Lightweight Bushcraft Axes: Which one is right for you?

Alive Outside
26 followers
1 Video View·Dec 26, 2022
Gransfors Small Axes, which one is right for you?
Hey guys, welcome to Alive Outside. Thanks for tuning in.
If you watch our channel, you probably know we're a fan of
Gransfors Axes and we have several small axes
and in an effort to find out which one is right for you, we figured what better way
to come out here to the mountains, spend three days, and put them to use.
The smallest of the three axes we have
is the Outdoor Axe, specifically made and designed for bushcrafting
according to Gransfors. It's only one pound. It has a metal collar
which separates it from the others. Very lightweight.
Second, we have the Wildlife Hatchet. It's a little bit
heavier than the Outdoor Axe. I'm not sure if it's to save weight
but I've noticed that, at least for these particular ones,
the Outdoor Axe seems to have a less dense grain
to the handle. Last, we have the Carpenter's Axe. Even larger
than the Wildlife Hatchet. Very straight face
and it has a nice notch here. It feels very good for carving
but specifically for doing, you know, designed for carpentry type work
but it's a nice size for out here.
Alright, one test we want to do is penetrating. How deep do these penetrate?
I'm going to swing all three axes as hard as I can. The heavy ones will be slower
but are going to have weight behind them and the light one is going to be fast
so let's see what they do for penetration. That was the Carpenter's Axe.
Now the Wildlife Hatchet and the Outdoor Axe.
Carpenter's Axe, our official measurement tool.
So the Outdoor Axe takes it for
penetration. Bushcraft science.
Next is chopping. We're going to do ten swipes with each axe. This is the Carpenter's Axe.
The Wildlife Hatchet. The Outdoor Axe.
So in my opinion, swinging that, swinging the
heaviest one was obviously the most difficult but
on the Outdoor Axe, it penetrated a lot easier like
we saw in the first test but you're only taking this much of a surface area
so it would take a lot more swings to get through that.
This one kind of was like a Goldilocks. It was right in the middle.
Felt really good in the hand. It's got this nice curve
right here so it's got the little weight it has to it. It's not going to slip
out but this one did pretty well as far as surface area and penetration.
This was probably the worst. Definitely not bad but the worst.
It's got so much area that you have to swing really
really hard to get a chip out of it and it doesn't go very deep.
Alright so yesterday when we hiked in it was 95 degrees.
We were so hot and exhausted we didn't bother with the fire but tonight
it's going to get down into the 30s and it's definitely an awesome opportunity to try
out these little axes to see how they process firewood. Just a quick
tip. We are in a national forest. We don't want to worry about catching things on
fire so we hiked up a rock from down by the riverbed, put it down in the
base of our fire pit to make sure we don't catch things on fire. When splitting
wood like this, the Carpenter's Axe is by far the better solution.
First of all it's heavier so when it comes to
an end it really pushes the axe through.
The handle's longer so you get more leverage and the face is wide
so when you're able to twist it out it really opens them and splits them
where the Outdoor Axe being so short on both the face and the handle
it had a hard time doing that motion.
I want to stop here and show you what makes this Outdoor Axe
a great batonner is the wedge is working here
while you've got this metal protection
on the handle but yet the head of the axe is still exposed
to continue to baton it down and it
just works really well. Yeah so for batoning the Outdoor
Axe takes it. Making some feather sticks.
Wildlife hatchet feels the best. I thought the Carpenter's Axe would but
this actually is just lighter. It's got a nice
face on it so when you feather stick it you can slide across really good.
I like it. So neither of us has ever tried a fire
steel on an axe. So we're making up some
really dry birch bark here to take a spark. We've got our twigs ready. We've got our feather
sticks ready and some nice dry pine.
So yeah let's see how these things work with a fire steel. You don't want to use
the blade on this. I mean you could if that was all you had and it was an emergency but it will damage
the blade. The fire rod is steel.
There we go. That will work.
Certainly not as good as the back of the knife. For making spark the Outdoor
Axe seems to be the winner but honestly I don't know if it's by chance
that this particular axe happens to have a sharp edge.
These are all handmade axe heads so depending on
the axe you get you may have a sharper edge or not and
you may even want to square your own axe's edge up just for this.
Last test. Which one can flatten a pretzel the best?
Let's try your carpenter's axe.
Well that didn't work very well. It just broke it up.
Yeah a wildlife hatchet worked the best on that one.
Yeah definitely. Wildlife hatchet takes it. I'll give it to you.
So here's the deal.
The idea is which one of these axes are going to be
best to take on a lightweight trip.
A lot of the stuff we did you wouldn't even use an axe for. You would probably use your knife.
Especially some of the batoning stuff.
Yeah a knife with a baton is
a very very versatile tool. You can do so much with a good
rugged knife that it almost makes some of these smaller axes what I would say is
obsolete.
But if you were to take just one of these things. If you could only
take one. I would personally go with this one here.
I have to agree with that. It's the lightest. The collar works really good.
You would think in your hand it feels like a toy.
It definitely feels like a toy.
When I got it in the mail I was like are you kidding me?
It felt a little ridiculous. Look at how tiny it is.
You get such a swing. You can swing so fast and it does
work well and the collar is really nice.
I agree with you. And regardless of any of this
Gransfors Brooks are awesome products.
All hand forged. They're beautiful. Every one of these is beautiful.
Every one came in the mail. We didn't pick these out. We didn't go to the store
and pick these out. They came in the mail with beautiful grain.
Nice straight grain. The only thing I'll add is I have
the Scandinavian Forest Axe. Which is big. It's big.
It's significantly bigger. I will not go on a winter camping
trip without that. It's in a class way beyond these
where you really can just crank through firewood. You can split stuff.
Actually if I were to say to bring an axe I would say go get
a bigger one given the Scandinavian Forest Axe. Then if you don't want to carry that
big weight then just bring a nice knife with you.
Of these three this is our pick.
Ultimately you bring a good knife and the right tools.
I'm probably going to take
this one and you can keep my cop and his axe.
The best is you're not making any noise.
