If Native Americans originally descended from a cave in Yunnan, China,
does that mean that the first Americans were Chinese?
Let's talk about it.
Welcome everybody to the Hot Pop Boys.
David and Andrew here.
What's the scientific breakthrough this week?
Current Biology Magazine released a scientific study
that links the DNA of modern day Native Americans
to a group of people who used to live in the caves of Yunnan, China.
The Red Deer Caves.
Here is a photo depiction of what they looked like.
Huh?
All right, so what is new about this information
that is on top of the fact that, you know,
Native Americans crossed the Bering Strait?
Well, basically it just says that there's a third group of people,
not just Siberians, not just Central Asians,
but people from essentially modern day Southeast Asia
because, you know, the Red Deer Caves,
it borders Myanmar, Laos, Vietnam.
They're the ones that became Native Americans.
Man, let's talk about this, David.
I think there's a lot of identity questions that come into play,
but also it's just kind of like funny information.
So let's talk about this right now.
If you guys are interested by this,
please hit that like button and turn on your notification bells.
David, what are like the main reactions that people had on the internet,
like the different groups?
Okay, we had to go first to the Native American subreddit.
Basically, they were like kind of rolling their eyes,
like, oh, great.
They're just another thing to sort of like take us away from who we are
because, you know, when the white man came
and like killed us all or took our land,
they were kind of like saying,
oh, well, you guys never really belonged here anyway.
Right, and then now people are like joking about like,
oh, what, are they going to like call us Chinese now?
Right, or the Chinese are going to claim us.
I don't want to be Chinese.
I'm Native American.
And by the way, I don't think this study invalidates their identity.
I totally think they should feel free
and they rightfully should identify as Native American.
What are like some European, like British responses?
Some people were like, you know,
I think this is like quite, you know, normal knowledge to me.
I think we've known this for like 100 years.
If you look at a Chinese and you look at a Native American,
they look quite similar.
And I think it's pretty funny because British people,
they're more familiar with like Europeans migrating different places
than even Americans are.
Yeah, because Americans are always like central around like,
oh, America is like the center of the world.
But then British are like, well, you know, you guys came from us.
Don't forget.
Yeah, but then white Americans,
and obviously I'm sure there's a range of responses,
but one was like, hey, man, I don't give a damn.
They could have came straight from Beijing 10 years ago.
We came over here.
We won.
This is our land.
Meanies, man.
What about like kind of maybe Chinese people
or maybe particularly people from Yunnan?
They might be feeling like kind of like, oh, that's kind of cool.
Like, hey, we got roots to the Native Americans to North America.
What's up?
Yeah, I mean, I think that Chinese people,
probably in the scientific community,
are just glad they made a big discovery.
But people in Yunnan, like you said,
they're really excited to see this link.
And I can see why.
Because, Andrew, a lot of the people
who live in the mountains of Yunnan right now
that are sort of these like tribal mountain people,
they still have Native customs
and a lot of things that visually are similar
to the Native Americans.
Yeah, I mean, especially if you count like Taiwan
and then like you're talking about indigenous cultures
from around the world,
especially when it comes to kind of like people
who are linked to Asia.
A lot of the culture is still kind of similar.
Yeah.
At least the old traditional like clothing that they wear.
And it's really weird.
It goes along like latitude.
So, for example, if you look at ancient Siberians
and then you look at Alaskans, it's really similar.
And then you go one notch level lower
and maybe like First Nations and Central Asians.
You know what I mean?
There's more of a linkage.
And then you kind of just go all the way down
because obviously if the migration pattern
went all the way down through Mexico,
all the way down into Peru, into South America,
that's like all one like link
of like one or three groups of people.
Right.
I guess, you know, should this affect how people feel?
Because we're talking about 14,000 years ago,
human migration, generations upon generations.
People probably didn't know why they were migrating
or I don't know if they knew where they were going
because they went through Siberia, which was super cold.
And then they could have just stopped
and set up shop in California, which would have been great too.
But they kept going.
I know, but everybody just wouldn't want to stop
in Santa Barbara or San Diego.
Yeah, yeah, yeah.
But like what does this stuff matter
or who does it matter to?
OK, in a modern day geopolitical sense,
it doesn't matter because most people in America
don't even study history.
They look at life between like 50 to 100 years max.
So as far as like America goes, it doesn't matter.
And not only that, like we said, unfortunately,
you know, the Native Americans,
I guess like they were on the losing end of the battle
with the Europeans for America by a long shot.
So I guess even if they did descend,
like we said, you know, back to that,
like that white guys, I don't care if they came
from Indonesia, Borneo, y'all know nothing.
We came and we won.
We won the game.
Damn.
That's messed up, right?
That's how like sort of some people see it.
And I would say this for me,
my major takeaways are a couple of things.
One, it made me consider the ancient link
between sort of like your, you know,
ancient Austronesian costumes,
Zhuang Dai people and Native Americans.
Some of the totem poles look the same.
Really like striking.
OK, it's interesting.
Number two, it made me think about the link
between Asians and Latinos,
not only in an ancient sense, like I just said,
but also a modern sense,
because even though Latinos nowadays are probably
a lot of them are, I guess, heavily mixed
with like Spanish blood from Spain,
you know, especially the indigenous ones.
I'm like, oh man, we all like kind of came,
went through the same situations.
Political identities developed
in the 60s, 70s, 80s, 90s.
So there's a lot of modern day shared history as well.
And then it kind of made me think
about like the collaborations that we have
between Native Americans and Asians.
Like, oh, you mean like the modern day ones?
Yeah, the modern day one.
For example, the movie Windtalkers
about Navajo Indians helping the Americans fight
against the Japanese.
But there's a lot of really good scenes in there.
One of them, you know, some of the white soldiers,
they don't trust the Navajo people
because they're like, they just look like nips to me.
They look like Japanese to me.
And then remember the Navajo guys like,
I do look just like them.
Yeah, because they do look Asian in the movie.
And then obviously that was directed
by John Woo, who's Chinese.
Oh, Andrew, Disney Pocahontas looks like a Filipino ABG.
Yeah, I mean, the way they drew for sure.
I mean, I'm not saying Disney is always the most accurate,
but Pocahontas look very Asian.
Our eyes were kind of like.
Yeah, I heard that there was some debate in Disney
of whether which tribe they should make her look like
because different Native American tribes
look more or less Asian.
Obviously, the more further south you go, maybe the less.
Well, what is the best current collaboration right now?
Oh, for sure, the casino.
Yeah, because the government sort of like,
I guess, I don't know if they really do,
but they kind of feel bad
about taking the indigenous people's land.
So they give them the casinos.
But then the main people who pump money into the casinos
and work at the casinos are actually Asians.
Yeah, man.
And specifically, probably Viets or Chinese Viets.
Dude, we didn't grow up too far from this spot
called the Muckleshoot Reservation.
And in the reservation, one, you can buy firecrackers
and you can go to the casinos.
Andrew, if Chinese Viets are the main people at the casinos
and Yunnan China is sort of in this Chinese Viet zone
where it's like kind of like tough to say it's 50-50.
You know what I'm saying, man?
Vietnamese were the first Americans.
Yo!
I mean, that's a new theory.
That's a new theory right there.
I will say this, Andrew.
If we put some fur around your head,
you could look like a little Inuit boy,
specifically from like Alaska.
And yo, in some of our Southeast Asian friends, Andrew,
if you put like a feather headdress around Richie's head,
he could look like a Cherokee.
Yeah.
Now for me, jokes aside for a second, for me-
That was all due respect.
Yeah.
I mean, hey, these are some funny theories, by the way.
Taking that aside, though, I think that ultimately
if something from like 14,000, 10,000 years ago
even affects your identity today,
then ultimately how far are you going to take it back?
Because if we take it back 100,000 years ago,
we're all from East Africa.
So I'm saying like, of course, we're all African
if you want to go back that far.
So how far do you want to go back?
50 years, 500 years, 5,000 years?
You name it.
It's up to you.
Obviously, I think this type of information
affects different people differently.
I think a lot of people won't care
and I think that's generally the right answer too.
But also-
Most people don't even care what happened 150 years ago,
let alone 15,000 years ago, let alone 150,000 years ago.
150 years ago.
If you have a picture of it, I don't know.
It matters a little bit more.
Your ancestor was a Neanderthal.
My answer was a Denevan.
The Denevans and the Neanderthals, they had beef
or they were homies.
Yeah.
But by the way, I don't think anybody out there
actually thinks Native Americans are Chinese, obviously,
because, guys, but there was a funny joke
when they were like,
oh, so what?
Is China going to go claim America as its ancestral land?
That was a funny thought.
I think it does bring up some interesting questions
because I remember there was a Sherman Alexie
who was a really famous Native American poet from Seattle.
Seattle is actually a Native American term
named after Chief Seattle, guys.
Not every part of America had as a contentious relationship
with the Native Americans as like other places.
Other places, I think they just wanted to eliminate them.
In other places, they're trying to find a peace.
That's more how Seattle is.
So I just feel like it's interesting
because it does bring up some deeper issues of identity
because if a white person who's Anglo
looks at a Native American
who's been here for 15,000 years and goes,
hey, go back to where you came from,
isn't that crazy?
Because maybe they think they're Asian
or they think they're Mexican in 2022.
That would be insane, right?
Because they've been here.
Yeah, I mean, you guys let us know in the comments down below
what you think about all this.
Is this information relevant?
Is it not?
What would you do with it?
Oh, one last collaboration.
Now, this is maybe not as much Native Americans
but more indigenous Central Americans and Asians is restaurants.
Yo, they'd be working together in the restaurants.
Oh, that's a good point.
Yeah, they make a lot of good food between those two
collaborating together.
Probably not the tallest groups of people either.
No, maybe not the tallest groups, yeah.
What was the thing that motivated them, man?
I'd want to know what motivated them
to make this crazy bell curve arc.
Well, first of all, no single person actually saw that travel
because they all died along the way
but something must have driven them
because at any point...
I would say, Andrew, those ancient mammoths and buffaloes
must have been delicious.
Amen.
You know, for me, I always knew that
growing up in a white-black binary America,
especially back in the 90s,
I always picked the third option, which was Native American.
When we're playing with cowboys and Indians,
I'm not trying to be stereotypical.
I would always pick the Indians because they looked like me.
Most of the white kids would pick the cowboys
because they were like blonde.
But I did have one friend called Jordan.
I'll just call him Jordan.
I don't want to say his last name.
But he used to always be with me on Team Indians
and he ended up marrying an ethnic girl.
Wow.
So it kind of goes to show...
Jordan.
He was down since kindergarten.
You were down.
Yeah, man.
I mean, I think that I'm looking forward
to more collaborations between indigenous Americans
of all types and Asians coming up.
I mean, I think there's a lot.
I think culturally, we also do relate in the sense,
like, you know, very family-based and stuff like that.
And shout out to Smoke Signals.
And I always remember this.
I'll end on this, Andrew.
I always remember, in Seattle,
we get a lot of Native American coaching.
And I remember this guy,
we were watching this Cherokee poet
and I always remember their language sounded so cool to me
because it was like,
♪ Key-la-ma-ko-la-ma-ka-la-ma-key-la-ma-key-la-ma-ko-la-ma-ka. ♪
Dude, I went on a field trip to Tilikum Village
and Tilikum Village,
you had to take a small little boat ride there
and it was for a field trip.
And I had the best salmon roasted on cedar.
And that was like one of my favorite salmon dishes
I ever had of all time.
And it was at a Native American museum.
All right, guys.
All right, everybody.
Thank you so much for watching.
Again, let us know in the comments down below
what you think.
Does this information matter to you?
Does it not?
Is it interesting?
Oh, shout out to the Muckleshoot.
Yes, and we are the Hot Pop Boys.
Until next time, we out.
Peace.
Oh, and last but not least,
I cannot forget both undersized basketball players,
but with a love for the game.