Politicians are Serving Big Donors Not the American People: Dan McMillan

NTD Business
1.7K followers
1 Video View·Nov 4, 2022
Dan McMillan is a historian, author, and former prosecutor. He says big money has far too much sway over policymaking in America and he wants to do something about it. His group, Save Democracy in America, advocates for changes to how election campaigns raise money. He says his changes would give power back to the American people—power that’s held by special interest groups right now.
Look what has happened to our political life in the last 12 years.
The partisan hostility has just escalated again and again and again.
Our government is now so thoroughly paralyzed by interest group gridlock,
parties don't have much of a positive program to offer us.
Both parties were captured long ago by moneyed interests.
Americans don't know this is why they've been disenfranchised.
We don't know why we've lost our voice.
And because we don't know that the money is our enemy,
we see our fellow Americans as the enemy.
Good evening.
Welcome to NTD's Fresh Look America.
I'm Paul Graney.
Dan McMillan is a historian, author, and former prosecutor.
He says big money has far too much sway over policymaking in America
and he wants to do something about it.
His group Save Democracy in America advocates for changes
to how election campaigns raise money.
He says his changes would give power back to the American people,
power that's held by special interest groups right now.
So Dan McMillan, it's great to see you.
Thanks for joining us.
Thank you so much for having me.
It's good to be with you.
What role do you feel big money will play in this election cycle particularly?
Well, I mean, most obviously the amount of money being spent
to basically buy politicians, to buy influence,
to help politicians you want,
or even more so because a lot of the spending
is actually to attack your favorite politician's opponent,
has risen dramatically.
The last midterms, it was $7 billion that was spent to influence those elections.
It's now been projected to be 9.3 by the Center for Responsive Politics,
which is a nonpartisan watchdog, very reliable source.
So you're already seeing a dramatic increase
and that's in constant dollars, that's in 2022 dollars.
But I think there's something even more important, I think, to understand.
I mean, we have to step back from it.
Look what has happened to our political life in the last 12 years,
but I think especially since 2016.
And that is to say that the partisan hostility
has just escalated again and again and again.
And the confidence of the American people
in our political leaders and in the system has fallen and fallen and fallen.
And of course, the most dramatic turn is that already there are so many,
depending how you talk to,
anywhere from 55 to 70 percent of Republican voters
believe that the 2020 election was stolen.
Or rather, it's more kind of, as I understand it,
maybe a third are convinced absolutely it was stolen,
another 30, probably another maybe 20 percent suspect.
But you're talking about at least 70 percent.
You're tens of millions of Americans and not just Republicans.
There are independents and Democrats who have that fear.
And all our political leaders do is accuse each other of causing this problem.
Neither party is making any effort to address these concerns.
And the question is, why?
Why are we at the first point in our history
when a huge fraction of our electorate literally doesn't think the elections are fair?
I mean, this isn't Brazil we're living in.
In fact, in Brazil, they have more confidence than Americans do
in the fairness of their elections.
And if the American people don't feel that our elections are fair,
that's the end of the republic.
I mean, we are in a very grave crisis.
One point you touched on was hostility.
OK, yes, and I haven't gotten to that.
Let me ask you a question on that, because usually when we think on hostility
when we think on Big Pharma or Big Tech or any of these special interest groups,
we think they have a particular economic goal or political goal or social goal.
How exactly does it play into the hostility that we're seeing from both sides?
Basically, our government is now so thoroughly paralyzed by interest group gridlock,
the parties don't have much of a positive program to offer us.
And so what they've defaulted to, and this has been going on
really since Karl Rove as Bush's mastermind, the strategy is get out the base.
And the idea of persuading the voters of the other party has been forgotten long ago.
And all they've got left to get out the base is to foment hostility toward the other side.
And I think that's why we've seen this escalation of hostility,
this demonization and now into these 2020 elections.
But already in 2002, but in 2020, the GOP didn't even bother writing a program, a platform.
And the number one message of both parties was identical.
If the other guys win, the world will come to an end.
Now, that's not a message of hope and promise for the American people.
That's not a path forward for the American people.
A second way that money fuels the partisan anger,
and I want to emphasize this is not a conspiracy, it's just a pattern
that we've seen in our politics for centuries because we're the most diverse society,
you know, racially, ethnically, because immigration, religiously,
there's always a temptation to divide and conquer.
That's how money stays on top.
To make it more concretely with the two parties for decades now,
what you hear from a Republican politician is, you know, to the middle class and the working class,
your problem is not the Wall Street firms that pay for all my campaigns,
crashed the economy in 2008, so you lost your house to foreclosure.
Your problem is Black people who are lazy, commit crimes,
and sponge off of government and suck up your tax dollars.
Your problem is immigrants who want to take your jobs.
Your problem is the government supporter of abortion rights.
And from the Democrat, the message is your problem is not the Wall Street firm
that has paid for all my campaigns, and Hillary Clinton
raked in Big Bang from Wall Street, if you remember.
Your problem is the racist gun-toting redneck who automatically hates you for the color of your skin
and could care less if your child is murdered in a school shooting
because he thinks he deserves to own 30 assault rifles
and who wants to ram his Christian beliefs down your throat.
Now, I'm not saying that abortion is an important issue.
It's very important.
I'm not even saying that gun control isn't important,
although I think we overstate it's important.
I'm not saying that immigration isn't important,
but in a way, both parties milk these issues to stoke the anger
because anger is all they've got left to offer us,
and also because both parties were captured long ago by moneyed interests.
They have nothing to offer us for our pocketbooks.
They let big companies get away with murder in the tax code
and shift the burden of taxation to small businesses.
The corporate tax code is totally unfair to small business
because big business has got this lobbying power,
and the way to divide the middle class and the working class against each other
is race, religion, hot-button social issues.
And I guess the third way that I think the money contributes to the anger
is that the American people are justifiably angry and frustrated about politics,
and they've been angry for a long time.
And in 2016, in a way, on both sides of the aisle,
Americans stood up and said no more.
Americans who voted for Bernie Sanders said,
this is unfair, we want change.
People who voted for Trump voted, I think above all, for change.
Drain the swamp or have a revolution.
But no one has given them this change.
And the American people have no way of understanding
that it's big money more than anything else.
Having a government that's for sale to campaign donors,
Americans don't know this is why they've been disenfranchised.
We don't know why we've lost our voice.
Because no one who works in politics has much of an incentive to explain it to us, right?
I mean, if I'm a congressman, I don't say in the campaign when I'm stumping,
you know, folks, I'll do my best to get you some crumbs from the table,
but realistically, I'm going to take care of my donors because they're my constituents.
And they're more fun to talk to than you are,
because you're boring and you don't have an Ivy League degree, right?
You don't win an election with that slogan.
Since the American people literally don't understand
that the money is their number one enemy,
they begin to see each other as the enemies.
And Republicans and Democrats turn their anger on each other.
So those are kind of, I think, the three ways that I think
the money has effectively paralyzed our political system,
which means politicians have nothing to offer but negative messages.
Big money has always stayed on top of this country to divide and conquer.
And because we don't know that the money is our enemy,
we see our fellow Americans as the enemy.
That's kind of my polarisation argument.
That sentiment you spoke about with Bernie Sanders and Donald Trump in 2020 or 2016,
are you seeing that continue this election cycle?
Because we see Trump-backed candidates like
Carrie Lake in Arizona or Tuna Dixon up in Michigan,
who seem to be outperforming,
even though they've spent much less than their opponents,
who are more established figures.
Yeah, I mean, in that sense,
I would say that these Republican politicians who claim
that there's been election fraud and that there will be,
I mean, Carrie Lake actually said that if she loses,
that automatically means there was fraud,
and therefore she won't accept the results,
which I think is, for me personally,
is not consistent with democratic values.
Now, I have to be clear, my organisation,
my effort to break the power of big money in politics,
save democracy in America, is non-partisan.
And we're finding actually that I'm getting support
from Republicans and Democrats.
This is becoming a unifying issue that can bring us together.
That said, I think that the anti-establishment rebellious energy
is still stronger on the Republican side of the aisle.
However, I think that many Republican politicians
have channeled it into a kind of politics that's not so helpful.
What do you think on that point, then?
The Republican Party, we see pretty significant divisions happening,
mostly between the likes of more established figures
like Mitch McConnell versus Trump and kind of Trump-backed allies.
Do you feel the more populist, like Bernie Sanders, Donald Trump,
when they get into power and their people get into power,
they follow through or they're also beholden to big money donors?
The thing is, they have to raise the money too.
And that's why, I mean, Donald Trump, he had it right.
He said we must drain the swamp.
When he got to Washington, however, the swamp is not drained.
And I don't even mean to say that to fault him so much.
It's just realistically, he had to raise the big money also.
And he's raised, he raised, I mean,
he didn't raise as much in 2016.
And Clinton out-raised him and out-spent him.
But of course, Trump had massive free media
because people could never turn a camera away from him
because he was great television.
I mean, he got effectively a billion dollars worth of free media.
So, but for this coming election,
President Trump and his allies have raised massive amounts from big donors.
And so when they get to Washington, they won't be able to do it anymore for us.
At the end of the day, until we change where candidates get their money,
nothing's going to change.
Let me just say, talk a little bit about healthcare,
which is one of the most shocking problems we've got
and one that we could gain so much by solving, okay?
Here we are, the world's wealthiest large economy.
We spend twice as much per American on our healthcare system
as do the citizens of France, Canada,
most other first world countries.
Yet our outcomes are worse.
Our life expectancy is well below.
In fact, on some rankings of life expectancy,
I've read we're below Cuba, Saudi Arabia, Colombia, Turkey, which is crazy.
One American in 10 has no health insurance at all.
Every year, half a million American families
are driven into bankruptcy by medical expenses.
And I mean, I tell my German friends,
because I spent a lot of time in Germany, speak the language.
I tell my German friends about these bankruptcies,
they look at me like I've got three heads.
It's like, what's wrong with you Americans?
Why would you do this to yourselves?
Well, it's not something that we choose.
But, and look, I don't have a plan for fixing healthcare.
But first of all, one way we can get costs down
and shave down these bankruptcies is regulate drug prices.
Americans spend twice as much for prescription medicine
as do the citizens of their first world country,
the Germans or Canadians.
Why? Because Big Pharma, year in and year out,
is one of the biggest donors to politicians.
And in fact, in the 2020 general, if I remember correctly,
they gave Joe Biden three million, Donald Trump a million.
I think Bernie Sanders actually got a million and a half, okay?
Why do politicians never even talk about regulating drug prices?
Because if they did, they wouldn't attract the money
they need to get a campaign off the ground.
You've got health insurance companies.
Actually, my friend, Dawn, who was here assisting me
with the setup, manages a healthcare practice
in Northern New Jersey.
And you've got healthcare and health insurance companies
micromanaging doctors.
You need advanced clearance to take a test.
You've got all this staff whose only job
is to haggle with insurance companies.
And insurance companies are working overtime,
finding excuses to deny coverage,
which is another way that Americans go bankrupt.
But we can't regulate the insurance companies
because guess what?
They're donors too.
And then you look at the malpractice bar.
I mean, yeah, in every medical system,
look, we've got to have a means to police
the medical profession and weed out the bad apples.
And there ought to be a way to compensate people
who've been seriously harmed by medical errors.
By doing it through the courts?
How can there be a way that's more expensive
than doing it through the courts?
But the trial lawyers bar, year in and year out,
is a very generous donor to the Democratic Party.
Now, this example is against the Democrats,
but this is a thoroughly bipartisan problem.
And this healthcare is just kind of one example,
one of the most dramatic of many.
The big money donors, the likes of Wall Street,
big tech, big pharma,
do they take the anti-establishment message
with a grain of salt?
Do they feel like even if candidates are pushing it,
they feel once they get into power,
they'll have to do what we want them to do?
I think that they know perfectly well.
I think they do.
It's been working for them well enough.
Well, you know, actually,
I think it's been working for them well enough.
But I think that these donors,
look, first of all, I want to say
the big donors are not villains.
They're doing what they have to do.
I mean, they have to protect themselves
from the political system.
And the head of any corporation
who doesn't spend money on politicians and lobbyists
is forfeiting an advantage to his competitors
and ought to be fired.
He's not doing his job.
So again, I'm not saying the politicians
and the donors are evil people.
They're not, okay?
The money's the enemy, not our fellow Americans.
But I think that one of the reasons
why I think that our reform effort will succeed
is that even if the big donors are saying
they're not getting what they need
from the political system anymore,
because what is the business community
have to have from every political system?
Yet they want lower taxes, light regulation.
What they have to have is stability and predictability.
And that's gone out the window in this country
seven or eight years ago.
So people told me when I started my venture,
you're going to face a wall of money
from the U.S. Chamber of Commerce.
I'm not saying I'm waiting for a check from Charles Koch,
but I think if I get a chance to talk
to the business community,
I think they will see that I'm not their enemy
and that ultimately it's in every American's interest
to bring back government by the people
and have a stable government
that all Americans respect and trust.
Then what gives you the confidence
that there is a solution
given the amount of money that is out there?
I've been studying this for a dozen years.
The best approach, and it's not a perfect solution,
but it's the best approach, I think.
And that's why I'm putting all my chips on it.
It's basically, it's been called Democracy Dollars.
It was invented by a couple of very smart guys
who teach at Yale Law School.
One of them, Bruce Ackerman, I've spoken to,
very nice guy.
And the idea, what I love about it is
it's so simple and common sense.
Problem, the only people in Washington
who have any influence
are high dollar campaign donors.
Solution, make ourselves the donors.
Whoever pays the piper calls the tune.
We want to call the tune, well, let's us pay the piper.
That is, let us pay for election campaigns.
Concretely, how that would work,
the government would give every registered voter
an online account of campaign cash
for every two-year federal election cycle,
$100 for the presidential years,
50 for the midterms, which are cheaper.
With 168 million registered voters,
you're talking about even more money
than was spent in the 2020 elections.
And if you make a pool of money available
that the voters control directly,
every individual voter,
you can't take the money out and spend it,
but you go online,
you assign it to the candidates you want to support.
And then all of a sudden,
any candidate, a good candidate, solid candidate,
can raise enough money from the voters
to run a hyperexpensive campaign
that you need to be competitive.
And their opponents are not going to have much excuse
for taking money from Big Farm, Big Oil, or anyone else.
Because if they do,
the one who runs on Democracy Dollars money
is going to say,
well, my opponent would rather be a stooge
for corporate interests.
I want to serve you, so I take only Democracy Dollars.
So you choose one of the two.
You choose big donors,
or you choose Democracy Dollars.
Is that how it works?
That's right.
I mean, realistically for this system,
you should let candidates,
if candidates want to take Democracy Dollars,
they should take no more than, say,
10% in private donations.
You don't want a system that's only Democracy Dollars,
because then it'd be very hard to challenge an incumbent,
because incumbents already have ways
of reaching the voters and attracting the money.
Now, as a practical matter also,
the courts will not allow us
to ban the private donations.
Because back in the 70s,
seven geniuses in the Supreme Court decided
that money spent to influence elections
is itself a form of free speech,
protected by the First Amendment,
which shows you, I mean,
that's the ultimate triumph of book learning
over common sense.
You know, if you assemble seven Americans in a bar,
you'd never get them to buy into an idea that stupid.
But, you know, with the disadvantage of a law degree,
you can come to ideas that dumb.
Anyway, the court's not going anywhere.
That's the way the court operates.
And Citizens United, for example,
is just one extension of that decision
in the 70s.
The long and the short of it is,
we can't ban the money.
But if we make available to politicians
a big enough pool of money that we control,
then I think the American people
can put themselves back in the driver's seat,
the way our founding fathers intended for us.
So in a word, Dan,
because I have one more question before we finish up,
that would be taxpayer dollars, is that it?
Absolutely.
That would be taxpayer dollars.
How far along is this?
How likely is it to come to pass?
Who would put up the biggest opposition to this?
You know, it's interesting.
Probably the biggest opposition
would come from the lobbying industry,
because they're the ones who really make the most money.
Politicians actually probably are going to like
what we're doing,
because then they get to get off
the fundraising treadmill.
But realistically,
leadership is not going to come from politicians,
because they're too dependent on their donors.
You can't say to the voters one day,
big money in politics is evil,
and the next day call up your evil donors
to ask for more evil money, right?
So it's going to have to come from us,
and our support is going to have to be massive.
I mean, literally, my task is one of persuasion, publicity,
educating the American people about money in politics,
because no one who works in politics is going to do that.
It has to be someone like me from outside the system.
How long will this take?
I'll tell you this.
Almost everyone I talk to,
no matter what their politics,
loves the idea.
I've had maybe 35 media appearances,
more on conservative talk radio
than on liberal or mainstream outlets,
and I am getting an enthusiastic,
not just enthusiastic,
warm, friendly response all across the aisle.
Because at the end of the day,
we're all Americans,
and we all understand that this country
is supposed to stand for government by the people,
that this is a special country,
because we stand for ideals,
and our ideals are not just about
a better life for Americans.
They're about a better life for all of humankind.
This is what, for me,
makes this the greatest country on earth.
And yes, do we always live up to our ideals?
Not at all.
There are a lot of fair criticisms.
But at the end of the day,
I think the patriotism of the American people
and our commitment to democratic values
will carry the day.
It's just that so far,
no one has shown them a concrete step
they can take to fix this mess.
All Americans are fed up with politics as usual.
No one has shown them a way.
Now, that's what we're doing.
And so far, so good.
I think we're going to win,
but it may take a while.
Dan, it sounds like a noble,
albeit lonely battle,
so we commend you.
It's not lonely at all.
People love me.
I've had everyone I talk to,
all these radio hosts,
and many of them call me back several times,
and they're like cheerleaders for me.
They're saying like,
Dan, this is a great idea.
Tell people how they can help.
And so finally, if you can,
go to our website,
savedemocracyinamerica.org.
And if you like what you see,
please share it with your friends,
because no message is more powerful
than one that comes from someone you trust.
You're not helpless.
If you spread our message,
you can move the ball down the field.
Dan, we appreciate it.
Thank you very much.
We will do.
Thank you, sir.
Until next time.
I appreciate you, sir.
You take care.
