00:00 Behind the 2022 Beijing Winter Olympics | Tea with Erping 02:00 China’s quest for gold medals 07:10 In the Shadow of the 1936 Summer Olympics in Berlin 08:24 IOC as an authoritarian collaborator 13:14 My Final Thought
While the Beijing Winter Olympics opening ceremony had the lowest viewership in history, it is not short of interesting stories–the party state resorts to all means to glorify its legitimacy. With “Diplomatic Boycott” by major Western countries, this Winter Olympics is dubbed as the Genocide Games by civil society groups over China’s dismal rights record. Let us find out what are the untold stories behind this Winter.
Welcome to Tea with Erping.
Today let's talk about
the Beijing Winter Olympics,
which started on February 4th
and will wrap up this Sunday on the 20th.
I'm an avid fan of speed skating
and often skated on
Beijing's Beihai Park Lake
before coming to America.
Interestingly,
Beijing is the first city in history
to have hosted
both the Summer and Winter Olympics.
Those who have lived in Beijing before
may find this a bit odd
because Beijing doesn't have
much natural snow,
even in the winter.
It turns out,
for a party state
that can produce quite a few counterfeits,
fake snow isn't much of a surprise.
Yes,
this is the first ever Winter Olympics
with 100% fake snow.
The Winter Olympics motto
is together for a shared future.
Yet this shared future
means something different for the locals.
The city's water supply
is struggling to keep up
with the city's demand.
To create 1.2 million cubic meters
of fake snow for the Games,
Beijing had to divert water
from a key reservoir
that supplies fresh water to Beijing,
and resettle hundreds of farmers
and their families.
Last November,
Chinese leader Xi Jinping
went to the Games' construction site
and said he wanted it to be
green,
safe,
and simple.
But according to Insider.com,
despite the government's estimate
of a $3.9 billion price tag
for hosting the Games,
which makes it the cheapest ever,
the real cost
might be more than $38.5 billion,
ten times the reported amount.
There are quite a few of the books' costs
of the Beijing Games,
such as the construction
of the $9.2 billion
driverless bullet train system
designed to ferry passengers
between Zhangjiakou and Beijing.
It appears that Chinese taxpayers
are not yet told of these numbers.
China does not have
a winter sports tradition.
In its quest for Olympic gold medals,
China has enlisted
more than 20 athletes
from North America.
These days,
it is relatively common
for countries to recruit
talented athletes
from other countries.
What's unique with Beijing's case
is that Chinese citizenship laws
do not allow dual citizenship,
while the Olympic Charter states
that athletes competing for a country
at the Olympics
must be nationals of that country.
There are quite a few drama episodes
that follow foreign athletes
as they compete to represent China.
The San Francisco-born
freestyle skier Aileen Gu,
also known as the Snow Princess in Beijing,
won her gold medal for China
in the Big Air competition.
Gu dodged every question
that asked whether
she is still a US citizen.
Her response is,
while I am in the US,
I am American.
While I am in China,
Hmm,
I guess scoring the cover of Vogue China
can keep a girl quiet.
Later,
a screenshot of her Instagram exchange
with a commenter goes viral.
In the screenshot,
the Instagram user asks Aileen Gu,
Why you got such special treatment
as a Chinese citizen?
That's not fair.
Can you speak up for those
millions of Chinese
who don't have internet freedom?
To that,
Gu replied,
Her response angered netizens
because it's a known fact
China blocks VPNs
and punishes those
who use VPNs
to circumvent the Great Firewall.
China also bans
foreign social media platforms
such as Instagram,
Facebook,
Twitter,
and YouTube.
Chinese netizens
fell in love with Aileen Gu
and commented,
Why would China build the Great Firewall
if VPNs are allowed?
One person was quoted as saying,
Not surprisingly,
Gu's comments on VPNs
is now censored in China.
Albeit,
she is at this point
still the darling and superstar
of the party state.
Chinese people feel divided on Aileen Gu.
Some feel that
she brought honor to China
regardless of her dual citizenship.
Others feel that
she belongs to an elite class,
enjoying privileges
too far-fetched
from the everyday people.
In sharp contrast,
Zhu Yi,
also Californian-born
and a figure skater
known as Beverly Zhu
in the United States,
has gotten a very negative treatment
by the Chinese public.
She has given up her US citizenship
and vowed to compete for China
on the Tiananmen Square.
Despite this,
she has been under attack
on Chinese social media
after falling and crashing into a wall
during a team event,
placing China fifth in the competition.
You bet,
those critical comments
are quickly removed
by the Chinese cyber cops.
The Chinese public,
driven mostly by nationalism,
is unforgiving
if an adopted athlete's performance
did not meet their expectations.
These athletes' loyalty and patriotism
do not seem to matter much.
Their performance matters much more.
Nathan Chen
is another US-born Chinese-American
who won the gold medal
for US men's figure skating.
He was called a traitor
and accused of insulting China
for his support of
American ice dancer Ivan Bate,
who criticized
China's human rights record.
The Chinese state media
tried hard to downplay
Nathan Chen's gold medal win.
Perhaps the most bizarre story
involving foreign recruits
is the goalie
on the Chinese women's ice hockey team.
Her current Chinese name
is Zhou Jiayin,
a Princeton grad
who is known as
Kimberly Newell
in her birth country Canada.
According to a Reuters report,
in a post-game interview,
Zhou Jiayin answered questions
in awkward Chinese
and was then asked by a reporter
if she could take a few questions in English.
She turned to her translator
and said in Chinese
that she was not allowed to do this,
which her translator
relayed to the reporters.
She is not allowed to speak English.
Her translator said in English,
I'll try to translate for her.
Not surprisingly,
her English translator
doesn't speak English
quite as well as this Princeton grad.
Yet Zhou was ordered
to speak Chinese only
so that she would appear
to be a native Chinese.
After all,
losing face is a very big deal
for the party state.
I know you all may be curious
and want to ask Zhou
or Kimberly Newell,
why?
Why doesn't an Ivy League grad
put up with such humiliation,
being banned from speaking English
to reporters?
Of the 22 men's hockey players
who dressed for China
in its 8-0 loss to the US
on February 10,
17 were either born or raised
in the US or Canada.
This Beijing Winter Olympics
is overshadowed
by leading Western countries'
diplomatic boycott
over a range of human rights issues.
Civil society groups
described it as the genocide games
because of the massive concentration camps
in Xinjiang,
false organ harvesting,
crackdown of the pro-democracy voices
in Hong Kong,
to name but a few.
Human Rights Watch
called the Olympic model
of higher,
faster,
and stronger
to be the perfect description
of the Chinese government's assault
on civil society.
Some human rights groups
likened these Winter Olympics
to the 1936 Summer Games in Berlin,
where the world allowed Nazi Germany
to host the Olympics
while the Holocaust was going on.
Many critics believe that
both events are an assault
on the fundamental principles
enshrined in the Olympic Charter.
The enjoyment of the rights and freedoms
set forth in this Olympic Charter
shall be secured
without discrimination of any kind,
such as race,
color,
sex,
sexual orientation,
language,
religion,
political or other opinion,
national or social origin,
property,
birth,
or other status.
Amid many accusations
of referee favoritism
for the hosting country,
there are press reports
complaining IOC
helping whitewash Beijing's cover-up
of the scandal
involving former Vice Premier Zhang Gaoli,
the head of this Beijing Winter Olympics
organizing committee,
and the perpetrator,
that former tennis star Peng Shuai,
accused of sexual assault.
The international community,
including the International Women's
Tennis Association,
continues to pressure Beijing
to let Peng Shuai speak freely.
If you are interested in learning more
about this issue,
do check out my earlier video
on this story.
Given China's zero-tolerance policy
on COVID-19,
tickets are not sold to the public,
and no foreign spectators
are allowed at the games.
It almost feels like
it's a virtual thing
and not a real Olympics.
Little wonder why
this Winter Olympics opening ceremony
had the lowest viewership
in history.
More than 350 games participants,
including athletes,
staff,
and media,
tested positive upon arrival
in Beijing for the Games.
The few foreigners
that have visas to cover the Games
are not allowed to go
out of the closed loop
from the airport
and Olympic Village.
Polish short track speed skater
Natalia Maliszewska
told Reuters that
she was ruled in and out of the Games
several times
due to conflicting COVID-19 test results.
She said that
they told me
there's so much politics stuff
that you will not understand.
It's China.
The authorities are constantly
harassing foreign journalists,
fearing that they will ruin
the government's perfect image.
The removal of Dutch journalist
for NOS
by a Chinese security guard
went viral
when he was doing a live broadcast
outside China's national stadium.
The IOC was quick to claim
this was just an isolated incident
and will not affect foreign media
reporting at the Games.
According to a report by The Guardian,
Beijing also hired an army
of Western social media influencers,
each with hundreds of thousands of followers
on TikTok,
Instagram,
and Twitch,
to spread positive stories about China
throughout the Winter Olympics.
Vipin Rajaswal,
a US-based newsweek contributor
and former executive at Fox News and HHBC,
signed a $300,000 contract
with China's consulate general in New York
to strategize and execute
an influencer campaign
promoting Beijing Winter Olympics
and Paralympics in the US.
At the same time,
Western governments are urging athletes
to leave their personal cell phones at home
and take burner phones to the Games,
due to cyber security concerns.
My 2022 is an app
required of all athletes
at the Winter Olympics
and records their health data
and COVID-19 status.
Researchers from cybersecurity group
Citizen Lab said the app
has encryption flaws
and censorship mechanisms
embedded in the app,
raising concerns about
social and political surveillance
by the Big Brothers in Beijing.
Organizers have also warned
foreign athletes
that their accreditations
could be canceled
if they speak out of turn.
Ironically,
the International Olympic Committee
claimed that Beijing won't bid
for the 2022 Winter Olympics
because of its focus on
sustainability,
legacy,
and transparency.
A UN report on alleged abuses
against minorities in the Xinjiang region
was supposed to be released
in September 2021.
We have not heard about it as of now.
Many are wondering
what is the motive for the delay
when international scrutiny
for human rights abuses in China
is growing every day.
According to a Reuters report,
the UN Human Rights Council
can only send investigators
to Xinjiang after the Games,
and this will be
arranged with it as well.
Just ahead of the Games,
12 Falun Gong practitioners
were sentenced
up to 8 years in prison
in mid-January
for providing photos and information
of the COVID-19 outbreak
in China to foreign media.
A half-dozen torture facilities
serving concurrently as labor camps
that hold Falun Gong detainees
are only 10 to 20 miles away
from Beijing's major Olympic venues.
So we have actually
two very different parallel worlds
side by side in Beijing.
While major democratic countries
declared diplomatic boycott,
leaders of the UN and WHO
joined a few dictators
from authoritarian countries
to attend the opening ceremony,
thereby lending support
to the communist host.
This makes people wonder
what are the leaders of the UN
and WHO doing there?
Aren't they supposed to take the side
of human rights and dignity?
Growing up in China,
I am proud of my Chinese roots,
and now I am proud of being an American.
No one would be happier than I am
to bring honor and respect
to this ancient Middle Kingdom.
Yet I am also mindful
of the totalitarian regime
that is trying to use
these Winter Olympics
to justify its dictatorship
and glorify the communist system,
instead of the people
who have no voice whatsoever
in state affairs.
At the end of the day,
just as wisely said by Homer,
which would you rather be,
a conqueror in the Olympic Games,
or the crier that proclaims
who are the conquerors?
Nadia Cominici,
gold medal gymnast,
said it well,
I don't run away from a challenge
because I am afraid.
Instead,
I run towards it
because the only way to escape fear
is to trample it beneath your feet.
We all root for a good Olympic event,
as we believe in the Olympic spirit
for humanism, fairness, and justice.
We can't afford to turn a blind eye
to any attempt by authoritarian regimes
to undermine those Olympic principles.
We must have the courage to speak up
and protect human values
such as truthfulness,
compassion, and tolerance.
As Ernest Hemingway said,
Courage is grace under pressure.
A cup of fine green tea
will help bring you such courage.
Until next time,
may peace and tea,
and courage,
be with you.