Loch Ness Monster - The Surgeon's Photo

Naked Science
162 followers
9 Video Views·Jan 10, 2023
But one picture that's always been hard to explain away,
at the very heart of the myth,
the so-called surgeon's photo.
Surgeon's photograph is the icon.
It is what most people see as Nessie.
It is their Nessie.
It's instantaneously recognizable,
but there is still an enigma attached to it.
In the 1930s, the surgeon's photo was a sensation.
Not only did it seem to prove that Nessie existed,
it came from an impeccable source, a much respected surgeon.
Yet the true story of the picture
is one of greed and deceit, and a desire for revenge.
In 1933, the seeds of deceit were sown
when an English newspaper hired self-styled big game hunter,
Marmaduke Wetherill, to hunt down the Loch Ness monster.
Within days, Wetherill claimed to be hot on its trail.
He found monster-sized footprints on the shore of the Loch.
The Daily Mail newspaper announced his triumph to the world.
And late in 1933, casts of the footprints
were sent to London's Natural History Museum for examination.
Just a week later, however,
the museum produced a damning verdict.
They could find no difference between the monster footprints
and those made by a hippopotamus.
Wetherill had tried to fool the world
by creating footprints with a silver hippo foot ashtray,
a souvenir from his hunting days.
Disgraced and bent on revenge,
Wetherill returned to the Loch with a model of a monster.
Made from a toy submarine
with a plastic dinosaur's head and neck,
it was the handiwork of his stepson, Christian Sperling.
He phoned up his son, his stepson Christian,
and said, OK, if they want their monster,
I'll give them their monster.
Wetherill didn't just photograph the model on Loch Ness.
He went a step further.
His hippo foot hoax had ensured that nobody would believe him
if he produced the new picture.
So he persuaded Robert Wilson,
a respected London-based surgeon, to join in the hoax.
Wilson, who loved practical jokes,
agreed to pretend to the press
that he had taken the picture.
The hoax was a runaway success,
and the surgeon's photo was accepted as proof
that Nessie existed.
Amazingly, the real story remained a secret for 50 years.
The true story of this hoax
was known amongst small pockets of people,
but it never got into the wider general public domain.
But how did a two-foot-high model fool the world?
Martin demonstrates by placing
a similarly-sized model in the loch.
The photo that first appeared in the newspapers was cropped.
The unedited version shows part of the shoreline,
indicating that the model was placed near the shore itself.
So we follow suit.
But the original photograph
shows a pattern of distinctive ripples.
Now we also have ripples.
Martin is happy the conditions are similar
and takes a photo.
And with a bit of computer trickery,
we can add grain and black and white.
Side by side, the two photographs are very similar.
It seems that the hoax was incredibly simple, but effective.
A vital cornerstone of the legend has been exposed,
and yet many seemingly mysterious sightings
remain unexplained.
