A History Chase on Postwar America: Primary and Secondary Sources - Rod Franchi

OER Project
100 followers
26 Video Views·Aug 16, 2022
Track Talk: Assessing Historical Thinking
In this talk, Rod Franchi discusses how teachers can prepare students to be historians in training and how teachers can assess students’ sourcing skills by using engaging—and sometimes jaw-dropping—sources. Learn how you can create your own History Chase and help your students sharpen their historical thinking skills.
OER Conference for Social Studies 2022: https://community.oerproject.com/events/oc-for-social-studies-2022/
Website: https://www.oerproject.com
Facebook: https://www.facebook.com/OERProject/
Twitter: https://twitter.com/OERProject
Imagine visiting a history classroom where students are leafing through a packet of primary and secondary sources.
You ask someone what they're doing. The response? They have to answer the questions that go along with the sources.
Oof! That's not how we want kids to see history.
While it's great that these students are exploring our favorite subject beyond a textbook, there has to be something more.
Hi, my name is Rob Franschi, and I teach AP U.S. History at Novi Michigan.
I'm so encouraged to know that history classrooms are looking less and less like this.
It is my privilege to work with teachers from every part of the country.
I'm so inspired by the passion and imagination they bring to their classrooms.
History education is definitely on the move.
The scene I described is not so common anymore, but it serves as a thinking exercise to remind us of the sort of classroom experience we know doesn't work with our students.
From there, we can dream a little about what history can look like.
In this track talk, I'll focus on how we can help students understand the whys and the process of doing history.
I'll share one of my favorite teaching methods, the history chase, where primary and secondary sources play the starring role.
Then I'll discuss an easy, engaging activity to help you assess your students' historical thinking.
We'll get to the history chase in a moment, but first, let's talk sources.
State curricula and standardized tests tell us we have to teach primary and secondary sources.
What an opportunity, you guys.
The past is filled with so many fascinating, sometimes super weird primary sources.
They have a unique ability to pique interest.
For example, a 19th century lithograph, The Way of Good and Evil, teaches kids that the path to eternal damnation begins with, wait for it, disobedience to their teachers.
Our kids know Dr. Seuss, but they are surprised to learn he once penned cartoons to bash isolationists in the early part of World War II.
And a close study of Billie Holiday's recording of Strange Fruit reveals a sort of poem about the horrors of lynching.
When primary sources grab our students' attention, we see them lean in.
They are ready to learn.
Secondary source selections can show students that accounts of the past can take so many forms.
History can be the new History's Us podcast, or a recent documentary on Watergate, or a book that moves our thinking in new directions, like one featured in today's lesson, Homeward Bound, American Families in the Cold War Era, by Elaine Tyler May.
This particular lesson is situated in post-war America, roughly 1945 to the early 60s.
The previous lesson was about foreign policy, America's new special role in the post-war world as we understood it, to protect democracy and capitalism from the menace of communism.
As far as content goes, I want students to see the peculiar pressures of conformity that seem to emanate from every one of society's institutions at the time.
The lesson takes the form of a history chase, which is a basic version of the history process.
A big problem is posed. Evidence is studied. Students discuss what they're seeing with peers.
Finally, each individual offers their own solution to the big problem.
An interpretation supported with evidence and a historical figure.
It's a sort of mini-history.
The lesson culminates in a fishbowl Socratic seminar.
We kick off the lesson with a hook.
Two questions for 1950 standardized tests for New York students.
The first asks, the best choice of color for painting walls in a living room with a northern exposure is...
Immediately, students are intrigued.
Wait, there's a right color to paint a room?
And the second question.
Happy relationships for a young married couple are likely to be strengthened when the wife...
Just take a look at those choices.
For this question, I've literally seen jaws drop.
Then I ask my kids, how is this standardized test an artifact?
In other words, what does it tell us about that period of our history?
Now it's time to introduce the big problem.
Who is the perceived real American of the post-war period according to society's institutions?
In my classroom, all year long, we talk about a real American club.
How the dominant culture defines a real American.
Who is in the club?
These are always rich conversations, but we have to be careful.
Just because we're asking the question doesn't mean we're buying into its logic or the assumptions that come with it.
It is important to note the troubling nature of the real American club.
And also how club membership has expanded over time.
Once the lesson direction is behind us, there can be a short discussion to surface prior knowledge from reading notes and elsewhere.
Then teams are ready to plunge into the history.
Lesson works best when teams of students can travel from station to station for two or three class periods.
In the chase, students encounter many of my favorite artifacts and secondary sources from the year.
One has to be seen to be believed.
It's part of a series of educational films shown to high school students in the 1940s and 50s.
This particular one is called Are You Popular?
When the teams have learned from all the stations, it's time for students to pull it all together.
Two formative assessments help them do this.
The first involves the student as an individual apprentice historian.
And the second, they are a member of their class community.
Let's talk about the first one.
Here students write to the lesson's big problem, either in class or at home.
This is a critical moment in the lesson.
Students are pressed to survey all the evidence from the history chase to determine the best obtainable version of the truth, as legendary journalist Woodward Bernstein called it.
With a good set of instructions, or even a rubric, students will be clear on what they need to produce.
It's important that our kids understand that their interpretation should flow from evidence.
We can ask them to show that connection with analysis in a circle of thinking, like causation and change.
The little history for this lesson could be required to employ evidence from four primary sources and two secondary sources.
The CER method is an effective way to structure these little histories.
Claim, evidence, reasoning.
CER, or something like it, is a really important part of any history in social studies class.
It reminds us there's a disciplined thinking process to build new knowledge.
Once their little histories are written, students are ready to engage with their class community.
The classroom becomes a fishbowl Socratic seminar.
This affords teachers an opportunity to quickly assess all of our students in real time.
Of course, there are a million ways to run a Socratic seminar.
I like for students to run the show with me on the outside observing a sort of teacher gag room.
Going into the seminar, students know to engage in civil dialogue that centers around these six questions.
Some of which invite students to take the discussion in new directions.
From the sidelines, I observe students' claims, evidence, and historical thinking.
Who might need a refresher lesson on CER or causation?
Who's getting better at analyzing sources?
Who might be a good peer model for the whole class?
I ask myself similar questions when I gauge students' grasp of the content.
Here, I'm especially interested if students can use historical thinking to find the bits
and create a coherent interpretation of the past.
But also, I just enjoy the show.
No matter how many years I've taught, it is always a special moment to see students make new connections
that help them build a new understanding about our past.
Lessons like this one can serve as part of a strategically planned K-12 curriculum that includes historical thinking.
Historical thinking is just one form of critical thinking.
This sort of work also speaks to an even larger purpose of history and social studies classes.
In our current historical period, disinformation is rapidly corroding American democracy.
As educators, it is up to us to teach future voters that constructive civic dialogue is a crucial element in our political system.
If we want the Great Experiment to work, members of this political community need to recognize the sacred link between claims and evidence.
There's no way around it.
Critical thinking is a necessary ingredient for any thriving, multicultural, multi-perspective democracy.
As educators, we have the power to design and teach lessons that engage our students with sources
that help them get better at all these critical thinking skills.
And that benefits all of us.
