The Best Sugar Cookies to Decorate with Royal Icing (No Spread!!)

Love Cake ❤️
222 followers
31 Video Views·Dec 7, 2022
Hey guys, welcome back.
So I get asked a lot, what cookie recipe do I use and how do I actually make them and
bake them?
So today I'll share with you the recipe that I use, which is actually from Lila Loa and
it's her vanilla 2.0 recipe, which is linked down below in the description of the video.
And I'll show you my few tweaks that I've learned over the years to make my recipe more
suitable to myself and have great reviews from my customers and my friends and family
that eat my cookies on a regular basis.
So let's get started.
Okay, so what we'll need today is measuring cups, specifically one cup and a half cup.
And then you're going to need your spatula and a teaspoon.
So then we're going to have our paddle attachment with our mixer.
If you don't have a KitchenAid stand with a paddle attachment, you can use your regular
mixer and then switch over to the dough hook when we get to the dough part.
So we're going to start with our butter, which is at room temperature.
Well, mine is almost at room temperature, so I've chopped it up a bit.
And then I have my brown sugar as well as my white sugar.
We're going to dump it all into the bowl to start with altogether.
Now I just want to talk about brown sugar in the recipe.
This is why I really like this recipe because it includes brown sugar.
I feel like there's so much more flavor that comes from it versus just all white sugar
or even some recipes that call for powdered sugar.
It's all personal preference, so it doesn't really matter.
But like I said, I like the way that the brown sugar, it sort of caramelizes in the oven
and it gives it some great flavor.
So here we are, we're just seeing everything being dumped into the bowl and then we're
going to proceed to put it into the mixer.
So I have a KitchenAid mixer here with the paddle attachment.
If you don't have one, no worries.
Just use your regular mixer.
But like I said, further down, you will have to change it to a dough hook if you have one
because the dough does get pretty stiff.
This one can handle it, but usually the smaller mixers, they have a little bit more trouble
when the dough gets a little too tough.
So I'm just going to start at low speed here just to incorporate my butter and sugar so
we don't have things flying out everywhere.
And I'm going to crank up the speed a few notches just to get it going and to whip up
that butter and sugar together.
We just want to make it more creamy and cohesive.
So we'll let that run for a couple minutes until you see that the texture has changed.
You can see it's still looking crumbly now, but in a little bit, it'll come together.
And just remember every once in a while, scrape down your bowl.
I find, especially with these mixers, the bowl is pretty deep and so you want to just
make sure that you're getting everything out of the bottom of there.
So again, I'll just turn my speed back up.
It's on sort of just under medium, I said medium low.
And then once you start to see the batter coming together there, it's kind of creaming
together, the color lightens just a little bit, then you know you're ready for the next
step.
So I've got my eggs here and I'm just going to add some vanilla to my eggs.
If you do have real vanilla, it helps the flavor comes through a lot better.
If you don't, no worries.
Imitation vanilla works just as well.
And so there's one more thing that I like to add to this recipe that isn't called for
in the original, and it's to add butter flavor from Loran's.
It's an emulsion and so it's quite strong and it doesn't lose the flavor in the oven
like some other, let's say extracts.
So it really brings out the butterness and the buttery flavor of the cookies and it really
complements well with the brown sugar.
So this is a little extra step if you have this or you can find it usually at Michael's
or a local, you know, cake or craft stores.
And if you can add it, I assure you it tastes great.
So I'm just going to add the eggs, the vanilla and the butter emulsion all together.
I usually try to add one egg, mix it in a little bit and then add the second one.
And again, we're going to sort of cream the butter, the sugar and the eggs all together
now.
And every once in a while, just check your bowl, make sure you scrape down the sides
that everything's getting mixed in nice and good.
You can see here my batter has lightened slightly in color and so everything's nicely mixed
in.
It's looking good.
So we can move on to the next step.
Just going to scrape my bowl down one more time just to make sure everything's in there.
There's no sugar stuck in the bottom and we're ready to go.
So I've measured out my flour and I'm just going to add some salt and some baking powder
to it.
And I just want to talk about the baking powder.
Usually people like to leave it out completely or just put a tiny bit.
The recipe only calls for about a quarter teaspoon, I believe.
I actually like to put a full teaspoon in there.
People worry about spread if they add baking powder.
But the thing is, baking powder makes your cookies sort of taller instead of wider.
So I do like to put a little bit more just to make them not so dense.
And I find that I don't really get much spread.
My cookies hold their shape really well.
So I'm just going to give this a quick stir and now we're ready to add it to our butter
sugar egg mixture.
So again, if you don't have one of these heavy duty mixers, you might need to change over
to a dough hook once we add a little bit more of the flour.
So just be aware of that.
So I'm going to slowly add the flour a bit at a time to make sure that it all kind of
gets incorporated.
And you want to sort of mix every so often, let it go for a few seconds, 10 to 15 seconds,
just so the dough can rehydrate itself and there's not flour flying out of your bowl
everywhere.
Okay, so every once in a while you do want to scrape the sides of your bowl and get right
to the bottom of your bowl to make sure that everything is getting evenly incorporated.
Now again, the recipe talks about the amount of flour to use and it depends on your altitude
and you know how humid your area is and this and that.
I found, I find I start with about four cups of flour myself and the reason being I've
tried with a little bit of less flour, a little bit of more flour and I found that this works
best for me.
I don't necessarily like too soft of a dough.
What I find is when I roll them out and I transfer them to the cookie sheet, if I pick
them up and they're way too soft, my finger, fingers leave imprints in the cookies or it
gets stretched out.
And I really found no flavor difference when I added a little bit less flour to a little
bit more.
And sometimes I even find I need more than four cups.
So I always do the four cups and I'll keep mixing it.
And if my dough is still a little bit sick, sticky or too soft and I can push my finger
into the dough, then I know that I need a little bit more.
So there's not an exact measurement.
Keep going until you find what works best for you.
But this is what I like to do and what I find that helps keep the shape of the cookies the
best.
Flour is a super important part in your cookie recipe, especially if you don't want spread.
If you leave out too much flour, you will get quite a bit of spread.
So it's all with the ratios to do with the sugar and the eggs.
So it's very important if you're getting a lot of spread, it could be that you're not
adding enough flour to your dough.
So here I'm just going to grab a little bit more flour.
You can see the dough is pulling away from the sides of the of the bowl, and that means
it's almost ready.
But when I touch it with my hands, I feel that it's a little bit too soft for me still.
And so I'm going to add some flour.
Now again, you know, if you want to roll out your dough right away, then I would suggest
you probably need a little bit more flour than you if, let's say you let your dough,
you roll it out and then you stick it in the fridge for a bit or you let it sit on the
counter for half an hour, hour and get back to it and rolling because the longer the dough
sits, the more it kind of firms up.
And again, I'll show you later on why I like a sort of firm dough to work with.
So once I'm happy, I usually squish it between my hands.
And like I said, if it squishes really easily and it feels super soft, I know there's not
enough flour for myself.
And another thing is to if your butter was really warm, your dough may need a little
bit more flour because your dough will be softer.
OK, so here I can see my dough looks pretty good.
It's got quite a bit of flour in it, and I'm just playing with my hands to see.
You can see the dough looks crumbly, but when I play with it, it comes together and I can
tell that the texture isn't as soft as it was before.
So this looks like it's ready to go.
So I'm going to grab my cookie sheets.
I use dark pans.
A lot of people use lighter pans.
They don't like their cookies browning again.
I really like the browning or the golden brown edges and bottoms because it gets that flavor
from brown sugar.
And then you just need your cookie cutters, whether you have metal ones or 3D plastic
ones.
It doesn't matter.
You can use whatever you have on hand.
And then also I use parchment paper to roll my cookies, my cookie dough in between.
So I have two long pieces of parchment paper.
And the reason being is if your parchment paper is moving around too much on the counter,
if it's a long piece, I can kind of hang a little bit over the edge and use my body to
kind of secure it against the counter when I'm rolling it out.
So now I like to sort of combine, like just play with my dough a little bit just to make
sure everything's combined.
You can see a few pieces are coming out.
So I just like to pick those all up in my dough.
And then I place it between the two pieces of parchment paper.
And then when I put the top piece on, I will squish it down first with my hands just to
sort of flatten out the dough a little bit.
And then I'll start to roll.
It just makes it easier to roll out like that.
The beginning gets a little bit tough.
The dough is like I said, it's a stronger sort of dough because of all the flour that
we put in there.
So I just roll it out and I don't have guides.
A lot of people use they have rolling pins with guides on them so you can roll them exactly
even all across the dough.
So all your cookies are the same height.
Other people use, you know, those paint sticks that you get from like hardware stores that
you mix the paint with.
You can put a couple of those sticks together and put them on the side of your dough and
use those as guides so that you don't go any thinner or thicker than that.
I usually just do it by eye, by hand.
I run my hand over the dough and see if there's any places that are thicker and thinner and
I try my best.
They are handmade cookies, so I feel like a little bit of difference here and there
makes them, you know, not machine cut basically.
And over, you know, when you have done it so many times, it kind of comes natural to
see how thick and thin your cookies are.
So you can see my dough is nicely, evenly shaped now, so I'm going to go ahead and cut.
I do like metal cutters, I almost prefer them a little bit because they have such a nice,
sharp, clean edge.
And so I push down evenly and I sort of wiggle them a little bit just to loosen the dough.
The same thing with 3D cutters.
It depends which ones you get, you know, some are better than others.
But again, I do the same thing.
I push it down and wiggle it a little bit in the dough just to loosen the sides.
Of the shape.
Now, again, because my dough is on the thicker side, the sort of more firm side, I don't
have too many issues with my cutter sticking to my dough.
That's one of the advantages of adding enough flour to your dough.
But if you do find that your cutters are sticking to your dough and you're not getting
clean shapes, you can always dip them in a little bit of flour or cornstarch and you
can use that to push them through and they shouldn't be sticking to your cutters.
So what I like to do is I like to take the dough that I rolled out and any excess and
I like to put in a bowl on the side.
I don't want to roll my dough too many times.
So then I'll put everything to the side and then I'll come back to it once I've rolled
all my original dough.
I usually take the pieces around the cutouts out.
And then what I'll do is I'll put my hand underneath the parchment paper and I'll sort
of lift up the piece of the dough, the cookie that I have there, and I'll try to flip it
either onto my hand or I'll try to pick it up with my hand.
If my dough is firm enough, this one sat around for a little bit while we're filming, so
it's quite firm. So I was able just to pick them up and place them on the sheet like
that. This way, I'm not damaging the shape.
I'm not getting my fingerprints in them by trying to pick up the edge.
So they stay nice and crisp and clean, as you can see.
OK, so now when I have all my cutouts on the cookie sheet.
Now, the recipe doesn't necessarily call for this, but I do like to do it just as an
extra precautionary measure to have no more spread is to put them in the fridge for a
little bit, just for 10 to 15 minutes, however long it takes me to roll a couple of
times and fill my next cookie sheet.
What popping them in the fridge does is it just makes the butter in the cookie dough a
little bit more solid.
And so it takes a little bit less time for that butter to melt in or more time to melt
in the oven and less time for spread.
So when my next cookie sheet is ready, I'll pop that one in and take the first one out
and pop it straight into the oven.
So once in a while, when you bake your cookies, you'll have like a bubble that forms on
your dough or an even surface sometimes.
So what you can do, I have a fondant smoother here or you can use the back of a
spatula or like one of those flipper spatulas and just press down on your cookies if you
have any of those bubbles.
These ones were the first my first roll out.
So they're pretty smooth.
Usually happens towards the end of your dough if you've rolled it a couple of times.
But that's a little trick that you can get to flatten your cookies.
I usually wait till I see the edges are sort of golden brown.
I know a lot of people like to see their cookies nice and white and not like any color
on the bottom of them.
But to be honest, I've tried that and I don't like the flavor.
It just does not taste baked to me and it doesn't have very much flavor.
So like I said, these ones have brown sugar.
They have some color to them.
And when you bake them, that brown sugar sort of caramelizes in the oven.
And so when you let it get that sort of golden color, I find it takes it to the next
level. And it's a really important step that I find people may not know.
OK, guys, so that is exactly how I make my cookies and roll them out.
You can see there's a few additions there to the recipe that I have linked below my
little twists on it, but they came out perfect.
The shapes are great.
They're ready to go and decorated and they taste great.
So if you guys like this recipe, let me know below if you've tried it or if you have
your own little tweaks.
I'd love to hear it.
And thank you so much for watching.
And I'll see you guys in the next video.
