Karate Belts: Discipline or Incentive? | ART OF ONE DOJO

Art of One Dojo
71 followers
Karate belts as an incentive or disciplenary tool? Can the belt rank system in karate and other martial arts be used for more than just marking the place in an art's curriculum? Today we explore a few different ideas on other ways the belt rank can be used as a teaching or motivation tool.
◼️𝗔𝗖𝗖𝗘𝗦𝗦 𝗘𝗫𝗖𝗟𝗨𝗦𝗜𝗩𝗘 𝗠𝗘𝗠𝗕𝗘𝗥 𝗖𝗢𝗡𝗧𝗘𝗡𝗧! ◼
(exclusive episodes, behind the scenes, seminars)
◽️ Patreon: http://www.Patreon.com/ArtofOneDojo
◽️ YouTube Memberships: https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCPM5DQ0mxQdLAlnu6R4d1YA/join
Video Production by Fade 2 Black Productions, Inc.
www.F2BPro.com
#karatebelts
#blackbelt
#Karatebeltranks
We've talked in the past about karate belt ranks and what they mean for the martial arts,
like what they really mean.
Are they good?
Are they bad?
And how much stock should a person put into a belt rank?
Now today, I want to talk about something a little bit different and look at the belt
rank as an actual tool other than a curriculum marker.
So we're going to explore that today.
And the unfortunate truth is, whether we agree with it or not, is that there are people who
will place great importance on belt rank.
So everybody views belts a little bit differently than everyone else, especially with children.
Children tend to identify to things a little bit more closely, especially when it comes
to social structure and bonding and status and things like that.
So it's important to keep all that in mind.
But there's several different ways you can use belts as tools in your classroom.
And one of the ways that belts can be used in a disciplinary manner is to take the belt
away when the student behaves.
And this applies really more to the kids than the adults, but unfortunately, there's some
situations where that might apply there too.
But of all the schools I taught for, it was several schools, and they all employed the
same general tactic.
If a student was misbehaving in class, after a couple of warnings, they lost their belt.
And then they had to spend however much time, a day, two days, a week, it depends on what
they did, to earn that belt back.
So it was used as a tool saying, hey, look, you're not living up to your responsibility.
The students here in the classroom are working hard for their belts and hard for their material,
and you're preventing them from learning, so you're going to lose your rank.
And a lot of times, the kids did work harder to earn the belt back.
And if we want to go down that road, there's also the idea of demoting students and putting
them back to the previous belt rank.
I know some schools will employ this.
That one I'm a little bit fuzzier on.
Our schools never really did that.
I don't know that I really agree with that, because I like the idea.
I'm a little bit more lenient to agree with, we're going to pause them at their rank, or
we're going to take their belt away for a little bit of a timeout.
But to put them back is a little bit of a slippier slope, I think, for more ways than
one.
Not really quite sure what message that's sending, because they're not losing the knowledge
that they had.
They're just not living up to where they are currently.
But then if you've got a school where parents have paid for belt tests, or even adults have
paid for belt tests, and all of a sudden you've put them back to the previous rank, you might
be setting yourself up for some conflict with families and parents being like, hey, I paid
for that.
They tested for it.
Why isn't my kid at that level?
Again, right or wrong, whether we agree or not, that is a potential conflict that could
come up.
So I'm a little bit less inclined to agree with the concept of demoting them, and more
along the lines of pausing their current rank, or just saying, hey, look, you can't really
wear it right now.
You have to earn it back.
I don't know.
I'm kind of curious what you guys think about that.
But that is a disciplinary measure, whether we agree with it or not.
Now I'm definitely not above, or definitely not against, the idea of withholding the student
from testing if they have not performed to the level that they are expected to perform
at.
And that doesn't mean just physical testing.
That doesn't mean just physical performance in class.
They might have all their techniques correct and perfectly, but if they're little jerks,
or if they're out of line, if they're talking back, or if they are not behaving, they're
not going to test.
And here's a situation that gets a little bit fuzzier.
I had one viewer actually leave a comment about a month or two ago.
They were very upset that they had technically failed their current test because they didn't
make it to school on time, and their instructor had them sit off to the side and sit out the
whole class, and they weren't allowed to test this time.
This one gets tricky because, first of all, if you're going to test, if you're an adult,
or if you have your own means of getting to school, then there's really no excuse for
you to not be on time for your test.
That is part of being responsible.
No one else in that school has responsibility or the obligation to make sure you are there
on time.
If that is within your control, then you need to make sure you are there on time.
That's part of respect, and if that's a condition, if that's a requirement and standard that
your instructor holds, they have every right to do so.
And honestly, the best thing to do is suck it up and just try to make it on time the
following month or whenever the next test is.
This gets hairier when it's a child who does not have their means, or a person who does
not have their own means to get to class, and then that might be a measure of if it's
a constant tardiness, if it's a constant issue, you might have to pull the parents aside and
talk to them, or maybe you're older, but you don't have a ride, maybe you can work out
a carpool situation.
Bottom line, though, is that's something that you need to, or that the student needs to
analyze on their own, and then make their own arrangements, because ultimately, it is
the student's responsibility to be in class on time.
In relation to that, we had a lot of kids who would forget to bring their belts to class
or whatever, and they're like, oh, my mom forgot to pack it, and we'd be like, well,
is it your mom's belt?
No, it's your belt, it's your responsibility to know where it is, and make sure you bring
it with you.
So it's all part of that teaching the children responsibility, or just teaching students
in general, setting the standard of what the accountability you expect is, and holding
them to that accountability.
But what are some other ways we could use belts to incentivize better behavior, or better
effort, or even just a well-rounded, balanced student?
One is, this was a tactic that my last instructor did, I thought it was interesting, he had
a camouflage belt that he used in the classroom, and basically, it wasn't the rank, but what
it was used for was, each week, a student who had demonstrated strong leadership, or
enhanced effort, or overall improvement, or just really stood out as a beacon of example
of what a student should be, they got chosen to be student of the week, and then they were
awarded the camouflage belt that they got to wear for that week.
And the privileges that came along with that belt was, they got to choose the first part
of the warm-ups that they wanted the class to do, and they got to walk around and help
out as a little helper in class.
Sometimes, giving the responsibility to a student, or giving the responsibility that
they've earned, can actually help students elevate their self-confidence, their awareness,
and even their behavior, because it's just positive reinforcement.
And then at the end of each week, that student got to put in their input with the instructor
as to who the next person was going to be, and they would take the belt off and hand
it to that student.
So, I actually like that system, and we saw a lot of improvement amongst children's behaviors
because they all wanted to be student of the week.
They wanted to wear the camouflage belt because it was something that was earned, and it was
something that showed, hey, look what I did.
Look how good I was.
Also, children tend to identify a lot more with visual progress, and this is where the
belt ranks really, really work, because an adult can train for four or five years and
not see a belt rank difference, and they understand the work that's put into it.
They understand what the importance is.
Kids are still learning at that level, and they might not have fully grasped, and if
belts take a few months to earn, then a stripe system's not a bad idea.
Let the kid try out once a month, or however often your school holds tests, give them little
stripes, something that they can earn incrementally just to show them that they're making progress.
It could be silly.
It's psychological, but it works.
This can get a little bit tricky, too, and we've had examples in the past of students
who they started really young.
Some kids started four years old, which is honestly pretty young to be working with any
sort of curriculum.
In a lot of kids, it took them a little bit longer to mature and acclimate to the material
that if normally a new student got their yellow belt, got promoted within the first three
or four months, these kids weren't quite moving at that pace.
The last thing you want to do, too, is hold them at six months at the same rank when everyone
around them is improving.
It can be discouraging, but if they're not at the next level, what do you do?
Well, there's half ranks.
Everybody might feel differently about this, but we saw this really, really more commonly
with the young, young, young students, like I said, the four-year-olds, the five-year-olds.
They would start off at white belt, and maybe after a couple months, they'd get their stripes.
After a couple months, when they would normally be due to test for the yellow belt, if they
weren't at the level yet, and of course, they didn't have the material yet, then they would
get a half white, half yellow belt.
They were still getting promoted.
They still saw the advancement, and then they would be at that rank for a few months getting
a new set of stripes.
Usually, by a few months after that, they were ready for the next level.
Sometimes you have to evaluate the student on an individual basis, so while a lot of
people might not agree with that, that is an option to take.
Sometimes half-ranked belts can be effective.
We saw some effectiveness with it, and it doesn't go all the way up.
It's usually just for the first couple levels until the kids actually start to find their
groove.
Then we have the slippery slope of skipping ranks or advancing quicker than normal.
I would exercise this one with caution.
We do come across students that are exemplary students.
Sometimes they are just really good, and they pick up the material, and they're little prodigies.
That has happened.
I've seen it.
Some kids just pick it up like that.
If there's cases like that, if they can fully demonstrate their techniques, if they can
fully demonstrate the curriculum at the level they are expected to, and they're little leaders.
We had a few kids that would actually go home and study hard, and they would actually look
up online academic material and look ahead and come back and ask questions, and they
would volunteer to help other students who were struggling with the same thing.
We definitely saw their level of growth increase.
Okay, so if that belt normally took three or four months, they might have gotten it
in two.
Now, here's a question for all of you.
How about maintaining a rank?
I know there's some schools, especially some Keokshin schools, where once you achieve your
black belt or you test for your black belt or second or third degree black belt, you
get a temporary belt, and then after a year, you get your official belt.
This is done to make sure that the student will continue to perform at that level.
Life of course gets away.
There could be a variety of reasons why someone falls out of practice or might fall behind
a little bit.
I like the idea and the notion of that, the message that comes across of, hey, you've
earned this, great job, but you will be expected to maintain this level and keep going further.
Your work is not done.
I'm kind of curious to know what you guys think about this one.
The final thing I want to bring up are instructor belts.
Now, this is interesting because we've seen this a few times.
When I first started in class, we had an assistant instructor.
He was on a black belt, but we didn't know that.
He was actually a green belt, but he was really good, and he was the top instructor aside
from my instructor.
He would work with the kids' classes and the young teens' classes.
The problem though is there's a psychological aspect there too.
Whenever a student is teaching and they don't have a black belt around their waist or a
green belt comes up, a parent might look at the green belt and be like, well, why are
they teaching my kids?
Why isn't the black belt teaching my kids?
That's not an instructor.
They haven't finished yet.
Or even to some degree, some adults might feel that way too, is, hey, why am I not being
taught by a higher level belt?
It's unfortunate.
It really shouldn't matter.
If the person knows the material, they know the material, but there is a psychological
aspect to that.
Sometimes schools will give assistant teaching belts.
They could be black belt.
In this case, he wore a solid red belt that said assistant on it.
Okay, it looks official.
It's a little bit more ambiguous.
You can't tell what the rank is, and parents didn't question it, and us as students, we
didn't question it.
We didn't care.
We knew as a teenager that he knew his stuff.
People coming off the street look at that like, okay, he's actually kind of got more
of an official title.
It's stupid, but the psychology is there.
Now, as far as wearing a black belt, I've seen schools use a black belt with the word
assistant through it.
That one's a little bit trickier because I do feel that that plants the notion of that
person being a black belt, and I do know some situations where the person acted as and told
people they were a black belt when they were not.
They were an assistant instructor.
So it might look good from the parent's point of view, but there's still a double-edged
sword to that.
I tend to lean more ... I like the idea more of the assistant belt, a specialized belt
for the assistants versus just letting them have a black belt because I've seen resentment
happen from other students who are like, wait, why is he a black belt?
He was a green belt last week.
Well, no, he's not a black belt.
He's a teacher, but it gets messy, so that's just my personal opinion.
I like the idea of using a specialized belt for instructor versus just letting them wear
a black belt because that could send the wrong message.
They are nothing more than a teaching tool, and how you use them is going to determine
the effect you get out of them.
Now, there's a lot more we can talk about with belts in the martial arts, so let's continue
here with this discussion where we talk about the pros and cons and whether or not belts
even belong in the martial arts to begin with and what they mean to you, and we also talk
about the myth of the origin of the black belt.
So let's really sink our teeth into some real meat, and let's see where you guys stand on
this one.
