J. R. R. Tolkien - A Biography' by Humphrey Carpenter - Unabridged Audiobook - Part 7: Chapter 2

John Ronald Reuel Tolkien
30 followers
36 Video Views·May 24, 2023
Chapter 2. Bournemouth. Even by the standard of English seaside towns, Bournemouth is a
peculiarly unlovable place. An urban sprawl that owes most of its architecture to the late 19th
and early 20th centuries, an anemic English equivalent of the French Riviera.
Like the majority of south coast resorts, it attracts the elderly in large numbers.
They come to spend their last years in bungalows and villas, or as residents in faded hotels,
where they are welcomed in winter, but where the weekly rates rise sharply during the summer season.
They take the air along the seafront at East Cliff or West Cliff.
They patronize the public library, the winter gardens, and the golf course.
They stroll among the conifers of Boscombe and Brangsom Cheam, and eventually they die.
Yet Bournemouth serves its purpose. It provides a setting in which elderly people of some
affluence can be comfortable and can spend their time with others of their age and class.
Edith Tolkien had come to like it very much, and not without reason,
for in Bournemouth for the first time in her life she had made a large number of friends.
Some years previously she had begun to take holidays at the Miramar Hotel on the seafront
in the west of the town, an expensive but comfortable and friendly establishment,
cheaply patronized by people like herself. After Tolkien had retired and had given up his
examination visits to Ireland, he had begun to accompany her on these Bournemouth holidays,
and he soon realized that on the whole she was far happier there than she was at home in Oxford.
This was scarcely surprising, for the social setting of the Miramar was very close to what
she had known in the Jessop household of Cheltenham between 1910 and 1913,
upper-middle class, affluent, unintellectual, and of an easy friendliness towards its own kind.
Yet the Miramar she felt entirely at home, back in her own milieu, as she had never been in Oxford
or at any other time during her married life. True, many of the other guests at the hotel were
titled, rich, and self-assured, yet they were all essentially of the same breed, conservative,
glad to talk about their own children and grandchildren, and about mutual acquaintances,
happy to pass much of the day in the residents' lounge with occasional interruptions for walks
by the sea, content to sit over the postprandial coffee and watch the nine o'clock news in the
television room before going to bed. Nor did Edith feel any sense of inferiority,
for she was now as well-off financially as any of them, and as to titles, her status as the wife of
an internationally famous author cancelled out any feeling she might have of inadequacy.
On a more practical basis, the Miramar became increasingly the ideal answer to the Tolkien's
domestic problems. When the strain of keeping house became too much for Edith, it was easy
to book their usual rooms and to arrange for their regular hire-car driver to take them down to
Bournemouth. At the Miramar, Edith would soon recover much of her strengths, not to say her
good spirits, while Tolkien himself was often glared to initiate visits to Bournemouth simply
to escape from the confines of Sandfield Road and from the despair caused by his own inability
to get his work done. He himself was not particularly happy at the Miramar. He shared
little of Edith's delight in the type of person, as C.S. Lewis expressed it, whose general conversation
is almost wholly narrative, and although he found an occasional articulate fellow-male among the
guests, he was sometimes reduced to silent and impotent rage by the feeling of imprisonment.
But, in other respects, the Bournemouth holidays suited him very well. He could work in his hotel
room just as much, or just as little, as at Sandfield Road, providing he remembered to bring
all the relevant papers with him, which was not always the case, and he enjoyed the comfort
and the cooking. He and Edith had discovered a local doctor, who proved unfailingly friendly
and helpful, if either of them should be unwell. There was a Catholic church reasonably near at
hand, the hotel was close to the sea, which he loved so much, albeit a rather more timid sea
than he might have preferred, and above all he could see that Edith was happy. So the visits to
Bournemouth continued, and when the Tolkiens decided to leave Sandfield Road and find another
house, it was not altogether surprising that they resolved to look for something near the Miramar.
He lives in a hideous house, I cannot tell you how hideous, with hideous pictures. W.H. Auden said
this at a meeting of the Tolkien Society in New York, and his words were reported at a London
newspaper in January 1966. Tolkien read them, and remarked, Since it is some years since his
sole visit, in which he only entered Edith's room, and had tea, he must be confused in his memories,
if he really said just this. It was a calm reaction to an insulting remark, and after
showing a little initial displeasure in a letter to Auden, Tolkien was soon writing cordially to
him once more. Auden's remark was silly, and it was not true. The Sandfield Road house, to which
he was referring, was no uglier than any others in the nondescript but modest street, nor were the
pictures that adorned the walls of Edith's drawing-room any different from those in the average
middle-class house of the district. But, of course, it is precisely what Auden was trying
to say. As a man of sophisticated tastes, he was astonished by the apparent ordinariness of
Tolkien's lifestyle, and by the conformity of the house and the suburban road. This lifestyle did
not specifically reflect Tolkien's own tastes. On the other hand, he did not exactly object to it.
Indeed, there was an ascetic side to him which did not even notice it. It is important to grasp
this before coming to any conclusions about the life that Tolkien led at Bournemouth, from 1968
until the end of 1971. He and Edith bought a bungalow, a short taxi-ride away from the
Miramar. What Auden would have thought of this plain modern house, 90 in Lakeside Road, can be
easily imagined, for in his terms it was quite as hideous as the Heddington house. But from the
point of view of the Tolkiens, both of them, it was exactly what they wanted. It had a well-equipped
kitchen, in which Edith could manage to cook with some ease, despite her increasing disability, and
besides a sitting-room, a dining-room, and a bedroom for each of them, there was also a room
that served as an indoor study for Tolkien, and he could use the double garage for a library come
office, just as he had done at Sandfield Road. There was central heating, something they had
never had before, and outside there was a veranda, where they could sit and smoke in the evenings,
a large garden with plenty of room for their roses, and even a few vegetables, and at the
bottom a private gate that led into a small wooded gorge, known as Wrexham Cheam, and so
down to the sea. There were Catholic neighbours, who often took Tolkien to church in their car,
regular domestic help, and the Miramar always near at hand for the accommodation of friends
and members of the family who came down to see them, as well as for regular lunches,
and even for sleeping overnight now and then, when he just needed a rest.
Inevitably the move to Bournemouth involved much sacrifice on Tolkien. He had little wish to leave
Oxford, and he knew that he was cutting himself off from all but a limited contact with his family
and close friends. And again, as with his retirement to Heddington, he found the reality
a little harsher than he had expected. "'I've fed quite well,' he wrote to Christopher a year
after moving to Bournemouth. "'And yet, and yet, I see no man of my own kind. I miss Norman,
and above all I miss you.' But the sacrifice had a purpose to it, and the purpose was achieved.
Edith was happy at Lakeside Road, as happy as she had been during the holidays at the Miramar,
and consistently happier than she had been before in their married life.
Besides the comfort of the new house, and the benefit she'd derived from the absence of stairs
to be negotiated, there was also her continuing pleasure at visits to the Miramar, and the
friendship she made there. She had ceased to be the shy, uncertain, sometimes troubled wife of an
Oxford professor, and became herself once more, the sociable, good-humoured Miss Brett of the
Cheltenham days. She was back in the setting where she really belonged. And on the whole,
life was better for Tolkien himself. Edith's happiness was deeply gratifying to him,
and was reflected in his own state of mind, so that the diary he kept for a brief time during
these Bournemouth years shows very little of the despondency which often overtook him at
Sandfield Road. The absence of what he called men of my own kind was partly made up for by
frequent visits from members of the family and friends, where the almost total lack of
interruptions from fans, the address and telephone number, even the information that Tolkien was
living on the south coast, were successfully kept secret, meant that a great deal more of
his time was available for work. A certain amount of secretarial assistance was given by the
doctor's wife, while Joy Hill, the member of Elinor Dunwood's staff who dealt with his fan mail,
came down regularly to attend to letters. The move to Bournemouth was initially made more
tiresome by a serious accident, when Tolkien fell on the stairs at Sandfield Road, and injured his
leg badly, with the result that he had to spend some weeks in hospital, and many more in plaster.
But once he'd recovered, he was able, at least in theory, to begin to work with some thoroughness
at the Silmarillion. Yet it was difficult to decide exactly where to start. In one sense,
there was very little to be done. The story of the Silmarillion itself was complete,
if the term story could be used, of a work beginning with an account of the creation of the
world, and dealing in the main with the struggle between the elves and the prime power of evil.
To produce a continuous narrative, Tolkien merely had to decide which version of each chapter he
should use, for there were by now many versions, dating from his earliest work in 1917, to some
passages written in the last few years. But this involved so many decisions that he did not know
where to start, and even if he managed to complete this part of the work, he would then have to
ensure that the whole book was consistent with itself. Over the years he had, by his various
alterations and rewritings, produced a massive confusion of detail. Characters' names had been
changed in one place and not in another. Topographical descriptions were disorganized
and contradictory. Worst of all, the manuscripts themselves had proliferated, so that he was no
longer certain which of them represented his latest thoughts on any particular passage.
For security reasons, he had in recent years made two copies of each typescript,
and had then kept each copy in a separate place. But he had never decided which was
to be the working copy, and often he had amended each of them independently and in
contradictory fashion. To produce a consistent and satisfactory text, he would have to make a
detailed collation of every manuscript, and the prospect of attempting this fooled him with dismay.
Besides this, he was still uncertain how the whole work should be presented. He was inclined
to abandon the original framework, the introductory device of the seafarer to whom the stories were
told. But did it perhaps need some other device of this kind? Or was it enough simply to present
it as a mythology that appeared in a shadowy form in The Lord of the Rings? And on the subject of
that other book, he had made his task even more complicated by introducing into it several
important characters, such as the Elven Queen Galadriel and the Trish Ents, who had not appeared
in the original Silmarillion, but who now required some mention in it. By this time, he had managed
to find satisfactory solutions to these problems, but he knew that he would have to ensure that the
Silmarillion harmonized in every single detail with The Lord of the Rings, or else he would be
bombarded with letters pointing out the inconsistencies. And even given these daunting
technical challenges, he was still not beyond reconsidering some fundamental aspect of the
whole story, the alteration of which would have meant a complete rewriting from the beginning.
By the summer of 1971, after three years at Bournemouth, he had begun to make progress,
although, as usual, he was drawn aside to the consideration of detail rather than the planning
of the whole. What form, he would wonder, should a particular name take? And then he would begin to
contemplate a revision of some aspect of the Elvish languages. Even when he did do some actual
writing, it was not usually concerned with the revision of the narrative, but with the whole
mess of ancillary material that had now accumulated. Much of this material was in the form of essays,
on what might be called technical aspects of the mythology, such as the relation between the aging
processes of elves and men, or the death of animals and plants in Middle-earth. He felt that
every detail of his cosmos needed attention, whether or not the essays themselves would ever
be published. Some creation had become a sufficiently rewarding pastime in itself,
quite apart from the desire to see the work in print. Sometimes he would put in long hours at
his desk, but on other days he would soon turn to a game of patience, and abandon any pretense
of working. Then there might be a good lunch at the Miramar with plenty of wine, and if he did
not feel like doing any work after it, why should he? They could wait for the book. He would take
his time. Yet on other days he was distressed that time was leaking away so fast, with the
book still unfinished. And at the close of 1971, the Bournemouth episode came abruptly to a close.
Edith, aged eighty-two, was taken ill in the middle of November, with an inflamed gallbladder.
She was removed to hospital, and after a few days of severe illness,
she died, early on Monday the 29th of November.
