Why Countries Change Their Flags

Children and Growing Up
267 followers
10 Video Views·Mar 20, 2023
Comments are disabled for this video.
On August 15th, 1947, the great symbol of the British Empire came down for the last
time, to be replaced by the banner of the new Indian government.
In 1947, India wasted no time in removing all Union Jacks that flew across their land.
The British flag had represented those who ruled the country, not the people who actually
live there and call it their home.
In its place, India raised its very own tricolour flag, which was designed by an Indian man
to represent the people of the country.
The changing of the flag was a somewhat ceremonial event, but it signified something much greater.
India had achieved independence, and was finally its own country, after decades of struggle
against colonial rule.
A country changing its flag is not all that uncommon, which can be done for a variety
of different reasons, and it's not always quite as obvious as in the case of India.
The first country we're going to look at is actually another former British colony, but
with a very different past… South Africa.
Unlike India, South Africa actually didn't even change its flag when the country became
fully independent in 1931.
It wasn't until 1994 that South Africa adopted its current flag.
In this case, the reason for the change was an end to what was called apartheid, the systematic
segregation and oppression of the country's non-white population.
How this came to be all goes back to colonial times, when Southern Africa was a region that
was hotly contested between the British and the Dutch.
The Dutch were the first to arrive in 1652, with the establishment of Cape Colony.
Many more settlers arrived over the next few decades.
Over time, these earliest European settlers would develop their own identity and language,
becoming known as the Boers.
The British took over Cape Colony in 1806, causing many of these Boers to trek inland
and find new dwellings.
They established two of their own republics, the South African Republic, also known as
Transvaal, as well as the Orange Free State.
There were other Boer republics, but these were the two that managed to achieve international
recognition.
In the 1860s and 1880s, massive diamond and gold deposits were found in the region.
These discoveries would lay the foundation for what would later become apartheid.
More immediately though, it led to two wars between the British and the Boers, as they
lay claim to the lucrative land.
The Brits would ultimately come out on top, annexing the Boer republics.
In 1910, all of these territories, including the Natal colony on the east coast, were merged
into one single dominion, called the Union of South Africa.
The country had experienced a period of rapid industrialisation, thanks to the incredible
wealth that was extracted from the land.
The local African population was used as a source of cheap labour, which kept corporate
profits high.
Black workers were often subject to strip searches to ensure there was no theft.
White workers didn't face the same scrutiny and humiliation.
In 1913, an Act of Parliament restricted the black population from owning land outside
of specifically designated reserves.
These were generally away from population centres and in less developed areas.
Sometime later, South Africa adopted its own flag in 1928.
The main component of the flag is an orange, white, and blue tricolour, that was an old
Dutch flag under Prince William of Orange.
Then there are three smaller flags in the centre, the Union Jack, plus the two former
Boer republics.
The dominant political party in South Africa was the National Party, made up of the descendants
of the Boers.
Although, by this point, they were more commonly referred to as Afrikaners.
Given their history with the British, the Afrikaner majority did not want a Union Jack
on the flag, but discussions became heated with the British descendant minority, so it
was put in as a compromise.
The whole of the parliament was made up of those of European descent.
Likewise, only white people were allowed to vote in elections.
1948 is often viewed as the beginning of apartheid, when the National Party began passing laws
of segregation based upon a person's race.
People were split into four different racial groups, white, Indian, coloured, basically
next race, and at the bottom, black.
The native African population was given the least amount of rights of any of the groups.
It was the white population that enjoyed the most rights and privileges.
The population became segregated by which towns people were allowed to live in, what
hospitals they were allowed to go to, who they were allowed to marry, and where their
kids were allowed to go to school.
White institutions were always better funded, while black institutions were often given
the bare minimum to get by, or sometimes not even that.
In the 1950s, the African National Congress, or the ANC, an organisation for African nationalism
and racial equality, began a defiance campaign against apartheid laws.
The non-white population was encouraged to purposefully break apartheid laws.
Thousands were arrested, and harsher punishments were put in place.
Among the most abhorred laws were the various pass laws, in which all non-white people were
required to carry passes, basically like internal passports, everywhere they went.
A person's race dictated where they could and couldn't go.
Passes were required to be carried at all times.
A protest against these laws in 1960 in Sharpeville caused the police to open fire on a crowd
of protesters, killing 69 people.
Up until this point, the ANC had tried to achieve their goals through peaceful means,
but this changed everything.
The ANC soon adopted a military wing, founded by a young Nelson Mandela.
The group was forced underground after the group was banned, and several ANC leaders
were sentenced to life in prison, including Mandela.
The following decades had their ups and downs.
The struggle against oppression never stopped, though the ANC faced many setbacks.
Through a combination of internal rebellion, plus now external pressure from a world that
had grown less and less tolerant of racial segregation, apartheid came to an end.
After 27 years behind bars, Nelson Mandela was released from prison, as the country entered
a period of transition.
He then went on to become president in the 1994 general election, the first election
in the country's history that allowed people of all races to vote.
And this was when the country changed its flag.
This was when the country went through a major change.
The new flag features 6 different colours.
Black, green, and gold, the colours of the ANC, and more broadly, Pan-Africanism, plus
red, white, and blue, the colours of the Dutch flag, and the British flag.
The government has stated that no specific meaning should be assigned to each colour.
The Y shape's official meaning is the convergence of diverse elements within South African society
taking the road ahead in unity.
The old flag is now banned from public display in South Africa, excluding certain specific
circumstances like in museums.
The flag carries many negative connotations for the vast majority of South Africans.
It's become a symbol of oppression and segregation, so much so that it's sometimes referred to
as the Apartheid flag.
The horrible events that took place during Apartheid have become so inextricably linked
to this flag that was flown during that time.
Flying this flag can be seen as an act of hate speech or racism, because there's the
implication that if you fly the flag, you condone what happened during the time of its
use.
It would be easy to draw parallel with another controversial flag, the Confederate flag over
in the United States.
Many claim it to be a racist flag, a symbol of hate, while some people in the South argue
that the flag is simply part of their heritage.
In the case of this flag, the Confederate states were fighting against the Union over
states' rights, and in particular, states' rights to own slaves.
Up until as recently as 2020, the flag of Mississippi featured a Confederate battle
flag in the canton, but has now been removed.
Many statues of Confederate generals were also removed all across the South around the
same time.
These changes were motivated by the murder of George Floyd and the subsequent protests
by the Black Lives Matter movement.
While we're on the subject of the United States, let's talk about the Star-Spangled Banner.
The American flag is actually the national flag that has been changed most often of any
country.
Obviate, mostly minor changes.
The first ever flag of the US actually had a Union Jack on it, although this was quickly
changed for obvious reasons.
In 1777, just one year after the Declaration of Independence, it was established that the
US flag would feature 13 white stars on a blue field, with 13 alternating red and white
stripes.
Both the 13 stars and stripes were for the 13 colonies that declared independence from
Great Britain.
The instructions though were rather vague.
There was no comment about how the stars should be arranged.
It was therefore left up to individual flag makers at the time.
Certainly the most iconic flag was the stars arranged in a circle.
This is called the Betsy Ross flag.
The story goes that George Washington visited the upholsterer in Philadelphia, and she sketched
a new design for the flag.
However, historians have mostly dismissed this origin of the flag, given that the first
known account of this interaction wasn't until 1870 by her grandson, nearly a century after
the fact.
Other interpretations include the Francis Hopkinson flag, who was actually one of the
signatories of the Declaration of Independence.
His design has a star arrangement more akin to the modern flag, rather than the radically
different circle arrangement of the Betsy Ross.
There was also the John Trumbull design, featured in many iconic paintings of the Revolution,
which were commissioned directly by Congress.
This features a 12-star square with one star in the middle.
Fast forward to 1795, when Vermont and Kentucky joined the Union, and the new flag was completely
unique among all other US flags in that this flag actually had 15 stripes, along with
also 15 stars.
However, after 5 more states joined the Union, it probably became clear that adding a new
stripe for every state would get very messy very quickly, and the flag reverted back to
13 stripes.
Five more stars were added though, and this became the convention of adding stars to the
US flag based on the number of states.
If we don't count alternate designs for flags with the same number of stars, for example,
this 33-star abomination, then by my count, the country has changed its flag 27 times.
The current 50-star flag has been in use for 62 years now, longer than any other flag in
the country's history.
The last change was when Hawaii became a state in 1960.
Of course, this might not be the flag forever.
There are two more potential candidates for future states, Puerto Rico and the District
of Columbia.
Both have held referendums and voted in favour of statehood.
However, admission to the Union must be passed by Congress, and there doesn't seem to be
any indication of that happening anytime soon.
Regardless, there are already unofficial 51 and 52-star flags designed.
Just in case.
Moving over to Europe now, where you find several examples of countries that have changed
their flag.
Let's take a look at Germany.
The country used to have a black, white, and red tricolour, but today uses a black, red,
and gold one.
So why the change?
Well, although the German identity, culture, and language have been around for as much
as a thousand years, it wasn't actually until 1871 when Germany became a unified country
for the first time.
This wasn't an easy accomplishment.
After 1815, the Congress of Vienna established a German Confederation, a loose organisation
of the various German states that had historically been part of the Holy Roman Empire.
It was actually around this time that the earliest version of the modern flag began
to take shape.
During the 1848 revolutions, which took place all across Europe, the black, red, and gold
tricolour was flown as a symbol of liberty and democracy.
These same three colours were used by the Frankfurt Parliament, the first attempt to
establish a unified German state, though it was ultimately unsuccessful.
Although there were many different German states, there were really two that overshadowed
the rest.
Prussia and Austria.
They were by far the two most powerful, and they had a long-running rivalry.
When this came to a head in the Austro-Prussian War, the northern states joined Prussia, while
the southern states joined Austria.
Prussia won the war and established the Northern German Confederation, comprised of the victors
of the war.
Prussia used the colours black and white, and many northern German cities had been part
of what was called the Hanseatic League.
It was a medieval, economic, and military alliance of sorts.
It used the colours white and red, and indeed many cities in the north used white and red
as well.
These colours of Prussia and the Hanseatic League were combined to form the black, white,
and red flag that was used from the 1860s until 1918 and the end of World War 1.
The Northern Confederation was not the first unified German state however, since it still
excluded most of the southern states that had allied themselves with Austria.
If there's one thing that can bring people together though, it's a common enemy.
This happened to be the French.
The Franco-Prussian War in 1870 united all German states to help fight against the French.
Some historians have suggested that the German Chancellor, Otto von Bismarck, actually provoked
the French on purpose in order to achieve the goal of uniting Germany.
However true this actually is, we'll never know, but that was the outcome.
Prussia won, and the German Empire was proclaimed in 1871, in the Palace of Versailles just
outside of Paris.
The notable exclusion from this newly formed empire was Austria.
So this tricolour was used until 1918, at which point the Weimar Republic was established
and went back to the colours from the 1848 revolution of black, red, and gold.
This didn't last long though, as the Nazi Party took over in 1933, and soon replaced
the national flag with the party's swastika flag.
And finally, after World War 2 and the division of Germany, both East and West opted for a
black, red, and gold tricolour, same as the Weimar Republic.
Initially, both flags were identical, but in 1959, East Germany added their communist
coat of arms to the flag.
This was seen in West Germany as a way of intentionally dividing the two Germanies.
The old flag is rarely seen today, although it has been somewhat appropriated by certain
neo-Nazi groups as a substitute for the swastika, which is completely banned from public display
in the country.
Regardless, the colours definitely remain, especially for organisations that were formed
before 1918.
Just look at the German football team, for example.
The main colour of their strip is white.
This white comes from the colour of Prussia, the dominant German kingdom that led the way
to a united Germany.
Many other European countries have changed their flag.
Spain used to have a very different flag, a white flag with a red cross.
This is actually called the Burgundy Cross, which may seem odd given that Burgundy is
a region of France.
This wasn't always the case however.
Centuries ago, the Burgundian lands stretched into what is today Belgium and the Netherlands,
at the time known as the Low Countries.
Through inheritance and political marriage, these ended up in the hands of the powerful
Austrian royal family, the Habsburgs.
Philip I, Duke of Burgundy, married Joanna of Castile, thus introducing the flag to the
Iberian Peninsula.
In reality, this was a time before the very idea of a national flag even existed, and
indeed Spain was yet to become a unified country.
But this flag can sort of be thought of as the first flag of Spain, and was widely used
during their colonisation of the New World.
An example of this can be seen today in the flag of Florida, which uses a similar design
with a state seal in the middle.
The first iteration of the modern flag was adopted in 1785.
Just across the border, Portugal changed its flag from blue and white to red and green.
Historically, Portugal's colours had always been blue and white, but when the country
had a republican revolution in 1910, the political party that was behind the revolution used
the colours green and red.
Since many of the revolutionaries were among those who redesigned the flag, these colours
were integrated into the new flag.
And of course, the crown was also removed.
Since green and red didn't have any historical significance for Portugal, they were given
meanings that would instil a sense of nationalism.
The green was said to represent the hope of the nation, and the red for the blood of those
who died defending the country.
This symbolism was to shift the flag from the specific politics of the republican party
to a nationalist symbol for the whole country.
Moving over to Asia, let's take a look at another controversial flag, Japan's rising
sun flag.
The design used on the flag can be found in Japanese art as far back as the 1820s, and
the rising sun has long been an important part of Japanese culture.
So much so, that the name of the country in Japanese, Nippon, literally means Sun's Origin,
which is often translated into English as Land of the Rising Sun.
However, this flag is most commonly associated with Japanese imperialism during World War
II, and especially the atrocities committed under this flag.
The controversy surrounding this flag is that it's actually still used even to this day,
and can sometimes be seen in parades or on ships.
Many countries in Asia find the use of this flag offensive, in particular South Korea.
In 2018, Japan pulled out of a 15-country naval exercise because Korea demanded Japan
not fly the rising sun flag.
Japan refused.
And in the lead-up to the 2020 Tokyo Olympics, Seoul protested to the IOC to ban the flag
from display during the event.
The flag was indeed banned.
Although this video is about countries changing their flag, Japan is actually the opposite.
They didn't change their flag.
Japan's current flag has always been the primary flag for as long as the country has had a
flag.
The Meiji government adopted the Hinomaru, as it's known, in 1870, as the civil flag
of Japan, to be flown on merchant ships.
In the very same year, the rising sun flag was adopted as a war flag, to be used on military
vessels.
This distinction between a civil flag and a military flag has mostly remained unchanged
in the last 150 years.
The Hinomaru is the flag of the country, while two slightly different variations of the rising
sun flag are used for Japan's navy and army.
Japan has defended its use of the flag, citing the fact that it was used long before World
War 2, and it's an important part of Japanese culture and history.
A national flag can be changed for any number of reasons.
For some countries, it offers a window into the country's past.
A change of flag is often accompanied by a change to the country itself.
Whether it be something minor, or a defining moment in the country's history.
If you're a regular viewer of mine, then there's a good chance you like learning new things.
Therefore, you'll probably be interested in this video's sponsor, Brilliant.
I've been using myself a lot lately as I've been trying to broaden my video topics outside
my comfort zone into things like science and technology, which is definitely a weak point
for me.
Whether you're looking to get ahead with your school studies, brush up on some old subjects
you're using for work, or simply learn something new to keep your mind sharp, Brilliant is
such a great way to achieve any of these goals.
The platform's fun, intuitive, interactive way of learning is such a good way to approach
the seemingly daunting STEM subjects.
Brilliant teaches you in the best way possible, learn by doing.
From starting out with the basics and building up to more complex problems, you'll make great
progress by simply adding the courses into your daily routine like I have.
I'm currently working through the Scientific Thinking course and I'm really enjoying the
interactive examples which help visualise the outcome and the detailed explanations
of the correct answers.
There's such a wide range of courses, from the simple that require no prior knowledge,
all the way to those for the advanced learners, such as Quantum Computing and Special Relativity.
And new course content is being added every month.
You can get started right now by signing up for free at brilliant.org forward slash wonderwhy
and the first 200 people to sign up will get a 20% discount on a whole year of Brilliant
and you'll even be helping support this channel in the process.
Go to the link in the description or click the button on screen now.
And as always, thank you so much for watching and I'll see you next time.
