The sport sedan showdown _ 2022 Subaru WRX vs 2022 Honda Civic Si

Car Crease
237 followers
2 Video Views·Dec 4, 2022
The sport sedan showdown _ 2022 Subaru WRX vs 2022 Honda Civic Si
This is a meeting of the manuals. Two sporty Japanese sedans with turbo engines and six-speed
manual transmissions. Both are brand new for 2022. On Team Blue, Subaru WRX. On Team Orange,
the Civic Si. Both of these cars are proof that manual transmissions do belong on modern high
performance cars, and you better go out and buy them before they stop building them. Or
is this the beginning of the end? If old ways have to die, go out with a bang. For 30 grand,
only the Volkswagen Jetta GLI comes as close as these two cars. That's it. There's no other brand
new four-door sedan with a manual transmission that's as fun as a WRX or an Si. And don't bother
trying to find other car reviews on YouTube. Subscribe to CarGurus. We have hundreds of them.
Time for fun. Yeah, it's winter. These two sedans are practical to drive all year,
and they'll make you grin from ear to ear. Corny, but it's true. I'm starting with the faster car,
and faster by a long shot. 271 horsepower and 258 pound-feet of torque. Yeah, I feel it.
Definitely do. It's only three more horsepower than before. Same torque. But the big difference
is it's a 2.4 liter engine. The old WRX was a two liter. Now, just like it does in the new 2022 BRZ,
I've driven that at Lime Rock Park in Connecticut, which is really fun, by the way.
But that same engine without the turbo, you can totally tell that the torque curve is a little
bit broader. It comes on sooner. You don't have to rev it so crazy high to get that peak power.
And it just is a little bit more refined and less buzzy than before. It's still a bit lumpy,
right? This is a Subaru flat four, the boxer design, just like Porsche. You get that little
kind of at kind of every speed. You either love it or hate it. I'm not in love with it,
but it's distinctive. And it's a very, very good design because it lowers the center of gravity.
It's very compact, all that stuff, right? But what you really want to know is that
the character of this engine with the turbo is a bit improved. Not a ton, but definitely
sounds better, a little more linear in power, certainly not as linear as the Civic Si,
but it's way more power. And I can say that even with less power than the STI,
which is not yet out for this generation car, plenty, all you need is the handling is right
there. I just don't love the steering. There's no selectable driving modes on here that can
change the weight of it because it's just, I don't know, it's a little too light for me.
I don't really feel like I get a ton of road feel, not much at all. I know it's there. I know the
grip is there. I know the car is just going to do it, but I'd rather feel it. I don't want to
trust a car, right? And you can't adjust this unless you buy the GT, which is several trims
above this one. That's a new trim for 2022, but it's automatic only. And so Subaru saves the
driving modes, adaptive dampers, and nicer Recaro sport seats for a trim that you can't get anything
but a CVT. So that's questionable. In my book, I think they should be bringing those upgrades to
the lower trims with the manual transmission because most WRX buyers are choosing the stick.
They don't want the automatic. Now the shifter itself, you get used to it. It's a longer throw
design. It's a little notchy. I don't really like it, but I'll get used to it. And the response is
good. I like the clutch action. It's easy to drive. I find it easier to drive than past WRXs.
I remember having a 2011 WRX as a test car. It was only a five-speed when at the time the STI
had the six-speed. And on the highway, it was horrible. You'd hear that engine exhaust droning.
The revs were so high. So in 10 years, 11 years, they've made some big improvements, and I'm glad
they have. And that's not always the case with Subaru because Subaru likes to keep things around
for a long, long time and not really do anything. They don't like to mess with success. I think they
should be changing more parts of the car, but hey, what works, works. The WRX has a formula
and I'm hopping in this 2022. I could be in any model year, feel right at home, and you will too.
The WRX is now riding on Subaru's new global platform. The previous one was an older version
than the Impreza that was out there. So they weren't matched up. This new one is a better
chassis. It's safer. It's stronger. I can actually close the doors on these cars and hear a nice
thud as opposed to a hollow metal. That's how Subaru's always used to be. So that makes me
feel better, but it also is just more rigid. It's better handling for that reason. Same thing as
the Civic Si. There's more adhesives on the structure. It's stiffer. The center of gravity
is a little lower. They've mounted the rear stabilizer bars on the body itself as opposed
to the subframe. So that makes things stiffer, better handling. The suspension's retuned. These
are all very subtle things, right? Matt Smith drove this car for the first time in California,
came away with a similar impression because, well, if you've driven one Subaru WRX,
you've basically driven them all. Driving at higher speeds, I definitely feel the WRX is quieter
than before, and it certainly has more insulation by a long shot. It's not exactly the most
comfortable highway cruiser, but it's definitely better, way better than before. Fuel economy is
still really terrible. 19 city, 26 highway, 22 combined. Honestly, I think you could post better
fuel economy numbers in a Corvette or a Porsche 911. So at this day and age, I don't know, man. I
expect better fuel economy from Subaru. I know this is the performance model, but wow, kind of
wasteful. Of course, the real selling point for the WRX is all the turbocharged power, but it's
the all-wheel drive grip in any weather, right? Just kind of power through turns and whatever
happens, happens. Maybe the tail comes out, maybe it doesn't. That's a rally car. When you come down
to speed and downshift, everything just comes together with the brakes, too. So while I don't
love the steering feel, braking feel is excellent. Most WRX owners pick the manual by a wide margin
over the automatic, but the fact that there's an automatic at all makes me question the WRX a bit,
because the Civic Si only comes with a manual. What's that tell you? It means that Honda really
cares about building a good manual transmission, more so than Subaru. Hondas have always had good
manuals. I can't really remember a bad one, and the Si has been this way for over 35 years, since
1986 when the first model came out. The Si has always been manual, and the fact that Honda in
2022 is still engineering it to be better, it's pretty impressive that anyone bothers to care this
much, but Honda does. The short throws on this shifter, they're 10% shorter than before. The
spring load inside the mechanism here, Honda's is just 30% more. These are all just numbers, but what
you do is when you drive this car, once you get used to the short linkages, because it really, the
gears are really close together. I've actually misshifted a few times. Once you learn how it goes,
though, it's just second nature. It feels so good. The only car that I could think of that'd be better
or just as good is a Porsche. Aside from the new mechanisms in the manual transmission,
there's a lighter flywheel. That's what keeps the engine crankshaft rotating. It keeps the engine
from stalling. A lighter flywheel lets you rev smoother, and it's let Honda install the Type-R's
rev matching system. So on downshifts, the car will do that for you, but I'm so good. I don't
need that. The engine is the same as before. It's a one and a half liter turbo. One and a half liters
is not very much, but Honda really does pack a punch in this car. 200 horsepower, 192 foot pounds
of torque. Now, if you're an SI fan, you'll know that's actually down five. The Subaru went up
three horsepower. The Civic goes down five. Why? Well, they've actually made the horsepower curve
at the top flatter. So instead of dropping as the revs go high to the red line, it actually stays
more constant. So you're not dropping power as you're about to shift at the peak power line,
which is just above 6,000 RPM. It also brings the torque on a little bit sooner. 300 RPM. These are
really subtle differences, but I'm not sure I can feel it, but you might. And the fact is, five
horsepower, not going to be great either way. Plus or minus, whatever. Would it be great to have more
horsepower? Yeah, but you have to wait for the Type-R for that. And the brakes are excellent.
They're just really confidence inspiring. Perfect engagement at the top of the pedal, so you get
like almost no dead zone, and it's nice and stiff. Now, despite there being only 200 horsepower,
this is a light car. It's under 3,000 pounds, and it feels so good. It really does. Put it into sport
mode, you get a little bit extra throttle response, get a little bit extra weight on the steering as
well. But even if you don't touch that, it just works. It really, really works. Because Honda also
has a limited slip differential in this car. You don't see that with most front-wheel drive cars,
because there's so much power getting sent to that front axle. It's a mechanical limited slip.
It's a gear system. They call it a helical system, and that just means that it doesn't require a lot
of maintenance. It's Honda after all, right? That's what they're concerned with, but they're concerned
with getting the power to the front wheels as evenly as possible. So when you exit out of turns,
you can get on the gas, and you know that you're not going to just start slipping and spinning.
It's great, and what you get is just really smooth, linear progression. There's no lag.
There's no surge of torque that catches you off guard. It behaves like a larger, naturally
aspirated engine, and because it's a Honda engine, it's smooth, and it sounds good. There is some
fake sound piped through the cabin, but it's not overwhelming. It's not bad, and if I didn't tell
you about it, you probably wouldn't know. Steering and the grip, well, of course they're good. These
are all-season tires. $200, you can get the HPT. That's the high-performance tire option
that puts summer tires. $200, that's probably the cheapest way to get a set of summer tires,
and you should probably order them. Of course, the WRX is the overall speed and grip champion.
The Si is just not going to touch it, right? But this is 400 pounds lighter, give or take.
That's a pretty big difference when you're removing the all-wheel drive, and I don't know
what else, but the Civic Si definitely gets out of its own way, and even though there's that big
power deficit, it's not as bad on the road as you would think. Less weight, less mass, makes you go
faster. Not as fast as that WRX, but it also gets better fuel economy by a long shot. EPA estimates
this at 27 city, 37 highway, and 31 combined. Honestly, it makes the WRX look like a Ferrari
by how much it drinks. Like most new cars, the Civic Si is stiffer, it's stronger.
Not only does that help you in a crash, and hopefully no one finds that out,
but it's better for performance. And with that, Honda has brought some components from the Type
R, notably the suspension bushings and some of the rear suspension links. Those are directly
from the Type R. Things are retuned more than before. I thought they were pretty great before,
but now they're better. Compared to the WRX, the Si also has the better steering rack.
Honda made a bunch of improvements to that, too. It was already good, like I said. This one,
there's just a lot of feel. The weighting is really perfect. I don't have anything bad to
say about it, really, at all. And as the loads increase, you can feel that change, right? You
can feel it coming through your hands. You feel where the grip of the tires are. You feel what
the chassis is doing. In the Subaru, you just don't. I know it has the grip. It's got all-wheel drive.
I know it'll outgrip this car in the end, but for just driving around at, say, 30 miles an hour
and then whipping on a back road even faster, I feel more confident in the Civic despite it
being slower. So go figure that. You buy these cars for the performance and for the looks.
The Si is most like an Audi S3. It's subtle, not much different than the slower car it's
based on, and tasteful. The WRX is most like a teenage boy. It doesn't know how to dress.
It's the car wearing a winter jacket with flip-flops. The WRX is the aggressor here.
The bigger grille, the angled lines, the slimmer headlights. It looks pretty bold. And of course,
there's a big hood scoop. It's functional. They've got to have it in a WRX. These fender
flares and all the cladding. Is this an Outback? I'm not so sure because I liked how the previous
WRX looked. It was sportier. This one, not for me. Now, the greenhouse is familiar. It's a little
tall for my taste, though. Now, the Civic, well, it actually is a lot sleeker and sportier because
it's more than two inches lower in height and it's longer in the wheelbase. The front end is
simpler than the WRX, but it still is sharp. LED headlights. Those low beams put four lights on at
the same time. It looks amazing at night. And you can tell the Si from a regular Civic with the mesh
grille, the black mirrors, the black window trim, and the black 18-inch wheels. Now, both exterior
paints are exclusive to these models. WR Blue on the WRX and Blazing Orange Pearl on the Si.
They really belong on these cars. The Civic keeps things classy. Nice clean edges, nice lines,
polished black decklid spoiler, chrome exhaust tips, red badging. Really tasteful. Over here,
the WRX has some nice taillights. There's a cool-looking texture if you look really closely
on these LEDs, but there's a whole lot of everything here. You got a black strip connecting
the taillights, this other decklid spoiler with all these extensions all over it, bumper which
has like three different tiers of plastic and cutouts that aren't actually cutouts. I think
maybe they might use that for the STI later, but a lot of it's just fake and it's bulbous and it's
all in your face. But regardless, they have big trunks. 12 cubic feet and the Honda, 14. That's
a lot in two small cars. It's the same vibe inside these cars. The Subaru has a way better interior,
better than the old WRX, not the Civic. The new Civic puts discount luxury cars in their place.
Cars like the Audi A3, the BMW 2 Series, Mercedes A-Class. I've driven all those cars,
they're not much better inside and they cost a whole lot more, like 50% more than where the
Civic is fully loaded. This is how you do premium in a small car. The best feature is this honeycomb
dash trim that blends the air vents into a single sweeping texture. It's got red outlines and toggle
vents. It's old-looking and yet because so few cars do this, it's refreshing. There's a solid
one-piece dash and it's padded top and bottom. There's elegant climate controls with a display
inside the fan speed control. There's a high-res screen, a cold metal shifter. Well, it's cold
today anyway. It'll be hot in the summer. And all the cloth and the plastic parts are high quality,
from the console to the doors to these one-piece seats. The stalks, the gauges, the color choices.
This is a car that doesn't need to try hard. It's good design becomes natural.
Some demerits on the Civic Si. You can't get heated front seats. You can't get navigation
or a wireless charging pad. But there's a really good 12-speaker Bose stereo that sounds a heck
of a lot better than the no-name system that they used to have in this car.
The infotainment is like other Honda models. Finally, it's really fast. You got color-coded
tiles by functions. It's really easy and quick to adjust settings, such as the sound. And there's
enough physical buttons here on the side, seeking, volume, home, and back. The early
Civics of the 10th generation, they didn't have that. You can't get onboard Wi-Fi in the Si
or navigation, but there's wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. The instrument panel is half
digital. On the right is a real analog speedometer. On the left, a really convincing digital version
of it. And you can customize what's in between the space, right? Speed and time. I can see my,
basically, all the trip computer stuff. I can see audio, phone. I like to put it on the turbo gauge,
so at all times, you can see what pressure it's at. That's fun to watch go up and down.
Navigation, the driver attention monitors, throttle brakes, G-meters, anything you want.
And now, more safety comes standard, which before, you couldn't get in the Si,
including blind spot monitoring and traffic sign recognition. And Honda Sensing is standard on the
Si, which includes emergency braking, adaptive cruise control, all the features that the WRX
doesn't even have. First off, both Honda and Subaru care about what you can see outside of
their cars. Thin pillars, wide glass. I really like that, especially in the WRX. The way these
mirrors are positioned, I can see right through them. It's really practical. And overall, especially
with this new screen, the interior is much better than before. The WRX Premium has this 12-inch
touchscreen. Now, it either comes with nav or it doesn't. This one doesn't have it. And Apple CarPlay
and Android Auto need a wire, not wireless. That's why they're grayed out right now. Not as
convenient, but the technology is there. Overall, yeah, this works, right? Got all the functionality
in it. But it looks kind of cheesy. These graphics and the icons, they remind me of the Nintendo Wii,
and that was like, what, mid-2000s? I think we need something a little better now.
I think these seats are more comfortable, and they're definitely better bolstered,
especially down by my thighs and legs than the Civic Si. But there's less attention to detail
in this car than in the Civic. You get the feeling that this was all kind of
clumped together. It works, but it's just not as nice of a form, design-wise. But there's more
convenience in the WRX than the Si. You get front heated seats, dual-zone climate, which you can
control also on the side with these buttons and not just the screen. There's a wiper de-icer,
rear USB ports, and auto up-down on all the windows, not just the fronts. Optional on this
car is an 11-speaker Harman Kardon stereo. Kind of matches the 12-speaker Bose, so they're pretty
much one-to-one in that area. But where they're not is safety, specifically Subaru's EyeSight
Assist. They're not even available, nothing, on a manual WRX. That car has everything,
the adaptive cruise control, emergency braking. You can only get those features on a WRX if this
is an automatic. And I'm sorry, in 2022, they should have figured out a way to make that
standard. The Civic Si is $28,710 with extra charge paint and destination. It comes only
one way. The other major option is a $200 set of summer tires. The WRX isn't priced yet, not while
I've driven it for this video. This one is the Premium, which is the second of four trims. Given
the sunroof and the stereo option, I'd say this is about $32,000. A Volkswagen Jetta GLI is priced
closer to the Si, and that's the only direct competitor to either car. Both cars are a value,
and more important, both cars are really fun to drive. If it's a speed contest, the Subaru is
going to win. All that extra power, the all-wheel drive, it's what makes the WRX such a legend on
rally racing circuits all over the world. And remember, this is only the start. The new STi
is coming later. If it's about a beauty contest, the Civic Si wins. The technology is also easier
to use. And remember, this is only the start. A Type R is also coming later. Me, I'm partial to
the Si for everyday driving, but what about you? What car would you choose? And what manual
transmission car would you even consider buying? Go to CarGurus.com, subscribe, we have more reviews
coming up. And remember, the manual transmission needs your support, and cars like these definitely
deserve to be in your garage. Thanks for watching, see you next time.
