You're watching a feedback session for the Spungella Animation Workshop. Topics that are covered: lipsync, body mechanics, acting, maya animation.
What experience do I offer? ✔️ Animation Director at Paramount/Nickelodeon, formerly Warner Brothers Animation and Industrial Light & Magic (18 years) ✔️ Teacher at Animation Mentor/Academy of Art University/my workshops (15 years) ► IMDB: https://www.imdb.com/name/nm1940902/
Need tips and help with your animation at an affordable price? ► Sign up for my Spungella Animation Workshop! $499! No minimum level requirements! From beginner animation up to advanced acting pieces!
You get unlimited planning discussions and 16 video reviews, which can be weekly or every other week or whenever you want/can submit, they never expire! Example reviews are available here on my channel.
All right, let's play this again. Here is the sound.
But, we let her live, because that's what heroes do.
They show mercy.
But, we let her live, because that's what heroes do.
They show mercy.
All right, so the sound for now.
And I saw your mail, so it's kind of like an inside joke to the bartender at the end.
Yeah, I mean, all makes sense.
I read the mail with your explanations on how he starts and ends.
I think, from a mechanical point of view, there's something slightly hard
when that whole body here goes back right there.
It feels like, I mean, these are hard chairs.
He's pretty big, though.
He'd probably bend this a bit backwards.
It just feels like we could soften that moment just a little bit.
It's a little bit of a bang right there.
And you can see, as he goes back, especially that's, for me, the frame 18.
What is it? 17, 18.
It kind of locks, almost visually pinpointing that area there.
So, if he goes back and then hits that point,
I would just ease into that a bit more, or we shouldn't come back.
Softly, though.
Again, imagine.
I mean, look at him.
He's huge.
It's like that behind the chair.
Imagine he leans back.
I think this can lean back a bit.
Just a bit.
That just felt just a bit harsh.
But also, it feels like there's a movement back, stop, and then a rotation in Y.
So, when I scrub, like, you know, you pinpoint that button or just the tie.
It goes back, stop, and then it just moves over.
That feels a bit mechanical, and it also feels like it's almost too soon.
It almost goes before that arm is going back.
I don't mind it here.
Like, when I look at just that section, I feel like, okay, that arm goes back.
Oh, turn me off.
I'm just kidding here.
It goes back.
It takes the shoulder back with it, but it also takes this with it.
Like, there's a connection and connectivity, I guess, to all of this.
But right through there, it's like the chest goes back while this goes down and back a bit.
It feels a bit weird.
And that's such a weird comment for you to say it's weird.
It just feels mechanically kind of clunky where we have this big move, stop,
then rotation over before that big move in the arm that would drive that chest to go back.
So, I would overshoot, come back a bit,
wait a bit with that rotation maybe by the time we get to around here-ish.
And then it's a little bit of a one-two moment of this going back,
and then it kind of stops.
I like that there's still some movement, there's some rotation,
but generally it feels like it's just kind of ending there.
And then suddenly we have a really sharp elbow drop,
a little bit of a shoulder drop as well.
But it's mostly where arm goes back, stop.
Suddenly elbow goes down, which gives this a bit of an IK feel.
There's so much rotational change in that elbow while this is staying the same.
Now, I know it needs to kind of stay the same because there's liquid in it
and it's holding the glass,
but just be careful when there's so much movement here,
yet the orientation of this is pretty much the same.
Like, this just feels like an IK arm.
I mean, you'd know better if that's IK or FK,
but that's what it feels to me.
Is he resting it at the end?
No, so I don't know.
Maybe it could be something done then with FK.
But I like the way it feels after that.
There's some good life, little tiny things like this line right there where that cup is.
A bit of a tangent.
I would probably keep it more like this and then lift that arm a little bit
and bring that cup up this high
just to kind of get away from this line, from the tangent with this.
So picky.
But like, that is nice.
Bit of a line here, it's a tangent.
But that to me feels a bit better than just the way it's right there.
Yeah, for me, it's mostly that.
Like, connective stuff.
It's a little bit sharp here in how much all of this goes back.
Look at this line.
So again, it feels like an IK arm, but this is almost glued.
And I think if you go back this much, I'm looking at the upper arm going back here.
I think you could have maybe this line would then go down to like here.
I mean, like this goes down to here.
Just a little bit of a transit over.
Again, taking away that one axis move back of an IK arm.
By the way, I'm so picky just because, you know, this is during the polish stage.
The rest is cool.
All the stuff you have there.
Even like when it goes down like that, like that compression through all of this is nice.
But be careful, the other thing that makes this stand out so much,
if you just look at this section, right?
If I scrub, you can see all of this, right?
There's something where all of this here, right before it compresses.
Look at this section, especially where the button is.
Like, there's not much going on right before it compresses.
See that? There's so much in here, but nothing really in here.
And then suddenly, it compresses down.
So I will give, while this goes down, just a bit more influence.
Imagine you're painting weights and that influence goes down just a bit more.
That's my main thing when I'm looking at all of this,
is that there's some areas that feel just separated
in terms of body mechanics and just the rig.
It feels a lot better.
There's even like little moves.
I see how that stuff is still moving, where it feels connected.
Again, like he's a big, big guy, big muscles.
That stuff is going to be fairly connected.
Watch out, even here, when he goes back, it feels a bit sharp.
Looking a bit at that chin line and these lines here.
Let's bring this sound back.
What heroes do.
That's what heroes do.
What heroes do.
I will just soften the amount of down you have and over.
It's a little bit like a frame or two.
I like that it's better with the sound, obviously,
because there's a big accent there.
Heroes do.
Heroes do, but it's still that last frame.
And then I feel like a big, sharp down.
And then suddenly, there's only a to the left.
And then suddenly up.
It's like literally a frame or two, softening just a bit.
And I think you can get away with it by,
if you look at the back line here of the head,
by just giving this line and a bit of this line,
some movement in the chest and the head.
So you keep the sharpness in here.
So I don't want to soften it too much.
So you kind of keep the sharpness.
But imagine like all of this drives the rest of the body back a bit.
And it might also be because you have a little bit of shoulder movement
that suddenly sticks right there.
What is this frame? 76, 78, somewhere there.
Heroes do.
Like that.
Just look at that line on the shoulder when he says do.
Heroes do.
Bam, it kind of pops back a bit.
Heroes do.
I think that way you still retain the sharpness
because of the line and the audio and everything,
while keeping that a little bit softer.
And I really am just talking a frame or two.
They show mercy.
Show mercy.
I'm thinking on C, mercy.
Just doing that, I would extend the corners just a bit more.
And if you want to open the jaw a tiny bit,
a really tiny bit.
But it's mostly the corners.
Show mercy.
Mercy.
All I'm reading, if I take the sound off, is show mercy.
Mercy.
You know, mercy versus mercy.
The C at the end is missing for me.
Yeah, it's cool.
Because the other thing too,
is that I don't want to loosen up everything too much.
I just want to make sure that a big arm move feels connected.
But I don't want him to feel super loose.
Because again, it's a big guy, big muscles in his suit.
There's a certain tightness to him that I don't want to lose.
Just to make that clear.
But I want to make sure that everything feels connected
and that we don't have little pops here and there.
The only other thing at the end
is like this finger really stands out to me.
I like you got some movement there.
You know, here feels like it really just kind of sticks out.
But it's okay.
That's cool.
Don't mind that.
Then goes back.
But then we're just kind of stuck
and it's this combination of thumb and index.
That just makes this really big here.
And then it's just all kind of together there and back.
So I would potentially on this,
you can go up and maybe bring out that thumb here.
And then rest it again.
So you have a bit of a different silhouette.
Maybe the index is then a bit lower.
The thumb comes out.
Something a bit different.
This feels suddenly a bit too blocky and simple for a final polish.
I see some cool compressions up on the fingers.
But we can especially hear some changes there.
But we can push that to the very end.
It's good hand pose here though.
In terms of just the finger and the grouping and stuff.
I'm not going to belabor the tangents.
It's just me being very picky.
It's like this here.
It's too close to me to this line.
I would take this and break that line a bit.
But then careful my align just with that.
I know that to me, that's always keep things clean.
I like this here.
This feels cleaner.
I mean, you know, if you have any problems with this,
you just take that pole and bring it over here.
So you don't have too many lines crossing here.
There's a lot of stuff going on there.
Which of course, you know, you can render this in stages.
And that's clean.
And the rest is blurred for some depth of field.
And that fixes it.
Now bring back the sounds.
Just click for lips.
But, but, but's okay.
So you got a compression in.
And then, but, but, but.
This really could be my player.
To me, it seems, but, too early.
But, speaking of which.
Always good to open this up with a different player.
But, we let her live.
But, we let her.
This is better.
This is the Windows media player.
I still feel like it's a framework too soon.
But, we let her.
Still feels a bit too soon.
Your but is a bit too soon.
But, usually in this player.
But, it's even a frame or two.
Earlier than what's actually being played last.
And I feel like.
But, we let her live.
It was even here.
We let her live.
It was a bit early.
Because that's what heroes do.
That's what heroes do.
But then it matches nicely here.
So you just have to check.
This might be, that whole beginning.
Might be a frame or two too early.
But, if you shift that.
Which I don't shift the whole thing.
Heroes do.
I like where this is at.
In terms of the sync.
They show mercy.
And the rest as well.
But, we let her.
Let.
You might have a bit further in your corner.
Let.
We let her live.
But, we let her live.
But, we let her.
Just a bit.
Just a tiny bit like that.
Again, polish.
We let her live.
Live, live.
Even here, I would go up a bit higher in that corner.
Careful that it's not super turning into a smile.
We let her live.
Because, to me, it's also in the audio.
It just goes up.
And I think you want to put that accent just a bit stronger.
For the shapes.
Let her live.
Because that's what heroes do.
Let her live.
Because that's what heroes do.
They show mercy.
Yeah, this is cool though.
Because it's.
I don't see a chatter.
There's a lot that he says here.
Let's turn the scrubbing off.
And I don't feel like it's overly busy in your back and forth.
Which is really good.
Because that's what heroes do.
They show mercy.
The only thing I would say is mercy.
Mercy.
I don't think that jaw is going to be going down so sharply in and back.
Just watch the mercy jaw.
Do.
They show mercy.
Mercy.
They show mercy.
It's a bit.
I would give this.
See that how your jaw goes down.
Down.
There's a big move.
Something like you're easing into it.
Then you go.
Pam.
And then you go back.
There's a one frame direction change.
And I will give this another frame down a little bit.
If you can.
I know it's going to lower it a little bit.
I would just soften this however you see fit there.
I don't want it to be locked in space either.
But it just feels.
It's mercy.
Mercy to me is mercy.
It's not like.
Let her live.
Because that's what heroes do.
Do.
Like do.
I can see this being do.
With the sharper.
With like a one or two frame ease in.
To keep that accent.
Versus mercy.
Mercy.
That has a bit of a longer ease into me.
So watch out.
Just that section.
That one frame change there.
It's a bit harsh.
But we let her live.
Because that's what heroes do.
And then through this.
I don't know.
I would cheat the pupils over.
So we can see them a bit more.
Especially here.
I'm just seeing white at this point.
So maybe it's also a bit of a.
I can go up here.
You know.
Maybe slightly reducing the lower lid.
Maybe giving us.
A different kind of eye.
Where it's not just black.
Maybe give a bit of a color with the iris then.
So we just don't lose this.
Like at this point.
I feel like it's here.
But we're just kind of losing it.
Because we're also losing completely here.
I want to keep a little bit of the pupils.
Visible like that.
That's fine here.
All that reads well.
A little highlight in there.
That's nice too.
Switch out.
Like that.
Like this still reads.
It's just here.
Here it turns into the exorcist to me.
Like I still kind of see it up here.
But I think we could.
Give this a bit more.
A bit more read.
A bigger readability pass on that.
I think that's it.
It's very picky.
Lots of picky stuff.
But it's cool.
I like it.
But we let her live.
Because that's what he.
Yeah.
It's mostly.
It's mostly the bigger pieces to me.
Are the back stop.
Turn stop.
Shoulder.
Down.
Chest inflate.
Right.
If you think about those moments.
Back.
Turn.
Arm.
Chest.
I feel like.
You can.
Instead of feeling it like this.
You just want to combine these.
And overlap these actually more.
And just work on that connectivity.
And then just a little polishing things.
That I mentioned here and there.
All right.
It's very cool.
All right.
There's an email.
You can sign up.
You can start whenever you want.
You can submit whenever you want.
You get 16 submissions.
Either way.
Like and subscribe.
Would be awesome.
All right.
Thank you.