You're watching a feedback session for the Spungella Animation Workshop. Topics that are covered: body mechanics, cycle animation, maya animation.
What experience do I offer? ✔️ Animation Director at Paramount/Nickelodeon, formerly Warner Brothers Animation and Industrial Light & Magic (18 years) ✔️ Teacher at Animation Mentor/Academy of Art University/my workshops (15 years) ► IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1940902/
Need tips and help with your animation at an affordable price? ► Sign up for my Spungella Animation Workshop! $499! No minimum level requirements! From beginner animation up to advanced acting pieces!
You get unlimited planning discussions and 16 video reviews, which can be weekly or every other week or whenever you want/can submit, they never expire! Example reviews are available here on my channel.
All right, let's check this out. Ooh, nice. That looks cool. All that jumps out is a bit of a
floppy, floppy toe. I don't know, it's a weird thing to concentrate on, but I feel like it's
this is some floppiness in there. It's a good feel. There's a little bit of a pause right there.
It's super subtle, but when I look at this, it feels like there's a slight
always on the on the downside here before that passing pose there. It feels like it's a little
bit of a slowdown. It's not a pop or anything. It's very subtle. I think overall it's really
looking very cool. Let me look at this view here, but I don't think it's a pop where like you have
you have a frame too many due to a cycle, but it's I feel like this is a really broad
pop in the leg here in terms of spacing. So when I do onion skinning here, right,
you got your foot here, you get to here, you get to there, goes forward, and then we're back to
kind of slow, but then it's again right there. So if I track the backside here, this frame
right there from this view doesn't look like much, but there's a slight there.
It's subtle, but this one seems a bit strong and you can see this. If you cycle right,
there's a bit of a pop going forward. Is that only the other leg? No, this one too. From here to here
it's strong. I just see a little bit of a
hiccup and maybe what I'm reacting to is also this here. You know what happens when you go
this far is you look at your thigh as it goes up and then we're locked in this space. That makes
sense. If you go from vertical to up, but then we're holding this, you know, you can see this
goes up and now we're stuck in that. It's a bit of a tricky thing where it might be because of
that pop there. So it's going to help to give this another frame through there and ease into
how that leg goes up. I don't see anything crazy in terms of pops of what the arms are doing,
especially that. What's this view? That's the front view.
Yeah, I definitely feel smooth enough in the arms. I think you can probably go a bit broader
in terms of either the inner arc of the foot or swinging on the outside, but in this case,
I feel like you want to swing in a bit more to come back out. It's a bit straight, but only
this one. If I look at the left one, it actually goes pretty strong in and then we are almost
locked. We almost go the other way. It was a bit strong where that is that kind of path versus
smooth out and you can see how it suddenly shoots to the left and then back to the right.
But this I like. See how it goes in and arcs out into a step. I think we can have that as well on
this one. I don't know if you have head align, head IK, whatever. You know, the rigs have always
lots of different names, but there's something that feels a bit IK-ish. Maybe it's because
there's not that much rotation this way. Like in Y, inside to side, loosening up a little bit.
I'm probably also reacting to this here, this sudden drop here over two frames that doesn't
really have that much drag or stop impact on the head. That doesn't be all floppy, but on this,
I would have a little bit of a nose up drag, but you can see how the chin just goes down and then
lock a bit. I know it keeps easing in because of what's going on through there,
but it feels like you want to just a bit more softness overlap where it just feels a bit stiff.
If you look at the shoulders like this area and the head, it kind of moves as one in terms of
up and down. But then at the same time, there's a bit of a spacing pop through there. You go down
and suddenly to the left, and then you go back to the right, up. It's on this one on this side.
It's a bit strong in the back and forth versus a little bit soft in your arcs.
Yes, it's a little bit stiff. Let me...
Even this hand here, you can see how it goes to the screen, right? And then it holds a little bit
and visually you can see this here. It's kind of locked in 2D space there. So keep going in the back.
I don't see it really in the right one. So through here, these frames are locked.
It's not crazy. It's not like it's, oh, this totally breaks the shot, but just generally,
I feel like I see some pops in there, a bit of a pop hold in here, a bit of a stiffness in the
up and down, but at the same time, still a bit some wiggle in there. These are the ones. And if
you're doing an update on this and sending this, it would also be cool to have one as a treadmill,
just parent the camera so that we just have this guy not walking A to B, but just as a treadmill.
But it's cool to see that the feet are not sliding. That's always a big deal breaker on any
cycles. When feet are sliding, that's good stuff. And then watch out, it could also be a bit softer
on how that straight, it's a bit of a cheat in terms of how this is modeled, but
how it pops into a bend here, I can make it soften that a little bit,
or really minimal. It's like when you watch it over and over, you start to see
a bit more. My main impression, again, it's just little pops and then watch out that your
forward translate is steady. I might be just feeling that sudden drop,
but there's an ever so slight feeling of like forward, stop, forward, stop, forward,
just ever so slightly. Alrighty, that is that. Thanks. All right. There's an email. You can sign
up. You can start whenever you want. You can submit whenever you want. You get 16 submissions.
Either way, a like and subscribe would be awesome. All right. Thank you.