Why VAR is Ruining Football!

Nonstop Football
66 followers
3 Video Views·Jan 29, 2023
Do you remember the good old days when we could celebrate a goal without having to wait
5 minutes to see if the striker's nose was offside? Don't you just miss those days?
VAR was supposed to make football better. So far, it's only made things worse. From
inconsistent decisions to lengthy delays, here are 5 reasons why VAR is ruining football.
1. Decisions are subjective
Goal-line technology has been a great addition to football.
It has. It's a black-or-white decision. Did the ball cross the line or not?
The same can't be said for VAR, though. Many decisions in football are subjective.
Whether it's a penalty or not is often down to interpretation.
Those who wanted VAR thought it would solve all the game's problems.
All it's actually done is created more of them.
Managers often call for consistency. They hoped VAR would achieve this.
But all it's done is just shift the decision-making to the video referee.
VAR gets decisions wrong, too. And it feels even more unfair than
it did when mistakes were down to the referee's human error.
As if that wasn't bad enough, there's more. The introduction of VAR and its robotic
interpretations have led to the laws being applied much more harshly.
Slow-motion replays and multiple camera angles mean even minor infractions are being analysed
The punishment often doesn't fit the crime. I mean, is it really fair to give a penalty for
a defender touching an opponent's shirt for half a second?
Alright, we'll admit that VAR has marginally improved the accuracy of decision-making.
But we'll never get the consistency that managers crave. It's simply not gonna happen.
And in the meantime, we're losing what's made the game so special in the first place.
2. It slows the game down
Technology's used successfully in sports like tennis, rugby, and cricket. But there's one
big difference between those sports and football, though. In tennis, rugby, and cricket, there are
natural stoppages in play. It means decisions can be checked without actually disrupting the match
to match. Football's different. It's a free-flowing game. Sometimes the ball can be in play for
minutes without any pauses. It's part of what makes football so entertaining. Teams can trade
blows and take turns to attack without any pauses. Well, that was the case before VAR, anyway.
Now we have to sit twiddling our thumbs for five minutes while the officials pour over
countless replays. VAR was introduced to prevent major injustices. It was supposed
to be used only occasionally. We were told that clear and obvious decisions
would be the only ones analysed. Yeah, right, look how that's turned out.
Too much time is wasted on VAR reviews. Yeah, referees can add on more stoppage
time at the end of halves. But that doesn't solve the main problem. VAR is ruining football's
natural flow. 3. It's ruined the offside law
The offside law was created to stop blatant goal-hanging. It wasn't created to measure
whether a striker's toenail was beyond the last defender. VAR's turned offside into a joke.
Instead of enjoying replays of a well-worked goal, we now have to sit and wait while an
official draws lines on a screen in a dark room hundreds of miles away. The worst thing is,
those lines can never be 100% accurate. Even with today's technology, it's impossible to
stop the frame at the exact moment the ball's played. If the actions paused a split second
earlier or later, the decision might be different. In a Premier League game earlier this season,
Liverpool thought they'd scored a last-minute winner against Everton.
To the naked eye, it looked like a brilliant goal. But VAR couldn't help itself. It just had
to stick its nose in and ruin the fun. It wouldn't have been so bad if there was an obvious offside.
But there wasn't. Sadio Mane's elbow was apparently behind the Everton defence in the build-up,
so Jordan Henderson was denied a goal. It was absolutely ridiculous. But sadly,
we've seen countless other examples in the last two years. Surely this isn't what anyone
actually wanted. 4. It encourages dirty tactics
Now, we're not saying the game was free of dirty play before VAR. Players have been diving,
feigning injury, and trying to get opponents sent off for years. VAR makes it worse, though.
In the old days, a player could roll around as much as he liked, but the referee wasn't
going to change his mind if he'd already waved play on. These days, with every tiny incident
looked at by officials in the booth, players have something to gain by milking the situation.
Most tackles look worse in slow motion, so the combination of multiple replays and a player
exaggerating can easily lead to a red card. In the first El Clasico of this season,
Sergio Ramos won a penalty after having his shirt pulled. It was silly from Clement Lenglet,
but the referee initially ruled no penalty. Before VAR, Ramos would have appealed for a
With VAR, he threw himself to the ground and disrupted the game to try and convince the
video referees it was a terrible foul. I suppose you can't really blame Ramos for doing that,
but football's got itself into a real mess when dirty tactics are basically being encouraged.
5. It takes away the fun Bill Shankly once famously joked that
football is more important than life and death. Yeah, let's be real. Football is a form of
entertainment first and foremost. VAR is ruining the fun. Football's about skill, teamwork,
passion and joy. It's not about VAR officials zooming into a replay to see if the ball
struck a defender closer to his shoulder or his elbow. There's nothing more soul-destroying than
celebrating a goal for your team than being forced to wait five minutes to see if it'll
actually be awarded. It's even worse for the fans. They haven't got a clue what's going on
when VAR does its thing. Even if we're getting slightly more accurate decisions this way,
it's not necessarily a good thing. Imagine all the great goals in football history that
might have been ruled out if VAR had decided that a teammate of Messi, Ronaldo or Pele
was fractionally offside 30 seconds earlier. Even very wrong decisions create talking points.
Maradona's hand of God is part of his legend. Would football really be better if moments like
that were taken away? VAR is ruining what we love about football by making the laws harsher,
slowing the game down and encouraging foul play. It's been a complete and utter nightmare. If we
want to make sure that football remains the world's most entertaining and popular sport,
we need to ditch VAR before it's too late.
