Is Equalization a Myth on Highline Anchors??? 2 guys + 5 dynomometers + 13 anchors!!!

HowNOT2
100 followers
1 Video View·Mar 1, 2018
Andy Lewis and I play with 5 dynomometers all afternoon to see if 13 different anchor set ups would equalize. Nerd out on these results!
Visit Andy's Youtube channel at Slacklife TV
Buy bolting apparel at www.hownot2.com
I heard that equalization was a myth, so we're going to find out in my backyard today.
Check it out on this episode of How Not to Highline.
Hi, I'm Andy Lewis, and today on How Not to Highline, we are going to test
is equalization a myth? In doing so, we have drilled four movable bolts that we
both come out of Ryan's patio, which are attached to soft shackles that attach to our dynamometers.
A dynamometer is basically a load cell telling us the force that is being placed on these specific
anchor points. Now, all four of these anchor points are tied together with a static rope to
make your anchor. This is the master point. So we have a dynamometer here, which will tell us our
load from our ram puller that is pulling in the direction of that tree. That will then go back
to our other dynamometers, and we are going to test this to tell you whether or not equalization
is a myth. Everything's in line here with the tree, and it should, in theory, equalize perfectly
because everything is coming off at a good angle. I think it will equalize evenly. What do you think?
I think that the two outside ones are going to be similar, but less than the middle ones. I think
the bolt that is closest to this tree in the middle is going to show the most force.
I think that our sliding X is far enough that everything should be pulling evenly.
So, we have our dynos all facing up with the soft shackles this way. So,
we can read it. Read off the tension of the main dyno. Here we go. Let's see what happens here.
We're at 0.9. We're at 1.2. 1.7. 2.2. 3.8.
4.06. Okay. Stop it there. We're at 5 kilonewtons, which is just about
over a thousand pounds, and we can see here that both of the outside ones are of similar nature.
The bolt that is furthest away from the tree in the middle is second highest, and the one
that I said is going to be the highest is the highest. Now, the interesting thing about this
is that I can change all of this by doing one thing, and what is that one thing, ladies and
gentlemen? That is changing the directional relativity of this force. So, with equalized
anchors, the reason why this slides is because if I kick it right now, let's see our anchor, and
oh, by golly, every single one of those changed. So now, check it out. That's holding almost
nothing. It's holding nothing on this side, and on the left side, it has gained quite a bit,
and now the one in the middle on the left has more tension. Okay, so now we have a BFK in this thing,
which in theory is even worse because you're eyeballing whether or not each strand is even.
So, I am personally not a fan of BFKs. I like sliding Xs with whoopies,
so we'll find out if this BFK equalizes those better than a sliding X.
These look exactly the same on this side, and then this one has a little bit more,
and this one has a little bit less, so this is actually more equalized than the last one.
Now, let me show you why I like the BFK. Let me try to switch those numbers,
and now we've got nothing on this one. Two on this one, 0.85, and nothing on this one. So,
way to go. You really worked it. So, I proved myself that you can really,
really change the way that your anchors work by just kicking it a little bit. So, if you guys
ever thought equalization is something that you should care about, it is because it's essentially
non-existent, and this is why it can be dangerous right there. So, what's more important than
equalization? Redundancy. So, if one of these bolts blow, you've got a couple more. Now,
our span set that is big and bulky and hard to quote-unquote equalize, so we're going to see
the difference between something that's easy to quote-unquote equalize and something that's hard
to quote-unquote equalize. So, let's tension her up. Click, click. You're at 7.5 kilometers.
Jesus. On that tree.
Okay. So, 0.42, 1.3, 3.9, 1.7. Wow. Wow.
So, my theory is that you can actually manipulate that. You'd have to put slack in it in order to
do it, but let's say we change the master point to let's try to put all the force right here.
I bet we can manipulate it because I don't see the span set able to slide and equalize.
Where you have it when you tension is where it stays in theory. So, Andy just yanked and kicked
his yank and kick method to equalize, and he was actually able to get these pretty close.
This one's still not very high. It's only 0.64, but the rest are all relatively similar.
So, that was interesting. Now, let's de-ratchet. So, try to get all the pressure on this one leg.
Okay. Well, I just tighten that one there. Okay. So, all of this, this is super, super loose,
super loose, ridiculously loose, and this one's going to be tight first.
I'm betting on that. Yep. This one's reading already 1 kilonewton on this, 0 on this.
Oh, we're on 2 kilonewtons on this one because it has to have something to balance it out,
right? It can't just be pulling on one. That wouldn't work. So, we're at 1.7 and 2.5. That's
interesting. This one pulled more, but this is still super, super loose, which is my issue with
span sets. But, obviously, static rope hasn't proven to be that great. So, see if you can
manually equalize it now. 0.16. Yeah. Well, this is what we call extension. So, now, part of the
reason why when you tie a sliding exit is a bad thing is that, let's say one bolt blows. If one
bolt blows, your anchor extends, and then you get a shock load. So, that's exactly why you
individualize your anchors. Even with a span set? Even with a span set. So, even with this,
the reason why there's no tension on the system now is because these had so much slack,
and the friction was caught right at the master point that when I kick this back and forth,
the tension is actually slowly sliding and slipping through, and now these are all pretty
much equal with nothing on them. So, without manipulating that further, ratchet some more?
Yep. We've got two on this one already, two now on that, nothing on this one,
and half a kilonewton. So, we're back to having everything on these two.
Nothing. There's still too much friction. Span sets have a lot of friction. You
can't really equalize them. You can't do a lot of stuff with all this junk going on
inside of a hard shackle here. So, now on this test, what we're going to do is we're going to
use climbing slings, which are made of Dyneema. They're very low stretch. We're going to have
them trying to be equalized only on two anchors. So, this is going to try to limit our friction,
which loses the equalization factor very quickly. So, hopefully, this system will promote a greater
equalization of the shared load of these anchors. What's Master Dino say? Master Dino says we are at
3.8 kilonewtons. And we've got half, 1.3, 0.9, 0.9. Well, that's better than the static rope was.
See if you can shuffle it that way.
Oh, yeah. We got more on the outsides now. Wow. We got more on the outside.
Why don't you just keep kicking it until it's equalized? No way. This one's low. This one's
low. Kick it that way. The lows are equal? Well, it's 0.8, 0.6, which is equal enough.
And what's the master point say now? Master point's 2.3. So, we have 2.3 kilonewtons,
and we have 0.7. It's the most equalized anchor so far. How many are we at? Okay,
we're at 6.6. 6 kilonewtons. Wow. Wow. That's what perfect equalization is going to look like.
It's never going to look like better than this. 1.5, 1.6, 1.6, 1.5. That, wow. That's an eye
opener. That is an eye opener. And the reason why this is a more effective system is simply based
on angles. So, our angles here, you can see, are sub-30 degrees on every single part of it.
So, that means that the equalization, quote-unquote, the shared load between the directional
relativity of our force to our main anchor is actually more equal this way because you don't
have the drastic angles from the fan set. You don't have the friction that disallows the actual
equalization of the anchor. So, by giving yourself two sets of two that are then connected by a set
of two, it's actually providing us a very much so equalized anchor. In fact, these are both the same,
and these are almost both the same, within 0.15 kilonewtons. So, yes, we found out how to make
the best, safest highline anchor. I might start rigging like this.
Not with climbing things. Not with climbing. 1.53, which is our highest load, divided by 5.7,
and we get 26 percent of the load is being seen on these bolts. You're actually quartering the
load being seen on each of your anchors by rigging. Wow. So, if you equalize five bolts
directly with just one static rope, you're actually not gaining anything except redundancy.
Actually, you're kind of losing redundancy, really. Well, you're still clipped. All the bolts have to
blow before you die, in theory. Yeah, well, only one bolt will most likely blow first. Yeah, because
all the load is on the one bolt. Yeah. But if you took the five bolts, or four bolts, whatever you're
until you get to this master-master point, that would be the most equalized. If you're going to
put on high, high, high forces, like a space net, you would want to do it this way. Well, ideally
speaking, this is all a relatively known material. The lower your angle, the easier it is to share
the load in between your points. Whereas, if these were spread out further, where this bolt was here,
and we were looking at a massive angle of 160 degrees, these would be reading a lot more tension
than these bolts are here. Okay, so what are we doing different here? So, what we're doing
different here is we're changing the angle between our dynamometers to see if this angle,
which is now probably closer to 45, rather than less than 30, if this will change the
dynamometers, even though this angle seems to have been brought closer by switching those. 5.92
kilonewtons on the master point, and we have 1.5. I mean, this one has more than that, but
everything else is around 1.4, 1.5. That's pretty equalized, equalized enough. So, that still works,
but it's not as good. Not as good, but pretty, still pretty good. So, I don't like, definitely
don't like how these rub right here. So, I mean, we're not, this isn't, this isn't about rigging
and stuff. This is about just forces right now. I wouldn't rig an anchor like that, though, for
sure. No, it's not ideal. It's not ideal. It's just to see what would happen. Okay, so now we're going
to try three bolts, and we zeroed these out. We put them on carabiner, so it slides really smoothly,
and only one sling, so we get just about no friction. We're all zeroed out. Let's see if three
bolts just pulls on the center one, or if they actually share the load because there's
less going on. 3.4 on the master point. Wow, that's double, double than any of these outside
ones. Wow, so a hundred percent more because of directional relativity. Wow, so the closest bolt
and the most in line with whatever the force is seems to be what holds the most pressure.
So, now what I've done is I've tied a BFK, which in this system should put most of the pressure
on the middle bolt. However, if this is just a little too long, and these take the tension first,
the middle bolt might not have any tension. So, let's see how well I tie by BFK. Here we go.
You sound like Bill Nye, the science guy, when you said that. Wow. Okay, all right, all right. We got
two on the outsides and 1.7 on the inside. So, 1.8, two. Wow, it's putting more on the leg that
just, it's just the way you tie your BFK. Exactly. One, two, 1.6, 1.8. Now, the reason why this
happens is because in this situation, you're not only depending on directional relativity,
but you're depending on the length of your anchor. So, the length between this point and the knot
right here is going to considerably affect your equalization. So, if I tied this any longer,
it might not even hold tension. Whereas, if these ones were any shorter,
this one also might not hold any tension. However, if these two were longer,
this one would get the most. So, a BFK can sometimes help equalization, as we have just
found out right here. So, let's find out if angles really affect this, which, I mean, they do,
but let's see here. So, we have, we just connected the two outside ones. What's your master point
read? 3.50. Oh, wow. So, 3.5. Yeah, you have. 3.4 divided by 3.5 is 68%. Damn, that's a pretty
good call. 3.06 divided by 3.58 is 57%. So, with this angle right here, you have between 57% and
70% of the load being seen on both bolts. Now, let's attach that same exact thing to the inside
bolts and see what a lower angle between the bolts will give us, and I guarantee you it will be more
like 30 to 40%. Here we go. Okay, so now, we have re-rigged it to the two center bolts. This is
giving us an angle of most likely around 25 to 30 degrees. So, let's tighten it up and see the
difference between the shared loads. I think I'm going to push your dynos together. Okay, stop.
What's your master point read? Master point reads 4 kilonewtons. 4 kilonewtons is,
oh, 2.5 and 1.3. This must be more in line with the tree then. Yeah, so that's 60% being seen on
that because it's more in line with the tree. Now, what I've done here is I want to try to
demonstrate what I believe in rigging is the most essential thing, which is how close is your bolt
to your anchor comparatively to your other bolts. So, having this distance, which is about 8 inches,
and this distance is about 16, and this distance is about 24, we should be able to take a percentage
from the reading we get right now and see how much difference 6 inches alone of distance between your
anchor points affects your equalization load pulling in a direction that is all the similar
direction. 5.3-ish. 5.3, so. Okay, so our first one should be, wow, our first one is only 0.89.
This one is 2.74, 1.35, and 0.25. Why is this one so much less? I think that one's so much less
because it has this right here. So, this has what I think is the most friction. So,
you think friction is causing those to be uneven? Because right now, I absolutely think that one is
the second one in line is holding, what, like almost half of the load. Now, in this case,
we're doing what proved to be the most equalized setup in the last video, and that is to equalize
two and then equalize those two miniature master points. So, from 1.7 to 0.9 is our two extremes.
I mean, the first and the last are off by quite a bit. Yeah, but what I think is going to happen
here is we are now trying to equalize our points but have the arms at dramatically noticeable
differences. So, now this arm goes to here like that. So, you did the last two equalized and the
first two equalized. Okay. I think that that is going to give us a dramatic enough effect of
having it be highest, second highest, third highest, fourth highest. Okay. Let's see what
happened. We're at 7, 6.8 right now, and we have 2.3, 1.6, 1.7, and 1. So, out of this pair,
the closest one holds the most, and out of this pair, the closest one holds the most.
But these are higher than these because these have more distance. What's your take?
I don't know. Those are the results. We're not quite sure what to think about it,
but we got high, medium, high, low. All right. So, we wanted to be able to predict how the tension
goes here, so I made the shortest angle here simply to the first bolt. So, now the first bolt
will be seeing one part of the load, and I made sure of that because it has a distance of just
these two red. This is all that's being shared. So, one part of the load, which is about 1.7,
and this part of the load, which I'm guessing is about 1.2. So, you equalized these back three
dynos. Exactly. And what are you trying to do? Put the most force on the front one? So, yeah,
exactly. So, now I know that by rigging like this, I can put the most on the front one,
for sure, in the system because it's just one sling. It equalizes really well. There's no
friction up here. So, we got 3.3, and then 1.8, 0.7, 0.4, 0.3. You have accomplished it.
So, my takeaway from this is the bolt that is closest and most in line with the direction of
pull is going to see the most force. You can manipulate that with BFKs or span sets with a
lot of friction, but you're manually playing with a lot of that, and you're guessing. If you don't
have dynos on all your bolts, I mean, you're just guessing. So, I'm all about redundancy. I'd rather
have five bolts in my system than two, but just know like if you have five bolts, one or two is
actually seeing the load. Just know that equalization isn't happening unless you spend a
lot of time on it and have ways of measuring it. But when you rig stuff that's really critical,
like off of cams, it's, I mean, knowing how to install a cam is important, but it's knowing
how not to put all the force of a highline on one single cam. And what you need to do is you
need to take like climbing slings and do just sliding X's like this between two cams and have
eight cams. So, that's four points of this and then come off with two of those, two of those, and tell
you V, V, V, V, V out to a master point. And that's going to give you the most flexibility, and it
needs to be able to move when the highline moves, but you need to make it so it doesn't shock load.
And so, you need to add whoopies in there, but it needs to be able to move. Automatic equalization
is a myth. You can get things pretty equalized. This is going to be your best bet. I don't like
rigging highlines with just climbing slings, and if you triple, quadruple these up, now you've
added friction. You might as well use a static rope, and now you've lost your equalization. So,
make sure you have redundancy, and make sure each point of your anchor is bomber.
The conclusion is, is that it is pretty much impossible to understand exactly what load is
happening on which part of your anchor. However, there are some things you can do to make it kind
of easier to understand where your tension is. You can feel your anchors. So, feeling your anchors
and looking at your anchors, you can see which ones are tighter and which ones are looser. But,
we found that if you do a four-way anchor with four bolts and a rope, the friction in between
the rope going around the master point makes it really hard to predict exactly which bolt
is going to have the most tension and which one is not, because of the friction on the rope. So,
you can just pull it and modify it and make one or the other the bolt with the most tension,
but that doesn't help us. We want them all to show the tension equally. So, to do that,
you use multiple slings with just two bolts, and the two bolts allows there to be less friction,
more predictability on the loads and your bolts, and that you can take twos and have even amounts
of bolts. You can have two, four, six bolts. Each of those can be broken down into twos,
and that is the most predictable way to rig an anchor for a highline. Perfect equalization is
not possible, and automatic equalization because you have a sliding X is a myth. So, therefore,
you shouldn't highline. Congratulations, you just made it through a 24-minute video
on kilonewtons and anchors, but this is where I'm supposed to tell you to not be an idiot and go rig
your first highline after watching some YouTube video about it, but rather go with people who
know what they're doing the first time you go out, but until you get that opportunity,
check out our other videos and don't forget to subscribe.
