Ooni Koda 16 vs. Karu 16 | A Comparison Video

Kitchen & Craft
17 followers
2 Video Views·Oct 28, 2022
Are you having a hard time trying to decide between the Unicoda 16 and the Unicaro 16?
It's a tough decision, I know. In this video I'll run through the specs for each oven,
I'll do some tests like comparing the preheat times and the recovery time between pizzas,
then I'll demo baking a pizza in each oven, and finally I'll tell you what I think the pros and
cons are for each model. If this information sounds good to you, I hope you keep watching
and let's get right into it. So for the Unicoda 16, the exterior dimensions are 23.2 inches wide
by 25 inches deep by 14.7 inches tall. That's 63 by 58 by 37 centimeters for everybody else in the
world that uses the metric system. For the interior of the oven, the Coda has a cooking
surface of 16 inches front to back and side to side. That is almost 41 centimeters in metric.
The stock corduroy stone that comes with the Coda is just over a half an inch thick,
it's about 15 millimeters. The oven comes with a unique L-shaped burner that runs at 29,000 BTU,
so that's pretty hot. The legs on this Coda fold up, which make it a snap to transport.
You can also buy a bag that has a handle on it, makes it that much easier to take it to
your friend's house or with you camping if you decide to make pizzas on the on the road.
The Coda 16 comes with a built-in gas ignition, it's like a dial on the side of the oven over
here, so that's not sold separately. And the hose is also included in the box. One more thing,
the exterior of this Coda 16 is built with a powder-coated carbon steel shell, makes it very
durable. I've had this oven for about a year and a half, I've baked a ton of pizza in it,
and I gotta say it still looks pretty darn good. And now on to the Karo 16, this is a newer oven
from Ooni. The exterior dimensions are 20 inches wide by 33 deep by 32 inches tall. That's mainly
because of this chimney right here. For metric, that'd be 50 wide by 83.7 deep by 81.2 centimeters
tall. I think I got that right. The unboxed weight of this oven is about 62 and a half pounds or
28.4 kilograms. The interior cooking surface is a little larger than the Coda 16. It's 16.7 inches
deep by 16.7 inches wide. And metric, that's almost 42 and a half by 42 and a half centimeters.
The stock corduroy stone that comes with the Karo is pretty much the same thing that you get
in the Coda. There's two pieces in this one though. There's one that sits under the burner tray or
underneath the gas attachment, you know, whichever one you're using. It's also just over a half an
inch thick or about 15 millimeters. Now the Karo 16, it's a multi-fuel oven. Right out of the box,
you can burn wood, charcoal, or a combination of both. If you buy the gas burner attachment
that's sold separately, you can run propane. So you have options with this particular oven,
as opposed to the Coda that's just gas only. Now the Karo 16 comes with a door. You've seen
me open this a few times already. And this just helps with heat retention and to better insulate
the oven. Has a nice piece of glass on the front here. That just allows you to keep an eye on
whatever you're cooking. Pretty cool. You've got a display down here that gives you the internal
temperature of the oven. Not the stone temp, but the ambient temperature. And I believe that's the
first time Ooni's offered that as a feature on one of their products. In the back here, you have a
This is where you would add charcoal or wood if you're using that type of fuel. And it also allows
you to keep an eye on the gas burner if you have that attached. The Karo 16 also has fold-up legs,
but it's much heavier, so far less portable. And finally, the exterior of this oven is built with
a powder-coated carbon steel shell. And there's some areas that have stainless steel on it too.
The inside appears to be stainless steel. All right, that pretty much covers the specs for
the Kodo 16 and the Karo 16. Let me fire both of them up and we'll bake some pizza. Sound good?
So to fire up the Kodo, all you have to do is make sure your propane's on and then turn this knob.
It's on. Now, to fire up the Karo 16, there's a few additional steps you need to take. First thing
is remove the chimney cap. You're going to do this when you're baking with any type of fuel,
like wood, charcoal, or gas. Then you're going to adjust this baffle right here. Horizontal,
that's closed. Vertical is open. When you're cooking with gas, like I'm doing in this video,
you want that baffle totally open. Last thing, make sure that the ceiling vent is to the right.
It's all the way open when cooking with gas. Wood, charcoal, you can adjust this to control the heat
on the inside of the oven. Now just pull the hatch, make sure the front door's still open,
and for the dial on the gas burner, just push that in. Turn it counterclockwise until you hear a
click and the flame should light up. Hold it in for a second and then let it go. And the Karo is
now lit. You put the hatch back on, close the front door, and that's it. Now we just got to
wait for these ovens to come up to temp and then we'll bake some pizza. All right, quick temp check.
We are at 830, 820, 840. All right, this oven took 25 minutes to get up above 825 degrees Fahrenheit.
That's what I consider ready to roll. That's about 441 degrees Celsius, so take note of that.
All right, first pizza going down in the Coda 16. Drop this heat a little bit. All right, let's take it
out. What do you guys think of that? Good looking pizza? All right, this pizza took a little over two
minutes to cook in that Coda 16. Outer crust looks nice, golden brown, some leopard spotting going on
there. Let's have a look at the base. You see that? Pretty nice, a little darker. I think still within
acceptable range though, for sure. This is called a fig and pig pizza or a pig and fig, you know,
doesn't really matter, whatever you want to call it. It has fresh figs on it, some fig preserves,
or in this case I have fig chutney that my stepmother made me. Absolutely delicious, by the
way. I have some prosciutto de parma. You could also use bacon or some other cured pork product.
There's fresh mozzarella on here and parmesan, okay? Now you'd finish this pizza with a little
bit of a fresh arugula. That's pretty typical. I'm not gonna put that on there right now because
it'll just wilt. Let's cook a pizza in the Karoo 16 and then we'll get that out and compare these
pizzas side by side before I finish them off and give them a taste. All right, let's see here. We
are temping out at 835, 836, somewhere in there. That's perfect. Now that took the same amount of
time to preheat, about 25 minutes. So these ovens are very similar in that fashion, okay? Let's bake
the pizza and see how long it takes to cook. What do you guys think of this one? Man, I don't know. That one's
looking better to me. All right, check that out. It's a good looking pizza, man. Nice and golden
brown all the way around. Even on the inside of the crust here I'm seeing some even coloring going on.
Not as much with the pizza that was cooked in the Unicoda. Underneath, good looking crust underneath
there. About just as dark as the other pizza. Maybe a little too dark for some. Pretty good
for me though. The cheese and the toppings look fantastic. This pizza took 90 seconds to cook.
That's a full 30 seconds faster than the one that I baked in the Koda 16. Now let's talk recovery
time. Well, with the Karoo 16 there is none. I could fire a second pizza immediately but with the Koda 16
it usually takes two to three minutes for that stone to come back up to temp before I can launch
a second pizza. Let's put these two pizzas side by side. I'll finish them off with a little fresh
arugula, a little drizzle of extra virgin olive oil, cut into them, we'll look at the inner crust, give
them a taste, and I'll sum everything up. All right, finish this off with a little fresh arugula.
There we go. That's good. This one over here. Just like that. Extra virgin olive oil.
Here's crust from the Koda 16 bake and now crust from the Karoo 16. Moment of truth.
I love the play on salty and sweet with the prosciutto and the figs. Fantastic. Then you get
that little peppery bite from the fresh arugula. Absolutely love it. I guess I should finish up here
by going over some pros and cons for each oven. Let's do that real quick. Let's start with some
pros for the Koda 16. Out of the box, it's ready to go. All you got to do is slide that stone in,
connect the oven to gas, turn it on, let it heat up, and you're ready to go. With the Karoo 16,
there's some assembly required. The ignition switch on the Koda 16 is on the right hand side
of the oven. That makes it really easy to reach over, adjust the heat and the flame, and manage
your pizza at the same time. When baking on the Karoo 16 with a gas attachment, the dial is located
all the way in the back of the oven. Makes that whole process a lot more difficult. The Koda 16
is much lighter than the Karoo 16. 20 pounds lighter, actually. And it's more compact, so
storage is a lot easier. And then, you know, because it's lighter, it's easier to transport,
let's say, if you're going camping or you want to bring it over to a friend or family member's house
to bake some pizza. Some folks will really appreciate that. And finally, that Koda 16 is
very nimble on gas consumption. Uni estimates that it burns about 1.3 pounds of propane per 10 pizzas.
All right, how about some cons? Well, first, it only burns propane. You don't have the option to
wood or charcoal or a combo. That might not be very important to some folks, but it's important
to point out. I did experience a lag in recovery time with the Koda 16. It usually took a couple
of minutes for that stone to come back up to temp before I could launch my next pizza. After baking
with both ovens, I kind of found that the Koda 16 isn't quite as forgiving as the Karoo 16 when
baking pizzas with gas. I think that's important to point out because baking pizza in an oven like
this isn't exactly a piece of cake. There is a learning curve, so folks might pick it up a little
quicker on the Karoo 16 than on the Koda 16. On to some pros for the Karoo 16. First, it's a
multi-fuel oven. You can burn wood, charcoal, a combo, or buy the attachment and run gas. For
recovery time, I didn't really experience any with the Karoo 16, but please keep in mind I baked one
pizza and then checked the temperature of the stone directly afterwards. I don't know if it'd
be any different after four or five pizzas. Another pro, and I've said this earlier, I feel like the
Karoo 16 is much more forgiving when baking pizza. I don't know if it's the additional distance
between the flame in the pizza, as opposed to the Koda, there's just not quite as much room there,
or it's the front door on this oven. Not sure, but it's definitely easier to bake pizza in. An awesome
thing I experienced with this oven is I didn't have to adjust the heat at all. I just kept it
on high the entire time and baked my pizza, whereas with the Koda, I'm constantly fiddling
with the ignition switch adjusting the flame up and down as I bake. And finally, the Karoo 16 is
the only oven of its kind that's been recommended for domestic use by the AVPN, which is the
International Authority on True Pizza Napolitana. I think that's pretty cool, and it might be
important to some folks, others not so much. Okay, let's move into some cons for the Karoo 16. First,
I gotta point out that with the gas attachment, this Karoo 16 does not fit on a standard 31-inch
deep table pushed up against the wall. You have to back the table out a little bit. And for me,
because my table is not super sturdy, that's an issue. It feels kind of wonky. The table rocks
around a little bit because it's not reinforced by being pushed up against the back wall.
So, I gotta figure out a different setup over here. Very important to point that out. The Karoo
16 is also much heavier than the Koda 16, which makes portability an issue. In fact, I don't find
myself moving this oven anywhere. It just sits on my back deck. In terms of gas consumption,
this Karoo 16 is an absolute hog. Uni estimates that it burns 4.9 pounds of propane for 10 pizzas.
That's three times as much as the Koda 16. For some folks, that might be a deal breaker. Finally,
and I know it helps with insulation, having to open and close a door multiple times when
baking a pizza is a real pain in the butt for me. It drives me absolutely nuts. And the last con,
again, it relates to the door. There's glass on it. It's nice to be able to look in the oven when
baking a pizza, but it makes this piece of equipment much more fragile than the Koda 16
because of the glass. That's pretty much it. I hope you guys found this video useful and
informative. If so, give me a like, subscribe if you want to. I'll catch you next time.
