What is the most powerful martial art? This is an often asked question, and to be fair...does it even have an true answer? Today we explore this by telling the story of "The Stone Cutter".
Greetings, dojo family! I hope everyone is having a great holiday season so far.
Now to cap off the end of this year, and this season of Artois Dojo,
I wanted to do something a little bit different and share a story with you that I feel
really encapsulates a lot of the messaging and philosophies that we try to put out here
through our show. I came across this short story on sageartstudio.com,
so I'd like to give them credit for this. And if you like it,
please visit their website as they have several more there to share.
So, which martial art is the most powerful one? What art can best defeat other arts?
I feel that the best way to answer this is to tell the story of the stonecutter.
Once upon a time, there was a stonecutter that lived and worked in a vast land,
spending his days wondering what it meant to be the most powerful.
In this land, power was considered a privilege, and the stonecutter decided that he wished to
dedicate himself to being the most powerful entity that there was. As he pondered this,
he could feel the sun's heat dancing across his skin. He looked up and realized that the sun gives
us life. It bathes us with its warmth and provides energy and light to our world,
so surely it must be the most powerful. So the stonecutter became the sun. He
raised up above the world, hot and radiant, and showered his energy down on the inhabitants below.
He truly was a spectacle, and it seemed that his power would see no limit.
Until one day, a cloud passed in front of him and blocked his light. Enraged, he cursed and exclaimed
that the sun could not be the most powerful entity in the world if it was so easily thwarted
by a measly cloud. If a cloud could stop the energy of the sun, then truly a cloud must be
the most powerful entity. So he became a cloud, but not just any cloud. He grew into the biggest
storm that the land had ever seen. High with his new powers, he showed the inhabitants just how
powerful he had become. When he felt generous, he gave them rains and water for their crops.
But when he wanted to show his power, he cracked that sky open with lightning and gave them a
horrible downpour and showed them his fury. Until one day he saw a boulder sitting there,
completely unscathed and unfazed by his wrath. This angered him. How could he be truly the most
powerful being if this boulder was unaffected? So he cast his fury down, blasting it with wind and
rain, and cascaded attacks of lightning that created the dirt around it. For days he put on
a show, but no matter what, that boulder sat there, ignoring his wrath. Bah! he exclaimed.
He actually stopped and said, Bah! How could this be? If a boulder could be unaffected by the storm,
then a cloud could not be the most powerful being. And the most powerful being must surely be a
mighty boulder. So he turned into a boulder. And on that hill he sat, powerful, immovable,
a king on his grassy throne. He based his glory on his accomplishments. Until one day a stonecutter
came along and chiseled him to pieces. So there's a lot that we can unpack here,
and it's interesting because on the website they list the moral of the story as,
sometimes the most important thing to remember is that you already have all the tools that you
need right inside of you. The power is an illusion. I don't disagree with that. In fact, I think that
is quite a powerful message. Most of us do already have what we need inside of us. It's just a matter
of learning how to reach in and become disciplined enough to use it. But I think the story tells
another message, especially relating to the martial arts. How often do we come across debates
about which art is more powerful or better than the other arts? How many times have we heard a
Brazilian jiu-jitsu practitioner poo-poo on karate saying that it's antiquated and won't work in
grappling? How many times have you heard arts being scrutinized and their ability to handle
multiple attackers, weapons, the octagon, or even live resistance? I don't think any of us are
strangers to these comments, and I think that's what makes the story so relevant. Which martial
art is the most powerful? Is it BJJ? Is it boxing? Is it old-school karate? Yes. We talked about the
concept of content versus context in our recent episode that explores the defining criteria of
the martial arts. It's really very simple. The value of any content is entirely dependent on
the context in which it resides. The value of any martial art is entirely dependent on the context
in which it is being applied. The competitive ring, the street, rehab and exercise, self-defense,
home invasion, the battlefield, law enforcement, all have drastically different elements that
dictate the effectiveness of any given skill. It's that brutally simple and straightforward.
The value and effectiveness of any martial art is completely dependent on the purpose it is being
used. This is the philosophy that we've been laying down for the past couple of years on this channel.
I know it's a topic that we've revisited a lot, but we felt that if we were going to explore and
share the world of global martial arts that it was extremely important that we solidify our
For those of you who have been with this channel for a while, you've seen us approach topics such
as comparing traditional arts to mixed martial arts, or the differences between fighting and
self-defense, or the importance of rank, or like today, trying to determine which is the best art.
And I think we've covered that thoroughly at this point, certainly well enough to push into a deeper
and more substantial exploration of the martial arts going forward. If you are new to this channel,
you can find a list of many of these episodes in the description down below. I always invite your
input on these topics. But asking the question of which art is the most powerful? Is it BJJ,
Shotokan, Judo, or any flavor of Karate Fujitsu? All I'm hearing is, which is more powerful? The
sun, a storm, or a boulder? We're all stonecutters, and we all have tools. Instead of spending time
searching for the best martial art, we may be better served to have that effort put into
understanding the context that determines the effectiveness of each art. Cross-train,
share ideas, learn. Always learn, and be open to new ideas. Learn the strengths and weaknesses of
the sun, the storm, and the boulder, and develop the understanding on how to become the one you
need in any given situation. And that's our mission. That's the entire purpose of this channel,
to explore different arts, to share history, ideas, training techniques, or any other aspect
of the martial arts you may not have considered otherwise. And that's why I wanted to share this
story today. It just hit that nerve and clarity that, and I felt that it would be an appropriate
way to cap off the year. And I thank all of you for your patience, your input, and helping us
carve the path of exploration over the past four years. We have a lot of exciting stuff on the
horizon, a ton of topics, arts, and interviews that we're going to be bringing you in 2022.
And I hope you all continue to make this trek with us and have the Art of One Dojo become a
hub for martial arts unity and a dojo for all. Happy holidays, everyone, and we'll see you back
here on the mat in the new year.