On the internet these days, one can't seem to get a straight answer on the age of the Great Pyramid of Giza, sometimes called the Pyramid of Khufu or Cheops. Egyptologists say it dates to the 4th dynasty of the Egyptian Old Kingdom, but a number of independent researchers say it is far, far older. Is there a way we can find out for sure? This video looks at the evidence.
►SUBSCRIBE to the World of Antiquity YouTube Channel for great travel videos about ancient ruins and ancient history museums.
► SUPPORT THIS CHANNEL Supporters get access to behind-the-scenes videos, early-release videos, course discounts and more! http://www.patreon.com/worldofantiquity
FTC Disclaimer Notice: Some of the links here may be affiliate links, meaning that if you click on them and purchase something on another website, I get a small commission. It doesn't cost you any extra, but I thought you should know! It does help support the channel.
For regular videos on ancient cultures and forgotten civilizations, please subscribe.
Hi, I'm just answering some voicemails. Let's give one a listen.
I had a question about the Pyramid of Khufu.
What exactly ties that pyramid, the largest pyramid, to Khufu?
A lot of the alternative history guys talk about that it's really tenuous and they found barely anything that ties it.
They found some document that talks about moving stones.
You've helped disprove a lot of the ancient history things, but I feel like there's still pieces that could help me understand better.
One of my challenges is just knowing where the provenance of when they say something is X years old.
Like, how do they come to that figure?
I wish more things would have a way to easily, as a layperson, know like, hey, there's these dating methods that made it, you know,
know it was tied to this and it was X years old.
Anyway, thank you. Bye.
Thank you for your question.
I am sure you are not the only one wondering about this.
How do we know when the Great Pyramid of Giza was constructed and what ties it to King Khufu of the Fourth Dynasty?
Let's talk about the scientific dating methods.
The most well known is, of course, carbon dating, which can tell us the date that a living organism died.
But that means we can only date organic material.
Fortunately, there is organic material in the Great Pyramid.
No, I'm not talking about a body.
The mortar that the builders put in between the stones of the pyramid was made by burning gypsum and limestone with wood.
A large number of carbon samples were taken from the mortar in 1984 and 1995 and carbon dated.
The trees that supplied the wood for the mortar were determined to have died sometime between 2871 and 2604 BCE.
Then we have the evidence from thermoluminescence dating, which calculates when the carved surface of a stone was exposed to sunlight,
which would be when the stone had been cut but not yet put into place in a monument.
As far as I can tell, no samples from the Great Pyramid were examined, but several samples in the vicinity were,
including a granite block from Menkaure's Pyramid, that's the third and smallest pyramid,
a granite sarcophagus in the Osiris Shaft, and granite stones in the Sphinx Temple.
Their dates came out, respectively, to 4400-2500 BCE, 3440-2300 BCE, 3640-2560 BCE, 3380-2100 BCE, and 1530-850 BCE.
That's as far as they could be narrowed down.
Although these aren't from the Great Pyramid itself, they do give a general indication of when granite used on the Giza Plateau was cut or carved.
As you know, there is a granite sarcophagus and granite blocks within the Great Pyramid, too.
We also have some astronomical dating.
The square base of the Great Pyramid is only 3.4 arcminutes off of True North.
That's accurate to about one millimeter for every meter.
On the other hand, some of the later pyramids deviate more from True North,
as if, over time, their architect's method for aligning them became less accurate.
Karen Spence from the University of Cambridge tested a hypothesis
that the two stars, Kokab and Mizar, in the Big Dipper,
could have been used by the Egyptians to ascertain True North
when the north celestial pole lay exactly halfway between the two stars.
Using the known positions of the stars, she calculated that their calculation was made in 2478 BCE
for the alignment of the Great Pyramid, give or take five years.
Mind you, this is not the only time stars could have been used to make this calculation.
Dennis Rawlins and Keith Pickering hypothesized that the stars Thuban and Draconis
could have been used to ascertain True North.
And this would have been done for the pyramid in 2638 BCE.
But what makes Spence's dating so compelling is that she matched the alignments of the other pyramids
constructed before and after the Great Pyramid to the movement of those stars.
And there appears to be a correlation.
In other words, it seems the Egyptians continued to calculate North in the same manner.
But as the stars moved, the alignment changed.
There are also markings in the Great Pyramid that provide some clues as to its date.
Stone masons left marks on limestone roof slabs in the saddle vault above the king's chamber.
The markings, which chiefly consist of numbers, are the types of markings typical of the Old Kingdom.
For example, some of the same were found in the saddle vault above the king's chamber in the Pyramid of Unas.
As you may know, Khufu was a king in the Old Kingdom.
How did he specifically become connected with the Great Pyramid if his body was not found in its sarcophagus?
Well, mostly from the testimony of Herodotus.
In his histories, he tells us that when he visited Egypt, the Egyptian priests told him
it was Chaops who had the Great Pyramid constructed, and we've been able to identify Chaops with Khufu.
Mind you, Herodotus lived in the 5th century BCE, some 2,000 years after Khufu,
so the priests of his day simply could have been wrong.
But Herodotus does say that they showed him some writing on the pyramid itself,
which stated how much it cost to feed all the laborers who worked on the structure.
This inscription no longer exists, unfortunately.
However, in the 19th century, Howard Weiss discovered graffiti painted in red ochre
inside the pyramid in the relieving chambers.
The graffiti identifies the writers as the gangs, companions of Khufu,
referring apparently to the stone workers that were working on the pyramid.
Now, some internet personalities have made the accusation that Howard Weiss and his assistant
painted the graffiti themselves, that they forged it.
But, there are three names of Khufu there, and one of them, his Horus name,
was not yet known by any Egyptologists of the time.
Weiss could not have known that name, and yet it was correct.
Moreover, some of the graffiti is set way back behind the masonry,
which Weiss would have found inaccessible.
These stones were painted before they were put into place and other stones placed in front of them.
So the graffiti must date back to the time of the pyramid's construction.
Add to that a document from the time of Khufu, the Logbook of Merer,
which refers to the transport of limestone blocks to Giza,
and specifically to the Akhet Khufu,
a name we recognize from later times as referring to the Great Pyramid.
The Great Pyramid, as you may know, is made largely of quarried limestone blocks.
But, how do we know when Khufu reigned?
Well, Egyptian chronology has been constructed from king lists,
contemporary documents from the king's reigns,
and synchronisms from the reigns of kings from other countries,
which places the reign of Khufu in the middle of the 3rd millennium BCE,
right where the carbon dating of the mortar, and the astronomical evidence,
and the thermoluminescence evidence, points.
But also recently, a high-precision chronological sequence was developed
by combining radiocarbon measurements of short-lived plant samples
with the historical information relating to rain order and length.
A Bayesian modeling approach was employed using the Ox-Cal calibration program,
and a new series of calibrations were achieved
to ascertain the time of king's reigns from the 3rd to the 21st dynasty,
the reign of Khufu was revised, with a 95% chance of accuracy
to sometime between 2629 and 2558 BCE,
and with a 68% chance into the narrower range of between 2613 and 2577 BCE.
To summarize, we have the carbon dates from the mortar in the pyramid,
the thermoluminescence dates of associated monuments on the plateau,
the astronomical evidence for the alignment of the pyramid,
the evidence that links the construction of the pyramid to Khufu,
and the carbon dates from plants that date Khufu's reign
to the same time as the carbon dates of the mortar
and the thermoluminescence dates of the associated granitework.
While the dates for the new calibration fit with those for the dating of the mortar and plant samples,
Spence's astronomical evidence is about a century later than the new calibration?
I'm not sure how this will be reconciled, but the Rollins-Pickering theory fits better.
Future studies will be able to achieve more accuracy with these dates,
but the case for a mid-3rd millennium BCE date generally
for the construction of the Great Pyramid during the reign of King Khufu
is, as you can see, very strong.
For those who are interested in reading the studies and getting more detailed info on this,
I'll leave the links below.
If you would like to leave me a question on my voicemail,
you can do so at SpeakPipe.com slash David Miano.
And if you like what this channel is doing and would like to support it,
you can do so for as little as $2 per month at Patreon.com slash World of Antiquity.
You might like my little e-booklet, Why Ancient History Matters.
It's designed to persuade people that the subject is important, even in the modern world.
You might also wish to use it to help spread the word.
So feel free to share it with someone you know.
It's free for anyone who wants it.
I've left a link in the description box below the video for you to grab a copy.
Catch you later.