The Friendship of C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien

John Ronald Reuel Tolkien
30 followers
32 Video Views·Mar 28, 2023
Thank you for your opportunity,
And thank you for the opportunity to talk to me about my life.
I'm friends with C.S. Lewis and J.R.R. Tolkien.
I'm going to be a friend in a while.
I started writing Tolkien in Oxford.
I use Cyfarwyddwr Ysbyty Anglo-Saxon,
I don't know, Cymdeithas Gŵr,
It was 1925.
My friendship with my predecessor for 40 years,
Maybe, obviously, you were not allowed to have any contact with him.
Especially with the end of the world.
I was a lot of friends with him.
In your school years.
I was in a club of Christian friends.
I'm sure you'll be fine.
Eight years ago I met Lewis and Tolkien.
I was connected to your friendship and to you.
I've developed my responsibilities as Lewis and Christiania,
Maybe a few years before I start my club.
I was a club member and I wrote a letter to you.
Tolkien, over the years, wrote a lot about the Lord of the Rings.
I'm going to give them most of my Hobbit.
I've been trying to get into mythology.
Our first digital and Bydlaerth.
Our time is now, and we're sharing a little.
Lewis was writing a great book,
I'm not going to lie to you.
or writing,
and writing,
the number of years,
Your problem is your pain,
I'm not going to say anything about Virgil.
I'm writing digitally.
Lewis was writing a lot of his time in Tolkien and you were all part of our writers' club,
new in the area of Cymru,
Tolkien and other writers were Charles Williams.
In the first year, 1949,
Lewis was in the writing room.
o'r Llywodraeth, y Llywodraeth a'r write
I was Tolkien.
Perhaps because Tolkien was interested in the stories of Narnia,
Lewis thought he had written something about the Gherkin.
And we can't be sure
Because you have to make a statement.
In the
I'm here to see the training of Chief Weinidog Warren Lewis.
I was writing, I was writing,
Written by a large group of people
o dsgwyr a professional
in the area of Cymru,
In the course of the year, the government has taken on a new role.
For the first few years of my writing,
Tolkien and his government didn't know
O'u counsel writes, Allan,
Especially as writers of fiction,
I'm not a bad person.
The Commission has not yet adopted a decision on the application of this Regulation.
I'm helping you keep your vision alive.
I'm a little bit interested in Tolkien.
I'm interested in the subject.
It affected Tolkien's interest.
Lewis was writing.
A little help from Tolkien and the Christ.
I was working with the author.
I'm not a friend,
Based on your narrative writing
I'm not writing.
I'm writing dynol.
I was in the Netherlands.
ac, over y years,
God bless you for your chynnal skills.
Christian, you are a good man.
In addition to the above
I'm a rhetorician.
In the course of years,
Cycled Lewis's writing
write mewn writeennol
However, Tolkien did not
I'm writing to Lewis.
I'm not feeling well.
write dynol,
I'm going to Rome.
Tolkien had written about Lewis.
based on the number of sierra-daus with
I'm writing a book about dynol.
In the un part,
I'm not a writer.
I'm not a man.
Ewyennwyr dynol
Newywywywy dynol
I'm working my way.
In the name of God
In your writing,
I'm writing to you.
Lewis is writing Dynol.
This is a great book.
O'r writing this,
I'm not gonna write.
I mean write write.
I didn't write with you.
I'm writing a'r writingwyr dynol
The European Union
In the year of writing and writing in the year of gael eu
Give me a break.
I'm not sure I'm ready.
I'm not sure.
Acidicity of hysterectomy
Ac y country
Change your name.
I didn't write it.
The Commission shall adopt the implementing acts referred to in Article 5 (2).
I'm writing this.
Hyn a
Through this.
I'm not going to be able to help you.
In fact.
Other, including
With all the work you do.
If I add on with my writing,
I'm not adding a seventh to my honey.
I thought Tolkien was afraid of you.
With ideas about mythological foundations.
It had a big impact on Lewis.
I'm not sure I'm connected to my faith.
I'm connected in a way, as Tolkien said,
I'm going to use a basalenol.
I'm afraid Tolkien won't write a theologically correct story.
Maybe theology is a new language.
Tolkien had worked all over the state of California.
Our trust between history and myth and future
A better language than theirs about their future.
I was telling a story I'd do in part of our process.
I'm afraid of my future.
I was just trying to get a little more confidence.
I was there for a while.
I was on Dynol.
Tolkien had seen the story,
In my mind, I'm telling you a story.
In the case of a primary
In my mind, the story was finished.
I'm a Dino and I'm not a ghost.
So I was saying bod stori dynol,
I'm not talking about the gossip.
I'm going to be successful in my future.
I was trying to tell you a story about the dynamo in Lewis.
Tolkien was watching the story.
I was telling you a story about the dynol.
I've had enough time to live and show this.
Maybe you'll get the idea from the beginning.
Well, I'm not gonna say this to the government.
I'm not going to live.
We don't understand the meaning of life.
low dimensional systemic basis,
The Commission has also adopted a proposal for a directive on the protection of workers from the risks related to exposure to ionizing radiation.
And I also got to photograph a new model of our cosmos.
One of the most important things, I'm not sure,
I have something to say to Francis Schaeffer,
I mean, in a photo, in a letter, in a letter.
The God Who Is There.
I'm not sure I'm right.
o see life and die,
And my ideas contain information about life and dynasty,
For example, if you are someone who is involved in a dynasty,
For example, maybe you'll be able to get a job.
I'm not talking about your life.
I'm sure you could be in a very important relationship.
o fileiiau in the dinol industry
I'm not sure I'm ready to give up on the basic,
Yung. What?
And I'm sure you'll be glad to hear it.
students in the States,
I'm not sure I can reach you in the language of the world.
Now, a little more about Tolkien.
o life of the deceased, life of the deceased,
I'm not writing like I'm interested in my life.
An important factor for the impact of Tolkien and C.S. Lewis,
I'm talking about what I was about to say,
You're teaching me to love my life.
I'm making my life fun.
I thought I was working from home.
I believe in life and death
I'm not sure about them.
The following are not included in the general classification:
I'm not gonna get caught up in this.
Our lives in general, our lives in general, and what God has done.
So, for Tolkien, this is not a story to be enjoyed.
I'm not talking about a dissolving gel.
But they're actually in a diylliannol,
I'm not allowed to geographically communicate with them.
In fact, Tolkien's plan was to destroy the world.
I'm really excited to see you.
I'm very interested in you.
Er bod hann yn yn fantasi adfywogol, and I'm not going to tell you.
There's no way to deal with the most interesting thing.
Gallorotonin is used as a food additive.
I'm not a fan of the Lord of the Rings.
The Chronicles of Narnia.
I thought your plan was very important to Sir Lewis.
I was in the middle of a fight.
Our planet is Malachandra and Perilandra, not Venus.
Especially, you're the most interesting person I've ever met.
I'm not interested in the story.
Also, my lord Glom, I have nothing to do with this.
In your book the most interesting of our world until we have faces.
I was in the spirit for students plant
It's not the most interesting, it's Narnia.
Recently, I've been thinking about it.
I'm glad you liked Tolkien and Lewis.
I'm finished, my mind is made up.
I'm telling you a little bit about the effect.
From the planet Narnia, you can come forward.
O'r Narnia.
For many years, I was interested in computers.
I thought of Chronicles of Narnia.
I'm not afraid to write in a foreign language.
In a very interesting way.
I was in the spirit world for Tolkien,
I've been in love for years.
In the spirit of Lord and Rhyngau,
a'r half years
I'm developing a little bit of Narnia.
Lewis was the inspiration for the founding of Narnia.
In a few years.
And now you're spirit-liaded
I'm not going to be able to do this.
Most of them.
Fel Tolkien, you are a good man.
Lewis was in a spirited mood.
I didn't have a good spirit.
In the spirit of Narnia
The EU is a very powerful force.
You are a child.
Beth was your wife.
I'm giving you the spirit of the institutions.
You're not going to kill yourself?
I was in the spirit world,
I was doing something different.
I'm talking about what I'm doing.
I'm not going to take mordiol.
I was a son of the spirit of Narnia.
In the spirit of fel
The Commission may decide to grant a derogation from this Regulation.
I'm not uned
Hyn, Hyn and her other friends,
Try to visit Narnia.
In y Cronaegolion
for a doctorate,
I'm going to go with Michael Ward.
a'r spiritoliwr o'r book Narnia,
The Commission has not yet adopted a decision.
In your hollow stories
A Lewis was the spirit of the General.
Later, the ward announced a dissolution.
I mean, I believe Lewis.
O'r by Narnia
The general way is the way they do it.
The most important rights
This is what Tolkien wanted.
The Commission has not yet adopted a proposal.
Like many of Tolkien's spiritual followers,
Lewis is the general manager.
or De Cymru,
I'm gonna be the king of that time.
I'm using it.
It's a modern book.
Mae Ward and Dow
The body of the astrology cycle
Playing a role in the cycle
In fact
In the name of the Lord, Lewis of Narnia
a'r stories
It's not happening there.
In fact, there are ways to practice
O'r Narnia
I'm not a ghost
the general
With the old man
by a
I'm not getting any spirit from the general.
Flat,
the body,
in Wales,
I'm not going to sleep.
You're going to be in the world.
I was a planet.
through all of his dealings,
The Council of Ministers,
Especially in the planetary field.
and stories
General Lewis.
The new system
Yna,
between astronomy
It's astrology.
I was
I'm old enough to live
Un.
I was just trying to get a grip.
and y y
With the truth
I'm not going to.
Y cyffredinau,
For example,
I'm not connected to you.
In the spirit of the portents.
So you remember?
Unfaithful to your word, honey,
Remember your faith
body and cyffredinau
It's really here.
I'm not going to tell you.
In the spirit of astronomy
I'm most interested in Lewis.
My story.
Content
I'm not an astrologer.
In the plan,
and astrologers,
Mr Llyfrgell,
Mars,
Mercury,
Jupiter,
Venus,
The planet Saturn
and the Government,
I'm talking about your spirit.
or institutions
O'er the spirit of the world
softly and snuck out of the room with a beating heart,
Taking the core of the apple with him.
For the rest of the day, wherever he looked at the things around him
And saw how ordinary and unmagical they were,
He hardly dared to hope.
But when he remembered Aslan's face, he did hope.
That evening, he buried the kernel of the apple in the back garden.
Now, if you want to find out the importance of that burial of the core of the apple
And you haven't read the stories, then that's one way to find out.
Sorry, I can't read any more from the story.
Now, let's look at C.S. Lewis' importance to Tolkien, the place of friendship.
Given that Tolkien has such a great impact on his friend,
What was Lewis' importance to Tolkien?
Tolkien himself answered this question in a letter
Written almost two years after his friend's death.
He wrote,
The unpaid debt I owe him was not influence, as it is commonly understood,
but sheer encouragement.
He was for a long time my only audience.
Only from him did I ever get the idea that my stuff could be more than a private hobby.
But for his interest and unceasing eagerness for more,
I should never have brought The Lord of the Rings to a conclusion.
It seems that Lewis did not influence Tolkien in the same way that Tolkien influenced him.
Rather, Tolkien found a willing listener and appreciator in his friend.
This reading and listening was institutionalized in the Inklings Thursday night gatherings.
Who knows, if these Thursday meetings continued past 1949,
There may exist today a complete telling of some of the tales of the earlier ages of Middle-earth,
approaching the scale of The Lord of the Rings.
Sadly, for various reasons, Lewis did not persist in encouraging the completion of The Silmarillion,
especially the great tales in it, such as that of Beren and Lúthien.
One reason may have been the gradual growing apart of the two friends in the 1950s.
Lewis illuminated the nature of his friendship with Tolkien
When he wrote his book The Four Loves, which was published in 1960.
The four loves he distinguished are affection, friendship, eros, or erotic love,
and charity, or agape, divine love.
He felt that it was vital not to lose sight of the real differences that give each love its own valid character,
Even where one love merges into another.
Like when friendship between a man and a woman becomes erotic,
or when one is called upon to care for a dependent family member,
a natural affection deepens into self-sacrificing love.
Love friendship, like his with Tolkien, involved the what-you-too factor,
the recognition of a shared vision.
Friendship for Lewis was the least instinctive, biological, and necessary of our loves.
In his day, it was hardly considered love at all,
And Lewis sought to rehabilitate it as a virtue.
In his book, he pointed out that the ancients placed the highest value on this love,
like the friendship, say, between David and Jonathan in the Bible.
Lewis actually had a view of friendship that had been common throughout Western history,
and which comes over in his book The Four Loves.
This is the view that friendship is characteristic between man and man.
Yet, in his life, Lewis had friendships with a number of women,
Like Joy Davidman, whom he later married,
The poet Ruth Pitter, and the writer Dorothy Alsayers.
The ideal climate for friendship, Lewis argued,
was when a few people are absorbed in some common interest.
Lovers, Lewis pointed out, are usually imagined face-to-face.
Friends are best imagined side by side, their eyes focused on their common interest.
Friendship, as the least biological of loves,
refutes heterosexual or homosexual explanations for its existence,
or explanations that see it as based on natural human affection.
Friendship, Lewis reckoned, made good people better and bad people worse.
Tolkien largely agreed with Lewis' view of friendship,
Especially as it was reinforced by the male character of Oxford society in their day.
But he wasn't as generous as Lewis in the breadth of his friendships.
Tolkien was a family man, however, while Lewis was a bachelor for much of his life,
Even though he willingly participated in his adoptive mother Mrs. Moore's matriarchy
The Kilns, his Oxford home.
This gave Tolkien a wider range of relationships,
to his wife Edith, and to his children in particular.
An important ingredient in the glue of their friendship, however,
was their shared Christian faith, with its distinct imaginative cast,
as if the friendship had become firmly established while Lewis was still a materialist.
Increasingly, I've come to think that it was Lewis' recognition
a Christian element in encouraging friendship
That helped establish the Inklings.
Lewis was prone to describe the group as being Christian
and having a tendency to write.
A little more about their shared beliefs.
Tolkien and Lewis had a number of shared beliefs, in addition to the ones I mentioned,
derived from their common faith.
In the very foreground of their perspective,
The imagination was of great importance,
and reveals their connection with the older Romantic movement.
They saw imagination, in Lewis's words, as the organ of meaning.
That is, imagination is involved in the way we perceive reality as a whole,
whether perceiving individual things like trees, stones, hills,
or even particular people, or the world as a coherent world around us.
Imagination is not like thought, concerned with abstracting from particular things,
or from particular experiences and relationships.
Both Tolkien and Lewis' writers, therefore, valued looking at reality
in a symbolic and what they called a mythopoetic way.
Mythopoeia being the making of myth.
Fiction, for Lewis and Tolkien, was therefore a creation of meaning,
rather than a literal re-statement of truths.
It reflected for them the greater creativity of God himself
When he originated and put together his universe and ourselves.
Natural objects and people are not mere facts.
Their meaning comes from their relationship to other objects,
and from other events and persons,
and ultimately from their relationship with God.
People have a created unity, and their meaning and fullness derive from that.
Clyde S. Kilby recorded in his notes a meeting with Tolkien
that he spoke of an idea which he shared with Lewis, to quote Kilby,
that everything is unique, and every thing, however small,
When a subject of attention, of necessity becomes the center of the world,
and requires all knowledge of the entire world to make an adequate explanation of it.
It follows that what is true of things is also true of our own sensations and experiences.
If we focus exclusively on them, we lose their meaning.
In their full meaning, they point elsewhere, to what is not them,
to a whole world of people, things and places,
and for Tolkien and Lewis, to things beyond what they called the walls of the world.
The desire to write fantasy and other symbolic fiction
was fundamental to Lewis and Tolkien.
And in a letter, Lewis confessed,
The imaginative man in me is older, more continuously operative,
And in that sense more basic than either the religious writer or the critic.
It was he who first made me attempt, with little success, to be a poet.
It was he who, in response to the poetry of others,
made me a critic, and, in defense of that response,
Sometimes a critical controversialist.
It was he who, after my conversion, led me to embody my religious beliefs
in symbolic or mythopoetic forms,
ranging from screw tape to a kind of theological science fiction.
And it was, of course, he who brought me, in the last few years,
to write a series of Narnian stories for children.
Not asking what children want, and then trying to adapt myself,
this was not necessary,
but because the fairy tale was the genre best suited for what I wanted to say.
Similarly, Tolkien wrote a beatitude
In the poem I quoted from earlier, Mythopoeia,
and his beatitude was addressed to the makers of legend.
Allow me to read a brief excerpt.
Blessed are the legend-makers, with their rhyme,
Of things not found in recorded time.
It's not that they've forgotten the night,
Or bid us flee to organized delight,
In the lotus aisles of economic bliss,
Forsaking souls to gain a circuit kiss,
And counterfeit at that, machine-produced,
Fake seduction of the twice-seduced.
Such aisles they saw far away, and those more beautiful,
And those who hear them yet may yet beware.
They have seen death and final defeat,
And they would not turn back in despair,
But to victory have turned the liar,
And hearts lit with legendary fire,
Illuminating now, and dark has been,
With sunlight yet unseen by man.
Tolkien is saying that these storytellers are blessed
as they talk about things outside of recorded time.
Though they have looked at death and even ultimate defeat,
They did not shrink back and they did not turn back in despair.
Instead, they have often sung of victory,
And the fire in their voices, caught from legend,
has ignited the hearts of their listeners.
In doing so, they have illuminated both the darkness of the past
and by the day when it is bright,
To quote Tolkien, as yet by no man seen.
Now a little bit about Lewis and Tolkien's view of the other
and the quality of joy, which I'm sure you'll hear a lot more about
This quality of joy during this conference.
As well as placing this enormous value on the imagination,
Tolkien and Lewis were alike in welcoming a sense of the other.
Great stories, that is, can take us out of the prison of our own selves
and our presuppositions about reality,
Hence the frequent accusations of escapism.
As far as stories reflect the divine maker in doing this,
They help us face the ultimate other, God,
as distinct as the creator from everything else, including ourselves.
Lewis' notion of joy, which is a technical term in his usage,
features very much in his autobiography, Surprised by Joy,
and is directed to the supreme other, God himself.
Lewis and Tolkien shared this desire to embody
such a quality of joy in their work.
An inconsolable longing or longing in human experience
was for Lewis a pointer to this joy.
In fact, this longing was for him a defining characteristic of fantasy.
as it tried to capture the quality.
Joy is a strong feature too in Tolkien and valued by him,
as his essay On Fairy Stories makes clear.
Joy is a key feature of fairy tales, he believed,
part of the comfort they give.
Joy in a story for Tolkien marks the presence of grace
Coming from the world outside the story
and even from beyond our world.
Tolkien writes, it denies in the face of much evidence, if you will,
universal final defeat, and as far as evangelium, the gospel,
Giving a fleeting glimpse of joy, joy beyond the walls of the world,
"It was as poignant as grief", he added.
In such stories, when the sudden turn comes,
We get a piercing glimpse of joy and heart's desire
that for a moment passes outside the frame,
It really tears the very web of the story and lets a glow come through.
For Lewis, joy was a foretaste of ultimate reality,
heaven itself, or to put it in other words,
It was a taste of our world as it was meant to be,
Untouched by the fall of mankind and one day to be rebuilt.
Joy, wrote C.S. Lewis, is the serious business of heaven.
In trying to imagine heaven,
Lewis discovered that joy is, in his words,
The secret signature of each soul.
He speculated that the desire of heaven
is part of our essential and unfulfilled humanity.
In Tolkien, as I've already said,
The quality of joy is linked to the sudden turn in the story,
the sense of reversal of disaster,
Or in a term he invented, eucatastrophe,
Which means a good catastrophe.
It is also connected to the inconsolable longing
or sweet desire in Lewis's sense.
I could talk for a long time about how you can find
this quality of joy in Tolkien's writings,
In, for example, The Lord of the Rings.
Now, a little about how stories, from the viewpoint of both men,
It's a great way to recover and re-enchant.
Another feature of fantasy for both friends
was restoration or recovery.
Tolkien, like Lewis, believed that through story,
the real world would become a more magical place,
full of meaning.
We see its patterns and colors in a fresh way.
The recovery of a true view of the world
applies to both individual things like hills and stones
and to the cosmic, to the depths of space and time itself.
Through stories like The Lord of the Rings,
a renewed view of things is given,
illuminating the home, the spiritual,
The physical and moral dimensions of the world.
Both friends had a deep affinity, too,
in their preoccupation with pre-Christian paganism,
in which their stories are told,
with Baldor, the god Baldur, and Psyche,
Calerovo from Finnish legend,
and Aeneas and Sigurd from Old Norse mythology.
Most of Tolkien's fiction is set in a pre-Christian world,
and one of C.S. Lewis' stories,
One of his greatest stories, Till We Have Faces, is
There were, of course, important differences
between Tolkien and C.S. Lewis.
They weren't Tweedledum and Tweedledee, by any means.
But the differences weren't enough.
to overshadow their affinities,
Even when the friendship had its ups and downs
and difficulties at times,
which you would expect over a period of 40 years.
Now, both Lewis and Tolkien believed
That good works of imagination
cannot be reduced to morals and lessons,
And this is because of the way they saw
integrity of imagination in writing fiction,
The way that the laws of such creativity
should be followed.
This does not mean that lessons cannot be derived
from the stories.
And, in fact, they believed that the truer the work,
The greater the applications that can be drawn from them.
In terms of a joke,
One of the inklings Neville Coghill once made,
Imaginative writers are not to sell their birthright
for a message.
In a review of Tolkien's Lord of the Rings,
Lewis noted that, quote,
Which shows that we're reading myth, not allegory,
Is that there are no pointers
The Commission has already
or psychological application.
A myth points, for each reader,
to the realm he lives in most.
It's a master key.
Use it on whatever door you like.
People might ask,
Why use fantasy to make a serious point?
When normal, realistic fiction could do the job?
Lewis's answer is,
The writer wants to say that, to quote Lewis,
The real life of men
is of that mythical and heroic quality
One can see the principle at work
in Tolkien's characterization.
Much as in a realistic work
would be done by character delineation
Here is done simply by making the character
an elf, a dwarf or a hobbit.
The imagined beings
They have their insides on the outside.
They are visible souls.
And the man as a whole,
Man pitted against the universe.
Have we seen him at all?
Until we see that he is like a hero
in a fairy tale?
The value of the myth
is that it takes all the things we know
and restores them
The rich meaning
which has been hidden by the veil of familiarity.
By putting bread, gold, horse, apple
Or the very roads into a myth,
We do not retreat from reality,
We rediscover it.
Finally, I want to tie up the conversation
By a brief mention of friendship as a virtue
which was very central to Lewis' thinking in particular.
Lewis' life, in fact, was shaped by friendships
as I have tried to show in my recent biography.
I'm trying to avoid stealing books.
Lewis saw friendship as belonging to
That bright, calm, rational world
of relationships freely chosen.
For himself and for Tolkien,
Their friendship with each other was chosen freely.
Friendship, as we saw,
Wasn't for Lewis like affection and erotic love
connected with our nerves.
It was rather the least biological of our natural loves.
It was distinctly human love,
not shared with the brutes, in Lewis's words.
Friendship, like the fantasy tale,
gave a person a vantage point
To see the world in a fresh way.
Friendship with Tolkien, he found,
Shake him awake.
out of the cold dream of materialism.
Although he had other close friends,
Lewis would not have been the writer and thinker that he was
Without his friendship with that highly strung,
The visionary author of The Lord of the Rings.
As for Tolkien,
He found a friend in Lewis who matched his memories
of his schoolboy friends in the TCBS
who now lay inert in the dead marshes of World War I.
He relied on Lewis' encouragement,
And without him, as we've seen,
He would not have completed His creation,
of what he called his epic for England,
as he thought of his thousand-page story.
Of friendship, Lewis eulogized,
This alone, of all the loves,
seems to raise you almost to the level of gods or angels.
Thinking of the company of friends after a day's walk,
He was certainly including Tolkien when he wrote,
Those are the golden sessions when our slippers are on,
Our feet are spread towards it,
and our drinks at our elbows,
When the whole world and something beyond the world
opens itself to our minds as we talk,
and no one has any claim on
or any responsibility for another,
but all are free men and equal,
as if we had first met an hour ago,
while at the same time,
an affection softened by the years,
envelops us.
Life, natural life,
has no better gift to give.
Who could have deserved it?
- Thank you. - Thank you.
