In Summer 2019, Abby and Lauren went to Scotland to lend our skills on a project led by Rebecca Olds of Timesmith Dressmaking at the National Museum of Scotland in Edinburgh. Recreating the Isabella MacTavish Fraser wedding gown was no easy feat (despite how simple the gown might appear...). 18th-century dressmaking is a fickle beast and a challenge for even those of us who are quite familiar with the mantua-making trades. This "simple tartan gown" demanded all of our skills, expertise, and patience to come back to life as a recreation, and luckily, we were able to document the process, from start to finish.
This documentary on recreating the Isabella MacTavish Fraser wedding gown, from its history, the history of tartan, reproducing the fabric, and recreating the gown, is a result of many months of work, research, dreams, bloody fingers, and incredible interviews with experts. We learned so much during this project, and we are thrilled to finally share it with you.
A simple tartan gown, a wedding from long, long ago. A family's history passed down from generation
to generation. The Isabella McTavish wedding gown is an iconic piece of Scottish history
and today we'll explore its origins, the woman and family it belonged to, its significance in
Scottish and dress history, as well as its modern recreation. Clothing serves as the great connector
to generations past and by studying old clothing it helps humanize and better understand our
ancestors, their daily lives, their likes and dislikes, and the experiences that shaped their
world. We all wear clothing. We all get dressed every morning one foot at a time and while we
might not all be kings, queens, or even blacksmiths and sailors, we all wear clothing and it's the
common thread that ties human history together. Hi, I'm Abby Cox, lead mantua maker for the Isabella
McTavish Frasier Wedding Gown Project and by recreating this special tartan gown we're going
to be able to step into the buckled shoes of the woman who wore the gown as well as the women who
helped make this dress for her. As modern dress historians, by recreating this gown we're going
to be able to uncover all of its quirks and secrets long since forgotten. Its triumphs and its failures
will be brought back to life during this two-day dressmaking event. But before we dive into the
recreation process itself, let's take a moment to learn about the history of the gown, Isabella
McTavish Frasier, and how it's become an iconic piece of Scottish history. I stumbled across an
image of this incredible tartan gown while researching to design my own wedding dress.
It really struck something in the heart of me at about the same time that I had just discovered I
did have a Scottish line of lineage myself, so it was especially important a personal way for me.
As a historical dressmaker it occurred to me quite quickly that this is something actually I could
make and that was the seed of the idea to start thinking about researching it to make a replica.
In researching it I discovered that so little was known about women's working, women's clothing,
real women's clothing in the Highlands like this black hole. I realized that this dress hadn't
really been studied and brought out and recorded and shared with the public, and that was the seed
for putting together a project that would not just be me making a replica in my own workshop,
but doing it in a way that other people could see and really learn about this dress.
And the more stories have poured in about how much this dress means to people all over the world,
that just it just seems like the right time to share it. Isabella McTavish grew up on a farm
a little ways out of Inverness in the Highlands. In her mid-20s she married Malcolm Fraser who
lived nearby. They actually got married in the town of Doris, just a few miles away from the
farm and again a few miles away from Inverness. They got married in the middle of the winter
just after Christmas in January 1785. In the history of this dress, after Isabella wore this
for her wedding, there have been three more brides. Isabella's son Tavish, when he married
Jane Fraser, she wore the dress. And then there was a long gap and no one wore the dress that we
know of until Isabelle Beaton, the current owner, wore it herself for her wedding in 1978.
My name is Isabelle Beaton and I am the owner of the dress which has now become known sort of as
the Isabella McTavish Fraser dress. In our family I guess it was just called the tartan wedding dress
but I'm getting used to calling it the Isabella McTavish Fraser dress too. It belonged to my
three times great-grandmother and I think now it's beginning to feel a bit of a responsibility
to do the right thing about the dress. It's amazing, it's amazing, the other side is it's
amazing the fact it's survived and gone are all the journeys where it must have gone and to have
ended up still existing is great. We generally associate tartan with menswear and that's what's
so great about the Isabella McTavish Fraser dress because not much survives relating to tartan and
women's clothing in the 18th century. We do know that women would have been wearing tartan, it
stands to reason that skirts, petticoats, shawls, or arisades as they're called in the Highlands,
these were definitely being worn. There's lots of visual evidence of arisades in particular
but this is why the McTavish dress is so unusual because it survives in its entirety and that
doesn't happen very often and we are still left with this perception that tartan is more of a
masculine thing and that's why this dress is so important because it shows that it wasn't
always just being worn by men. Since clothing up until the late 19th century was especially
made for individuals by skilled tradesmen and women, by recreating their clothing we were able
to become intimate with the body that wore the gown and its maker. How tall were they? How short?
Was there an old injury that caused them to walk a certain way? Were they left-handed or right-handed?
How old were they when this garment was made? What problems did the dressmaker or tailor have
when making this item? How did they solve the issue? When recreating an 18th century gown,
whether from an original or taking inspiration from a painting or a book, one must always start
with the correct materials. In 18th century Scotland the main fabrics that you have are
linen, wool and towards the end of the century you start to see cotton coming in but for most of the
population most of their wardrobe would have been made from linen and wool. Standard perception might
be that all of this would have been made within individual households, that you make your own
cloth, you make your own clothing and that would have been true to some extent possibly in the
rural areas but the Highlands of Scotland were by no means cut off and we know that there was a lot
of cloth being brought in. Sometimes that cloth might have been brought in from somewhere like
Edinburgh up to the north or from abroad. As early as the 1720s we know that there were families in
Inverness who were buying in silk. To be able to faithfully recreate the hard tartan used in the
original dress, Rebecca set out to find a weaver who equaled her passion for the Highlands and
Scottish history as well as possessing the facilities and skill to reproduce the fabric.
Tartan in the Scottish context is both a fabric and a pattern so as a fabric it's traditionally
woolen but it can be made from many other fibres it can be wool and silk it could be cotton and wool
a mixture of all of them and as a pattern it's at its most basic form it's a check so to create a
all you really need is two yarns of different colours and the weaving pattern creates the check
the more colours you have the more complex the check can be and the more complex the tartan
will be. This leads to Prickly Thistle a tartan weaving business located in the Scottish Highlands
and owned by Clare Campbell. Clare's expertise in tartan weaving and antique looms meant that
she was able to recreate the fabric. That's not to say reproducing the tartan was easy
in fact it is impossible to create an exact reproduction changes in loom and weaving
technology breeds of sheep becoming extinct and differences in commercial dyes all meant
that a true reproduction would never be possible. Colour is obviously very important in tartan and
there are theories that there's certain status or meaning associated with red in particular
unlike today we see a tartan and we associate it with a clan and colours can even have meanings
in the 18th century it wasn't really like that it was more about how expensive the dyes were that's
what gave you status so for the Isabella MacTavish Fraser tartan that's in the gown there's a lot of
red. Red was a high status colour because it was very expensive in the 18th century you could get
cochineal imported and we know that tartan manufacturers in Scotland were importing
cochineal so it wasn't just a cottage industry it wasn't just something that people were
using dyes and lichens from the hills and moss to create their own tartan certainly that was
happening but it was also a commercial enterprise and you could import expensive dyes to create
these really bright vibrant colours. Choices in construction were determined by a mix of
thoughtfulness in working with the tartan and speed mistakes were made in this gown and the
fixes were done so well that the only way we could figure out that there had even been a mistake
was recreating each section stitch by stitch and uncovering its secrets. So before we went to
Scotland we decided that it was in everyone's best interest for us to do a test dress version
of the Isabella MacTavish Fraser wedding gown. We only actually had photographs that other people
took of the original gown we we didn't really know quite what was going on so we looked at
those really really closely and then tried to reproduce what we were seeing in the photographs.
What we found was a gown that was quickly made for a woman who would be considered extremely
average in size today which further explains how so many of her descendants were able to
wear the gown for their own weddings with little to no alterations. The hard tartan fabric unusual
for a woman's gown in the 18th century dictated most of the design choices during the late 1780s
when this dress was thought to have been made small pleats and pieced backs were all the rage
but the bold broad tartan required broad back pleats long out of fashion winged cuffs the only
bits of decoration on this simple gown were severely outdated by the mid 1780s but would
have been fashionable for the 1740s. While there is no way to confirm whether the tartan gown worn
by a girl long after the failed Jacobite rebellion was meant to be worn as a political statement or
as a romantic one it is difficult to overlook its stylistic similarities. So what we realized
very quickly that this gown is not made in a way that we like to make gowns. It's very atypical so
we were looking at the photos and we're like oh well that's that's an interesting construction how
fascinating and then there were other parts of it that were like what are you doing like why
why did you do it that way and it's what we get into when we do the makings why did they do this
yeah is this a mistake how did they correct it one of the most interesting points of the
construction process with this gown were actually the sleeves oh my favorite yeah I love the sleeves
and something we noticed eventually in the making up of these sleeves is that there was a massive
mistake made by the mantle maker where we hypothesized that she actually made the sleeve
too tight too tight below the elbow and Isabella couldn't bend her arm yeah to touch her nose or
take a drink of water so they made a quick fix which was they actually got up in there and clipped
into the crook of the arm so she could bend her arm and then they covered all of that crazy business
with the cuff part of our challenge was actually breaking that down figuring out what happened
figuring out why that happened and then figuring out how to fix it in a way that we were able to
honor the cork in the gown and make it make sense in our reproduction of it that right just looking
at it that's even though I know that's what it is it's throwing everything off yes I agree
and then pleat it before you put it on the arm yep and as you get on the arm yeah because right
now like I can see the split hanging out too yes so I think it's not the right place it needs to
be pleated and it needs to have the seam allowance folded correctly too long then potentially yeah
because it's not going to be down here we're here in Nevada the gown's over there in Scotland and
we're just looking at pictures as best as we can on google drive we're trying to figure out the
back pleats of this gown I looked at the photos and I worked out the tartan set and about
approximately based on the known quantities the width of the individual panels how wide
the pattern in the tartan was and then I printed it out on a piece of paper yes and we tried to
pleat this piece of paper this tiny like 1 32nd scale piece of paper yeah to figure out how deep
the back pleats were because of course you can't get your fingers in there and measure any of that
on the finished piece no so we had like hardly any measurements to work with we did three or
four iterations of this back on paper and on our plain wool fabric trying to figure out
how this back went together because we we didn't have the whole story yet it wasn't working
luckily Rebecca ended up sending us a sample piece of the tartan that we were going to end
up using in Scotland and that's when everything started to make a lot more sense the lines the
squares and the stripes on the tartan we could see what was lining up with what from the photos
and once we had that piece of tartan it very very easily went together there were still challenges
though especially with the back seam yeah in an English gown it the back seam is angled and it's
what brings everything in but on the original dress that is offset there's a little bit of
mistake there that's part of the challenge is reproducing like the human nuances that are in
this gown so we're sitting here moving the seams like 30 1 32nd of an inch we're talking mill like
fractions of millimeters here trying to get it to to look the way that they did it here though and
that was just the half inch folded over for the seam allowance yeah so that's about what i'd say
the second time this recreation was undertaken was with a team of seamstresses from all over the
united kingdom and in front of a live audience at the national museum of scotland and edinburgh
and it was organized by rebecca olds of timesmith dressmaking we have eight people on our team
the dressmaking team is headed up by abby cox vice president of american duchess abby has
extensive experience in cutting and draping on the body with the 18th century dressmaking
techniques lauren stowell is founder and ceo of american duchess and royal vintage she's a very
experienced historical customer and researcher and she's co-author of the american duchess guide to
18th century dressmaking and the american duchess guide to 18th century beauty also on our team is
perrin westerhoff nyman from canada she lives here in edinburgh is working on her phd in scottish
dress history at the university of st andrews katie stockwell is a professional historical
dressmaker and milliner specializing in regency ladieswear alexander bruce has just completed her
b.a honors degree in costume production from rose bruford college of theater and performance
georgia golf is our model she's a multi-period historical dressmaker and re-enactor
and last but not least flora mccluskey is our team pa if you like once we got to edinburgh before
the two days of the project we invited the team over to our little apartment to do a master class
we needed to roughly run through how the stress was going to be made some of the quirks of it so
that on the day itself there wasn't a mass confusion terror and chaos yes we are trying to
prevent that from happening the other thing that we did on friday before the big event is we ended
up cutting out the bodice shapes on georgia in the privacy of our flat we wanted to include it
as a part of the program but unfortunately with our time restrictions within the program itself
i knew from my experience that it just wasn't going to be a feasible option so we ended up just
doing that in the privacy of our own flat and that way it also helped us to see where any potential
quirks or issues could arise on georgia as an individual person because when you're dealing
with a mix of a reproduction and a recreation you you have to find that balance within the
modern human body who is completely unique from isabella but then trying to honor the design
choices that were made in isabella's original gown day one day one straight into the museum
straight into cutting things out the first thing that we cut out were the skirt panels
easy right yeah the interesting thing about hard tartan is that when it comes off the loom
there is no other process it doesn't go through walking it's not tendered and so the plaid
especially when it's a large set like the isabella mctavish fraser one it's very noticeably
a little bit off grain and it has to be stretched back into position so this is one of the issues
that claire was facing during the weaving of this fabric is that even though she's using
antique looms they're still 19th century looms they're still mechanical looms they're not
the hand looms of the 18th century and so they're much more aggressive in the weaving process
that's actually why the plaid just got ever so slightly skewed which meant that we had to
attempt to tenter enter it back into the ourselves this is one of my favorite memories for the
entire project the first day there's perrin and there's katie and they've got one corner each and
they're pulling and yanking on this big panel to like get it back into position because we didn't
think about that taking up time and it really did and like yanking this to just to get it
because otherwise nothing you lay out none of the pattern that you lay out is going to have
the landmarks that you need this was actually the first time we were cutting the actual tartan
rather than our test fabric which was just a plain solid wool yeah and we discovered all
kinds of interesting cutting choices that the original mantua makers made some of them were
very oh yeah economical and very interesting and thoughtful we you learned a lot in the why
they cut things the way they did but it was not nearly as straightforward as what you would have
thought it would have been the sleeves in particular and also the bodice fronts the tartan
is a very very big set it's a big bold pattern so you don't have a lot of room for
squidging around on making a decision where you're going to put things you have to get it in the
right place so you have a big blue square and you have a big green square you have this triple
stripe and you've got to get it on the right place on the arm or the right place on the bodice
that took so much time we had the ipad out looking at the photographs trying to figure out okay what
square color square and where's the stripe on the sleeve how does it line up this took a long time
and a lot of brain power to figure out it took a lot longer than we thought we ever would have
budgeted when you look at the gown side by side i am really proud of how well we did with our
pattern matching we'll never know why this gown was cut on the straight the way that it was no
at this point in time when isabella was getting married it's 1785 and the stay shapes at that
point in time in history are very curvy they're very thrusty and so cutting a gown on the straight
at the front with that kind of thrusty shape to the stays is not a good idea it may have been
that the mantua maker was like oh nice selvedges don't mind if i do yeah but what happened is
exactly what we thought was going to happen which is those straight panels in a fabric that is not
stretchy cut on straight of grain produced a rumpled front yes and the lacing did not help
the situation either i think the lacing strips were solving one problem but then it caused another
yes when we fit the gown the first time doing the fronts to the backs we didn't have the lacing
strips put in we just had it pinned at center front and it looked great yeah nice and smooth
looked beautiful but the fabric is so heavy with all of this bulk around the waist that it pulled
the back of the gown bodice away from the body so they used the lacing strips to pull that in
yeah but that produced this extra going on at the front oh man that gown was heavy it was so heavy
once we got all the skirt on there i think the thing must have weighed like 20 pounds at least
at least 20 pounds this thing weighed a ton and it took more than one person to do a fitting on it
like so yeah so at one point there's footage that i'm trying to fit the front of the gown
and you're just i've got the skirt skirt when you put the skirt panels on to the back because
this is an english style pleated back down there's a weak point created when after you make the scary
cut very scary cut and then you've got like 10 pounds and 10 pounds of skirt pleated ready to
fit on the body and if you let that go it could just rip the entire skirt off the back of the
we replicated the back pleats exactly to the original dress but unfortunately what that meant
is that we were not going to be able to get the shoulder straps in the exact position
because our model had a different shoulder width than isabella originally did what we ended up
doing was we opted to match the original gown and then we dealt with the shoulder straps not
matching on the model it's sad that we had to do that because that is one of the most interesting
parts of the gown for me is how those pleats and the shoulder straps intersect but unfortunately
when it's a recreation and not a replica you have to make those difficult choices and we tried to
honor the way that the mantua maker would have solved that problem as well all told we had about
13 14 hours across two days to do this project which puts an extra challenge on top of an already
difficult project yeah from my previous experience working in a gown in the day
gown in a weekend kind of format i i had a really good understanding of what
points we had to hit at what time to be able to complete the gown unfortunately with challenges
that we could not have anticipated like pattern matching and the heat in that it was extraordinarily
hot because of the time with cutting out cutting out yeah and tentering and tentering we were
basically 30 minutes behind yeah everyone was sewing at speed but all told we did get the
gown done it was a real push at the end we did get the gown done and were able to dash across to
great friar's abbey and do the final photo shoot and yeah we did it what started off as a dream
for rebecca olds quickly became a mission not so impossible for her international team
together we were able to display historically accurate dress making techniques
as well as tell the story of isabella mctavish fraser's wedding gown and the women who made it
for her we hope you enjoyed coming along this journey with us as we recreated the
isabella mctavish fraser wedding gown and we hope you learned as much as we did in this recreation
process