoning,
and English grammar.
We'll just take one.
In the humor study, the psychologists
asked two groups to rank jokes on a scale of 1 to 11,
1 being not at all funny and 11 being very funny.
Group A was a set of average Cornell undergraduates,
and Group B was a small set of professional comedians.
The idea was to see if average people would
believe that they were above average at picking out
what was funny or as good as professionals.
After Group A had ranked the jokes,
the researchers asked them to compare their ability
to pick what was funny against the professional comedians,
to rate themselves.
And unsurprisingly, on average, everyone overrated their skills.
Remember, 50 is average, and the whole group
together said that they did 66, which
I would rank as an 8 out of 11 on our joke scale.
But this is where the surprise comes in.
Those who did the worst placed themselves
in the 58th percentile on average.
They believed that they were better than 57 other people
out of 100.
Their real score?
The 12th percentile.
They were worse than 88 other people.
These were the victims of this newly discovered
cognitive bias, the idea that people
with a little bit of knowledge or skill in an area
believe that they are better than they are.
Dunning and Kruger went on to show
that this bias exists multiple times
with different experiments, like when assessing
effective leadership, raising children,
constructing a solid logical argument, and so on.
Generally, in each study, the participants
in the bottom 25% of scores consistently
ranked themselves in the 70th percentile.
It is worth pointing out that self-confidence
is extremely important.
Self-esteem is valuable.
We should all feel good about ourselves.
That said, we should also have a good assessment
of what we're good at and what we are not good at.
For example, I'm pretty good at making science videos.
I am not very good at kung fu, farming, or financial policy.
It's easy to dismiss Dunning-Kruger as just
overinflated ego, but that's not actually what's happening.
Even ego can see its own limits, and there
are some serious examples of people not even realizing
their own failures thanks to this bias.
These experiments work not just in humor, logical reasoning,
and rules of grammar, but also have been replicated
in math skills, wine tasting, chess,
firearm safety among hunters, and medical knowledge
among surgeons.
And that's where things get really serious.
A 74-year-old woman awoke from a simple spinal fusion surgery
in terrible pain because her surgeon believed himself
to be one of the best around.
Instead, he's now in prison for life.
He's accused of maiming multiple patients
and causing two deaths.
Meanwhile, he claimed, quote, everybody is doing it wrong,
and that he was, quote, the best in the whole state.
It's pretty amazing that it took us so long
to give Dunning-Kruger a name, because it is everywhere.
The more we look for it, the more we see it.
That said, Dunning-Kruger doesn't apply to everything,
namely in areas where it's easy to compare.
Baking, for example.
If you assume you're an amazing baker, then you bake a cake,
and it's inedible, it's pretty hard to deny
that you're a terrible baker.
One paper I read said that most people who play golf
don't believe that they are as good as Tiger Woods
when surveyed.
But I would guess if we asked, they would still
rate themselves above average.
Because an online survey of over 1,700 average adults
in Great Britain found that one in eight men
believed that they could score a point against Serena Williams,
the woman ranked number one in tennis for more than six years.
That said, it's very important to point out
the Dunning-Kruger effect is gender neutral.
It applies to us all.
Interestingly, though, Dunning-Kruger found
that people at the top don't overestimate themselves.
In fact, quite the opposite.
Dunning-Kruger found the best around
tend to rank themselves below their actual performance.
Yeah, DK has two parts.
People in the bottom 25% rank themselves at near the top,
and people in the top 25 tend to rank themselves a bit lower
than their actual score.
This can help us understand why it is
hard to counter Dunning-Kruger.
In order to know you don't know anything,
you got to have to know something.
An example, if your cognitive bias
has you assume that you're amazing at driving,
but you only drive in, say, rural areas of the desert
southwest, how would you ever find out that you're bad at it?
You would need to drive around others
or take classes to learn good driving habits
or ride with someone who is objectively
considered a good driver to see what you're doing wrong
and then get that critique and recognize it and then learn.
You think many of those people who
believe they're good drivers are going to do those things?
Yeah, I didn't think so either.
In a bit of follow-up research, Dunning
has found people who are low performers, in reality,
are not good at accepting criticism
and often don't show interest in self-improvement.
He told Forbes, quote, research subjects
were willing to criticize their own previous poor skills
once they were trained up and could
see the difference between their previous poor performance
and their new and improved performance,
but to get them to train up on their own was very unlikely.
If we never change the knowledge that we assume we have,
then we can just keep on going thinking we're amazing.
Who doesn't want to do that, even if we're not?
Yay, cognitive biases.
In the end, Dunning-Kruger is a cognitive bias
that can affect anyone and everyone.
If you're actually above average at any task,
you might be undervaluing yourself.
And if you're average or below average at some other tasks,
you're probably assuming you're pretty good.
In the age of the internet, everyone
can be a quote, unquote, expert.
We all have access to infinite information.
Our minds are drawn to learn a little bit
about a lot of things.
And that little bit of information
is enough to make us weak-minded humans feel
confident about what we know, even when we know nothing.
And add to that the global platforms of social media,
and then everyone can feel like an expert,
and most won't accept any critique.
Let's face it, I have probably been one of those people,
and maybe you have too.
It's crucial in today's overstimulated world
to be able to differentiate a real expert
from an overconfident novice.
And that goes for understanding your value as well.
The key is know your talent, understand your pitfalls,
take criticism, and keep on learning.
Way back in 1871, long before we knew what Dunning-Kruger was,
Charles Darwin wrote, ignorance more frequently
begets confidence than does knowledge.
And it turns out he was right.
I wonder if Darwin would have rated himself
as being above average on that one.
Thanks so much for watching After School.
It was awesome to get to work with Mark on this.
I hope you all liked it.
If you want to watch more science videos,
check out my channel, Uno Dos of Trace.
I make a new video every week that
scratches that curiosity itch that we all have.
Here's a recent one on the golden ratio
and how it's not quite the mystical, magical thing that
was promised.