Does Fairtrade actually work? Is Fairtrade really fair? We're happy to report: yes! Though, not without limitations. This is our critical take on Fairtrade, where we breakdown the advantages and limitations of the Fairtrade system. Read more about other limitations at foodunfolded.co/fairtrade
Produced by Jane Alice Liu Motion Graphics by Jamie Burton
Reconnect to the origins and future of your food. FoodUnfolded is powered by EIT Food, an extended body of the EU. This project is co-funded by the European Union.
Hi, I'm Jane. I'm the Editor-in-Chief here at Food Unfolded, and today I'll be addressing
the question, does the fair trade system really work? Some of you have asked us to investigate
if the fair trade system is really fair or if it's just greenwashing. Greenwashing is when
a company or organization spends more time and money marketing themselves as being ethically
driven rather than pursuing ethical practices. This is not the case for fair trade. The system
is actually focused on making a real impact on the ground with producers and laborers from low
income regions. Studies have shown that the fair trade system does indeed improve the lives of its
producers and their surrounding community. They have higher bargaining power in trade negotiations,
they receive higher shares of revenue because of the minimum price model, and the fair trade
premium has had a significant effect on the social welfare of the community as a whole.
But it's also important to point out that benefits for fair trade producers and laborers
will vary depending on product and region, a critique we'll be exploring in just a moment.
Now whether or not companies are using the fair trade label to market themselves as being ethically
driven is another question. Companies can't just slap on the fair trade label. They actually have
to be paying the fair trade price in order to even be allowed to use that label. At the beginning of
the trade chain, producers are already paid the fair trade price by the first buyer. These costs
are just passed along the trade chain. While some companies might pass on these fair trade prices
on to us, the consumer, others absorb the costs and take a lower profit margin. So whether or not
it's just a PR move for companies to use the fair trade system, it's still making a difference for
producers and laborers in the fair trade chain. But the fair trade system does have its limitations.
Here are three ways in which it's limited. Fair trade focuses on long-term financial sustainability
of its producers and laborers, but long-term financial sustainability cannot be achieved
without considering environmental sustainability. Fair Trade International says it themselves,
Farmers are on the front line of climate change, facing higher temperatures, droughts, floods, extreme
weather, crop failure, and more. However, while fair trade standards encourage sustainable agricultural
practices, it is not mandatory. Though it's important to consider that sustainable agricultural
practices like organic farming can have higher costs. The benefit of being part of the fair trade
system, though, is that producers earn more and can reinvest some of their revenue into more
sustainable practices. Another environmental issue with fair trade farming is the cluster of
monocultures present in regions, as small-scale farmers are producing the same crop. To tackle this,
fair trade has been working together with farmers to diversify their land, crops, and products to
protect their producers from further losses due to issues of climate change. Fair trade is also
exploring the concept of climate risk insurance. One study in the Costa Rican coffee sector showed
that unskilled workers like coffee pickers and laborers did not see an increase in their wages
under the fair trade certification system. To be clear, under fair trade, all laborers are guaranteed
the legal minimum wage of their region. However, there is often a gap between minimum wage and
living wage, meaning the cost of having a decent house, decent food, access to medical care, etc.
So then how does paying minimum wage line up with fair trade's aim to empower the most vulnerable
people in the trade chain? It's very delicate from an ethical standpoint because the farmer
himself is already poor. When you have this very small farm where maybe for a few weeks a year they
will hire someone to help them and these guys are already poor, it's difficult to go and tell them
hey you have to pay them a wage that you are not getting. But it's an issue and that's something we
are trying also to regulate and to check and so on but it's very delicate and it's very complex
because first you have to make sure that a small farmer is getting enough paid so that he can then
afford to pay his workers correctly because if you only protect the worker you will chase the farmer
So what has been done to improve conditions for fair trade workers? On fair trade certified
plantation and estates, fair trade premiums are 100% reserved for its workers. The workers manage
a joint committee that receives the premiums and there they can collectively agree to use part of
that money as supplemental wages additional to their minimum wage. They can also use the premium
in other ways like buying coats or paying tuition fees for their kids. The most important aspect of
the fair trade system is that it leaves the decision solely up to the workers, not plantation
or estate owners, allowing them to invest these additional funds into what they feel best fits
their needs. Fair trade's auditing system has also come under fire as child labor was allegedly found
on a fair trade cocoa plantation in the ivory coast by an investigative journalist team from
Danwatch in 2020. It's unclear whether the lack of auditing was due to travel restrictions under
COVID-19 or systematic flaws but whenever you hear one case it really makes you wonder how many more
cases like this exist. How does fair trade truly ensure that its producers are not using any illegal
forms of labor? Fair trade audits are usually announced in advance but by announcing their
audit schedule how can they be sure that there are no opportunities for cover-ups? Fair trade has
criteria to identify high risk situations and in areas that have shown to have a higher risk
of illegal labor certifiers do conduct unannounced audits. The general spirit is one of trust and it's
sometimes a western point of view to say we are going to check these guys because they're the bad
guys well they're not necessarily the bad guys i mean they're just people like you and me i mean
because these people the children work in a farm they would rather send them to school but they
can't afford it and they need them to work on the farm because they cannot afford to hire someone
for a few weeks for the harvest that's why i think the whole certification and auditing process is
only part of what we're doing and it's a means to an end it's something that that make things better
but it's not going to solve everything and that's why we also want to tackle the root cause
you can limit yourself to audits and rules you know it's forbidden you cannot have child labor
that's it it helps to have rules because at least things are clear it helps to check because
to create a little bit of pressure but if you at the same time don't do anything to make sure that
these people are paid better prices you're not going to tackle the root cause of child labor
fair trade's approach is one of balancing strictness and encouraging development of course
if major certification requirements have been breached certifiers will suspend or decertify
fair trade producer organizations or traders but fair trade's overall focus is to give their
producers an opportunity to address problems and improve over time fair trade is not a perfect
system but it's a good start today the fair trade system is comprised of over 1.7 million farmers
and workers from 72 different regions and territories and has over 35,000 fair trade
certified products it might seem like a lot but fair trade producers actually account for less
than one percent of the 570 million smallholder farms worldwide this means that over 99 percent
of smallholder farms do not work under a trade model that guarantees fairer prices or the respect
of basic working rights one thing is clear fair trade has impact the movement has been gaining
traction with more consumers and retailers committing to buying more fairly traded goods
since 2014 fair trade farmers and workers have received over half a billion euros in fair trade
premiums the fair trade movement has brought light to the pervading and deep-rooted problems
of the trading system today and while it may not be the solution for change it's certainly one of
many