The Rise And Fall of Carmelo Anthony | Nonstop Sports

Amazing Basketball
156 followers
30 Video Views·Oct 23, 2022
He's one of the most dominant scorers in NBA history, but with no success in the playoffs - many NBA fans still consider him a loser. Here is the rise and fall of Carmelo Anthony.
He won a national championship in college,
three Olympic gold medals,
and only eight players scored more points than him.
But with no success in the playoffs,
many NBA fans still consider him a loser.
Here is the rise and fall of Carmelo Anthony.
Growing up in drug-infested Baltimore,
Carmelo's childhood looked like a scene from The Wire,
filled with criminals, guns, and narcotics.
Looking for a safe place,
Carmelo found his escape through basketball.
He started his middle school career as a skinny point guard,
which developed his ball-handling skills and shooting touch.
But after a major growth spurt,
Anthony sprouted to 6'8", and in 2001,
was named Baltimore Player of the Year.
As a junior, he was averaging 23 points
and 10 rebounds per game.
But because he often skipped school and had terrible grades,
Melo was forced to switch schools,
and it turned out to be a blessing in disguise,
because he transferred to the famous Oak Hill Academy.
With Melo on the team,
Oak Hill became the most-watched high school team in the US.
When they matched up against LeBron James
and his St. Vincent St. Mary,
it felt like the NBA Finals.
11,000 spectators and 200 media members
came to watch the showdown between the top junior
and the best senior in the country.
The game became a basketball classic,
and both players lived up to the hype.
LeBron dropped 36 points in 12 of 27 shooting,
with 8 rebounds and 5 assists.
Anthony put up 34 points on 14 of 25 shooting
and 11 rebounds.
Despite LeBron's brilliance,
Carmelo's team pulled out a 72-66 victory
and finished the season with 32 wins and only one loss.
After dominating the McDonald's All-American Game
and winning the Sprite Dunk Contest,
Melo was wanted by every major college.
He chose Syracuse University
due to a great relationship with coach Jim Bohan.
Carmelo produced one of the best freshman seasons
in NCAA history, averaging 22 points
and 10 rebounds per game.
Melo led Syracuse in scoring, rebounding,
and minutes played,
and his 33-point explosion against the University of Texas
in the Final Four set an NCAA tournament record
for most points by a freshman.
In the NCAA Finals, Syracuse played against Kansas,
who trashed Dwayne Wade's marquette
by 33 points in the semifinals.
But Carmelo couldn't let that happen to him.
He finished with 20 points, 10 rebounds, and 7 assists
to lead the Orange to a sensational victory
and NCAA championship.
Even though he planned to stay three years in college,
Melo already climbed to the top of the mountain,
and his beloved coach, Jim Bohan,
advised him to go to the NBA.
The entire world expected the Cavs to select LeBron
with the first pick of the 2003 NBA Draft
and Detroit to pick Carmelo at number two.
And then, a huge surprise.
The Pistons opted for European prospect Darko Milicic,
which meant Anthony would be selected third overall
by the Denver Nuggets.
Even as a rookie, there was no way to stop Carmelo Anthony.
Against Wade and LeBron, a defender could step back
and let them take an outside shot,
but against Carmelo, it was a point of no return.
The man had every possible tool in his offensive arsenal,
and he'd score no matter what the defense does.
If you put a bigger guy on him,
Melo was so explosive that he would drive by him.
If you put a smaller defender, he'd post him up
and bully him on the way to the basket,
or simply make a silky smooth mid-range jumper.
Anthony led the Nuggets with 21 points, six rebounds,
and three assists per game,
and became the fourth player in NBA history
to capture all six of the Rookie of the Month awards
in a season.
However, LeBron was also a Rookie of the Month
six times in the East,
and was voted Rookie of the Year over Anthony,
despite the Cavs not making the postseason,
and James posting slightly lesser numbers.
Denver won 17 games in the season before Melo.
With him, they won 43 games and made the playoffs,
their first postseason berth in nine years.
Melo's first playoff series didn't go great.
He struggled mightily against MVP Kevin Garnett,
and the Timberwolves won four games to one.
Despite the loss,
the hype around Carmelo was bigger than ever.
He was selected to represent Team USA at the 2004 Olympics,
where he got into his first big fight with a coach,
something that would later become
a far too regular occurrence.
Larry Brown played Sean Marion and Richard Jefferson
instead of Melo and LeBron,
and Anthony openly protested due to a lack of playing time.
Brown then torpedoed Carmelo to the end of the bench,
and the Americans failed to win Olympic gold
for the first time ever with NBA players.
When the next season started,
Anthony argued with his Nuggets coach,
who then got replaced by George Carle.
In the beginning, everything was wonderful,
and Carmelo did his job as a scorer perfectly.
Even though he was never interested in playing defense,
he directly brought victories to the Nuggets five times
with clutch buckets in the last seconds.
All of his five game winners were jump shots.
The Nuggets made the playoffs again,
but immediately lost to the later champions,
San Antonio Spurs.
Then, in 2006, Melo's scoring average
soared to 26.5 points per game,
but the result was the same,
and the Nuggets lost in the first round
of the playoffs once more.
In the first eight games of the following season,
Melo went over 30 points six times.
But then, another huge disappointment.
In December of 2006,
when the Nuggets played the Knicks at Madison Square Garden,
one of the biggest player fights in NBA history ensued.
Almost every player from both teams
was involved in the brawl,
and after Anthony slapped Marty Collins,
he earned a 15 game suspension.
He then started hanging out
with the newly acquired J.R. Smith more intensively,
and Carmelo's focus quickly shifted
from basketball to partying.
And on February 2nd, 2007,
all that partying almost cost Carmelo and J.R. their lives,
when after one wild night out,
Melo and J.R. were involved in a car accident,
but even after their life flashing before their eyes,
nothing changed.
Then, the arrival of Allen Iverson
was definitely not an injection of professionalism
for the team, and soon enough,
there were videos of drunk Nuggets
in front of the nightclub.
Even though they had a decent team on paper,
Denver simply did not have the chemistry
or maturity for a serious result.
Anthony averaged 29 points, six rebounds,
and four assists that year,
and he finally made the All-Star team.
But the Nuggets lost to the Spurs
in the first round of the playoffs again.
2008 was a different year,
but the story was the same.
Melo and Iverson averaged over 25 points each,
but the Nuggets lost in the first round
for the fifth year in a row,
this time getting swept by the Lakers.
Anthony then suited up for Team USA
at the 2008 Beijing Olympics,
and finally washed the sour taste of defeat from his mouth.
Melo impressed with his outside shooting
during the tournament,
and the Americans finally brought the gold medal home.
With the Olympic success and being around Kobe and LeBron,
we saw a more mature Melo,
Trading Iverson away
and bringing veteran point guard Chauncey Billups
also helped,
and Anthony played the best basketball of his life.
The Nuggets won 54 games in a season,
which was their best result in 20 years,
and Melo sacrificed shots for the better of the team.
Then in the playoffs,
the Nuggets finally advanced past the first round,
defeating the Hornets four to one.
In the second round,
Carmelo played the best playoff series of his life.
He averaged 30 points with phenomenal shooting numbers,
and Denver defeated Dirk Nowitzki
and the Mavericks in five games.
Against Kobe and the Lakers in the conference finals,
the Nuggets tied the series at 2-2
before returning to Los Angeles.
But in the rest of the series,
Denver wasn't up to the task,
and the Lakers advanced to the finals.
Despite the loss,
it was the best season in recent Nuggets history.
Carmelo was entering his prime,
and Denver fans were expecting a berth
to the NBA finals soon.
Unfortunately,
the only thing they got was a bitter disappointment.
In 2010, despite Carmelo averaging 30 points in the series,
the Nuggets lost in the first round again.
Throughout the entire 2010 and 2011 season,
Carmelo had conflicts with Coach Karl.
He was even suspended once
because he refused to leave the game
when the coach asked him to.
So Carmelo decided to ask for a trade.
The disbelief of Denver fans soon turned into open hatred.
Anthony did not want a contract extension.
He wanted to go to a team of his choice,
more precisely, the New York Knicks.
After months of public fights and bickering in the media
that was dubbed the Melo drama,
the Nuggets realized it was best to trade Carmelo
than lose him for nothing three months later,
like the Cavs lost LeBron the year before.
They traded Anthony to New York in a multi-team trade,
and the Knicks lost a lot of debt for a player
that could have signed for free
if they waited just half a season.
But they wanted Melo now,
and he wanted them.
Too bad their gamble didn't pay off.
Even though he played with the best teammate of his life
in Amari Stoudemire,
the Knicks got swept in the first round
One of the main reasons for the lack of success
was the inability of Melo and Stoudemire to work together.
Even though Anthony always insisted
on playing the small forward position
because he did not want to scrap and wrestle
with taller and stronger players in the post,
his ideal role was that of the stretch forward.
He was at his best when he scored from isolation
in the high post,
spreading out the defense with outside shots,
driving by slower defenders,
and making lots of mid-range shots.
His offensive play, while outdated by today's standards,
was damn effective.
However, due to his stubbornness to play small forward,
he was never a great defensive player.
Melo was always a bit too slow laterally
to guard the best small forwards effectively,
and extremely unmotivated to play top-notch defense
for more than a few possessions.
That wouldn't be such a big problem
if Amari wasn't almost the same player as Melo.
They liked to occupy the same real estate on offense
and were equally bad defensively,
what showed in the results.
The Knicks regularly played better
when one of them was not in the lineup.
It didn't take much for Anthony
to start beefing with Coach D'Antoni
and complain about the tactics.
To keep their superstar happy,
the Knicks fired D'Antoni.
Mike Woodstock took his place,
and the team started playing better.
Lynn's sanity was in full effect.
Tyson Chandler got voted Defensive Player of the Year,
and the chemistry improved.
But the Knicks lost in the first round
of the playoffs to the Heat,
partially because Amari punched through the glass
of a fire extinguisher after a Game 2 loss,
which resulted in him playing with a cast on his hand
for the rest of the series.
Then came the summer, and the wounds healed again.
The Olympics in London promoted Anthony,
along with Durant, as an American player
who is best suited for international competitions.
Melo shot like he was hypnotized,
and his 37 points in 15 minutes against Nigeria
was a true masterpiece.
Team USA won another gold,
and just like that, he blossomed again.
And the 2013 post-Olympic NBA season
brought peak Carmela.
The addition of Jason Kidd
stabilized the flow of the Knicks' offense,
and Carmelo thrived as a finisher,
now dribbling the ball half as much as he used to.
Anthony replaced a lot of long twos with threes,
an average 28.7 points per game,
which brought him an NBA scoring title.
He played the most efficient basketball of his career,
and the Knicks won 54 games,
their best result since 1997.
Even without Amari Stoudemire,
who went down with a knee injury,
Melo led the Knicks to a playoff series win,
defeating the aging Celtics in the first round.
But in the second round,
the Heat were just too good,
and Carmelo was quickly kicked out from the postseason.
In 2014, Kidd retired,
and Melo suddenly found himself in a strange situation.
He expected to be paired with another superstar,
surrounded by solid role players in the big market
that would adore him and celebrate him as a savior.
However, Amari was destroyed with knee injuries,
and in just three seasons,
the Knicks lost all perspective,
squandered all their assets,
and ruined any future with illogical trades
and stupid contracts.
New York never made the playoffs in the next four years,
changing coach after coach
until it was finally time to trade Carmelo Anthony away.
Melo then joined forces with Russell Westbrook
and Paul George in Oklahoma,
and it didn't go well.
Melo's averages dropped from 24 points and three assists
to just 16 points, one assist,
and some pretty inefficient shooting.
But the worst part was that all of his numbers
decreased further in the playoffs,
and OKC lost in the first round.
So his next stop was Houston.
Who figured that a 34-year-old Carmelo
could change his habits and adjust to playing
without the ball and shoot only three-pointers?
That proved to be a gigantic failure.
Melo didn't fit into their offense,
and at this point of his career,
he was an absolute nightmare defensively.
After just 10 games, Melo was cut,
but that wasn't the worst part.
The worst and most insulting thing
was that nobody wanted to sign Carmelo
for the rest of the season,
even though he was a 12-time All-Star
who scored over 25,000 points.
The entire season passed by,
and Carmelo was still teamless.
The next season started,
and Melo was yet to play pro basketball
until finally, after a few injuries to their roster,
the Portland Trail Blazers gave him a chance.
Against all odds, Melo started playing great
after a one-year absence.
Finally swallowing his ego and buying into a team concept,
he became a solid role player who shoots threes,
moves without the ball,
and at least tries to be engaged defensively.
Then after two years in Portland,
he signed with the Lakers
and joined his longtime friend LeBron James.
It was with the Lakers, at the age of 37,
that Melo had the most efficient shooting percentages
of his career, which showed us
he was still an offensive genius
and that he was quite inefficient when he was in his prime.
So what's the legacy of Carmelo's career?
Melo was arguably the best isolation scorer
in the NBA in his prime.
Kobe even called him the toughest player
he ever had to guard.
He had a quick first step for a player of his height,
perfect footwork, deceptive athleticism,
soft shooting, and a determination to score
that made him a walking bucket.
He averaged 25 points per game with the Nuggets
in the slowest era of NBA basketball,
when teams didn't shoot any threes
and would rarely get past 100 points,
so his 25 points were worth more than they are worth today.
The problem is that the Nuggets, just like the Knicks,
didn't assemble very good teams around him.
Over the years, Melo has always had solid teammates,
but he never actually had an eight-man rotation
to contend for the title.
But another big reason for Melo winning
only three playoff series in his career was Melo himself.
He was too stubborn, always fighting with the coaches,
too selfish to change his offensive diet
and play the power forward position,
and too lazy to stay engaged on defense.
Every coach's ideal is when your best player
is also your leader.
But since Carmelo only played hard on one side of the ball,
he made it plain he couldn't lead the Nuggets,
even though he said he wanted to.
Coaching him meant working around his defense
and compensating for his attitude.
George Karl said in his book,
after coaching Carmelo for six years,
in our book, the biggest what if of his career
is what if he was drafted second overall by the Pistons
instead of Darko.
Detroit won the 2004 title
with Milosevic playing garbage time in it.
Then they went to another finals
and three more conference finals.
If they had Carmelo on their team,
surrounded by all those veterans,
they would have probably influenced him
to become a better defender and great overall player,
and his scoring would probably propel the Pistons
to at least one or two more championships.
The basketball world would probably look differently
at Carmelo if he had won three NBA titles
next to his NCAA championship and three Olympic gold medals.
But this never happened,
and his game and legacy ended up to be extremely similar
to Bernard King and Tracy McGrady,
phenomenal scorers who never had success in the playoffs.
