Over 50 samples in the last 8 months on SlackSnap we have explored different sewing patterns on slackline webbing so we get the highest strength out of something that isn't redundant when we highline. If you put in a thick enough thread in often enough, it will hold but watch what we learn in this episode. The chart can be found at https://www.hownot2.com/hnth/slacksnap
Thank you to J.P Sutjak, Joel Loxenbagelman, James Hogarth, and SailRite https://www.youtube.com/user/Sailrite1 for helping us learn about sewing patterns.
All donations go straight back into making this channel better. We put donors names in the ending credits and give them exclusive access to the SlackSnap Raw Data spreadsheet + corresponding footage associated with each break. This all couldn't happen without you!
What's the best sewing pattern
for sewing loops on slacklines?
Check it out on this episode of How Not to Highline.
Hi, I'm Ryan Jinks, and welcome to my gear room.
We have been working for eight months
on sewing loop patterns,
because people keep asking,
are bar tacks the best way to create a sewing loop?
So what we did was we tested rectangles,
and Ws, and zigzags, and diamond-shaped,
and we did on all sorts of webbing
over the last eight months,
and we've done over 50 break tests
to see what is the best pattern.
Now what we did was we did four different sets of tests
as people brought them up,
had stuff made, and sent them to me.
And JP Sutjack sent some tubular webbing to me,
and Joel Luxon-Bagelman sent some stuff from Puerto Rico,
and James Hogarth has been super helpful.
He has a $30,000 sewing machine,
and he did a set of patterns with me.
We've also done a lot of other tests
that are gonna be coming out soon.
And then there's Sailrite,
a company that actually makes sewing machines,
wanted to test different patterns that they promote,
and sent me a bunch of stuff.
Now whenever this subject comes up,
especially on Slack chat,
this chart from caves.org always seems to be popping back up
and it's interesting because it shows
that what I'm calling a W pattern
is the highest breaking strength.
And this is done on 3 1⁄4 inch tubular webbing,
and the bar tacks are, eh, they're okay on here.
They're better than all the other options,
especially squares or even boxes.
However, we always seem to come up with different results
here on Slack Snap,
and I think doing different patterns on different webbings,
one inch and two inch,
will help us figure out what is the best pattern.
Now Given does do the box with an X
on it on their trick lines,
and they don't do bar tacks.
However, everywhere else does bar tack,
and including all the climbing gear I have.
For example, cams, Dyneema slings,
and every sewing loop from every Slack line company.
So now let's analyze our four batches
of break tests that we did
to see what kind of results we got.
So JPSetJack sent me tubular webbing,
and he sewed everything with a bar tack machine
with number 69 thread.
That's basically the smallest thread
you would pretty much ever use,
and that's what some of my bar tacks have on them.
If you have access to the Slack Snap samples,
these are samples number 133 to 139.
If you want to see the full videos,
all my patrons have access to that.
I always test this stuff with a web lock to web lock
to find out what the RBS is,
the realistic breaking strength,
because the MBS is not always
what we get in the field when we use it.
They use big giant diverters in a lab
to find out what minimum breaking strengths are for webbing.
However, it's not achievable for us usually.
So on JP's tubular webbing,
we got 17.79 kilonewtons,
and then when we tested his W pattern,
we got 16.5 kilonewtons,
and then he had an eight bar tack test,
which I have found eight bar tacks is not enough.
10 is actually barely enough with the thread size,
number 69, and that of course has broken lower
at 11.75 kilonewtons.
Now we did something a little bit unique
is we tried to make sewn loops redundant,
and because we have all of our eggs in that basket,
of course we have a backup line,
but that also has a single loop,
and I was not entirely sure I trusted loops
at the point we tested this,
so we tried a redundant loop.
Now these did break technically in two stages,
so if one broke, you would know to get off the line,
but you would have to hit that sweet spot
between when the first break happened
and when the second break happens.
So basically the final break was only 15.15 kilonewtons.
Now we only had seven bar tacks,
and if you consider that it was on both sides,
so technically that would be almost the equivalent of 14,
it still wasn't that great.
So next was Joel Luxenbagelman's samples from Puerto Rico,
and he also sent a tubular webbing,
and he also used number 69 thread,
but it was on a home sewing machine
and not a bar tack specific machine,
and the sample numbers are between 202 and 210 for these,
but the patterns we basically tested here
were all of these crisscross diamond shaped
zigzaggy kind of patterns.
So what we had was a looser stitch and a tighter stitch,
and then we had a short and a long version,
and the long version was about 30% longer
than the short version.
Now this broke super interesting
in that it ripped in real time,
it looks like slow motion,
but in real time it broke the stitching
starting at the end of the loop
and working towards the part that goes around the shackle,
and then at the very end it breaks real quickly
just like tubular webbing does.
It did this on all four different kinds
of these crisscross samples we tested,
and the looser stitched crisscross,
whether it was short or long,
basically had the same results
at 6.6 and 6.7 kilonewtons,
and the tighter crisscross,
where you had basically a lot more stitching per inch,
gave us 9.6 or 10.5 kilonewtons based on how long it was.
If Joel made bar tacks in the same length
as the short samples,
it would have held at almost full strength
of what we can achieve with sewn loops.
So up next is James Hogarth's sewn loops
that he's done on his expensive $30,000 machine
that he has access to.
He's a detailed individual
who has done a ton of loops for Slack Snap.
Now his machine can push through multiple layers of webbing
with TEX270, which is the 11 millimeter static rope
of thread.
So all of these samples swing all the way
to the other extreme with the largest thread
you would ever use on a sewn loop instead of the 69 thread.
Now these samples are number 294 to 303,
and you can see that we have two of each that we've done,
which is actually the majority
of all of the tests in this video.
So on tubular webbing in the rectangle pattern,
we got 17.7 kilonewtons,
and that is through three layers of tubular webbing.
And with nine bar tacks in the tubular webbing,
also through three layers, we got 18.9 kilonewtons,
and it always is breaking the webbing
in all of these samples here instead of the stitching.
But it did retain more strength,
not much than the rectangle.
And of course our weblock to weblock test
is a little bit stronger, usually is,
versus a sewn loop at 19.13 kilonewtons.
Now our Feather Pro samples were super interesting
in the fact that our rectangle broke at 19.4 kilonewtons,
but it's pulling out the center.
This is a polyester nylon mix with pillowed edges,
and you can just kind of see how the thing is weaved
by the way it breaks.
And nine bar tacks in three layers of Feather Pro
also broke very interestingly,
and it actually gave us two kilonewtons
more than the rectangle at 21.4 kilonewtons.
And then we did what I'm calling a W pattern,
basically a giant vertical zigzag,
and it broke at 20.8 kilonewtons,
a little bit less than the nine bar tacks,
and it ripped out the center of the webbing.
It was super, super interesting.
And Feather Pro weblock to weblock
is 25.5 kilonewtons for comparison.
Nine bar tacks in these samples proved to be the strongest.
So our last batch of tests come from Sailrite,
and they make a sewing machine,
and some of the stitches that they promote and teach
is some of the stuff that we tested.
And our first webbing type is two inch seatbelt poly,
which is 100% polyester flat webbing.
And we tested 10 bar tacks,
which it broke in my line lock before the stitching broke.
And then we tested the diamond,
which it actually broke the thread,
which is a V92 poly thread.
It's a little bit bigger than the 69,
and it's 100% poly.
And then we tested a W pattern,
which it broke the webbing right at the beginning
of the sewing pattern.
So we got three different kinds of breaks,
but they all came out to 19 kilonewtons.
And our web lock to web lock,
or in this case, a line lock to a line lock,
gave us 22.69 kilonewtons.
The next webbing type is one inch poly tubular webbing.
Now, none of us actually walk on this for slacklining,
but it is a great way to test different sewing patterns.
The first one was 10 bar tacks that broke at 13 kilonewtons
at the first bar tack.
And then the diamond pattern broke also the webbing
at the beginning of the pattern, also at 13 kilonewtons.
But when we tested the W pattern,
it only broke at five kilonewtons,
which was a super random breaking strength,
and it just broke the webbing at the sewing pattern.
And then we tested a unique box pattern
that looks a little funny on one inch webbing,
and it only broke at eight kilonewtons.
And web lock to web lock on this stuff was 13 kilonewtons.
So our 10 bar tacks and diamond pattern
basically came out the same as a web lock,
which is interesting.
Usually we get more strength out of web locks.
And our last webbing type was one inch heavyweight nylon.
This is not tubular, but it is 100% nylon.
And 10 bar tacks, it broke the webbing
in a unique way at 26 kilonewtons.
And the diamond broke only at 21 kilonewtons,
about four and a half kilonewtons less,
but it broke the stitching and not the webbing.
And the W pattern was similar as the diamond
at 22 kilonewtons, and it broke the stitching as well.
And when we tested this in a web lock,
it was 25.9 kilonewtons,
which is actually less than the 10 bar tacks that we got.
So bar tacks won in this situation,
even above a web lock, which is pretty rare.
Congratulations, you just made it through a 10 minute video
about sewing patterns.
Now the climbing industry and the slackline industry
has generally stuck with bar tacks
because they're more consistent.
If you stick a thick enough thread in often enough,
you can use any pattern.
You can write your name in the webbing
and it'll probably hold.
Now the crisscrosses were the worst,
and I definitely don't recommend that,
especially with a 69 thread.
But the bar tacks are stuff that I will choose to use
on my webbing and will continue to test those
because they're the most common
and the most easy to compare against other bar tacks.
If you do use a 69 thread bar tack,
you wanna make sure that you go back and forth,
maybe even three times,
and then up and down all the way across.
Now it's a lot more difficult to do that
on a home sewing machine or a normal one,
and it's better to use an actual bar tack machine.
When I've watched bar tack machines do it,
I'm like, wow, that's the right tool for the job.
So far and what I've learned
is that 10 bar tacks minimum for the 69 thread,
seven bar tacks minimum for number 138,
and also seven bar tacks for text 270.
And text 270 isn't all it has cracked up to be.
There is a happy medium in the number 138 thread,
but that is coming out in another episode soon.
Now remember, there is no redundancy for a sewing loop
other than your backup line,
which probably has a sewing loop.
So make sure these things are right,
and if you're wrong, you're gonna die.
Therefore, you shouldn't highline.
Hey, thanks for watching,
but don't be an idiot and try to sew your own loops at home,
especially if you've never done it before,
without least sending me a sample to break test it for you
so you don't die.
And if you're like Puff here and get involved
with either patreon.com or PayPal,
then we give you access to all the Slack Snap data
and the folders correlated with it
so you can nerd out even more
if you like this kind of stuff.
She likes this kind of stuff.
Can also buy some cool shirts,
that's in the link in the description below,
and find slackliners near you on slackademics.com.
Until you have a chance to make some sewing loops,
don't forget to like, follow, and subscribe,
and hit that bell button
so you can see more of Puff on Talenta Highline.
Cheers.
♪♪