When they play into these more submissive sexual stereotypes and really sell themselves as that,
it does contribute to the pattern of portrayal in media.
Are white women now mad at Asian women for taking all the good liberal white guys?
I don't know, but that is the premise of Elaine Cho's new viral article where she calls out a
lot of the shameful and stereotypical Asian female characters that were written by white liberal
comedians who she says probably subconsciously imagined Asian women as a threat.
Oh man, Elaine Cho is on a hot streak, man.
First she went on the cut, dis-colonizing white guys in real life.
Now she is dissing Tina Fey's writing, you know, in the writer's room.
Basically saying, why are you making us look like slooty magrudes, Tina?
You're supposed to be liberal.
You're supposed to be progressive.
How come all these liberal progressive white women are still writing us like we're homewreckers,
dragon ladies, Wendy Dengs?
Is that how you really see us?
All right, guys, we're going to talk about it from a micro, a mid and macro perspective.
We do have a special Asian female guest that's going to be weighing in on this.
So if you guys are excited, please hit that like button
and check out other episodes of the Hot Pop Boys.
Now get onto the micro, David.
All right, you guys, let's get into this.
In the micro, I will say this.
I think that she's correct.
Obviously, she has 20 years of examples, liberal white writers writing Asian women as like,
you know, essentially sloots and basically people who will steal your husband,
even though he's a mediocre white guy and she's like 30 years younger.
Do I think that there have been some examples of this manifested in real life?
I'm sure everybody's seen it if you like live in a big city.
So I think that there's that aspect.
And I also think that to be fair, Elaine Cho is making a career right now
or getting like really well-known dissing white people.
Although I will say I agree with a lot of her things that she's writing.
You know, there may be some like motivation to do it.
Yeah, for sure.
I think that her voice does count because she's able to write and appeal
to the liberal white like Hollywood audience
versus like maybe an Asian woman who's straight from the enclave,
who's keeping a super AZN like people like Hollywood's not going to care about her opinion.
Right.
You're saying that Elaine Cho is very interesting because she's on the inside enough
that they let her diss them on their own platforms.
It's like you're dissing the white women who read Vanity Fair
on Vanity Fair, which is pretty meta.
Yeah.
And one last thing of the micro is like, guys,
I think it's a cycle when it comes to Asian characters.
Listen, for a while growing up,
we just wanted to see Asian characters that were acknowledged as Asian.
Come on, give us Asian characters.
Give us Asian faces.
And then you get some Asian faces and you're like,
that's not the Asian faces or characters I wanted.
And then now you're just complaining and trying to get your way
to have them write better Asian characters.
So things are getting better and better and evolving.
Mean Girls was in 2004.
Obviously, when we all watched it back then,
it probably went over our head, all the offensive material that was in there.
But now looking back on it, you're like, oh, not cool.
For sure.
When you look at it within retrospect,
everything Elaine Cho points out is offensive and would not happen in 2022.
However, that was a different time, a different era,
different standards for everything.
Moving on to the mid, I'll say this.
I mean, I think Elaine Cho is really interesting
because she's very deeply enmeshed in the white culture.
But it seems like as she got older,
she reached a breaking point where she was like,
I thought I was just like passing and blending in with everybody that was white.
I probably have all white friends,
you know, white relationships and things like that.
And then she's reaching this point where she's like,
noticing everything is not equal for her despite like being in the party.
Yeah, I mean, I think that she's very relatable in that sense
that a lot of like people are waking up to this.
I don't always want to use the word woke,
but she is like woke now to all these things that were happening
for a lot of her life.
And maybe to her, it's hitting her being like,
yo, now it explains a lot of the stuff that's happened in my life.
Wow.
Yeah, I think a lot of people, when they want to be in a room
and they want to be part of the frat or the sorority,
they're going to overlook that they might not have first citizen status.
Maybe they have 1.5.
Because, you know, 1.5 citizen status, Andrew,
it's enough to make you kind of gloss over it.
When you're second class or third class citizen,
it's like pretty obvious.
You're like, I'm being clearly mistreated.
I want out of this frat.
But when it's 1.5, you're like, well, there is a lot of perks and benefits.
I'll take it.
All right.
So now I want to move on to the question on like who's accountable.
And in order to talk about this,
I think it's important that we have like an Asian female voice in this
because we are talking about like an Asian female author
with Asian female representation.
So that's what we're going to do.
Oh, Andrew, we also have to address the gorilla in the room
that is sort of like hinted at at the end of the Elaine Cho article.
Are white liberal women truly jealous of Asian women in 2022
because they're taking all the good liberal white men out of the pool?
All right.
So we have Rue with us, our special female commentator guest.
First of all, what do you think about the article?
I thought it was pretty eye opening.
It definitely highlighted a lot of patterns
that I was never really exposed to in my social circles.
So the only example I was very familiar with was the Mean Girls one.
And at the time, because I was still pretty young, like middle school age,
I just noticed that they were Asian.
And, you know, it's a funny movie.
Everyone was like being joked.
I didn't really see it as super offensive.
Yeah, I mean, to be fair, I will say this.
And first of all, I'm not fully disagreeing with Elaine Cho,
but the blonde women get played out super hard
in Mean Girls as well as super ditzy, dumb,
almost stereotypical, archetypical things.
I mean, I think Tina Fey made a career off stereotyping people,
but stereotyping people in a smarter, more thoughtful way
than like previous tropes.
I will say if they made a Mean Girls three in 2022,
I'm sure the same tropes would not be recycled.
I think it would have to be updated for the times,
especially everything that's happened.
Listen, but of course, I think Tina Fey...
It's like 40s.
In her 40s, Elaine Cho, I believe is like 40.
You know what I mean?
Like they're from that era where, man,
there probably was a lot of sideways stuff said about Asian women,
obviously Asian guys too,
but that's not the point of this video about,
you know, from white women towards Asian women.
Like that era, like the life of a 40-year-old
is way different than the life of a 25-year-old.
Like, let's be honest, culture changes.
So when it comes to the topic of like who's responsible,
of course you can always look at all the people,
the producers, the writers,
even the actors to a certain extent,
you got to blame them.
But like in your opinion,
like who should be held accountable for this kind of stuff?
Is it everybody?
I'd say in the media portrayal
because it is so white dominant.
A lot of white women like Vandy Fair,
it's all white women, you know, throughout.
Yeah, who runs Vandy Fair?
It's probably like 95% white, yeah.
Yeah, so with producers of shows, movies,
also a lot of white women,
of course they're the ones writing these sorts of jokes,
bringing forth these sorts of characters.
However, I'd say there are also a multitude of reasons
why Asian women in real life
are playing into these sorts of stereotypes.
It is a trope that you not only see in media,
but don't cancel me guys,
you also do see it manifest itself
in the streets of any metropolitan city in America.
Yeah, we've seen this in real life at times, yeah.
Yeah, I'd say I haven't come across
that many Asian women in my demographic,
like around my age, more social type,
who are direct representations
or direct reflections of these characters that we see
that are so exaggerated.
They more so take on a couple of qualities
of these characters.
Right, so you're saying that you've seen shades
of these characters in real life,
but obviously these movie versions
are way more out of control.
Yeah, yeah.
Is it a generational thing, you think?
Because Elaine is older,
and obviously I think this is even more perpetuated
amongst the older crowd.
Well, who runs Vandy Fair?
It ain't a Gen Z publication.
It's not like the 18 year olds on TikTok,
like I don't even know if they know what Vandy Fair is.
I think the white women
who have been perpetuating these sorts of stereotypes
are definitely the older generation.
Personally, with my white girlfriends,
I haven't even heard any of these sorts of stereotypes
brought up.
But have you heard it from the older generation?
Definitely, and I've been on the receiving end
of this sort of shadiness, criticism,
and just general insecurity from them.
Right, them thinking that you might play out
like one of the Bridget Jones characters
with somebody they know.
Yeah, whereas with white girls who are my age,
like fresh out college type,
when I'm hanging with them
and they're white boyfriends,
it's all platonic, no one cares.
I don't feel any sort of way.
That's interesting.
Well, I mean, it makes sense
because their cultural references and touch points
and real life reps that they've seen
are probably very different
than a 40 or 50 year old white woman.
I mean, what do you think?
Do you think that Andrew's opening question
that Elaine Cho kind of poses
at the end of the article,
and she doesn't really get into it,
she tries to just kind of sidestep it.
Do you think that liberal white women
are threatened by Asian women?
Because a lot of Asian women
do date the good liberal white guys.
I'd say for the smart progressive ones,
there is definitely the element of insecurity
when it comes to intelligence
and really matching that sort of level.
I do think it comes back to
what field we're talking about.
In a STEM field,
you're probably going to hear
less Asian woman slander
and less Asian guy slander,
less Asian slander in general.
But if you're talking about entertainment,
which is very visual based
and it's not technical based,
vibes based,
story based,
cool based,
obviously, yeah,
people are going to use their power
to slander Asians a lot more.
And yes, Asian women
also being part of that slander.
Yeah, definitely.
Which is why I feel that the Asian women
I have noticed in my life
who date more white guys
or integrate themselves
more into white circles,
they are doing it strategically,
whether it's consciously
or subconsciously,
unconsciously.
They just notice the pattern of-
Well, they're trying to be part
of the white society, right?
Yeah, some sort of upward mobility
when it's in these sorts of entertainment,
like music industry fields.
It's all connection based.
The people at the top
surrounding them are all white.
So they kind of know
what they have to do,
what kind of act they have to put on
to get there.
And I don't think it should be
like blaming them.
We shouldn't be condemning them
for doing that
because, you know,
we're all in this country
just like trying to build a life
for ourselves.
But yes, when they play
into these more like
submissive sexual stereotypes
and really sell themselves as that,
it does contribute to the pattern
of portrayal in media.
And as a result,
like the rest of society
seeing us that way
without revealing too much
of who I am or what I do.
I'd say I'm more of
the focus of documentaries.
There's a very niche audience
of young girls
who are trying to be
very ambitious, driven,
and need Asian-American role models
to look up to
in these sorts of fields
who are in like
more positions of power.
So you're saying you're not
looking at the fiction field,
sitcom field.
You're more looking at documentaries
about power, Asian women
rising up the ladder
of corporate America
or whatever system.
With the more general
entertainment focused population
who just want to watch,
you know, a funny movie
like Mean Girls,
a character like the
over-sexualized girls
who got the coach,
that would be way,
way more entertaining
than someone like me
who is just trying
to mind their own business.
You're saying that the writers
aren't coming to your work
looking for characters
and seeing you
as the main inspiration.
You're like, no,
I'm much more of
a documentary character.
All right, so I'm-
60 minutes on Asian women
killing it in big companies.
No, I'm much more
of an interviewee,
not a acting character,
comedic character.
Let's talk about the macro
and close it out here
of like what do we do
from here on out?
Because Elaine,
at the end of the article,
she says,
listen, this needs to change,
but I'm not going
to wait on white people.
It's on us.
And then she ends it there.
She doesn't have any
like specific
like calls to action,
which I thought
it was a strong ending
and she had me.
But then I was like,
wait, what do we do, Elaine?
Well, because the whole article
feels like she's about
to ask for like a laundry
list of things
from white people.
And then she goes,
but I don't need it.
Well, she won't give it to me.
Maybe it's a cliffhanger
for our next article.
I don't know.
But like, I guess
what is some advice?
And I think you kind
of mentioned it of like,
don't look to
silly entertainment
for role models.
Look to it for entertainment
versus like, you know,
look on, you know,
in the professional field
for role models.
I guess what what advice
do we have for people?
What can we do?
What is some call to actions?
I'd say the most obvious
would definitely be
to integrate women
into all aspects of media,
whether it's less bias forms,
just like news reporting
and then more entertainment,
like comedy,
like Mean Girls type.
Another thing that we could do on,
I guess, a personal level
with our relationships
with white men, white women
is to just really hold our own,
not give into the stereotype
that Asian women
have to be more submissive
and really mold themselves
around the white man
in order to achieve
the life that they want.
Of course, if they just
like white guys,
if they want to be friends
with white girls,
like by all means,
you like the banter,
you like the sitcom-y
everybody's conversations on.
If that's the culture
and lifestyle that you want,
then yeah, so be it.
However, you should not be,
I guess,
diminishing your own Asian-ness,
like your own morals and values
and what really makes you
like more Asian-American.
Don't downplay and delete
any Asian-ness in order to do that.
Yeah, exactly.
And by doing so,
I believe culturally
the white circles
that these girls are around,
they will respect them more
and really see Asian women
and subsequently Asian men
who get more involved with them
as less the quiet,
like mousy,
awkward type
and overall just have more respect.
What do you think Elaine Cho's
third article should be about?
Because she's kind of
on this hit streak
where she's like, boom,
the cut against white men,
boom, Vanity Fair dissing,
I mean, at least criticizing,
you know, liberal white women.
I would really love to see an article
where she explores the perspectives
of these Asian women more
and goes deeper into the intentions
behind not only writing
these sorts of characters,
but playing it out in real life
with their personal relationships.
You mean kind of a self-reflective
of an Asian woman perspective
would be like,
hey, why does this stereotype exist?
It is true that she hasn't really broached
the topic of, I guess,
self-agency or culpability
in article one or article two.
Yeah, and I'm not seeing it
in a way to really blame
or condemn Asian women
for putting themselves
into these sorts of characters
in real life
or these relationships and situations.
But it is something for us
as Asian women to remember
that the more we act like this in real life,
the more people are still gonna
keep believing this about us
and these characters
are still gonna be made
and it will still be normalized.
All right, you guys,
thank you so much for watching this video.
Huge shout out to Ruth.
Thank you for being our special guest today,
giving the female perspective.
Andrew, my final takeaways is that,
man, I'm really excited to see
what Elaine Cho writes next.
To be honest, I mean,
I think she's doing a good job
of stirring up controversy.
I do think it's interesting
that she's becoming woke
after seemingly let it go for a while.
But at the end of the day,
kudos to you.
I have some questions for the audience.
Some calls to action is,
I want you to leave it
in the comments down below.
Answer these questions.
Should we kind of in hindsight
look back at all these series
from 20, 15, 12 years ago
with all these problematic characters?
And do we delete these
and cancel these series to ourselves?
Like, do we stop watching them?
Like even Friends is accused
of a lot of like diversity issues.
And there was like one Asian woman on there,
but maybe she wasn't
even portrayed correctly either.
So I'm like, yo,
do we just got to cancel Friends?
And so that's what I want to ask
a lot of people out there
who watch a lot of entertainment.
I think for me,
I'm just looking more forward
because the past is the past
and we can microanalyze it.
But you know, like for me,
one thing I'll say is like,
I would never spend time
in the urban hip hop world
and then talk about how like
Foxy Brown was like misappropriating
her Asian heritage
or like her eighth, you know,
Chinese, Haitian or whatever.
Like, you know what I mean?
I would never sit there
and do it right out of line.
Should we get at China Doll
for using that name?
Yeah, I mean,
because I kind of understand.
I'm like, hey man,
they run their world how they run it.
And obviously it's not,
it's not like fully how we would want it,
but it is what it is.
And also like, yeah,
what are some solutions
or what is like,
is the topic of self agency?
Is that a legitimate topic?
You know, like everybody contributes
for stereotypes of Asian guys.
Like, you know,
that's why a lot of Asian guys
tell the Asian guys to work out
because we want to combat
that exact stereotype that we have.
So I guess those are
just questions for the audience.
Let us know what you think.
I think this is a ongoing conversation
and I'm glad that we got
to talk about it with you, Ru.
And thank you everybody for watching.
And until next time we out.
Peace.