Bushcraft Knife Competition- Esee, Bark River, Benchmade

Alive Outside
26 followers
6 Video Views·Dec 26, 2022
This knife is way better than your knife. Hands down. Hands down. So what's up guys? It's Craig
and John with Alive Outside. We've been debating all day about which knives are better. If you
listen we could start debating. There's highs and lows. We'll figure this out. So we came up
with a plan. We're going to have a bit of a contest. We haven't eaten all day so the reward
is food and drink. So stick with us and you'll see how it turns out and how full I get by the
end of it. But we have an SE5 1095 steel. A Benchmade and a Bark River but these are
super steel. You don't even know what you're going up against. This is a Benchmade Bushcraft
Reward. I believe it's 162. But it's stainless steel. S30V. Super, super, super edge retention.
Very, very hard knife. It's very, very hard to sharpen too. But all these knives have been
sharpened from coarse all the way through these stones through three
strops. But just super sharp. And this one's the Bark River. This is the Bark River 1.5. This is
an SPM3V. It's not a stainless steel but it's supposed to be very, very rugged. Very, very
durable and it's supposed to hold an edge very well. So I'm personally curious about how these
two stack up in terms of edge retention. But we're going to be looking at chopping, feather
sticking, comfort, balance. The whole package. The whole thing. How these perform as a bushcraft
knife. What would you want to take with you in the field? I've been using this for a year and a half
so we'll see. Stick with it. So here's the loot. Here's lunch. I thought you made a sandwich. I
did make a sandwich. So this is the stuff we're going to be. So apparently one of us has eaten
today but I haven't. So this will be mine when I win it I guess. So here's how it's going to work.
We're going to, we each bet on a horse. Pick a knife and then we're going to do a test and we'll
do a test to see who wins the cheese. And then that'll go in front of that knife and so on and
so forth as we do the tests. And then whichever knife you pick, that's the stuff you get. Okay.
I can handle that. Yeah. Oh but uh hey Uncle Peter. Come here buddy. Hey buddy boy. Um here's the thing
since we're participating, I think we should at least get a Michelob Vulture and the winner can
get the Blue Moon. Like a participation ribbon? Yes. Okay. Let's do that. Sounds good to me. Okay.
First test is feather sticking for a teriyaki beef stick. For, okay. So which one you going with?
I gotta go with the new Bark River. Although it's, it's a, it's risky because I don't know
much about the CPM3V. I, I just don't have that much experience with it but I gotta go with it.
It's, it's such a beautiful knife. I gotta go with it. How about you? I'm gonna have to go with the
Benchmade. Oh man. Now I'm gonna switch to the uh the S30V Benchmade. This one felt better but the
the shavings are fat. Let's try the uh the Esee. I don't know. It's a toss-up. For me,
it's a toss-up between the Bark River and the Esee. You give it a try. I'll start with the
Bark River. Benchmade. Esee 5. And the winner is Benchmade. Benchmade. Definitely Benchmade.
The Esee feels good. Feels the best but it's, it just, it doesn't get real thin sticks. It wants
to bite into bigger sticks. Just a little too long. The Bark River works really well but
it just, it's a long blade. It's a long blade that leverages off and it's a 90 degree
grind on the back. So when you get your thumb up on it really hard it actually
starts to dig in pretty good. But that's gonna do well on our spark test. Yeah it will. Yeah
it will. The Benchmade overall cuts real thin sticks and feels good in the hand. It took it.
Next up. Let me finish chewing because I'm, I won that one so I got to eat. Yeah yeah yeah.
I think we do the cheese next. Oh I'm all for the cheese. Yeah. Batoning. Batoning. For the cheese.
Do you know who happens to have picked the larger of all these knives?
You going for that? I'm going for the Esee. No you have to stay with your,
you can't switch mid, this is picking the best bushcraft knife. We didn't talk about that. No
you're stuck with that. This is my knife for the whole contest. Yes. The whole,
I thought we got to pick each end of a one to end the series. No, no. What are you gonna carry
all three on your next trip? You have to pick one. I'll stick with the Benchmade. The Esee
is gonna win this one though. No way. No one's gonna get to eat. This is batoning not chopping.
Yeah but this is a beast. But look how long.
You're familiar with this problem. It's a little too short.
This is the log we're cutting and this is the knife I have. Yeah. And I have to stick with,
we did discuss those rules before we started you know. You never even get through that.
Here you can get that out. So batoning. Bark River. More comfortable in the hand. Longer.
That little bit of, that little extra inch really makes a big difference for getting through.
But the Esee, dead in the blow. It didn't transition into your hand as much. It didn't
hurt as much when you're going through the knots. So it's kind of a toss up. I think Craig would
give it to the Esee. I would give it to the Bark River. But either way he picked the Benchmade
so I get the cheese. So this one's about comfort, balance, the overall feel in the hand.
I gotta thank the Esee because I've been using it for so long. It fits really well. It's nice
and wide. You know you're grabbing onto a good knife. The Bark River is great. It's very
comfortable but it's very thin in the handle. And I got a lot of vibration in this when I was
batoning. Benchmade, Benchmade feels better than the Bark River to me. From all the work we've
been doing I'd have to give it to the Esee. Second I would give this one and since I picked
this one it's mine. So I think I'm taking that one. What do you got? You done eating? You full?
You got, can you speak? So in my opinion hands down the Bark River handle is the most comfortable
handle. Just fits in nicely but this is a long knife and it's a little too front heavy. This
feels, I've been using this for years now so I would give it to the Benchmade. Benchmade wins,
Craig wins peanuts. Those are not going to waste. You can finish your cheese.
What do we got left? Another meat stick. Another meat stick, this one be a meat stick. Fire stick
for meat stick. Fire stick for meat stick, okay. Bark River, Benchmade. Benchmade actually,
that's better. No go on the Esee? Honestly you just won yourself a meat stick. I mean this one's
plenty adequate but Benchmade, yeah I don't even have to try it, I know it.
This is the all-important one for the Blue Moon edge retention. Edge retention, okay.
We'll do a practical test cutting paracord rather than paper because that's real life. Yep. All
right. That was no effort on that. No effort, less effort.
All right, edge retention results, S30V, CPM3V, 1090, 1095, 1095 high carbon. I will actually
give, this is by no means conclusive but for practical purposes, doing the stuff we've done,
the Benchmade seems to cut paracord easier than the other two. This would be a second and this
would be a third but you know what, not a distant third. I mean for practical purposes you're out
and you want to cut, it's there. So 1095 standard steel. But the last camping trip we had, the canoe
trip, this thing got pretty dull on the third day and I actually had to cut paracord a few times to
get through it and I had nothing to sharpen with, well nothing legitimate to sharpen with.
Goes to Benchmade. That's mine. Enjoy your beer. We just came in the house and we, you know,
we just got done saying that the Benchmade felt sharper but when we came in and I tried the
knives on paper after all that work cutting wood, the S30V is just still sharp. So yeah,
the Bark River definitely won. A few passes on the strop,
get these things back to shaving sharp and then let's go have some cutting fun.
So guys, thanks for watching. You know, when it comes down to the end of it, there's really
no definitive winner. It's preference. The high carbon steel dulls really easy but it's also easy
to sharpen. It's beefy. You got these super steels that are really difficult to sharpen but
they stay, they hold an edge like unbelievable. We came in and the bottom line is we didn't really
work them super hard but we worked them. We came in, we strapped them, I don't know, 10-20 strokes
on the strop and all three of them just ripping through the paper, hair popping sharp. So
it's a matter of preference. You can check out a million reviews.
It's all a matter of what you want, what you like. I like the SE because it's just such a,
it's a tank of a knife. I think it actually weighs a full pound. Some people like that,
some people don't. I like it. I think it just makes it a more durable product.
But anyways, thanks for tuning in. Before we go, lastly, you know that we, what we do is try to
raise funding for scholarships for kids to go to Nature's Classroom or different organizations like
that that promote kids learning in nature. So we have patches that we've ordered. We're working
on a way to get that out to you guys if you want to order them. We're going to charge bare minimum
of what we can and 100% of profits will go to these organizations. Everything we make from the
YouTube channel goes to those organizations. We keep nothing. We're doing this for a lot of fun.
So I'm sure you have comments about these. There's a lot of people who are really passionate about
knives. Both of us are. And you know, we just had some fun with this review. So in this competition,
but Benchmade won.
