Introduction to Hume An Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding

Famous People Bio
133 followers
4 Video Views·Nov 2, 2022
David Hume was born in Edinburgh in 1711 and was a central figure of the Scottish Enlightenment.
The philosophical context he was born into was one that was trying to understand the world
scientifically. Francis Bacon had argued for a science based on experience, an experimental
inductive method of observing and recording. Galileo had disproved the geocentric model
of the universe, that everything revolved around the earth, and Newton had laid down
the laws of motion and classical mechanics in physics. Hume wanted to do the same for
the human mind. He worked for various merchants and governments but spent most of his life writing,
finding success in his day for a history of England. He published a treatise of human
nature in 1739 when he was just 28. It's since become one of the most influential works in
but was largely ignored in his day. He later clarified and distilled his thoughts into the
shorter An Inquiry Concerning Human Understanding, which contains most of its key themes.
He was the third of the great British empiricists. Locke and Berkeley before him had both contributed
to building a picture of human reason based on the scientific method and empiricism,
and Bertram Russell describes Hume as developing this to its logical conclusion.
His influence can be divided into two parts, his theory of mind, human understanding or psychology,
and the moral philosophy that follows from it. It's necessary to understand the former to make
sense of the latter, and the relatively short inquiry is a clear, witty introduction to his
thought. After an obligatory philosophical introduction that criticises how philosophers
have approached their subject matter in the past, Hume ends the first section with a call to
undermine the foundations of an abstruse philosophy which seems to have hitherto
served only as a shelter to superstition and a cover to absurdity and error.
He begins then by dividing the faculties of the mind into two, impressions and ideas. Impressions
are like inputs, from the senses, from hunger, from emotion, the foundational feelings of the mind,
and ideas are then recollections of these impressions which are inevitably weaker.
We receive the impression of a tree, we recollect the idea of a tree. Ideas can combine impressions,
we might see gold and then see a mountain and then combine them into a golden mountain,
this is how imagination works. All ideas though, however complicated, can be traced back to
original impressions. This is what makes Hume an empiricist, all knowledge, he argues, comes
through the senses. Even the idea of God, for example, is the impression of wisdom, intelligence,
power etc, all combined and multiplied to infinity. In the next section he asks how we create ideas
out of impressions. All ideas, again, however complicated, must have been made through some
logical connection, and for Hume there are only three, resemblance, contiguity, and cause and
effect. For resemblance we might put the impressions of two different trees together
into one category of tree, or we might put a tree and a bush together because they look similar.
For contiguity we might see a bird perched on the tree and make a connection there. For cause
and effect we see a pan over fire boils water, and hold this idea in our mind. All ideas are
Human reason, what the mind can create, can only be a product of either matters of fact,
those impressions through the senses, or relations of ideas, combining those impressions together
logically through resemblance, contiguity, and cause and effect. This is what became known
posthumously as Hume's fork, and that knowledge can only be acquired this way leads Hume to his
skepticism. Everything we know is based on experience and cause and effect. We see the
sun rise, it gets light. We eat food, we stop getting hungry. We put water over fire, it heats.
But because it's only based on experience, there is never any real rigorous,
philosophic guarantee that it'll happen again in the future. We only ever see A leading to B.
We never really see the cause of something. We see a billiard ball hitting another,
and the other moving. But event A again only leads to event B. You can't see a necessary link,
only correlation. The effect is not a necessary part of the cause. There is nothing inherently
necessary in billiard ball one that equals the cause and effect of the event. And our minds,
Hume observed, can only operate on the probability that an event will repeat in the same way.
We're confident that the sun will rise tomorrow because we've experienced it so often,
but there's no way of being certain. This is still debated to this day and
troubling for many scientists. It's called the problem of induction. Our minds act as
though we can predict the future, but they are only acting, even the most scientific minds,
on past experience. Science doesn't guarantee anything, it only ever shows the probability
of events recurring. This, what Hume refers to as modest scepticism, gives us the limits of
human reason. But it also leads Hume to another question. How do we live our lives effectively,
with no guarantees of what we know from experience, repeating next time? He says that every
time we see a cause and effect repeat, it grows into custom or habit, which he calls the great
guide of human life. He writes all belief of matter of fact or real existence is derived
merely from some object, present to the memory or senses, and a customary conjunction between that
and some other object. We put pencil to paper, it leaves a mark. We repeat, it does it again.
This leads to a custom in our mind. We peel a banana, the inside is softer. So we eat it,
do it again, and it forms another habit that helps us eat. We can create new customs and
habits by mixing old experiences together, using the associations, resemblance, contiguity,
cause and effect. This pen resembles the pencil, maybe it does the same. There's a tree that
resembled the first tree, maybe a bird will be sat in it again, as trees and birds are contiguous.
Sand sometimes leads to sea. The fact that everything comes to our minds only through
impressions from the outside, even emotional feelings, and these associations leads Hume
to a position of determinism. Everything we choose to do has a cause outside of us,
and so we're never the true authors of our actions. Even presented with two seemingly
equal choices, what to have for dinner for example, choosing between a burger and pasta
is never arbitrary. We're influenced by what we had last, where we are, how much time we have,
what our taste buds crave. The closer you look, he argues, the harder it is to see free choice
anywhere. And he says that while there's no such thing as real chance, chance being only the
ignorance of the human senses in seeing the real cause and effect, we nevertheless have to organise
our habits around a judgement of probability. We experience cold when the sun's at its lowest,
we experience that when it's farther from the earth snow is more likely, or when certain wind
conditions blow we can intuit the likeliness of snow tomorrow and then through habit or custom
take a thick coat. But we can never see the necessary connection, we can never know for
sure that it will snow tomorrow, and logically we can never know that the sun will rise,
we can only expect. He writes, we say, for instance, that the vibration of this string
is the cause of this particular sound. But what do we mean by that affirmation? We either mean
that this vibration is followed by this sound, and that all similar vibrations have been followed by
similar sounds, or that this vibration is followed by this sound, and that upon the appearance of
one the mind anticipates the senses and forms immediately an idea of the other.
This view is troubling for many. Of course we know that the sun will rise tomorrow,
but it's also logically airtight, and philosophers attempting to dispute it is what made Hume's work
so influential after his death. The text finishes with a commentary on religion and miracles,
views he was ostracised for in his day, but which also serve as a great analogy for a critique of
any fantastical view. A wise man, he says, proportions his belief to the evidence.
He proceeds with more caution, he weighs the opposite experiments, he considers which side
is supported by the greater number of experiments. To that side he inclines, with doubt and hesitation,
and when, at last, he fixes his judgement, the evidence exceeds not what we properly call
probability. All probability, then, supposes an opposition of experiments and observations,
where the one side is found to overbalance the other and to produce a degree of evidence
proportion to the superiority. When we think about contrary testimonies,
witnesses contradicting each other, or people having doubtful characters,
if a miracle is the suspension of the laws of nature, what is more likely?
When anyone tells me that he saw a dead man restored to life, I immediately consider with
myself whether it be more probable that this person should either deceive or be deceived,
or that the fact which he relates should really have happened.
I weigh the one miracle against the other, and according to the superiority which I discover,
I pronounce my decision and always reject the greater miracle.
He finishes the inquiry with his famous lines,
If we take in our hand any volume, of divinity or school of metaphysics, for instance,
let us ask, does it contain any abstract reasoning concerning quantity or number?
No. Does it contain any experimental reasoning concerning matter of fact and existence?
No. Commit it then to the flames, for it contains nothing but sophistry and illusion.
The inquiry can be thought of as an introduction to the treatise, which contains in three volumes
a more detailed exploration of understanding, that which we saw here, and in volume two,
passions, and in volume three, morals. The rest of his thought expands upon this,
what some consider to be the very first psychology, and I'll return to his moral philosophy
in part two.
If you like these videos, I need your help, and here's my request. If you think you get
the same value from four of these videos as you do from just one cup of coffee,
then please consider pledging just a dollar per video, that's three to four dollars per
month to keep this channel going. You can even limit your pledge to one dollar a month,
and if you pledge five dollars, I'll add your name to the credits.
To those that already support Then and Now, thank you so much, this channel just wouldn't
exist without you. You can also hit like, share, follow me on Twitter and Facebook,
etc. All of these things really contribute to helping Then and Now grow.
Thanks for watching, and see you next week.
