A school in Shanghai, China implemented a gender-specific textbook for its male students - 4th and 5th graders - which is aimed at teaching the young boys on "How to be a Man".
The textbook is an attempt to combat a problem which began in the 90's called the "Boys Crisis", which suggests that the male student population has been underachieving or out-performed by their female counterparts. This has lead to a percepction of loss of masculinity.
Chinese schools have tried to combat this situation in many ways, such as all-boys classrooms and hiring more male teachers to act as role models.
In this most recent attempt, a children's illustration book hopes to address the loss of masculinity by educating the young boys on gender roles and other behaviors that will help them "cultivate masculinity".
What's up guys?
Welcome to Off The Grid.
Whoa!
Look who's here!
It's Dan.
It's Katie.
It's Felicia and Ellen.
Oh, what?
We also all decided to coordinate.
Yup.
Check out this outfit.
Oh, by the way, none of us communicated.
This happened.
No, this just happened.
This is how in sync we are.
We all just woke up feeling blue.
Yup, yup.
This is called group simpatico.
I knew you were gonna say that word.
It's like, he loves to put out some SAT words.
Really interesting thing we guys
wanna talk to you guys about,
which is in 2016, this year,
the Shanghai Education Publishing House,
they published the first gender-specific textbook.
And it's titled Little Manly Man.
小小男子汉
Little Little Manly Man.
And it is aimed to teach fourth and fifth graders
how to be a man,
how to be aware of their bodies.
Make a man out of them.
Mr. Idol, make a man.
This is a book that they started publishing
and they're trying to see if it's gonna work.
Yes.
Work as in to make these young kids more manly.
Masculine.
Yeah.
It's supposed to teach you all sorts of things,
like, you know, biology, psychology,
how to deal with issues,
problems you faced growing up,
how to be a manly man.
There's a lot of interesting questions in there.
Yeah.
Sometimes in China,
and this is just from my personal experience,
like a lot of things goes unsaid.
And you know how like there's those memes
that would be like,
I still don't know such and such,
but at this point I'm too afraid to ask.
Yeah, yeah.
You know, I think that maybe this book
is supposed to address some of those issues.
And just to like let you guys know,
like some of the questions include like,
why am I a boy and not a girl?
What are the differences between a boy and a girl?
What does a father mean to a boy?
Why must a real man shoulder responsibilities?
And like things like that.
And it's like,
and they also include other random questions
and it's kind of like,
is human part of nature?
Like they want to explore the role of man.
This is more like Confucius poetry or something.
He got real deep.
He got real deep, you know?
And like, what kind of boy is cool?
You know, how does a real man express love?
And then it also goes into things like finances,
which I'm thinking fourth or fifth grader,
like how-
So they're mashing up like parenting,
like life skills,
like home mech and all that stuff.
That's what it sounds like.
Yeah.
Yeah, and also the,
don't forget the physical part,
which, you know,
we relate to in the States,
you have physical education
when you get to a certain age.
And I feel like they're trying to roll that-
This is their take on it.
Yeah.
All rolled into one.
If you grew up in the West,
I feel like finding a textbook that's like,
just for boys is kind of weird.
Especially telling you how to like be your gender.
Right.
Yeah.
We dug a little bit further
and we actually found some of the pictures
that show these illustrations.
And there's actually a deeper reason
why they're doing something like this,
if you're wondering.
It's a pilot program in Shanghai.
So a teacher, I think,
created this book,
this illustrated book,
and they're trying to answer this question,
which is in China right now,
girls are outshining the boys.
And this is a study they've done.
The reason that this book actually came about
is because there's what's been called
a boy crisis in China.
Academically speaking,
boys have always outperformed girls
before the 90s, apparently.
Like this is according to the study.
And it was always expected
because the boy was the one who had to like
lead the family.
Exactly.
And now I guess there's like some backlash
because like all these women are like,
yeah.
They're succeeding.
Yeah, women are doing way better,
actually, in academics.
And that can be found in some statistics
regarding the Gaokao,
which is the national entrance,
college entrance exam in China.
It's a big deal.
And in the past,
like most of the top rankers,
top scores,
like number one,
in the region were boys.
And now they're mostly girls.
Yeah.
And people are shocked.
Yeah.
And so they're taking like the scientific research
and they're saying basically
they're correlating masculinity
as one of the major problems
why boys are being left behind.
Yeah.
But that's what I don't understand.
Like the correlation of being more masculine
and your grades.
Right.
How you define masculinity.
But then what is masculinity?
And so the whole process seems like pseudoscience
and kind of confusing to me.
I like that pseudoscience
because I feel like this is what it is.
And also, apparently,
there's also physical tests
where they said that they're not as in good health.
Like active.
Yeah.
I blame that on video games.
Yeah.
I think that's it.
Real reasons.
I think that's like.
And too much study.
That's what it is.
Like this seems like a problem
that has multiple sources
for where these issues are coming from.
And it seems like,
I don't want to generalize,
but it seems like a Chinese method
of dealing with this
is just like social engineering
and controlling things to a crazy amount.
Right.
You know, like a lot of these problems,
I think,
came up because of the one child policy.
We're talking about imbalances in,
you know, gender.
First of all,
do you think there is a issue?
Do you think that boys are losing their masculinity
or are in danger of not becoming
what society thinks is masculine in China?
There are some studies that show that,
yes, boys are performing not,
maybe they're not performing as well as girls
and maybe they're not as healthy,
but I don't know if being less masculine
is what's causing that.
And I feel like to make a book
that's titled basically Little Manly Man,
I don't know if that is accurately addressing
the fundamental issues here.
Yeah, exactly.
You know what I'm saying?
It's kind of like missed the point a little.
And it's like,
why did they choose to shape it this way
to kind of encourage,
I don't know,
boys to perform better?
I don't know.
Yeah, exactly.
It is an issue
and they definitely missed the boat on it
because I feel like
you can't just change people's behaviors
through a textbook.
You can't.
It's never worked like that.
You can teach somebody
how to do arithmetic
or how to draw something
or put together something through a textbook,
but you cannot teach them
how to become a man.
Okay, you know what,
you know who teaches them?
Their mother and their father.
Exactly, parents.
So that,
I think that that's the major point
that right now the society is missing on
because there's a huge lack of role models
for the children there, okay?
There are definitely role models.
There are certain people that behave like a man,
but I'm just saying across the board
and I think back to my own parents,
my mom was a great role model for me
but I would say,
and my dad would tell you guys this
that he probably didn't do a great job
of not raising me
but setting,
becoming that sort of man
that the young boy looks up to.
I think because a lot of the teaching goes on at home
and that's what's missing.
I feel like in Chinese society,
you're constantly pushed to achieve
but a lot of times the parents miss opportunities
to teach you and how to guide you as a person.
It's more pushing for the academics.
Well, there's a lot of pressure.
I mean, there's a pressure
because you're talking about only children, right?
Your parents only have this one opportunity to,
I mean, in very like basic terms,
have some financial stability when they're older.
So they want to make sure that
you're on the right path, right?
And like the question here is like,
well, why are we even talking about
teachers being role models?
Because teachers can be role models
but the issues we're talking about are like,
well, these are kind of things
your parents should be teaching you.
So what is,
is there potentially a problem in parenting?
Yes.
I wanted to ask you guys next like,
what do you think is masculinity?
And I think like being a man is a lot more generic.
It's about like having the right moral values,
like doing the right things.
And like these aren't necessarily,
like my dad, for instance,
we didn't really bond.
We didn't like throw footballs around.
We didn't do stuff like that.
But he taught me how to be a good person.
And I think in my opinion,
masculinity is completely tied to how you treat people,
how you act and kind of this,
having this kind of self-confidence in yourself.
Yeah.
You know, I think that is what masculinity is.
Yeah, it's not always the superficial stuff
like how much money it is
or like how much time you spend.
It's like the principles that they instill in you.
And I think you guys answered it greatly
because nowhere does it say like,
oh, you're an A-plus student and you're masculine.
Yeah.
Or like you have to look buff or something.
It's like, yeah, the way you treat people,
the way you like view your life,
it's like all the interpersonal things.
I do agree.
I think that those are things
that are much more universal than people think.
And that's my issue really with this book
is I feel like it tries to do too much.
I feel like there's a certain set of this book
that's quite helpful,
but I don't feel like it should be labeled
as little manly man.
It should be little good person, I guess.
I think certain information about biology,
psychology should be taught.
And I'm not gonna-
It's a taboo subject.
It's very taboo.
It's like you wouldn't talk about this
with your parents.
No.
And that's the thing.
A lot of things just go unsaid, swept under the rug.
And I don't think that's right either.
And I think there should be a textbook,
whether it's like, you know,
whether it's taught in gym classes,
that's kind of like in the West,
you get taught in PE, I think, right?
I'm not sure.
But there's a, it shouldn't be called like that's,
that's like, you know, associated with like masculinity.
I feel like the parts,
the good parts of this thing should be separated.
Like, okay, how to be a good person,
basic principles of being a good person,
plus some biological,
like separate the biological stuff
and the growing up, like psychological stuff
that maybe that's a separate thing.
Because lumping it all together makes it seem like
this is the only way you can be a man.
Exactly.
Right, it's very like hand-fisted.
Which is confusing to like a fourth grader.
Yeah, exactly.
Like-
You're like nine.
Yeah.
And you're telling them how to deal with finances
and like private life and what a boy is like, what?
I mean, I think there is a way
of dealing this in the right way.
And again, like we go back to like
the one child policy, right?
It's kind of like this.
It's this hand-fisted, like general sweeping thing.
Okay, we have one book and it's going to fit everyone.
Obviously it's not.
What about you, Felicia?
Like, what do you think over the course of your life
you feel like is a good definition of a man being masculine?
Well, I said it was like the principles, right?
And the way they like deal with people around them,
like how I think of my dad, like to be supportive.
And because I do have kind of the traditional values,
it's like being there for your family,
being there when people are in need
and like offering help when available.
That's the type of thing.
It's not the superficial.
Right.
Yeah, so, and you had told me something
that your grandfather had taught you about.
Yeah, my grandparents were, you know,
arguably way more traditional than my parents.
And they told me that what they thought was being masculine
was if a guy could forbear,
if they could handle a lot of things,
like if they have a big heart,
if they can, you know, meet things and let it go,
you know, when you,
everyone's going to run into troubles in life, you know,
but if you can kind of like stand back
and be the bigger person,
well, you'll always say like, oh, be the bigger man,
you know, and of course this applies to women as well.
And I think that that's a pretty good definition.
And again, I'm thinking,
they're saying that they want to do another book for women,
you know, targeting girls.
And I'm like, I better,
I'm thinking you better make it
so that it's pretty empowering.
I feel like if there was more things
like what you guys are saying,
like taught of the preservation of values,
traditional values over time,
whether it's your grandparents, your parents,
that is what ultimately makes you the man you are today.
It doesn't have to be your father, right?
If you didn't really have a father figure,
there's plenty of people out there that could be that,
but there has to be those people.
And a book, I can tell you right now,
a book will never,
just look at this, like in concept,
it might be all right to teach you
how to be a better person,
but what's actually in there
isn't how to be a better person,
it's like how to superficially appear
to be a better person that society recognizes.
And to address certain issues
that are way deeper than what this book
is going to talk about.
Yeah, it's kind of like
being able to put a face to a name.
Like right now they're just like,
here, read this book, take it in.
But like, you don't really understand it.
One of the funny things,
the parents actually like it.
Well, not all parents.
There's been criticism.
Some are saying that it's helpful,
some are saying that it's kind of weird.
And I think that it's pretty split at this point.
I'd be a little offended.
I'm like, you're trying to teach my kid how to,
that means that I'm doing a bad job.
That's true.
And like, but let's be honest, guys,
like Asian parents or Asian culture,
like they're very straightforward
with like what they want from their-
And the image that you should be molded to.
So it's like, I understand to a certain point
why people think this is a good idea.
Is it a good idea?
I don't know, you know?
I think the book is a step forward.
Now I'm just-
It could be a conversational story.
I think that the fact that it's published
and it's out there,
it does address a lot of issues
that were previously swept under the rug,
not talked about in school.
I think that's really helpful.
And I think that what it does
is that it furthers our attention
on what helps maybe boys and girls learn.
This book is helpful in the way
that it really gets us thinking.
I think we should further,
like this is just another topic,
like I think we should further traditional education.
And well, I haven't been to school in China
for like, you know, seven years.
You know, it's been a while,
but a lot of traditional texts in China
talk about how to be a good person,
how to be a sound person.
And it's not just about a man,
also about a woman,
like how to be a good person.
And I think that if that's covered,
then you can focus more on maybe the growing up,
growing pains stuff.
By the way, we haven't fully,
we've only seen a couple of pages of this textbook
and these are all reports coming out of China
and the program itself has just been rolled out
like for a couple of months.
Yeah, it's hard to say like what they're actually saying
under all these kind of themes or chapters.
Guys, let us know what you think of this article.
We'll post the link below.
Let us know, like, do you think that this is a good idea?
This is how to address the issues there.
Have you experienced such issues there recently
if you've been to China or know somebody
that has children in the school system?
Anyways, guys, thanks for watching.
See you next time.
Bye!