Was Pele the Most "Overrated" Player EVER? (RIP)

Raymar Football
21 followers
16 Video Views·Feb 3, 2023
Back when I started my YouTube channel, one of the very first videos to start getting a lot of views
was the one where I talked about why Pele is the most overrated player ever. Sure,
maybe I wanted to clickbait a little to help grow my channel and might have said some outlandish
things, but for the most part, it's undeniable just how misunderstood Pele's career was.
Trust me, I get he's an idol to many, and one of the greatest ever whose impact to the game
of football is unmatched, so I understand how the video title might anger some. But to see
how many people refute the facts and still claim his career is free of criticism blows my mind.
So today, we're going to change the clickbait title and discuss once and for all why Pele,
despite being the greatest of his generation and arguably even the entire history of football,
still has, more than any other footballer, the most misunderstood and controversial career
of all time. But regardless of that, what's definitely not controversial and is a widely
known fact is that there is no better dungeon battle RPG than today's sponsor, Raid Shadow
Legends. Raid Shadow Legends has, without a doubt, the best lore, combat, and graphics of any RPG
I've ever played on mobile. And right now, they're celebrating their second anniversary since they've
absolutely took over the internet. Right now, they're having special events and tournaments
running from March to the middle of April, like the Champion Training Event and the Champion
Chase Tournament, which I'm super excited for. I decided to give them a try and was amazed at
how huge the game really is. I've always loved characters that do long-range attacks, so I
decided to start out with the Dark Elf Champions because for some reason, their attacks remind me
of long shots, which are my favorite types of goals in football. But you could always choose
your own champions and level up and gain special skills and attacks that suit more of your preference.
There's also the epic and absolutely massive campaign story that really gives you a true
fantasy experience. And come on, just look at how insane these graphics are. If you want to get a
huge start in Raid, all you have to do is hit the link in the description or scan the QR code you're
seeing right now, and you'll get a free epic champion, Jotun. That's right, a free epic
champion, as well as 100k silver, 50 gems, and 3 ancient shards so you can summon awesome champions
as soon as you get in-game. So why not download Raid Shadow Legends right now and join me? Click
the very first link in the description and sign up for Raid Shadow Legends today. First off, I want
to start by saying I'm in no way trying to mock or disrespect Pele. It's not the goal of this video
and definitely not reflecting of my opinion on him. I truly believe Pele is one of the top 5
greatest of all time and unmatched in his era and influence over global football. My goal here is to
simply talk about the controversies in his career and many common misconceptions surrounding it,
giving both pro and con perspectives on the argument. To start off, the biggest and most
well-known is, of course, Pele's goal-scoring record. It was the first thing I mentioned in
my older video and it's probably the most well-known misconception about Pele's career.
For years, Pele's PR team and supporters will always stand by the fact that Pele scored 1283
goals during his career. However, the facts support that his official record is 767 goals
and 812 appearances, meaning that almost 40% of his goals were scored in friendlies, exhibitions,
and tour games. Now, regardless of that, he still has an insane career goal-scoring ratio of 0.94
goals a game and I don't think any single person can say that isn't anything shy of legendary.
But many people use the fact that for decades, Pele and his team have always denied the official
goal number, which has caused many people to dislike him and call him overrated simply because
so many casual football fans had believed and still do believe that Pele's record was really
1,283 goals without knowing anything else. But even then, his official goal tally is still
insanely good. But you still see jokes all over social media, especially on Twitter,
because people dislike the fact that he's trying to make his official stats better than they
actually were. Many people also claim that those unofficial games were mostly against
farmers or absolute scrubs. I mean, I certainly did in my old video. However, an argument that
Pele fans can make is while he did play matches against teams like the Brazilian Coast Guard,
who are far from professional players, a lot of those goals in friendlies and unofficial matches
were also against top teams in every European league. I mean, the list is just too long to
read one by one, but look at how many wins he has in each country and how many goals he scored
against each team. If you add it all up, he scored 145 goals in 130 matches across 16 European
countries, an insane 1.12 goals per game ratio. He also had his best performances against Italian
teams with 41 goals in 38 appearances and in West Germany with 29 goals in 19 appearances.
I'll admit when I made my original video, I didn't really know that, but it's just absolutely
incredible. Because many of Pele's critics say he never played officially, they try to take away
the fact that Pele absolutely destroyed those teams, regardless if the wins or goals had any
weight behind them or not. But you definitely have to give him credit for that. So honestly,
I believe a lot of people just used this argument against Pele because he was dishonest about his
record for so long. But when you really look at it, how could you blame him? If you played that
well across the best clubs in Europe, you would want those goals and matches to count too, right?
Even if they weren't exactly official. The next point I made in my video was that the overall
competition and level of football that Pele was playing against wasn't really competitive at all.
In a way, I kind of still hold onto that opinion. While there were a few legendary defenders in
Pele's era like Franz Beckenbauer and Bobby Moore, the talent pool was very uneven and top heavy.
In fact, the only goalkeeper who really made a name for himself back then was Lev Yashin,
arguably football's greatest goalkeeper. And you don't really hear much about other goalkeepers
in that era at all. While there were only a very few good players that stood out, the rest
were nothing really special at all. Especially between defenders and goalkeepers of that time.
I mean honestly, look at most of these highlights. Do you see much world-class defending?
Sure, Pele's insane touch, skill, and dribble would make any defender look foolish. But just
look at every other defender he beats. They just stand around and watch while most of them do simple
jabs. Pele was way ahead of his time and was without a doubt the greatest talent in the world
during his prime. And it made it a lot easier that 90% of the players trying to take the ball
away from him were most likely not the best. If you look at today's game for example, the talent
pool is honestly quite spread out with your average defender being much better than they
were in Pele's time. Those who try to defend Pele's case would say that there shouldn't be
any comparison. They were completely different eras with different training, diets, and philosophies
of the game. And trust me, I get that completely. Comparing eras of a sport isn't really the best
way to analyze things. Pele was like the Albert Einstein of his era and a lot of you guys pointed
out other similar analogies to me in my previous video. However, on the other hand, many of you
claim and swear that Pele faced incredibly aggressive defense that were out to break his
legs. I have to firmly disagree with that completely. If you look at footage of defenders
in Pele's era, they in fact make much more legitimate challenges and clean tackles than
players do today. Just look at what you're seeing right now. They are in no way trying to break
Pele's legs or injure him. They are actually going for the ball and trying to make clean tackles.
Do they seem like extremely skilled defenders? Well, some of you might say yes and others might
disagree. But to say that he faced a much more ruthless and aggressive defense is a pure myth.
Defenders in Pele's era I would say are without a doubt more disciplined than defenders of today.
You rarely see any horror tackles or malicious attempts at taking the ball. I mean, come on.
Compare that to defensive plays of today's game, you're definitely much more likely to get injured.
I mean, guys like Pepe and Sergio Ramos are infamous for their over-aggressiveness.
Some of these tackles I'm showing right now are outright scary and you would never want
your favorite player to come across those types of plays. From what I could gather,
defenders back then played more by the book and less risky. Would Pele do well against the best
defenders of modern football? Well, I believe he absolutely would. I mean, he played with a heavy
leather ball and still had that much control and skill. But I also believe his career would be
shorter or, at the very least, receive more injuries because defenders are just a lot more
aggressive and play more dangerously in modern football. Another point I made in my old video
was that Pele's international record and achievements are surrounded with a lot of
misconceptions. I've seen a lot of people, especially on Instagram and Twitter, mistaken
some of his international records. For one, some people believe Pele held the record for the most
goals in the World Cup, but that record belongs to fellow Brazilian Ronaldo the Phenomeno. They
also think that Pele has the most World Cup matches won, but that record of 16 wins also
belongs to another fellow Brazilian, Cafu. In fact, many of you would be surprised to hear that Pele
has never won the World Cup Golden Boot. Just look at his performances in the World Cup side-by-side
with the Golden Boot scorer. However, on the other hand, nobody has more World Cup trophies
than Pele himself. He's the youngest to ever score a hat-trick in the World Cup at 17 years old. And
even if you think the defense back then was subpar, it's still an insane achievement. I mean,
it's not his fault he was too good for his era, because that record has never been close to being
beat and I don't think it ever will be. But another side of the argument is that it was a
lot easier for Pele because Brazil had the best players in the world by a long shot. Sure, Pele
was definitely the greatest of his era, but his teammates were right behind him as the greatest
players in the world, making Brazil basically a super team. And although Pele was the best player
in his country, many people seem to have the misconception that Pele single-handedly carried
Brazil without any doubt, which isn't the case at all. In fact, during his first World Cup final
in 1958, his teammate Didi was voted the player of the tournament, winning the Golden Ball. Also,
in Pele's second World Cup win in 1962, he was injured and didn't even play any significant
minutes in elimination matches. While his teammate Guerincha carried Brazil to a win
with some breathtaking performances that won him the Golden Ball and the Golden Boot as the top
player and top scorer of the tournament. And on his third and final World Cup win in 1970,
it was Jairzinho who scored 7 goals and led Brazil in scoring compared to Pele's 4. Now,
in no way am I saying Pele wasn't an integral part of Brazil. I just want to demystify the
misconceptions that many people have who claim that Pele single-handedly carried Brazil to 3
World Cup wins. However, regarding in 1962 when Pele was out for the elimination stages of the
World Cup and say he really only won 2 of those tournaments instead of 3. Because, for example,
many people, including myself, say that Ronaldo the Phenomeno has 2 World Cups under his name.
But during his first win in 1994, he was the youngest player on the squad and didn't even
play at all. So when I discredited Pele in my previous video, saying his 1962 World Cup didn't
really count, it's not really a fair criticism. Simply out of curiosity, how many of you have
ever been told by the previous generation or by simple rumors you've heard online that Pele is
without a doubt the greatest player of all time? And just take it as a fact without ever questioning
it versus actually watching his highlights, learning about his career, and then forming
your own opinion. I'm not saying it's a bad thing, but in my original video, I mentioned that a young
17-year-old Cristiano Ronaldo claimed Pele was the best player ever. But how could he have known
that? Pele had already been retired for 8 years by the time CR7 was even born. I'd imagine in 2002
when he made that comment, it wasn't as easy to watch specific highlights or documentaries about
Pele like we can today. My guess is that Pele was just that great. That almost everyone said he was
the best player of all time. That is how legendary and above the rest Pele was. Whether you agree or
not, it's undeniable that he was so great that his name is known by generations who have never
even seen him play. And just for that, you have to give your respect. Pele, probably more than anyone
else, has made football the global game that it is today. Even during those friendlies and
exhibitions he went on throughout the world that many people criticize him for, he was spreading
the love of the game to younger generations or people who had never really cared about football.
Showing them the beauty of the sport and inspiring them to play or be a fan. Pele's influence
throughout the years remains unmatched. You don't have to believe that he was the greatest player
of all time or the most skilled player of all time. You might even dislike him and think he's
overrated. But if there's one thing you can't deny, Pele is a footballing icon whose name will never
ever be forgotten.
