Why JWST's first images will just be 18 fuzzy blobs - Orbit 12.11

TMRO Space News
221 followers
3 Video Views·Apr 1, 2019
This week we are joined by NASA's James Webb Space Telescope Program Scientist Dr. Eric Smith. We talk about the most ambitious space telescope project humans have ever undertaken, and why when we get the first images back it will likely just be 18 fuzzy blobs.
If you would like to continue the conversation we have a few great ways to do that:
- Comment right here on YouTube. We'll comment back or even feature it in the show
- Create a new post on our community forum at https://community.tmro.tv
- Head over to our real-time Discord channel here: https://discord.gg/9NkkFWD
Hello everyone and welcome to tomorrow episode 12.11 and we are so glad to have you here on our
show today we've got a pretty exciting one but before we get into that let's introduce ourselves
my name is Jared I'm going to be your host for episode 12.11 today I've also got Sarah
over here as well who's going to be like you're also a host we're like co-hosting together but
like it is uh and we have an an awesome guest today I'm like super stoked about this been
waiting all week uh for Dr. Eric Smith from the James Webb Space Telescope he's the program
scientist from NASA headquarters so uh doesn't get much uh much bigger than that uh for James
Webb and Dr. Smith uh thanks for coming on the show today. Oh my pleasure uh always happy to
talk about James Webb. So uh let's let's go ahead and just jump right into it uh by sort of talking
about uh you a little bit kind of what's your background uh with with astronomy and and how
did you get involved with James Webb? My background started out as a optical astronomer uh I started
my research in interacting and active galaxies so when galaxies come together and collide they
often drive matter to the centers where their black holes are and that in turn creates some
activity that we see in various forms. After I did my ground-based work I went to the Goddard
Space Flight Center where I was a postdoctoral fellow working with Dr. Sarah Heap on some
astronomy related to Hubble but also working in the ultraviolet part of the spectrum on something
called the Ultraviolet Imaging Telescope and there again I was looking at different types of
interacting or active galaxies or clusters of galaxies. When that work was tailing down uh and
I was thinking you know what's the next thing I want to get involved with uh Dr. John Mather who's
the project scientist at Goddard for Webb came to my office and said hey I'm thinking about uh
designing a new telescope you want to work on that with me and I thought well that should be a fun
activity for a few years and you know 27 years later that's what I'm doing today and uh I'm now
much more interested in all the aspects of putting space missions together and not just the science
that comes out the back end. So you're really diving into this project scientist role and all
of the aspects of it? Yeah I've had many different uh roles on Webb started out as John Mather's
deputy project scientist moved to headquarters as the program scientist was deputy program
director program director and always stayed the program scientist so I've seen Webb from
many different aspects and that's been really interesting. Very very cool um so you know before
Webb uh there were several there was a proposal before it um called Hi-Z and did that sort of
end up morphing itself into Webb? Uh Hi-Z was a proposal that was submitted by a man named Peter
Stockman he submitted it to NASA he worked at the Space Telescope Science Institute and it was
largely in response to a report that NASA commissioned uh that report was titled HST and
beyond and it was the agency asking the science community now that Hubble is repaired what should
we do next? One of the they listed three things one of which was build an infrared optimized space
telescope and so the Hi-Z proposal was submitted in response to that. Ultimately uh NASA headquarters
this was before I started working there uh sent a letter to John Mather saying hey why don't you
design uh an infrared telescope similar to Hi-Z and that's where Webb started that was October
of 1995 and I started in March of 1996 working on the mission then. Man that's yeah but Hi-Z was
actually uh in response to the the astronomical community saying we needed this kind of mission
and what became Webb grew out of that. The science is similar the technology is very different than
ultimately what was in uh Hi-Z. Gotcha and you know March of 1996 you're like right there at the
straight up beginning uh of James Webb um was that was that time period sort of like the paper
napkin moment like this is this is how we're gonna you know we're gonna do it and then this is our
proposal and this is how we're moving forward? Sure I can remember very well the the whiteboard
drawing of what was called the yardstick mission whenever the government is designing a flagship
mission like this it has its own design ultimately you send out a request for proposals to industry
and then they propose but the government has to make its own design to be more or less a smart
buyer and so I can remember very clearly seeing on the whiteboard the little drawing of basically
what Webb looks like even today and when I see the hardware now and I think back to that drawing
it's like wow I didn't realize how complex this would become from that very simple little line
drawing on the whiteboard. Wow I I'm I love how your early science kind of made you the perfect
fit for this this particular telescope as we look back at the early galaxies you're going to be
watching you're gonna be get you're going to get to see the mergers that you studied in close-up
galaxies but at the beginning of our universe. Yeah the the type of science I used to do when
I was still active you can now trace much earlier in the history of the universe one of the things
that will be very exciting that Webb will do not right away because it will take a number of years
to accumulate the data but because we'll see some of the first galaxies and of course we can look
at nearby galaxies we will be able to watch the universe build up galaxies all through cosmic time
and so contain a complete obtain a complete history of galaxies and how they grew so that
that's very interesting for me and although it will take a long time to that for that to
be accomplished and it'll be done by young researchers today I still really look forward
to the answers. A lot of our I think this might be a good time to clarify a lot of our
chat is asking sort of is this a successor to Hubble so how would you answer that I know this is
dedicated infrared and Hubble was a wider field of frequencies. Well I like to describe Webb as
the scientific successor to Hubble it doesn't duplicate the wavelength coverage as you pointed
out we're primarily near infrared to mid-infrared we do go a little bit into the reddest parts of
the spectrum that your eyes can see but for the most part we're studying heat radiation infrared
we're doing that because Hubble in looking for the early galaxies Hubble did try that
it found that those galaxies are far enough away that the light that left them has shifted into the
near infrared part of the spectrum so to see it we had to build an infrared optimized telescope
so we're the scientific successor Hubble pointed the way and we're going to follow it up with Webb
so we can't duplicate the things that Hubble can still do even today and next year is 30 years for
Hubble we're still grateful that we'll be able to have them both there at the same time but it will
be able to do things that Hubble pointed the way to but couldn't quite get to because it didn't have
the right kind of wavelength optimization. So Hannes Rohrwerp from our Twitch chat room
kind of to go in with the wavelengths you know with infrared is asking will James Webb
make color pictures or will all the pictures be black and white and I think this goes into a very
interesting thing about sort of like you know putting out false color if you will so that
you can interpret the data with it yeah yeah so the pictures from Webb will look just like
pictures from Hubble they'll be that very sharp visual acuity to them and we'll use different
filters they won't have names like blue red or green filters they'll have wavelengths associated
with them in the near infrared but you can use these multiple color filters just like you do
in visual photography to colorize your photos so and we'll probably use the same coloring
conventions where redder things in the picture are cooler and the bluer things are hotter so
the pictures will be colorized just like the ones from Hubble are and they'll be just as sharp in
their vision. So to kind of go with James Webb here what is what's like the specific goals of
James Webb because with Hubble you know there were there was very there was a very clear set
of goals with it what are those what is that set of goals with James Webb? The primary goal for Webb
was to image the first stars and galaxies to form after the Big Bang. Hubble tried that as I alluded
to and it wasn't able to see them they were further back in time they were fainter so we needed a
bigger infrared telescope so that's the primary objective because it's a general purpose telescope
with a lot of capability we know that it's going to be doing not only this early universe science
recently the whole field of exoplanets has exploded and we know that people are going to
be using the spectroscopy capabilities of Webb to look at the atmospheres of nearby exoplanets to
see if they might potentially be habitable and then because we can see the earliest parts the
the earliest structures that form the universe we know people will watch the universe evolve
through time so they'll study this evolution of galaxies and then importantly because we're an
infrared telescope that means the light that comes to us can penetrate dust clouds in our own galaxies
which is where stars and planets form so this telescope will be an excellent one for studying
the birth of stars and galaxies those are just the things we know people are going to do today
usually the most amazing thing that any observatory does is the project you haven't thought of yet
today but somebody thinks of in three or four years and the observatory wasn't really planned
for that but that turns out to be really exciting because it's brand new. I actually want to kind of
piggyback off of this one and it's the major function of primary mission goal of Webb is
what you just said but so your job part of your job is safeguarding the level one science
requirements of this mission could you tell us a little bit about what that was like what kind of
fights or it was it all very collaborative what does it go what does it look like making this
telescope happen over such a long period yeah in the beginning you have to decide what are your
your must-haves for the telescope and because we knew these early galaxy was the must-have for the
mission we had to use the best theoretical estimates at the time for how bright would
these objects be how dense would they be on the sky and then that you turn into engineering
requirements if I know it's this faint and there's this many of them that I have to have
a telescope that's so big and it has to be optimized for the infrared and now that you
have these engineering parameters you have an engineering group goes off and designs it
and they'll do a cost estimate for it and often the tension between science and reality in some
sense comes in when that cost estimate comes in and someone says well if you want this this is
how much it's going to cost and sometimes you have to say okay well I can back off a little bit
on my requirement to bring down the cost in the case of Webb our level one requirements have
stayed stable since the late 1990s because this very specific goal of finding these first galaxies
that really sets a pretty hard limit on your wavelength coverage and your aperture size
and the rest of the mission sort of flows from that so where the program scientist is very active
is in the beginning of the mission helping and getting it established and then at the back end
of the mission as you get ready to do science making sure the community is ready to analyze
the data you get there and we have the great advantage on Webb of being able to use the folks
at the Space Telescope Science Institute just like we did on Hubble so they're going gangbusters and
I have no doubt that the community will be ready to hit the ground running for Webb.
Yeah so talking about some of the things you have to put together what were some of the biggest
challenges working with the James Webb Space Telescope because this is going to be the
largest infrared telescope and also the largest telescope anybody's put into space as well.
Yeah well we had challenges in I'll say a couple of arenas there's the obvious technical challenge
of making something that's this big and it has to fold up to fit inside a rocket shroud
and that one is people can understand that pretty easily here you have a telescope that's
six and a half meters 20 more than 21 feet wide it's got to fit inside a five meter shroud so it
has to fold up and because it's an infrared telescope we want it to be very cold we want it
to be colder than the signatures we're looking for if your telescope is warm and you're looking
for heat it's like trying to observe while shining a flashlight right in your eye so we have to have
it very cold and very large and deployable and so those give us very stringent technical
requirements things have to be able to work while they're very cold where material properties are
completely different and non-intuitive at Webb's temperature everything but helium is a solid
so when you are building something like this the other challenge that comes in
are collaborative or management challenges we partner with international space agencies on
almost all large NASA missions and Webb is no different we're partnered with the European
Space Agency and the Canadian Space Agency and at the beginning you have to do the elaborate
dance where you find out what your partners want to contribute do you want that is it useful
in addition to the fun stuff they want to give you science instruments for their science community
you want to get some functional things from them as well so there's that negotiation
and sometimes the people part of it is harder than the technical part because
the technical part just obeys the laws of physics the people part well that's more complicated
I like that people are more complicated than physics right it's a good good way to describe
it so there aren't a whole lot of algorithms to uh never mind just kidding all right
must abort that statement but that actually uh so your comments actually brought up uh
give me a good in for Hanny's War Warp from Twitch and being an infrared telescope is there
any chance of JWST lasting as long as Hubble or will it run out of coolant long before then
uh great question Webb uses uh two ways to cool its instruments one is passive cooling so all the
infrared instruments are cooled just by the telescope radiating heat to space so there we
don't run out of coolant for them and on the mid infrared instrument which we do need to cool the
detector to six kelvin six degrees above absolute zero we have a little refrigerator system so it's
a closed system so we don't run out of coolant there the life-limiting aspect of Webb is the
fuel that we use for station keeping as we orbit about the second lagrange point
and we use our reaction wheels to turn the spacecraft we sometimes have to use propellant
to what's called desaturate those wheels push against something to take the spin out of those
wheels and that propellant will eventually run out now we've sized it for 10 years
if we get a very precise launch to our L2 orbit we might get a little more and I think as people
learn how to operate the telescope better they'll learn to conserve fuel so I anticipate we'll get
somewhere between 10 and 15 years out of Webb but eventually we will run out of fuel yeah and Adam
Smith on YouTube is actually asking why is James Webb going to orbit in a Lagrange point uh that's
because we're an infrared telescope and you want to get away from sources of heat when you're in
space and if you were in a low earth orbit like Hubble or most telescopes then you are very close
you're 300 miles away from a giant infrared source the earth and by going to the second
Lagrange point which is roughly a million miles away from earth you can arrange to follow the
earth around the sun in its orbit and you can keep the earth the sun and the moon roughly at
the same point in the sky behind you so you can have like web a sun shield on one side that looks
back towards the sun earth and moon rather than a tube that most telescopes use and that saves
you mass and so you can put that mass that would have otherwise been in a tube into things like
science instruments or telescope mirrors so um yeah just to kind of talk about saving mass uh
just real quick uh how much does James Webb weigh versus how much does Hubble weigh uh web is about
one half the mass of Hubble so there's where you can see technology advancing we have very lightweight
structures both in our mirror and the things that hold the mirror and we needed these lightweight
structures so that we could again put the mass into things that we wanted which is mirror area
and science instruments in the case of Hubble they didn't really need to be so mass constrained
so they were again about twice the mass of what web is okay so Dave Anderson from youtube was
wondering if JWST is going to be the first instrument to occupy L2 or are you going to
there are actually yeah there are actually several other satellites that have gone there both
U.S. and some from the European Space Agency it's actually a great place to put
uh space telescopes because it's a very benign environment you don't have the debris that's
associated with low earth orbit there's a lot of stuff floating around out there now
L2 is a place that you really orbit about it's not a single location so it's there's an enormous
region of space where you can orbit and therefore you're not really worried about running into
anything and the thermal environment again is very benign it's very constant temperature so
it's a good place to put space telescopes and uh Rebel in our chat room has a really interesting
question which is uh is James Webb a larger project than Hubble was at its time or is it more clear
cut because we know more engineering wise and astronomical wise and I guess kind of just to
you know piggyback on that a little bit um what lessons has James Webb applied to itself that have
been learned from previous space telescopes as far as the project size I think they're probably
comparable I don't know what the uh the staffing levels were back in the late 70s early 80s when
Hubble was being built up when Webb was at its peak there was about 2,000 people or so working
on the program now I think we're you know probably around half of that so in size of the
you know number of people working on it probably comparable as far as what lessons learned you're
always learning lessons from previous missions and one of the ones that we learned from Hubble
was that you need to test your mirror in a different way and even better at a different
facility from where you made the mirror everyone recalls that when Hubble was built it had this
problem that it was the mirror was made perfectly but perfectly out of focus and that was because
test for the focus was made at the same facility that made the mirror and it was the facility
itself that contained the error and so we knew that when we built up the mirror for Webb we
needed to test it in a different way in a different place than when we manufactured it
and we did that and we verified actually a couple summers ago that the telescope mirror works
exactly as planned and it will all these 18 mirror segments will function like one when it gets into
space that's good sort of on that we've got a question from Elias 1981 on YouTube can it be
refueled in orbit it's going to an L2 so with Hubble's vision issues it was great that it was
in orbit around earth but James Webb is kind of going to be on its own out at L2 is there anything
that we can do to either refuel it or fix any errors that happen out there well let's see I'll
talk first about how did we design in I'll say redundancy or tolerance because we knew from the
start we weren't going to be able to repair it if you think back to the time when this was being
designed this was the late 90s in the earliest design phases the way that people got into space
then was either via Soyuz or space shuttle we knew that those were both low earth orbit vehicles and
we were going to L2 so there was no imagining that there would be any astronaut servicing
for Webb the telescope is complex enough and the system's distributed in a way that precludes the
easy instrument replacement that Hubble had if you remember seeing the astronauts taking those
instruments they sort of slid them out and in because they were self-contained in the case of
Webb a lot of the functionality is distributed through the structure and so you can't just take
one instrument out and put another one in in the same way so therefore we had to design in a lot of
redundancy in the moving parts so that we had more than one way to address an actuator
electrically and the mirrors themselves we know we can push and pull on them we can tip and tilt
them we can even press on the center of them flatten them or let them curve more so we built
in adjustability knowing that we wouldn't be able to go up and fix it now the question on refueling
is an interesting one we don't currently have the capability to refuel Webb but as we're finishing
up the spacecraft we want to make sure that we don't preclude some future capability from going
to do that so there are targets on the bottom of Webb the pieces that attach to the rocket
optical targets just like you've seen when things come up to the space station they have these black
and white targets that cameras can look at we have those and the fuel ports are on the bottom so if
someday there's a robotic mission that could fuel Webb we want to be able to take advantage of it
we just don't have that in our plans right now yeah well there you go yeah that's awesome so all
I mean hearing about all of that I mean like but I when you're talking about being able to move the
mirrors that way I literally just like my face exploded there was I wanted to ask actually kind
of piggybacking on that and so one of the some of the research I was doing into you know the tech
on board one of the advancements that has come out of this already is we've some of the the work on
adapting the mirrors being able to flex them and and the algorithms used to make sure that
everything is precisely positioned they've already been used to aid in diagnosing human eye
variances and working improving LASIK surgery is there anything else that has come out of this
James Webb telescope already that we don't know about well that's that's probably the one that
has the widest applicability to you know everybody who's going to have LASIK surgery the need to
measure our own optics very precisely with what generated this it's an interferometer it's called
that can measure very precisely optical surfaces I know that as various components for web
were being manufactured and because of our thermal requirements we need to be very cold
we have a lot of structures made out of graphite material sheets of graphite that are glued
together so they become very stiff and rigid at cold temperatures but they're very lightweight
and how those are put together sometimes they're just glued together and the companies that make
these parts had to come up with new ways to bond and glue these together for our requirements but
then they realized oh you know this is actually a better way to do these bonds for everything so
sometimes the improvements are in manufacturing techniques that don't get such wide public
recognition but they do help U.S. industry so we look for you know everybody thinks of the
spinoffs that are publicly recognizable but a lot of times they're in manufacturing
and they benefit us in ways that aren't quite so direct yeah and Lupe in our chat room is
asking about you know these advances for adaptive optics maybe for ground-based telescopes as well
with the ability to move those mirrors as finely as you can that's right and ground-based telescopes
use similar technologies in fact they often now in some of the ground-based work for
exoplanet research they rely on smaller mirrors in the system not the big giant ones but those
mirrors are called deformable because they have many many actuators behind them that can push
and pull on the whole surface to make it move very rapidly as well they need they need to do
that in response to how the atmosphere is changing light when the light from stars come through the
atmosphere we don't need to move very rapidly we'll probably only be adjusting web on the weeks
or months time scale as the mirrors change their shape in response to different temperatures as the
telescope is illuminated from behind a little differently not the telescope but the sun shield
is illuminated by the sun it will introduce slight temperature changes in the mirrors and we'll have
to take those out by moving the mirrors around so lucas van hout from youtube has two really good
questions that i kind of want to throw in there uh which is what is the volume difference between
web and hubble and i assume the volume i assume that being like both size and and also let's say
mirror as well um and they're also asking how much power does the james webb space telescope
use when fully operational uh it uses two kilowatts is the power um so it's actually
you know it's a sizable amount of power but not compared to a larger commercial spacecraft so
our power requirements aren't that great as far as the volume it's a little difficult to compare
because hubble is this uh you know more or less traditional a tube like telescope and we have this
sun shield and then the telescope sticks out of it and of course it and then it looks in one
direction like that so i'm not sure if you would want to include the volume of the whole
james webb area perhaps it's best just to compare the mirror sizes hubble's mirror is 2.4 meters in
diameter and ours is six and a half meters in diameter so there's a factor of seven in area
of mirror and we not only use that factor of seven gives us an advantage we have advanced
more sensitive detectors and because we're in a place that we're not going in and out of the earth
shadow every 90 minutes we can observe constantly and so those three things give us a greater
observing efficiency sometimes you'll see the phrase bandied about a hundred times more powerful
than hubble it's some multiplication of those three factors that give you that and uh henny's
rower in twitch uh has a question which i'm sure a lot of people have which is how confident are
you about the origami unfolding of the telescope um so if you could tell us a little bit about you
know what how you have to prepare webb um for launch and also in our chat room um from youtube
racer x ninja is asking why not launch on a falcon heavy um and i know that's thrown out all the time
now and i personally know the reason as to why you can't watch it on a falcon heavy um but if
maybe you want to take on why are why the specific rocket that uh james webb is flying on was chosen
and the uh preparations that you're going to have to do because launch is technically two years
to exactly to this day uh that we're shooting it on march 30th so uh so if you want to tell
us a little bit about that go for it okay so first i'll start with the origami aspect of it
we practice the folding and unfolding of the telescope a lot on the ground in fact that's
the stage we're in the integration and test phase right now where we will articulate the telescope
on the ground just as it will be in space so we have to build very elaborate gravity offloading
systems because when the telescope's unfolding in space it's unfolding in zero gravity and the
structures are built to operate in zero gravity so we can't operate them that way on earth so we have
to build something that counteracts their own weight and so we'll uh you saw a little video
earlier of that secondary mirror tower coming out we lay the telescope on its side and actuate that
and we've folded the drop leaf table sides of the mirrors up we've actuated the mirrors and they
have practiced numerous times folding and unfolding the sun shield as you can imagine that's the most
complex of all of them because there are five layers up to this sun shield each layer is about
the thickness of a plastic baggie and it's roughly the size of a tennis court and that has to be
unfolded and then very precisely separated from one another so there's space between them and then
they have to fold it back up again and as they fold it the layers are folded sort of back and
forth over one another these five layers and then they must all line up and then they must be held
down during launch by a pin there's about 109 pins that go through this sun shield to hold it in place
during launch and then when it unfolds all those holes can't line up because you can't let light
through so they have to be offset from one another when it's unfolded so the origami aspect of it is
that was a great engineering problem and it's one that we will just practice practice practice to
make sure that it works in space now as far as the launch vehicle when we were setting up the
collaboration with in this case the European Space Agency they wanted to provide us science instruments
and we wanted them to because they're they may build good science instruments but we also wanted
something on the more functional side and we looked at various components of the spacecraft
or operations but in the end what they had that was the most value to us and was the simplest
technical interface was a ride on the Ariane 5 rocket and the ESA's Ariane 5 built by Ariane Spass
is actually the most successful rocket in the world for its weight class so we're riding the
safest ride we have to space and when our mission was designed we had to use the vibration and
acoustic spectrum of the Ariane 5 and so we're designed for that if we had to design for something
different then we'd have to do all kinds of testing all over again for different acoustics and
vibration environments. So Sploden from our YouTube chat, nice name there, so we've already
talked about the first part of their question which is what is your confidence level for a
successful launch but they have a second part of their question which is there a backup plan so I
guess sort of like do you have contingencies like let's say the upper stage of the Ariane 5 has
like a hydrogen leak somewhere and they burn through the amount they have in reserve
and it doesn't quite put James Webb on a trajectory to L2 do you have sort of like backup
contingencies for things like that? Well we would have to use some of our own fuel then to get us
into the proper orbit and what that would do is it just reduced the mission lifetime if we have to
use a lot of our fuel then we take away the fuel that we would have used for station keeping later
on. In the case of planning for contingencies once we're released from the Ariane upper stage
that's what's going on right now at the Space Telescope Science Institute where the mission
will be operated as well they are already practicing you know what's we'll rehearse the
the mid-course correction burn and then they'll throw in an anomaly and say well it didn't work
quite right you know what do you have to do now to get it back or we're going to turn on our
instrument oh it didn't turn on the way you think so they practiced getting it to turn on in a
way so planning for these kind of contingencies is something that every NASA mission does and
we're doing it just the same way on web too. Very very cool and kind of you know the name James Webb
yeah who's James Webb because like we know we know Edwin Hubble you know especially us
who work at Griffith Observatory you know because he did his work locally here in the Los Angeles
area at Mount Wilson Observatory and basically we like to say discovered the universe so so we know
about Hubble but who is James Webb and like what what why is he special enough to get this space
telescope named after him yeah this is a question that we get a lot of times and it's actually a
very reasonable one because James Webb was the second NASA administrator but he was the man
who designed the Apollo program and if you think about it this was a program that went from
the early 60s to successfully landing on the moon by 1969 just an astounding feat going from
almost no space program to landing on the moon in less than 10 years and that whole enterprise
was put together by Webb. Webb was actually a lawyer by training so not a scientist not an
engineer he was a master at making the government work and that is something that the space program
actually needs we have lots of talented scientists and engineers but sometimes you need management
to get it to work. Okay so so Webb was a good guy for getting the Apollo program why is a science
mission named after him? Webb realized that to get the Apollo program to work on the time scale that
Kennedy the President Kennedy asked him he needed to have the best scientists and engineers he could
get his hand on and to have the best there he had to allow them to do their own research as well
research was a critical part of reducing risk for this incredible Apollo mission and so
Kennedy would have just been happy to say look we're just we're going to the moon get some people
on the moon scrap the rest of it. Webb recognized no I need to have science in my agency if you want
me to do this engineering feat and so the reason the telescope is named after him is in part because
the reason we do science at NASA is somewhat attributable to the fact that James Webb was an
administrator. Wow yeah so very very cool that we got that named after him so yeah so those of you
who didn't know who James Webb is now you know who James Webb is so if you're a big fan of Apollo
he's the guy and who isn't yeah I mean 50th anniversary yeah coming up on it so
there's actually a pretty good book it's a small book you probably have to go to a
largish library probably can get it on Amazon called Powering Apollo and it's the biography
of James Webb and it's a pretty interesting read to read about his background and how he put the
whole Apollo program together. Very cool so Raj Luthra in our YouTube channel is asking about the
data that gets collected by James Webb is that going to be shared internationally and I would
assume it is and I think even some of the instruments on board are international as well.
That's right we have four science instruments on web one the near infrared camera or near cam is
built by the University of Arizona and Lockheed Martin. Dr. Marsha Riki is the principal
investigator so that's a U.S. only instrument. There's the near infrared spectrograph that's
provided by the European Space Agency with components from the Goddard Space Flight Center.
There's the mid-infrared instrument or MIRI that's a collaboration of about 13 countries in Europe
and the Jet Propulsion Laboratory and then we have what's called the near infrared imager and
slitless spectrograph and that comes from the Canadian Space Agency. So we have an
international suite of instruments and just like Hubble people all over the world can submit
proposals. They'll be peer-reviewed and once the data come back they either become public
immediately or sometimes astronomers elect to analyze the data for one year in an exclusive
use period and then it's all public after that. So everything that Webb looks at is public
eventually if not immediately. All right and Hennie Zwerwerp on Twitch is asking how does someone
book time on James Webb because if I recall correctly there was actually some time on Hubble
set aside for people who were not professional scientists or researchers to work on it and also
if I remember very early on I can't recall the name of who's the director of the Space
Telescope Institute but he actually gave some of his his own time that he gets.
Discretionary? Yeah the director's discretionary time to public proposals as well to make that
happen. So is there something similar going to be for James Webb and and what's that process like
to do that? Well there'll be a call once a year just like Hubble for anyone who wants to to submit
a proposal to the Space Telescope Science Institute where it would get reviewed. Now just like Hubble
the director of the Space Telescope Science Institute will have director's discretionary
time that he in this case could dedicate to anything he wants. They've already done that
for the first year. He created a program that's called the Early Release Science Program and these
are a wide range it's a wide ranging program. There are 13 investigations looking at almost a
panoply of astrophysical phenomena and all those data become public immediately so that people
proposing for the second round will have web data to work on to get their hands dirty so to speak
so they know how to write even better proposals the second time. Whether there's any time set
aside for say amateur astronomers or some public interest that's TBD yet. So Karthik Narayan
NKKN in our YouTube chat is asking what will be the first discovery from James Webb and I kind of
want to sort of rephrase that a little bit which is what are some of the first things that
we're expecting from James Webb? Is there things already scheduled and lined up that are
planned for James Webb in its initial maybe during like its calibration period or even
during that first run with it? Yeah I actually was wondering what is the first thing you plan to aim
that telescope at? Well I can tell you the first thing we'll look at is probably I'll say a single
star but a very small star field that we'll use to focus the telescope. Now in the case of Hubble
or most telescopes you want that first picture to be perfect. We know that the first picture from
Webb will be 18 or so fuzzy blobs because those eight mirror segments won't be phased perfectly.
That first picture will be these blobs and then they'll start moving the mirrors segments around
and they'll bring it all to focus. So eventually there'll be you know a sharply focused star.
But the first picture will be probably you know 18 fuzzy blobs or something like that.
But we do have people who are called guaranteed time observers. They've been working with us
since 2002 to help define the science of the mission. Their targets are already planned for
the first year and this early release science program is also planned. You could read about
the early release science if you went to the Space Telescope Science Institute's website
and or if you just googled JWST early release science you can see the list of these 13 programs
and they range from looking at very hot nearby stars to looking at the deep universe. So already
we can see that Webb is going to be doing a lot of things in its first year from looking for those
early galaxies to looking at atmospheres of nearby exoplanets and also studying things in the outer
solar system. Moons of Neptune and Uranus most likely. Very cool yeah well very cool objects
with that right there. So talking sort of like going back a little bit to sort of like
administration and things like they had with James Webb the namesake. With that there were
some sort of like schedule and budgetary things that happened with the telescope which sort of
the exact same stuff happened with Hubble during its development as well. Were those sort of
similar to each other or were there sort of unique things to James Webb that that caused you know the
schedule delays and the budgetary increase with it and you know it's like exclusive to Webb as
opposed to what Hubble went through? I wasn't around when Hubble was going through some of its
issues but I think many of those were related to the serviceability of the mission because
similar technologies for telescopes had been built for other government agencies.
In the case of Webb some of our delays came early on from how the mission was funded
and that was there wasn't sufficient funding laid in early on so that if a problem was determined
to arise you know I need more money to do something this year well if you don't have
that money then you postpone it you push it out into the future and that eventually causes a delay.
Another area where Webb experienced delays was just in the sheer technical challenge
of doing this one-of-a-kind, first-of-a-kind telescope. Unlike many other space missions
we couldn't rely on anyone having built anything like this before and so we're learning what it
takes to build a large articulated cryogenic structure in space and those technical challenges
were the primary cause for the most recent delay and we just need to make sure that we test every
we finish integrating and testing everything having now essentially built it all to be in
just two pieces the telescope and science instruments which have completed their testing
and are ready to go and the spacecraft and sunshield which are undergoing their testing
before we put the two pieces together. Okay I have to ask where is the telescope right now?
We know it's gone through vibration testing and it's being well where is it right now?
The telescope right now is in Redondo Beach, California so if you got in the plane and you
went down south you could see it at the Northrop Grumman facilities there in what they call Space
Park. Oh my gosh I think we just planned a road trip. Yeah I think we could literally drive like
30 minutes right now and go get it real quick. So you can get us in right? Sure yeah yeah you can
see the telescope sitting in a big clean room. The spacecraft is just about ready to undergo what we
call its thermal vacuum testing so it's already been blasted with sound waves like would come
from the rocket and they put it on the vibration tables and they've shaken it and they're about to
put it in a thermal vacuum chamber down there in Space Park so that's where all the hardware is
right now it's in Southern California. So what's it like to work on a project like this because this
is like this is a flagship mission these are the types of missions that end up changing our
fundamental understanding of the universe what what is it like to be a part of that?
It's an incredible privilege first off to work with the people who make missions like this
possible. There are so many talented scientists, engineers, managers, resources people, budget people,
legal teams that look into both U.S. and international law. The most fun for me is
just getting to work with all these very dedicated people and I think that this flagship type mission
really draws out people who are willing to dedicate a substantial fraction of their career to it
and it's that dedication the shared mission that is the thing I'll always remember the most from
Webb that and the crazy things we've all done over the past 20 years to put it together.
So what has been your favorite moment working on James Webb because you've been on
Webb since the beginning March 1996. What has been your absolute favorite moment so far
working on Webb? I think it was seeing the telescope when it was finally put together
and raised up in the clean room at the Goddard Space Flight Center and I think I might have seen
a little clip of it go by there and to stand in there's a big window you could stand and see
yourself reflected in that mirror. That was really a cool moment to think of all the work
that's gone in from all these people and to stand there and to see yourself reflected in their work
was it was moving. So great. I would love to know if way back in 1996 did you have any idea what you
were getting yourself into? Obviously not. Would you change any of it? Everything I had worked on
in retrospect now small projects but I did see other people who had worked a long time
on Hubble there at Goddard and I saw the camaraderie, the pride they felt in Hubble
and so I knew oh you know these big missions there must be something to them because a lot
of people here really love them and now having worked on Webb I understand the same feelings
they had for Hubble I have for Webb. But yeah I didn't imagine it was going to be this long but
it has been fun. And you know Dr. Smith human spaceflight excites everybody. It's very difficult
to find anyone who's not excited about it but with astronomy you know folks like us on the show
are very excited about it. So for the folks who may not have that same level of excitement
why should they feel excited about a mission like James Webb? What is that special thing
that James Webb is doing for us? Well I like to think of Webb as NASA's deepest space exploration
and we're an agency that explores space. We use humans to explore local space. We send robots to
nearby planets to explore them and we use telescopes to explore even farther and so each
of those is an expression of human curiosity. Eventually we'll push people out farther than
they've gone today. We'll push our robotic missions out farther than they've gone today.
There are some places in the universe where we can only go via telescopes and that's always been my
pitch to people who understand the human side of spaceflight or the human part of NASA and
its benefits. And I say that same curiosity is what we're carrying just to the places where we
won't ever be able to send humans in person. All right and Dr. Eric Smith thank you so much
for coming on the show today. Program scientist from the James Webb Space Telescope. Thanks again
for coming on and having this awesome discussion with us today about a telescope that is going to
be unbelievable with it. Well thank you very much for having me and thanks to your viewers for their
great questions. I really enjoyed them. Excellent. All right and of course our viewers we want to
thank our viewers because this show is brought to us by our viewers. Our patrons and the folks
who give us their time working on our projects and everything. We really genuinely would not
be able to do this without you folks. And you know we always say that you know we wouldn't be able to
do it without you but we really wouldn't. We wouldn't be able to get you know stories like
from Dr. Eric Smith here out to the world. We wouldn't be able to have you sort of I guess
have access if you will to these folks. And that's that's pretty unique to me and I can't really
think of anyone else who's doing something like this and we're doing this because you help us
enable us to do this. So it's incredibly important for to have your support and we are ever thankful
and ever grateful for your support here at Tomorrow. So thank you so much and I guess that's
going to wrap up our show for today. So thanks so much for tuning in and
have fun out there exploring the universe. So see you later.
