SHOP TALK | My Philosophy On Knife Making

Jason Knight
2 followers
12 Video Views·Mar 24, 2023
Hey y'all, so what we're going to talk about today is going to take some twists and turns
probably.
We started out originally with an idea about I'm sanding a blade, I'm going to talk a little
bit about that.
But then I started really philosophizing about how to do this or why to do this, mostly
why and then all the other crazy stuff.
So this is one of those videos that it takes turns like this and then ends up at the end
and that's where you finish.
So subscribe, like, leave a comment, let me know what you think and that way we can keep
having this conversation.
So I love doing Brutally Forged knives.
This is one of the knives out of a bunch of them that we forged during the forged series.
If you haven't gotten that, you should.
So this has been hardened and timbered and finished and I just, in particular, I like
the forging here and I had very minimal grinding so what I thought I'd do is I'd just go back
and I would just sand the parts of the steel that I had to grind.
I thought I'd just do kind of a satin finish, you know, not too crazy but maybe 220, a little
finer.
So I'm going to do that and it philosophizes a little bit about this whole idea and why
we would sit there and spend so many hours sanding on something.
I like the way all the different finishes look.
I like the way it looks when it's left ground, you know, 120 grit or maybe even a little
coarser sometimes.
I like the way it looks when you sand it.
I love the way it looks when it's just left forged.
So there's so many different ways to finish a knife or a sword or any kind of edged piece
of art here and I'm just going to share some of the concepts.
I have a piece of micarta and it has this hard rubber backing on it, one size radius.
It gets cut and you start putting it on this side.
I'll show you what I'm talking about.
You put it over here and you start sanding, it cuts it.
If it's too sharp, it'll cut into it.
That's where all that stuff comes in.
So I'm just going to keep sanding until all the grinder scratches out.
There's no real point in going finer and finer.
If you still have scratches from the grinder in there, it's kind of wild.
You know, I think about what's the philosophy of sitting here and making knives and doing
videos on making knives.
What's the point, right?
You know, why would I share all these ideas, all this information with you?
And it's because there's so much stuff out there.
We're looking at the computer, we're looking at the internet, whatever it is, you know,
and how can you tell what's true?
How can you tell what's false?
It's real hard.
And I like that we do this.
This is just straightforward and honest.
There's nothing...
What you see is what you get.
You know?
And the narrative is so strange.
It's nice.
It's refreshing to have something just honest and straightforward like sanding a piece of steel.
How do you do it?
How do I sand a piece of steel to make it shiny, you know?
It's just a simple thing, you know?
The 220.
The other thing I'm going to do...
I got it on the hard side right now.
As I'm working this, I'm going to kind of blend it over.
Because it's pretty much flat, but then it's also condexed into the sharpness, you know?
Also good on these kicks where I make all different kinds of knives, you know?
I've made swords and Damascus and art knives.
I mean, everything you can imagine.
But I am right now, honestly, really on this kick with just doing the brute-to-forge knives.
Just forge to finish.
I'm really enjoying that.
And I'm not going to say it's coming to an end.
Because I like to make these knives.
I like to offer them for sale.
I enjoy that process of making this knife.
But there's things while I'm doing this that I begin to consider.
Like, hmm, what if I did this?
And this is how you get a new idea.
So one of the things I really like about the brute-to-forge,
it's like, if we're forging or bladesmithing, you know,
it's very, again, it's very honest.
A lot of times, you can see a knife that's perfectly finished and polished.
And just like, wow, that's just stunningly gorgeous.
And you don't know if that person can actually forge or not.
You don't really know how they arrived at that place.
So sometimes I'll get on an idea like doing forge-to-finish knives.
And I'll stay on it, like literally since I've built this shop.
And I moved in here.
I've been kind of stuck on it.
I've done a few, I don't know, maybe 20 knives
that are all sanded and polished and finished out.
You know, whether they be carbon steel and a smooth finish.
Or Damascus, mostly Damascus.
Because I feel like if I'm going to do all that extra work of sanding,
I'm going to do it in Damascus because it's beautiful.
It's a pattern.
But what's really nice about this finish is like you can just see.
There it is.
There is the skill of the bladesmith right there.
You can see the plunges that I've forged in.
You can see that everything was set up in a certain way.
And I look at people's brood to forge.
How's that?
Some people can and some people can't.
You know, if they can't, they just have to get better.
It's like practicing something.
You're not all of a sudden just good at it.
You have to practice it.
I mean, I don't know.
I feel like I'm getting better at it.
I want to get better at it.
I'm still practicing.
That's why I do stuff like that.
That's why I'll spend a lot of time making one subject.
Like making kukris.
I forge a kukri and grind it over and over and over.
I'll do the same knife with all the crazy fullers.
I started doing the fullers in kukris in about 2010 or 11.
And then I really revealed them in about 2012 at the blade show.
And I had a bunch of them.
And I didn't invent fullers.
Everybody used to call it a blood groove.
That's a dumb thing.
That's not what it is.
It's a fuller.
Looks cool.
Reduces weight.
Makes the blade stiffer.
But I did it because I like the way it looked.
And I like the way it would cut stuff.
Just now, in the last year and a half,
you start seeing a bunch of people doing it.
That's cool.
Things take time to catch on.
Sometimes it's hard to figure out.
So what am I working on now?
Well, I can't tell you.
But I'll show you at the blade show.
You'll see at the blade show what I'm working on now.
And that's the fun part.
When you come up with some new concepts,
when and where do you reveal them?
It makes me think about Prince.
The artist Prince.
He was a pretty impressive character
because he did what music he wanted to do
the way he wanted to do it.
And if he couldn't find someone to play
accompanying him,
he'd just play it himself.
And you're looking at someone who is such a genius,
such a brilliant mind,
always going up,
always getting better,
always improving.
It was just amazing to listen to his music,
watch him play,
or see whatever he was doing.
That kind of genius is very uncommon.
And I'm not saying that I'm anything like that,
but I feel like everybody who attains
that level of wow, that's amazing,
you have to practice that.
You have to do things that are maybe
outside of your comfort zone
or maybe even going back.
This is like original,
old-school stuff, right?
Well, I'd say most of the
very well-known blades,
they can't do this.
It's just because they don't want to,
or either they don't try, I don't know.
But a lot of people forge kind of close,
and then they grind.
This is actually over-forged,
to tell you the truth.
You have to go farther
than where you want to go to stop.
Say, hey, I'm going to stop now
and grind it all clean.
You've got to go past that
to get this finish.
So that's one thing you need to know
if you're interested in it.
So this is a 220,
and I'm going to leave that at 220.
And the truth is,
I've done blades where I've done,
I'll use this, a sax, for an example.
I made a sax back,
I don't remember when it was,
but me and my friend Bert went up to Ashokan
to the hammering up there,
and I made a sax,
and I did this 220 grit finish,
and nobody could figure out what it was.
They were like, is that 600?
No. Is that 800? No.
220.
But if you do a finish evenly,
it's hard to tell.
It's just a matter of doing it evenly.
You can't tell if it's 400 or 600.
And that's just for you, you know.
That's not for anybody else.
I do it because I think it's fun
to do a nice, even finish.
Other people do it because they think,
hey, I want to show everybody
I can do a 600 grit finish.
Well, I want to show everybody
I can do a 220 finish
that looks like a 600 finish.
What does that mean?
When you do a hand rub finish on a knife,
that means you'll damage the finish faster.
That's rub, right?
That is true.
Two sides.
See, I don't like shiny stuff.
I don't like it to be shiny too much.
It's like,
if you sand it and make it mirror polish,
it reflects what's around it.
I don't know.
It doesn't interest me too much.
I like to see things
the way they really are, you know.
On our live feed the other day,
we start,
I'm talking about
when I was going off on the whole idea
of the sacks.
The sacks, however you say it,
I don't know.
Nobody speaks that language no more.
You know that if,
if,
if truly people were speaking English
a thousand years ago,
no one's speaking the same version
of that English now.
So I'm going to use that word sacks again.
Go back to,
it's an ancient Scandinavian
language or word.
But everybody has their mythological
viewpoint of it.
It's always interesting with knife making
when someone will
try and argue with you
about
how they did a thing.
I remember a guy saying,
well, the,
those people,
they, they didn't have
fire hot enough
to melt steel.
Right.
You can melt steel with charcoal.
Charcoal
and air.
It will melt steel.
So it's always silly
when you're listening to someone on
whatever, discovery history,
whatever any of those
things you might go look to
for your information.
Or even a book.
A book written by someone
who didn't do anything.
He just looked it up and said,
well, here's my opinion.
I'm going to write all this information
in a book
because I looked at it.
But I don't know how they did it
and I don't know how to do it.
So I'm just going to tell you
how they didn't do it.
See, this doesn't make a lot of sense.
Today,
we'll take charcoal
and we'll make a
small little cupola
and we'll smelt some
iron from, you know,
iron nodules or sand or whatever.
We'll make steel.
Or even better yet,
if you go there,
there's,
you know,
people will make woots.
And that's like,
oh, nobody can make woots.
Well,
people can make woots
and they do.
Alpendrae is an example.
What do we know?
Well, nothing.
My opinion is that
as Americans especially,
we have one of the most
ridiculous views of history
of any other culture
on the planet because
truly in America,
there were people here.
They had a culture here.
And everything that was in the way
is all gone now.
You know,
it's all gone now.
What's our culture look like now?
I always feel like we like
to cover it all up.
Like,
American culture likes
to get hidden with some
nonsense.
Some mythological nonsense.
What am I talking about?
I don't know.
I'm sanding.
You know,
you lose your mind
while you're sanding.
You sand too much?
How much?
It's like the other guy
who's asking me
about the American
knife
is a Bowie knife.
That's nonsense.
There were people here.
They were using knives.
We can't ask them
what kind of knife.
You know,
we want to...
because all those cultures
have been wiped out.
Do you think
primitive people
built Machu Picchu?
I mean,
that doesn't make sense.
It's just funny.
It's like they'll sit there
and make you believe that.
You know,
it's a stone age culture.
You don't know what
those people had.
And the other
ridiculous view
is aliens.
That's the stupidest
one I've heard.
We're told
tales,
tall tales.
And they made
the sound good.
This knife
doesn't fit into
any timeline
from history.
Where it fits into
is
my timeline.
This knife is
my design.
This knife
fits into the timeline
that I grew up in,
that I created,
that I developed
just through my
experiences
of playing
in the woods
and growing up
in a swamp
and enjoying
being out there.
So this is
the result
of that experience.
When I look at that knife
I recurve
this way.
That's the result
of that experience.
So this ain't
something I pulled
out of a book
and said,
oh,
I'm going to
recreate that.
This is mine.
I'm not
sure it's a copy
of something.
You can look
hard enough
in history
you'll find
a knife
that looks
like that.
But for me
for right now
this is my knife.
This is not
my knife.
This is my knife.
I'm going to
tell you why.
So you probably
see this shape
a lot
in knife making
and
I didn't see
this shape.
I never saw
this shape
anywhere.
I saw elements
of this shape.
I saw elements
of the design.
Things that I liked
I pulled in.
This idea
came from
1957 Chevy
fins on cars
from
shark fins
from
fish hooks
and
that's where
I
saw it.
That's where I first
saw it.
I never saw it
on a knife.
Recurves
of course have been
around.
I saw those on
kukris
and some
Filipino knives
and
I always liked that.
There was
some of the
old school makers
with some
Don Fogg
stuff.
Recurves
is cool
cool pieces.
I always liked them.
The handle
the flare
these are just
elements
that I knew
that this would work
kukris
and
knives from the
barongs
but
the other place
where this knife
came from
was from
using the knife
going out
and using the knife
in the woods
and playing
with knives
in the woods
and seeing
what would work.
My friend
Adam
contributed
we worked together
for a while
on some ideas
so we would
play with things
like why does that work
why does that work
but when you
when you're coming up
with a thing
and you say
why is that your knife
or why is that my knife
I'll go back
and show you some
other
just things
just to
conceptually
how about that
so this was recent
this is from the
forged series
this is the pattern
I used
this is from
20
11
2011
2012
that's the
Phantasmagora
this is from
2010
called that the founder's
Bowie
so I made a version
of this
my friend Nick Wheeler
also made a version
of this
this is from class
this is the knife
we make
this is one of my
it's kind of a hunter
you know it's the
EDC
this knife could be
a great hunting knife
this could be
maybe even
a defensive knife
if that's what you
wanted to do with it
but I'm going to put
this in production
here very shortly
but these are my designs
because
I developed them
in my mind
and I put them
on paper
and then
I made them real
and I tested them
and I modified them
and I changed
little things
subtly on them
you know I made
them my own
I didn't look at
someone else's knife
and go
I'm going to copy
that knife
I didn't do that
I just
I didn't see
what I liked
and that's one
of the reasons
that I came up
with my own designs
because I didn't
see knife designs
that I was like
oh man
I like that
I want that
I want to use that
I didn't see it
and not that
there aren't
great designs
out there
because there's
a lot of great
designs out there
I saw a lot
of makers
that I loved
their work
and I was like
that little piece
or that little piece
and when I talk
about knives
and knife design
and ideas
you know
do what you want
to do with this stuff
you know
you want to
borrow something
from me
do it
I don't care
I'm cool with that
because I have
more and more
and more
and you know
I was talking
earlier about
the Brut de Forge
and you know
leaving the forging
on
well I'm still on
it's like my
it's like being
Picasso
you know
Picasso
did classic work
and then he just
started to do
his own thing
and you see the work
that we know
of as Picasso
and never
trash talk
Pablo Picasso
because he laid
foundation
for everybody
else to come
after him
to be able
to make it
as an artist
he put a giant
volume of work
out there
massive amounts
of work
not 20 pieces
or 120 pieces
or whatever
thousands of pieces
you can go and see
Picasso's work
and you can
research a little bit
and say
man that guy did something
he did something for us
as artists
leading a way
you know
I don't know
nothing about him
personally
I don't
you know
that doesn't
really matter
what matters is
when you see
some work
that inspires you
and you want to
build on that work
hey you know
it's art
you can do that
so that's
that's my knife
and there may be
some other knives
out there
that look similar to this
but they didn't
come before my knife
anyway
point is
you can do
anything you want
and you can keep
developing
the idea
keep developing
and that's a
kind of a
barbecue knife
going through this
box
there's a tomahawk
all I'm trying
to say is
you can design
a knife
it will help you
a great deal
if you go
and use your knife
now there's
fighters are
fantasy knives
to be honest
you know
I can make that
and say
oh it's a fight
it's for fighting poverty
it's for fighting
my poverty
that's what it's for
but for a chopper
for a camp knife
man that's a handy knife
man I could go out there
and trim the bushes
and cut all the stuff
on the ditch bank
and really enjoy
doing that
with that knife
that's what that knife
is about
that's not a weapon
that's the stupidest
thing to consider
that being a weapon
that's stupid
a weapon is intent
you know
you have to think about
a weapon that has
intent behind it
this intent
is
to trim the bushes
to enjoy the art
of it
to look at it
functional
yes functional
perfectly functional
well designed
perfectly functional
and still
in the process
of refining
that design
every time I make
this knife again
I refine that design
the handles change
the blades change
all that stuff
but
the intent
is
trimming the branches
clearing the trail
stuff like that
I'm gonna tell you
one more thing
but you gotta
come in
close
for this one
hey
that's it
for today's video
but I really
want to thank you
I want you to
click subscribe
thumbs up
leave a comment
let me know
what you think
and let's keep
having this conversation
where
I'm gonna share
with you
and you're gonna
give me feedback
and I'm gonna share
some more information
okay
