Choosing the Right Paint Roller | Foam Paint Roller vs Fabric Paint Roller | This or That DIY

Welcome to the Woods (Melissa Woods)
160 followers
10 Video Views·Dec 3, 2022
Hi, welcome to The Woods Fans. It's Melissa and on this episode of This or That DIY
we will be comparing a fabric roller with a foam roller to figure out applications and
the type of finish these can achieve. For this demonstration I'm going to be painting
this plain pine board and the types of rollers I'm using is a mini roller. This one has a
3-8 inch nap and this is just the brand I like if you have them in the nards in your area.
This is my favorite. It doesn't get all glumped up on the edges when your paint
slightly dries and it just rolls really really nicely. And then this one is the foam pro. You
can get this on Amazon. The yellow foamy rollers and these say they're for smooth, semi-smooth,
and semi-rough surfaces but let me show you how these interact when you're using them for paint.
You'll notice here that this fabric roller does get quite saturated and if you're using a half
an inch nap it would get even more so saturated. So you roll it out a few times and you will see
see how it applies where the edges are a bit fuzzy but as long as you're applying in a
crosshatch motion like a v-shaped motion you should get pretty even coverage. And it loaded
a lot of paint. I could probably paint this whole side of the board with how much paint is on my
fabric roller right now and I only rolled it a couple times. Alrighty now let's try the foam
roller and you will see I'm going to roll this in the paint and get it really saturated. Okay
and then we're going to roll it on our board. Can you see how differently that's applying?
I have to roll over each area more often and you still have to use a crosshatch
and in order for me to get full coverage I have to press down
significantly. And I don't know if you can see this on camera but this layer here
has less coverage and is a thinner layer than this one and you can just tell.
Not sure if you can tell on camera but in person you can. So basically the fabric roller
holds more paint and puts down a thicker more saturated layer of paint than a foam roller.
The foam roller is slightly thinner application and that's just what I've noticed from the way
I use it. In order to get this to really be more saturated you really have to press down and use
your muscles a little more so it's a little more tiring. I don't usually have an issue with little
pieces of the fabric coming out into my paint if I use a good brand like I recommended earlier.
So for that reason I prefer fabric rollers for paint. So if I don't like to use foam rollers
for paint you might be wondering what do you like to use them for? I prefer to do a finishing coat
with this because it has a very fine finish and the foam really prevents anything from getting
into your product. So I often seal with polycrylic and this works really well with the foam roller.
This also applies a much thinner coat which is what you want because you're going to build thin
coats on top of each other to create like one really strong sealant on whatever piece you're
doing. A lot of times people use a polyester bristle brush to apply polycrylic but I just
think that using the foam roller is easier to avoid brush strokes and make it look like really
perfect. So you would never want to apply polycrylic or polyurethane or any other thin sealant with
a fabric roller because way too much of it would get absorbed and you wouldn't be able to lightly
roll it. I also think you might risk getting little specks of dust or little pieces
of fabric in your finishing coat. You can see that bubbles appear and we're gonna be able to
roll those out with the foam roller. You just have to go over it many many times. So often what I do
is I will put on the polycrylic layer like this in the crosshatch motion again and I always like
to say it's a w motion for woods for welcome to the woods. I'm kidding and so I just do that and
you can see there are tiny little bubbles but if you just give it a second then those will kind of
start to dry and you won't see them anymore. So now there's less bubbles that has dried a little bit
but I'm gonna take my roller again and go over it again and this time I'm not gonna press down at
all I'm just going to roll it ever so lightly over the top and this kind of pops any of those
bubbles that are happening. It also picks up extra polycrylic product that we don't want on our thin
coat and I usually finish it by rolling very lightly all in one direction so we don't see any
roll marks or strokes. There that looks perfect. So now you know why I prefer to use a fabric
rollers to apply paint and foam rollers to apply sealants. You can see that the different
applications really allow you to be more successful using these products. As far as price difference
they're pretty similar the foam rollers tend to be sometimes a little more expensive at least at my
local hardware store. I have all the supplies I used in this video linked in the description below
if you want to check it out and if you have more questions about how to apply polycrylic you can
look for a video on that coming up in the near future. Thank you guys so much for joining me
for this or that DIY with Welcome to the Woods. We'll catch you next time. Bye!
