Why Traditional Chinese Medicine is Not Traditional

Dr. Alex Heyne - Acupuncture and Chinese Medicine
1.1K followers
81 Video Views·Dec 2, 2021
My guide, "4 Daily Rituals That Can Add Years to Your Life with Chinese Medicine" is completely free, which you can download right here:
➔ http://alexheyne.com/free/
Become a patient of mine ➔ http://alexheyne.com/clinic/
/// R E S O U R C E S /// B O O K S
My book on tiny, daily health habits "MASTER THE DAY" ➔ http://amzn.to/28HIbsL
Get my book on Audible here: MY AUDIOBOOK ➔ http://bit.ly/masterthedayaudio
__
/// F O L L O W
Instagram: https://www.instagram.com/afheyne/
__
/// M O R E
If you want to get even more strategies and tips on living longer with natural medicine, traditional Chinese medicine, you can subscribe right here on my website:
http://alexheyne.com
.
.
.
.
.
So if you've sought out an acupuncturist you might have heard the term traditional Chinese medicine
which is what acupuncture is a part of. But in reality traditional Chinese medicine is anything
but traditional. I know this sounds contradictory to some people. We hear how ancient it is and we
hear traditional in the word so it seems logical. But in reality it's really not that traditional
and I want to share why that is and a little bit about the history of this kind of modern
traditional Chinese medicine. What's up you guys, Dr. Alex Hine, licensed acupuncturist and doctor
of Chinese medicine. So before we jump into this video here today there's two very important links
right below. The first is if you'd like to become a patient of mine locally in Los Angeles or
virtually via telemedicine you can contact my private practice right below this video here.
And there's also a free download for you, four daily rituals that could potentially help you
add years to your life with traditional Chinese medicine. So again those are right below this
video. So why is traditional Chinese medicine not traditional? When you look at the history of
Chinese medicine, and honestly you see this even throughout science and throughout, you know,
medicine in Western Europe, it was never one unified field or one unified profession. Typically
what you would see is different family lineages, different branches and schools of Chinese medicine.
You know you have, for example, there'd be the Shang Han school, there'd be Wen Bing practitioners
later in the last few hundred years. Even within China you see those variations culturally and
dietarily and herbally, the kind of herbs practitioners use. Maybe that was just due to
what was regionally available. But typically what you see is these family lineages or individual
lineages throughout the country. And so it never really was one unified profession. So really in
the last hundred years there was this push with the cultural revolution and when China was really
trying to modernize itself and be recognized as a credible serious power, it was trying to get away
with anything that was superstitious or not modern or not scientific. So it really put together this
kind of TCM curriculum, this traditional Chinese medicine curriculum, which is really a hodgepodge
of various practices, formulas, acupuncture approaches throughout Chinese medicine history
into a way that effectively these barefoot doctors could use almost as like a manual.
You know, if there's damp heat and the person has urinary dysfunction and is burning, use these
points and use this formula. And in reality, clinical medicine is a little bit more complicated
than that and has to be a lot more specialized. But this very modern thing that we call traditional
Chinese medicine is ironically anything but traditional. For example, when you take three
famous formulas, I've just pulled these randomly, that are name brand formulas. The first is Gui
Zhitang, stereotypically known as a formula for when someone is about to get an acute cold or
fever. Su Jun Zi Tang, more for let's just call it digestive problems. And Yin Chao San, when
someone's getting a, let's just say a cold with a sore throat, right, to extremely generalize it.
It's called wind heat. These three formulas are from very different dynasties. Gui Zhitang from
the Han dynasty in the Shang Han Lin text around the year 200-250, closer to the time of Christ.
Su Jun Zi Tang, maybe around the year 1000-1100. Maybe it showed up sooner, but at least in a
book, roughly that area. And then Yin Chao San with the Wen Bing fever school practitioners in
the last 300 years or so. So around the year 200, around the year 1100, around the year 1800,
1700-1800. And these are all lumped into a modern traditional Chinese medicine curriculum
as traditional Chinese medicine, but these span 2000 years and there is no context given for these
formulas or where they come from, what they do, or why those individual physicians or that clinical
approach was even used. So a lot of what we learn in school is a hodgepodge of random formulas from
random times and random doctors, a few of their famous formulas and a few famous formulas from
this doctor and a few famous formulas from this time period, put into something that's traditional
Chinese medicine. Now the beautiful thing about this is that it is a very organized and systematic
way that is a little bit closer to paint by numbers. It's easy to learn. It's biomedical.
It's very linear. It lends itself easily to being protocol-based, right, but real medicine is always
more dynamic and more complicated than that. And there's that saying that, you know, after a year
of practice of medicine, you look like all the patterns seem easy, but after 10 years of practice
in medicine, you don't see any of those patterns in your patients. And this idea that, you know,
cookbook medicine is not real medicine because in reality, humans are far more complex than that.
And to really achieve great clinical results, it has to be highly customized and highly specialized.
So, you know, my particular mentors cautioned me against practicing in a traditional Chinese
medicine way, saying that it was not that clinically effective, that it was a hodgepodge
of various techniques and various formulas, that it was really trying to be biomedical,
like conventional biomedicine, you know, juxtaposed to Chinese medicine, and that in general though,
it was anything but traditional. So when it comes to this idea of traditional Chinese medicine,
unfortunately, you know, what you learn in school is called traditional Chinese medicine,
but it is not that traditional. It's very modern. It's very biomedical. It's very influenced by this
push, the Great Leap Forward in China to try to be taken seriously as a scientific discipline,
you know, acupuncture and Chinese herbs, but it loses the heart and soul of Chinese medicine
and the clinical efficacy, which is a problem. But I thought this would be something worth
talking about because people have this idea of TCM being so ancient and so incredible and so
this long lineage of doctors, but the way that it's taught in school, it really loses that heart
and soul and the clinical power of it. But that's why the school I went to called it a classical
Chinese medicine school. So just something food for thought, people are always wondering about
the history of medicine and the history of Chinese medicine. So I thought I would share, again,
if you want to reach me or contact my private practice, info is right below
this video and otherwise I will catch you in these two related videos over here.
