Does the Asian nerd stereotype come from reality or media? There's a hot debate online right now. Let's talk about it
Yeah, this discussion was going viral on reddit. There were so many many discussions going on
Why is it so bad to be an Asian nerd in America? Is being a nerd even bad?
How come white nerds seem like they have the better than Asian nerds? What is the cause of it?
Is it society? Is it Hollywood? Is it the parents? Is it the stem subjects?
Is it just our culture?
And then of course there was even arguments way outside of that joining us today for this complicated discussion all the way from LA
We've got one of the original hot pop boys Nelly Nell Chan in the building. What's good, man?
It's always good to be back in New York and have these type of hot topics and discussions with y'all man
Yeah, Andrew
We got to get into it right because make sure you like subscribe turn on your notifications
Because this is a topic that gets brought up quite often
Yeah, I'm sure this is not the first or the last video that we're gonna make about this
But yeah, let's go through the four main points that you need to understand about this topic when you're discussing
Being an Asian nerd in America and then also at the end
I might tell you why I think being an Asian nerd in America is great right now
All right. It's a great time to be an Asian real quick
I think we have to establish Andrew this Asian nerd stereotype particularly for East Asians has been around for 40 years
Literally, this is the Time magazine cover in
1987 of course, there was still a variance you still had your Chad good-looking nerds up there
And then you've got you know, some of the nerdier nerds at the bottom of it, but basically those kids play tennis
Yeah, some of the kids were like better looking nerds and other ones, but it doesn't matter
Anyway
what I wanted to talk about was just like a lot of people feel like this stereotype has been forced on to the Asian American
Community and a lot of people are always reacting to it whether they're buying into it whether they're rebelling against it
Whether they accept it reluctantly, but they have a bad life. So we got to get into four different points
Like I said, this is such a complicated topic
But we're gonna get into what we can I would say this number one Andrew being a nerd in America
It's particularly polarizing for Asian guys in the sense that everybody's always imagining the fat kid from lookism
Or you're like a 10 out of 10 ratchet Kevin Wynn. So I just why is that?
Why does it seem like there it's always like it's never gonna be the fusion person
It was like 5 out of 10 on both who's like distributing their identity equally
It's always gonna be the people on the extreme ends of the spectrum that get characterized in media or even online
Well, I would say that definitely Asian nerds in media are only depicted as super nerds
Like they're the side character there. They don't they're not also athletic. They're not also the hero. They're usually
The butt of the joke everything like that right now. I will say that there are some
examples of like white
Heroic nerds kind of like a spider-man Peter Parker type thing
but there's not that's also not the main thing either most people like to have one or the other and
This is where we can blame media where we know that there have always been if you know enough Asian people always been like
Athletic Asian nerds right a little like captain of the land for example, right? He went to Harvard
He scored high on his exit like Jeremy is all by all means went to a nerd
But he's also, you know great basketball player
So it's kind of like I think that that it doesn't get shown enough and I think this is where you can blame me
Do you think people end up buying into that like because you know some people know you grew up in an Asian neighborhood
You knew people who are both probably both ends of the extreme spectrum, but also in the middle, right?
Yeah, I think going back into social media. We're not like
Glorified in that middle range area where like, you know
We're not a 10 out of 10 nerd or like, you know a 10 out of 10 like f-boy, right?
But there's no really like public figure for that in that middle area for us
Yeah, I would say for example for like white nerds. You've got like Jeff Bezos who's like William winning, right?
He's got like a lot of women good deal on Elon Musk the Winklevoss twins
It seems like the elite white people. They almost are like both they could be like a 10 out of 10 Brainiac
But then they're like a 10 out of 10 Chad at the same time
But like we said Andrew for Asians that archetype doesn't really exist yet and those people maybe if they do exist
They haven't been thrust into the limelight
That that is one of the things that is noteworthy about point number one Oh Andrew
I did also notice even people who had to play Asian nerds in media
For example, like Jacob Balaton from spider-man, you know, he's playing like a computer and Peter Parker's friend
But he didn't really get girls
He in his own life wants to get like really cool and almost looks like a DJ now and like the DMC championships
Yeah, I mean I think in media in America
They it's easy to thrust like Asians or minorities into nerdy roles or into roles that they just want to see because I think in
America actually there are like so many archetypes of people there's archetypes in America that don't even that rarely exist in
Asia or that are definitely not glorified right kind of like you're huge stocky like buff nice gentle giant
Like those are some of the people in Asia, but they never really get there's no equivalent of like the rock or Dave Bautista in Asia
Yeah, there's no even like Chris Hemsworth Mark Wahlberg these kind of like ruddy stocky kind of heroes and heartthrobs
Um, interestingly enough point number two in Asia
I think being a nerd because it is to be honest more academic more scholarly more part of the
Inborn Asian culture Andrew there's more shades of nerdism in Asia than there is here
So not only do Asians get shoved into like a zero one binary in America where it's like you're either a f-boy
Or you're a nerd boy in Asia. I think there's way more shades of nerd. Well, it's not shocking that in Asia
they're gonna more glorify nerds or being
Kind of nerdy is already like the status quo like everybody's maybe just a little bit more nerdy in Asia for the most part, right?
Because that's what they value and that's kind of where society is built out of right
Maybe the sports systems are still catching up to America
Maybe the the fight systems or all this the entertainment systems are no you play pro ball in Asia
You would say the pro ballers in Asia are not nearly as elevated in status as the pro ballers in America, right?
No 100% not I don't think that's like what they value or like what it's like what they want
Just based off due to the upbringing and like the know the parental system and stuff like that
There's just like they just want to be they like to do what they like to do
But but like at the end of the day, they want to be successful in other ways
I would say that to your point like like you were saying like, you know
Your kid being really good at math and your kid doing like all these extra workbooks in Asia
That's not looked down upon like it is in America
I'm not saying that some parents wouldn't look up to in America, but other parents would be like, oh my gosh
Your kids not gonna be popular at school. Like that's like the standard. Yeah, they think that's tight
Yeah, they think it's good in Asia. My kid loves math
Yeah, I would say overall American culture is not nerdy like even though there's a lot of nerds in America and nerds like to come
Here and study. I really don't think that American culture at least pop culture is nerd
I agree with you America has always needed nerds on a back-end
invisible structural level to maintain
Economic and technological dominance in the world, but it is never on a pop cultural level ever value nerds
Look at like Marilyn Monroe or look at like Elvis or James Dean
People were famous because they were like swaggy and swaggy things and like smoke cigarettes
They were not famous and do crazy things. Yeah, and even like Albert Einstein people go. Oh, yeah, that was a great American scientist
He was from Germany
Wasn't even American. Okay, he's got a crazy accent. Um moving on Andrew in the u.s. Particularly
There's a good transition to talk about u.s. Culture
Why do you think it is in the u.s? And I think that every culture has this but in the u.s
There's a particular desire for a tamed wildness
But they want the wildness and maybe I think there's a reason why that quote-unquote like nerdy people that are hyper
Stereotypically nerdy in America have such like a are viewed as like I guess not desirable to hang out with
It's like what is it because they lack the wildness and they lack the unpredictably factor
What I think there's a couple of things they could be looked at there. They're not cool. They're you know, kind of shelter
They're not confident and they're boring. They're not fun
But I mean, like I said society's perception of nerds is that's not how it really are, you know, right?
Yeah, I mean there's a lot of like books written on why women are kind of attracted to bad boys
Because they're like masculine they're dangerous
They're kind of mysterious and if you can tame a bad boy and bring the good out of him
That's almost like an accomplishment, right?
And and maybe it works a little bit differently for how men kind of perceive women
But basically like yeah, America is a great country to be a bad boy. Is it a great country to be a nerd?
I also still think it's a pretty good country to be a nerd in but it's definitely not the best country
And definitely the people who are using
America for its freedoms the most I think would be considered like bad boys like these
like the guys who are not running the system, but they're using the system and they're kind of like these, uh
cool, like, you know guys who are on the edge doing edgy things but like
Because they even look at how like a Cyclops Cyclops get what he gets played out by Wolverine, right?
Doesn't Wolverine take Cyclops his chicken X-Men? Yeah. Yeah
They would never allow that storyline they would be like, oh that is so bad for the society like
Cyclops is who everybody should try to be like, why does the why why do we make the bad boy get the top girl?
You know, maybe the top scoring guy on the test should get the top girl
I'm not saying that the bad boys in Asia don't get something too, but it's a smaller niche, right?
They don't promote it for sure. They're for sure. They don't promote it for sure, man
Yeah, I do think we can blame sometimes the American media machine because you know in Asia
They whether it's not I'm not even talking about China and how strictly they censor stuff
But even in maybe Korea there there in Asia in general to various levels
There's a stronger linkage between what the government wants to promote as good society and media
Like those are gonna be more like coalesced into one. There's a lot more
The morals just saw different man morals the morals and you know values are just gonna be different
It's almost like more comparable what I would say to like 1930s American morals or like maybe 1950s definitely pre
1970s morals
Asia's like still like that to be honest for better or worse it right you guys decide
Um Andrew last but not least obviously there are reasons why Asians push their kids into STEM fields, right?
Like STEM fields traditionally. I do think it's changing right now in 2023
We're considered the most stable and the least image based because obviously us we all have careers that are based off image, right?
Sometimes it is tough as an Asian, right?
So you want to put your kids in the fields where like only?
Delivering on the equation or figuring out the algorithm or figuring out the medical problem is the answer, right?
You don't want to be in high-level banking or marketing or finance something where like I guess it's very like relationship based
Yeah, I mean, I think it's tough
I feel like for nerdy parents who are raising a nerdy kid and maybe the parents aren't super social
You got to find a balance for the kid
You got to get that kid in social interactions and social systems somehow so that they develop
Sociality because we all know a lot of nerds who are very smart, but they're like kind of shut-ins
they're introverts and
How are they ever going to really live like a good social life?
Or by the time they get older and they finally decide they want to it's very very hard to change, right?
Yeah, I think it's tough because no you would you agree that the majority of like high-level Hoopers are probably not STEM majors. Oh
Yeah, for sure probably eight out of ten nine out of ten of like high-level Hoopers are not necessarily
I mean, let's just say it's eight out of ten
So what do you tell you say to like Asian parents?
They're like, yeah
I wanted my son to play basketball
But then all of his teammates do not care about school or tear about school as much as I want them to so why would?
I let my son play basketball man
I think going back to what you were saying about putting them in a field or environment that
accommodates the best out of the values you're looking for for the kid is like
I don't know put them in like an Asian League or like with other like, you know kids who are like do good at school
But they also enjoy playing basketball or soccer or whatever sport that they want to play in but like just put them in the environment
That fits what you want them to be right, right?
It's not like a hundred out of a hundred basketball teams all none of them care about
Yeah, don't put it like find the ones don't put it like the a you hood hood kids or something, you know
Yeah, I think that you can position them in a thing that has best of both worlds
I think that goes back to my original point Andrew. How come people feel like you can only be one or the other?
I think you can be like a nine out of ten nerd and why can't you be a nine out of ten into something else?
But anyway, Andrew that leads us into your takeaways. Yeah, my takeaways is that right now in America?
It is great to be an Asian nerd
There is no other time in American history that it was this good to be an Asian nerd
I just spent all this to the last couple points telling you how bad it is
Yeah, so obviously being an Asian nerd is it not as fun or not as cool as being like a white nerd in America?
Yes, because we're in America and that's how America is designed
So that's just a little bit of truth that you're just gonna have to accept for now
However part that was going that was a pretty viral debate and the thing. Yeah, but to me it's not a debate
It's literally no debate. It's just how it is
But but here's things that you can do about it
And here's what you should consider as an Asian nerd guys
The world's economies are moving in your favor. The world is getting nerdier more techie, right?
All the biggest viral most viral people of the past five years were nerds
Whether it's Elon Joe size CZ Zuckerberg, even if you wanted to say same Bankman Freed who kind of messed up, right?
anyways, and then
number two the knowledge on how to better yourself is
More accessible and plentiful than it ever has been so whether we're talking about style guides
Workout trainer the gurus the advice videos the support community the role models all the procedures you could do all these things are more
Plentiful and accessible for you to change yourself and better yourself
So it's like almost like you live in the information age
And if you're a nerd you understand that you do so it's just like just use the the information to your advantage, right?
And then also Asian men are more successful
There are more powers of position and have more leverage in society
A lot of them are more CEOs
Right as we know a lot of the Indian CEOs and even a lot of like other East Asian CEOs and everybody else
They're just Asians are just rising up in general
and then also I would say that it is more frowned upon to bully geeks and
Nerds than it was 20 30 years ago
If you guys think it's bad being an Asian nerd today, then you can only imagine what it was
Like being an Asian nerd 30 years ago. It was worse
I think my biggest thing is like I just hate the way people buy into the societal constructs that are like built by
The Western world like in Asia if you have someone like a demos Chang or you have somebody that is like half-half
You know and obviously some of that is just genetic like on a looks-based basis
But they have like cool nerds that are getting everything they want out of life in Asia
Yeah, just because we don't have that archetype in America
I just always refuse to you know what?
I mean like why why can't you be 10 out of 10 into school and be in a scholar and academics or whatever given field?
You're in and then be like
Six seven or eight out of nine or nine out of ten in a different field, right?
I just don't understand why people can't like mix and match and it is true in America
I think the way that things are segmented it does make the mixing and matching of like opposing identities more difficult
But would you say what technology and the Internet is totally doable now?
100% you know what social media being so big like whatever lane you're playing you can like market it or you can do it and
You get that entrepreneurship is like so easy to you know do now
You know what?
You know what social media now that everybody can be like teaching some type of like nerdy thing nerdy topic or lesson finance
Or anything like doing yourself out there
Yeah
Be entrepreneurial about your identities if you feel like your identity that you have is not like being rewarded fairly or treated
Well, which we all just listed a bunch of reasons why it potentially may or may not depending on the fishbowl of society that you
Inhabit then there are a ton of moves. You can bust. Yeah, definitely
You know, my last thought is like you don't have to give up the stem field
But you can also do one other thing that is clearly not stem like we're not gaming though
Yeah, let's say you wouldn't pick gaming guys. No disrespect. Don't put nine out of ten game me either
Yeah, don't be like all right. I'm nine out of ten on stem and the other one that I pick is gaming
Maybe not gaming guys. I think there's good reason for that. But yeah, I mean
let's say you want to be really in a basketball play a lot of basketball while you're a stem major or you're a stem major and
You're really into UFC MMA fight, you know, like mixed martial arts, whatever. Maybe you're really into style
Maybe you happen to be one of these stem nerds who's like super in the dressing
Yeah
Nobody said that you can't be cool while still being good at your stem subject
Nobody ever said that Hollywood did say that though or Hollywood implied that honestly
I think a lot of your parents thought that and your parents didn't believe that you could be cool and a nerd and good at
School at the same self agency. Yeah, not to not not fully to their fault
You know, I think they're very fearful and they're just like doing what they know
But you gotta understand guys, they just knew what they knew whether they were like stem themselves or not stem
They just knew what they knew and you got to know that they only knew what they know
But now you know what you know
You and you know, you gotta know that. Yeah, you know what they know
So you just know that you know more and you know this world more than they anyways guys
Let us know in the comments down below what you think about all this
And also, yeah, let us know in the comments down below
Do you feel like that it's more media's fault or reality's fault and what constitutes reality?
Is it your parents your culture your look?
Whatever how you are as a person your own personality that you're born with you
Let us know in the comments down below this discussion could go on and all we might make more videos about this
Of course, it is the hot pop boys from frivolous to serious. We're talking about it all
Thank you for joining us today. Nelly Nell Chen until next time. Let us know in the comment section. We out. Peace