Apple Pencil 1 vs Apple Pencil 2

Magic Hands
30 followers
8 Video Views·Nov 9, 2022
Apple Pencil 1 vs Apple Pencil 2
Okay, so we're going to compare Apple Pencil 1 with Apple Pencil 2. Now in terms of which is best,
it's clearly an unfair comparison because this is the first generation, this is the second
generation and Apple have gone a very long way to improve it. Having said that, it's been three
years since this one came out into late 2015 and we're now late 2018, so there's three years between
the two. So it's been a fair amount of time for Apple to really iron out any issues that we had
So as you can see, just in terms of a physical comparison, the new one is shorter and it feels
better in the hand. It is a more natural pencil length. I've always felt that the first generation
Apple Pencil was just a little bit too long. It felt slightly ungainly in the hand, the weighting
was somehow a little bit off. But now they've fixed that, they've got it to a much more comfortable
and natural feel length, much lower like a real pencil. One of the other gripes that I had with
Apple Pencil and most people have had is the cap that you lose, the lightning port plug that you
have to stick into the iPad itself. Clearly that was a strange design solution, really ungainly,
really awkward looking and potentially a good way of breaking both your iPad and your Apple Pencil.
Compare that with the latest Apple Pencil, it just magnetically attaches to the top of the iPad
like that instantly. Much, much better. So it charges, it pairs, it stores it. This is the
solution we would have ideally had right from the get-go. However, things take time to evolve and I
guess we should just be grateful that they have actually managed to figure it out and come up with
a solution. Other benefits between the first generation and the second generation Apple Pencil
is that we have a flat surface on the new Apple Pencil. So it's rounded the majority of the way
around but then on one edge we have a flat surface. Now that's really good, adds an extra
level of being able to grip it, feels more natural. If you've used pencils a lot then often
pencils will have exactly that kind of form and it really does help convince you that you're using a
traditional tool. Added to that we've got a more of a matte finish compared to the gloss finish
of the original and it just feels a lot nicer in the hand. In terms of the way that they actually
operate on the iPad there's no difference. They have the same latency, the same accuracy, the same
speed, nothing has changed in terms of the actual usability on the iPad itself. Between the iPad
Pro 3 and the iPad Pro 2 the screen refresh rate is at 120. So there's no change there, so it's not
going to be more responsive, it's going to be exactly the same to use but it has other benefits
as we've discussed. One of the other major benefits of the new Apple Pencil is that you can
double tap it for functions. So within an app like Procreate we can draw, double tap, we instantly go
to the eraser, double tap again, we're drawing, double tap, we're erasing. Feels really natural.
Initially I thought you were going to have to tap on the flat edge and I thought that might be quite
awkward but it turns out if you tap it anywhere within that area of the Apple Pencil then that's
fine, does not have to be on the flat edge. So grip it however you want, it's always going to be the
perfect place here to double tap it there. Now obviously within Procreate this is the default
setting is to use the tool and then use the eraser but within the settings you have all sorts of extra
functions and you can change the preference and the gesture controls and you can set it so that
you double tap on the Apple Pencil does different things. If your iPad has gone to sleep and you tap
it you will instantly go into notes and that's a really cool feature as well so then you can
instantly start writing or drawing or whatever it is, note-taking, whatever it is you wish to do.
Another thing to bear in mind is the fact that it permanently attaches or attaches rather at the top
of the the iPad. It means that you don't have to make a special conscious effort to charge the thing
so it's all so natural to be sticking your Apple Pencil into the end of your iPad before but it
meant that charging it became an issue it had to be something you had to bear in mind whereas on this
because this is probably a good way you're going to be storing where you're not using you'll never
have to really consider whether it's charged or not because I think the majority of the time is
going to be charged. Now in terms of some of the negatives they are not compatible with each other's
iPads so the Apple Pencil 2 you cannot pair it, you cannot charge it on the older iPads,
the older Apple Pencil you cannot pair it, you cannot charge it with the new iPad so unfortunately
that means if you want to use this Apple Pencil you do need a new iPad and if you want to make
any use of your old Apple Pencils you need to hang on to your old iPad so if you're wanting the new
Apple Pencil it's best to sell your old Apple Pencil and your old iPad and then hopefully it
will go partway towards funding the new Apple Pencil which is not cheap either I think it's
about $120 ish, £120 in that sort of region and that's sometimes changeable it depends on where
you are in the world and how the currency translates but it's more expensive. So in the UK
this was £79 when I first got it, the Apple Pencil 1 and this one was £119. Clearly there's
benefits, the technology has got better, there's more functions involved in it but still it is
more expensive. It seems these days that you're paying whenever they have an upgrade in technology
things advance then there comes a hike in price which seems a little unfair. It used to be that
the technology remained the same price and just got better year on year but gone are those days
it seems that if we want better technology we have to pay for it every year these days. Frustrating
but in all honesty if you have the money and painting and drawing is really important to you
then honestly I think the differences are pretty big in terms of the feel and usability of it.
Bear in mind it won't make you a better artist, it's not going to fundamentally change the way it
interacts with the iPad in terms of the painting and drawing, it's all the added functions around
the added benefits really that has changed. Also bear in mind if you've used a grip on your old
Apple Pencil which I have for the last three years then that is not going to be compatible,
it's not going to be something you're going to want to use on the new Apple Pencil because as
soon as you do that you cannot use a double tap function because it totally then consumes the area
in which you would be double tapping. So you either like the feel of it as it is or don't
buy it. Having said that I really don't think I'm going to miss having to use a grip. I think
it feels better in terms of the texture, it's lighter somehow feeling in the hand. I don't know
whether it is lighter but it feels I guess because of the slightly shorter length it feels better
balanced, it just feels really good. But don't fret if you've not had an iPad and Apple Pencil
very long and the monies, the finances are not available to upgrade at this point, you're not
missing out on a huge amount. It is definitely a better Apple Pencil and a better iPad but your
artwork won't suffer. Okay I'm going to be doing a video soon where I'm testing out the new Apple
Pencil on the iPad and just seeing how I get along using it to do some actual artwork. So please make
sure to subscribe, check out my other painting tutorials. I do all sorts of tutorials from
landscapes to textures, natural elements, you name it. So subscribe, I'll catch you back here again.
See you later.
