Ivy League schools are no longer requiring an SAT score in order to apply.
Does this mean that meritocracy is crumbling,
or does it just mean that test scores were maybe a little bit overrated?
Yeah, this is going viral in a lot of corners of the internet right now.
Columbia University, Andrew, is the first Ivy League school to indefinitely say
they are no longer requiring an SAT or ACT test score
to have their application taken a look at.
For example, previously, Andrew, they would throw you out of the pool
if you didn't have the SAT or ACT.
Nowadays, they'll still look at it.
Right, so it doesn't mean that they're just letting in anybody,
but they are just going to take a look at your resume and application
if you didn't have the test score.
Guys, this obviously produced a multitude of reactions,
which we're going to go over.
Please hit that like button right now and check out other episodes of the Hot Pop Boys.
David, before we get into the first response,
generally, this policy is supposed to help kids who come from families
or come from backgrounds where they were not able to prepare
for the SATs in the same way.
Non-traditional, unconventional, definitely not like a typical overachiever
from an upper-middle class or wealthy household.
Right, because there are a lot of SAT prep classes,
even I took some growing up, that you can study for
and build your muscles just to take this test.
And it is true right now, the majority of Columbia's incoming freshman class
are white or Asian.
So obviously, it may be designed to help more underrepresented groups,
specifically black or Latino.
Yeah, so I guess who is it going to hurt?
Well, it's kind of up for debate,
but a lot of people feel like initially,
it's going to hurt Asians who generally score very high on the SATs,
who put extra work into taking that test.
Because theoretically, a lot of the legacy whites
that are very connected from wealthy families,
they're not going to take their spots away
because they're like building the library or whatever.
So I don't know, guys, it's very complicated,
but we are going to get into as many responses as we can
and our own takeaways.
The first one is,
man, that's like saying the NBA should have no talent regulations.
What about that?
The talent for going to an Ivy League is the test scores.
The talent for going to the NBA is being good at basketball.
All right, all right.
I don't like this comment
because you cannot compare sports and education.
You got to more likely compare sports to like the military.
That's more of how it works, guys.
And also, if America was such a strong meritocracy,
why are we still picking on the math geeks and the scientists?
Right, I mean, I think it's taking a look at sports
like that's an end product industry,
whereas education should be for like building up the country
and building up different groups.
I don't know, guys, like we said,
different people are going to perceive things differently.
Somebody said, man, these lowered standards are ruining America.
Obviously, it depends because using their new criteria, Andrew,
somebody could be good at everything except the test scores.
So that could make them a great individual.
For example, Andrew, Malala,
like maybe if she wanted to go to Columbia,
she would have great everything,
everything she's accomplished in her life,
but not the SAT scores.
She should be allowed in.
Yeah, for sure.
And I don't think like applications to colleges
were ever solely based on test score.
Like very few of them were, you know what I'm saying?
So it's always based on your holistic resume.
Obviously, the test scores is part of it,
but I guess Columbia's, I mean,
they're going to test out this program.
Yeah, it obviously depends on their implementation, right?
And how they weight things and different impacts.
Somebody said, why not hide the name and ethnicity,
then just make it completely fair and totally blind of everything.
Yeah, I mean, I think the other argument against this is like,
why don't you more heavily weight economic status?
Like if they come from a lower socioeconomic level
and they can prove it,
then maybe you give them a little bit of a boost
because they're coming from a more struggling background.
I think with a lot of advanced technology nowadays,
and I know that in Boston,
they were trying to do that
with their selective public school system.
You can really segment things by geography,
family situation, income ranges,
like a lot of things that in previous years,
Andrew, there was not the information
or the computing power to process.
So I'm just saying, I'm just recommending people
look at using more modern technology.
Somebody said, man, this is so stupid.
This whole thing was caused by rich legacy white kids
because now the minority's got to be pitted against each other
and fighting for a few reserve spots.
Because of course, the rich kids,
they're always going to have their spots no matter what,
because their dad built the library
or built this wing of the building.
So now you're just pitting minorities against each other.
I mean, again, I do want to remind people
that they're not just letting in anybody.
They're not just letting in anybody,
but they are just going to take a look at applications
that do not have a SAT score.
Of course, to get into Columbia,
I'm sure your resume is still going to have to be stellar
to get in.
Yeah, and I think you're going to have to see
the applicant percentages of like,
that came out of the pool that didn't take the SAT or ACT.
Right.
And who knows, maybe they're only taking
the most amazing people on planet Earth,
but they're just from like a different planet,
you know, a different, very non-Ivy League upbringing.
Somebody just said, you know, the Ivy Leagues,
they're just not what they used to be.
And actually, interestingly enough, Andrew,
I have a friend at Google who does hiring,
and he said that it's less surefire than it used to be.
And that's why they test everybody at Google
for just execution ability,
regardless of what school they went to.
Yeah, but maybe that's not a bad thing either,
because I think if private companies have their own tests
that they want to put onto people,
then that's their choice.
They can totally do that.
And I'm like, totally for that if that's how you feel.
But I do feel like back in the day,
people used to just get jobs
just because they went to a college, right?
Right, because they have the name brand recognition.
Yeah, you would see UPenn, or you see Columbia,
or Cornell, or something, some other pretty good school,
and then all of a sudden you're like, they get the job.
Yo, I used to, I remember I used to see people
with the Team Bank, Andrew, colorways of Nikes.
If you had a Team Bank colorway of like the Shox BB4s,
I was like, yo, you got to be nice at ball to get those Dukes,
because there was no way to get them.
Nowadays, Andrew, anybody can just buy any sneaker
in any color.
Yeah, I guess, David, so I can tell that this is
a very emotional thing for a lot of people,
because I think a lot of Asians immediately jump to the fact
that this is going to hurt Asian applicants.
And then also a lot of people who are very traditional American
are like, ah, the American meritocracy,
it's going down the drain.
This is the beginning of it.
To be honest, I think Asians are more split on it,
because we see the logic behind it.
But then, of course, you're more looking
for the self-incentive in it, right?
But I definitely know that a lot of conservative whites
definitely do not like this.
Yeah, and here's my general takeaway,
and we got a bunch of takeaways here,
so please hear us out and finish the rest of the video.
I think, first of all, man, a lot of these people who are mad,
they're saying that America's this meritocracy that's crumbling.
I'm like, I don't know if America was ever a meritocracy,
to be honest, in my opinion.
Are you sure it wasn't?
Because that's what I thought it was.
That's why things were stacked the way they were.
That's how it played out, because it was a meritocracy.
Because being successful in America as an Asian guy,
of all people, I feel like Asian men
and Asian people should understand this,
that we know that no matter what you do,
it doesn't mean you're going to live a happy
and successful life in America.
Yeah, it doesn't mean you're going to be
completely oppressed either,
but it's somewhere in the middle, in the gray zone.
But I'm saying success was never always predicated
on your test scores.
Because as Asian people, we've always generally,
as a mass, have done well on tests,
but how come we're still hitting bamboo ceilings?
How come we're still getting treated this way?
We're stuck in middle management.
Yeah, we're stuck in middle management.
So clearly it's not a meritocracy, guys.
And then clearly we still pick on the scientists.
We still pick on the math geeks.
And then, you know, we elected a president who,
you know, didn't have any prior political experience.
So I would say for me that I absolutely see the pros
and the cons of this, of Columbia, you know,
getting rid of the SAT requirement.
But at the end of the day, you know,
I guess if they're trying to do something
and they're missing out right now on some great applicants
that just didn't take the SAT or have really bad SAT scores,
then by all means, they should review those applicants
against the other pool.
Because otherwise it's going to be so homogenous.
It's either going to be all either upper middle class Asians
who studied super hard every day of their life
or really rich legacy whites
that kind of study a little bit hard.
And they're all just going to go into finance or tech.
You know what I mean?
Like it's going to be too homogenous
of a student body population to be like fully edifying.
Possibly, yeah.
I mean, I think that's an argument for it.
David, what are some like, I guess,
middle of the road solutions, you know,
solutions that maybe people from the both sides can-
Yeah, that are not politicized.
I have not seen any of these from any party.
I'd say, man, what if they kept the test requirement,
but they just cut the weight
and the impact of that pie slice by 50%?
Okay, so just weighted the test score less,
but still kept the requirement.
And what if they said that,
what about every student should get evaluated every year?
So it's not like you're making that big of a commitment
to a student by letting them in for four or five years.
What if every year they had their status
at the school re-evaluated everybody?
That would keep everybody working so hard,
almost like a one-year contract in the MBA.
Okay, I think they have some type
of probation system in college, right?
Yeah, but I'm talking about even ramp that up
or make it more advanced.
Okay, okay.
What do you think about an app
that like even develops youth development even earlier
that has some built-in incentives?
So people from certain groups,
like they can learn the skills earlier
rather than trying to recorrect this at a college stage.
Yeah, I mean, I think this is an interesting idea.
Like the app could reward you
or maybe pay you or something if you learn certain things
because I think maybe like classroom learning,
it's not always fit for everybody
or people got to learn some other way too,
because not all classrooms are created equal.
So we all know that.
But anyways, also, I think that Columbia University
said indefinitely, they can always change this policy back.
They might take the results and the data
that they get over the next five years.
They'll take a look at it and be like,
you know what, maybe these kids
are not really graduating or whatever.
I don't know whatever happens,
whatever is considered bad results,
they can always turn it back.
But I do think it's important to give it a shot.
At the end of the day,
I do not blame Columbia University at all.
I think that things were looking really homogenous on campus.
And I just think that the process
to try to fix these historic injustices
is super clunky though.
Like on the other side,
I could see valid arguments on both sides
is what I'm trying to say.
But I'm just like, I don't know.
Somebody should try something, I guess.
Like, I mean, I don't know.
Like it'd be much better to try to implement
free SAT learning or free different classes
at a more structural level.
But I just know that that's going to be
like too difficult to execute.
Yeah, as far as what one college can do,
I think that giving it a trial run is worth it.
You got to try these things out.
And a trial run is not just three years, right?
That might be too little to get a full rep in.
Yeah, for sure.
But ultimately, I think we all agree
that education or some type of opportunities
at a younger age are much more helpful.
Because you can't always change people's families.
You have no control over that.
But at least if you give them more opportunities
at a young age,
or give them some type of extra learning,
like a fun app where they can get rewarded on
or whatever it is, that can actually help a lot.
Yeah, I think people deserve extra help.
But obviously, if they don't make full utilization
or they're taking that help for granted,
then it's also okay to make that help
come with some prerequisites.
And remember, they still have to have
a super sick resume to get in.
Like the rest of the resume,
if the resume is amazing
and they just don't have the SAT score,
sure, why not, right?
Anyways, guys, let us know in the comments down below
what you think.
Is America truly a meritocracy?
What are some possible other solutions that could help?
Or do you agree?
Do you disagree?
Should Columbia and other schools just try this out
and just see how it goes?
It could possibly break the cycle for a lot of people
and help a lot of people out.
And you know, you let us know in the comments down below.
We are the Hot Pop Boys.
Always just trying to put thoughtful videos out there, guys.
So thank you so much for watching.
And until next time, we out.
Peace.