Eyewitness to History: Holocaust Survivor Estelle Laughlin

Memory Quill
73 followers
6 Video Views·Oct 21, 2022
My name is Bill Benson. I have hosted the Museum's First Person program since it began
in 2000. Through these monthly conversations, we bring you firsthand accounts of survival of
the Holocaust. Each of our First Person guests serves as a volunteer at the Museum. We are
honored to have Holocaust survivor Estelle Laughlin share her individual personal account of the
Holocaust with us. Estelle, thank you so much for joining us today. We are just thrilled that
you are our First Person. You have so much to share with us, Estelle, so we'll get started.
Please tell us about your early life in Warsaw, Poland, to get us started.
I was born in Warsaw, Poland, to a happy middle-class family. My father was a jeweler.
His workshop was attached to our apartment, and he was always available to me. He taught
me to be reflective and kind. My mother was feisty, romantic, and very compassionate.
In spite of the fact that she was chased out from a shtetl in Belarus
during a pogrom, she still spoke about the Russian people as being a suffering people.
Although anti-Semitism, outbursts of anti-Semitism were common in Warsaw, Poland, still
Warsaw glows in my selective memory in golden radiance of lilac trees against open blue skies,
rich sounds of good neighbors, kindness and trust and love.
And Estelle, you had one sister, is that right?
Right. How could I have omitted that? She was a year and a half older than I was,
and she was my playmate and role model.
Frida. Estelle, 82 years ago today, on September 1st, 1939, the Second World War began when Nazi
Germany invaded Poland. You were just 10 years old at the time. Please tell us what changed
when the German army marched into Warsaw less than a month later, as we see here in this
Immediately, my life changed beyond recognition. My once peaceful streets were now patrolled by
foreign soldiers. They snapped whips in our homes and streets. They accused us of being greedy,
yet they walked into our homes like common thieves and helped themselves to whatever they wanted to.
They rationed all food, closed schools, and made books illegal. We had no electricity,
no transportation, no telephones, and we couldn't reach friends, even in an emergency.
Radios were confiscated and newspapers were stopped the same day. We lived in a state of
darkness cut off from the world and everything that was taking place there.
Estelle, please tell us when you were forced to wear a white armband with the blue Star of David,
and you remember that. Oh, absolutely. We had to wear an armband with a
Star of David, as though my religion were an insult. You've shared with me in the past that
children helped by keeping watch for German soldiers. They helped to hide contraband
and do other things. Will you say more about that? Yeah, miraculously and gratefully,
children remain children and play in the world of make-believe. But children are also very wise,
and they see right from wrong. In a time of war, children rise to the occasion.
So, we used to play in the courtyard or in the streets, but we were also extremely vigilant
to look out for a uniform. If we saw a Nazi uniform, we flew like a fury into the
building and warned everyone Nazis are coming. And not only that, we would run home and help
our parents hide contraband, such as white bread and books. And yes, children were extremely
vigilant, and children are extremely wise and resilient, and they rise to the occasions.
In October 1940, the Germans established a ghetto in Warsaw and moved all Jewish residents of Warsaw
and the surrounding towns into that ghetto, including your family. The 1.3 square mile
ghetto was now inhabited by more than 400,000 people and was enclosed and sealed off from the
rest of the city. Please tell us about your life in that ghetto. They built a thick wall around us
and filled the ghetto with people driven out, Jewish people driven out from the surrounding
area. Most came on foot, often without a penny in their pockets, and often without
shoes on their feet. The place was so crowded that approximately like 10 people per room
would average. And we had to pay for that wall too. And also, there was not enough food, there
was not enough shelter, so people died of cold and starvation and illness in the streets. People
covered the bodies of dead children with posters saying, our children must live, children are the
holiest things. Estelle, tell us about your father and his love of books. So, in this inferno,
some people sometimes asked me, and asked probably other survivors, why didn't you fight back? But
we did fight back. There was an immense moral resistance. So, to own a book was an act of
defiance. And my father, punishable by death, this was a capital crime. And yet, all over the ghetto,
people had secret libraries. My father had a stash of his favorite books by Yiddish authors,
by Sholem Aleichem, Sholem Asch, and Isaac Peretz, nice windows blinded with dark covers
to keep our existence secret. My father would pull out his books and read to us.
We had a flickering carbide light, we had no electricity. Our room felt like a capsule of
paradise, separating us from the deadly quiet outside our windows. Estelle, just to make sure
our audience heard you correctly, not only was owning a book an act of defiance, it also meant
risking one's life to have a book, which is incredible. Not only one's life, but the whole
family's. Or maybe even everyone in the building, and maybe even everyone in the street. The Nazis
were very good in keeping people in fear and life. They were demigods. They controlled our lives
completely. And despite that, you've shared with me that there was the ability among those of you
in the ghetto still to celebrate holidays and celebrate some form of culture. How did you
manage to do that? That was our form of resistance, our form of holding on to our humanity.
Guns hovering over our heads did not stop us from celebrating holidays. We pulled the window
shades down and we celebrated. We even had theaters. Imagine theaters when there was no bread.
There was a wonderful writer and historian in the ghetto, his name was Chaim Kaplan, and he said,
it is strange that when we don't seem to need it at all, we need poetry more than we need
bread. And it is true. I think that our ability to think for ourselves, our ability to create
is our godliness. Estelle, despite schools being formally closed, of course,
did you have the opportunity for any school learning? We didn't have an opportunity,
but we created the opportunity. The parents said children above all. Some parents,
you know, the food was rationed and very, very little food was really allowed. Yet some parents
traded their bread for tutors to teach their children. I remember my mother saying,
we went to, I'll describe the place where we went for our tutoring. I remember my mother saying to
my father, isn't that crazy? We don't know if we'll see another son, right? And you think of
sending them to risk their lives and our lives for tutoring. And my father said, I remember them
whispering that. And my father said that maybe the only childhood we'll be able to give them,
and we must risk. So down the street, there was a hidden little house behind tall hedges. And
this is where we ran every morning, hiding our books, whatever we had under our clothes,
knowing that if we would be caught, we would be shot and the people we loved would be killed.
So we ran into, to open that little fence door and walked into the small building and into the
room where our wonderful teacher, Pani Marysia, waited for us. The room was bare. There was not
a picture in the room. There was not a scrap of teaching materials, just a few children sitting
in front of the teeth of Pani Marysia. And she held her voice, embraced us, her enthusiasm,
everything about her is unforgettable to me. She had some records that played to us,
a few books that she had, she shared with us and made us see in our minds things that did not
exist there for us, yet she brought to life, to our imaginations, beauty and love and security.
The moments that we were there, we forgot about our misery. It was our little paradise.
And this school existed for maybe a year and a half. And I remember also, she found some seeds
and we planted outside. We found a little soil and we maybe took stalks of beans and how proud
we were to see the little sprouts. Yes.
You've mentioned that food was scarce. How did you manage to get food and otherwise survive
in those conditions? Right. So the food was rationed and
I think that we were allowed about one tenth of the minimum calorie daily requirements.
So you could not survive and a majority of the people, the street was strewn with corpses.
It was so ghoulish. I remember looking at them and saying, oh, I don't want to die that way.
I don't want my mother or father or my sister or my friends to die that way with nobody crying.
It was overwhelming. It was littered. In fact, there were carts that would go down the street
and collect the corpses. And yet we had books and yet we had cigarettes. That's how we held on.
And secret school, that's how we held on to our humanity and to meaning.
The Nazis started deporting large numbers of Jews out of the Warsaw ghetto to the Treblinka
Killing Center in July 1942. For a period of time, your family was able to avoid deportation.
Tell us how that was possible. How did you avoid that?
In July 1942, the month of my 13th birthday, things became even worse,
more horrid. This was the start of the Warsaw ghetto deportation. We had no idea that the
deportations meant death. Some people were forced to write false letters inviting families and
friends to places where they were fed and clad and sheltered. So, of course, some destitute
people went willingly and unknowingly to their death. But many hid. We lived in apartment
buildings. Where does one hide in an apartment building? We hid in cupboards. We hid in drawers,
in closets, behind chairs, between mattresses and back strings. My family and some other people
designated one room or selected one room and put a wardrobe in front of the door. And everyone
in our apartment building who lived in the same row of apartments obscured the same door not to
give away the secret. So, we hid behind in the secret room. While we were in hiding,
the deportations proceeded with 20th century know-how and stone age values. Between
mid-July 1942 and September, in less than two months, 99% of the children disappeared.
I was, my sister and I were among the 1% that survived. Can you imagine a world without the
sound of children? Without grandparents? Because old people and children were the first
to be killed. We never heard from the people who were wrenched from us. But a few managed
to come back under the cover of night and told us about the horrendous train ride
to a place called Treblinka where our people were guests. I cannot imagine how anyone who loves the
wives and children and mothers could do such a thing. This is why I am telling the story that
is so hard to listen to and so hard to talk about because it generates such pain. And I believe this
is why the audience is listening here today because we need to be reminded from time to time
that human beings are capable of great cruelty. And seeing that and recognizing that appreciates
so much more the value of life. The world is one family. If the dignity of any human being
is tarnished, all of humanity is diminished.
Estelle, as you said, the deportations began in July 1942. In less than two months, by September
of 1942, three quarters of the population, the Jewish population of Warsaw had been deported
from 400,000 down to about 100,000. But you fortunately, you and your sister and your
mother and father survived that. In 1943, you began to work in a German factory. Tell us about
going to work in the factory, how that was possible. You were what, 13 years of age at the time?
So as soon as the people that remained, by then there were very few people left in the ghetto.
As soon as the people, the surviving people in the Warsaw ghetto heard about Treblinka,
they began to organize themselves into armed resistance. My father was a member of the armed
resistance. The resistance fighters began to build bunkers in basements, and we moved from
our second floor apartment to the ground floor because we were the only people still alive in
our building. So it was no problem to find a place on the ground floor, and we too had a bunker.
The freedom, the resistance fighters dug tunnels for navigation between the bunkers and
also to get under the wall to the Christian side to get from the Polish people,
from the Polish underground arms. And they also used the sewers a great deal. There was a lot of
navigation using the sewers. Estelle, before we turn to the full fury of the Warsaw uprising,
you went to work in this factory. Tell us how that came about and what you were doing.
Right. Most of the people were deported. The buildings were empty. There were so few people.
If I would walk out from our courtyard to stick my head out to hear a familiar voice, all I could
hear was silence. The silence was palpable. So only a small group of people was allowed to
remain in three different streets. The rest of the ghetto was vacant. And the people,
only those people who were lucky enough to find employment in one of the German
factories was allowed to live. They were defined as useful. All the others were condemned to die.
They were useless. We called them the wild people, and there were quite a few among us
who were there. They were wild people, unofficial. My mother's sister and I had worked
in a factory mending Nazi uniforms. My father was also among the wild ones.
Right. And so they were busy getting ready for resistance if deportations would occur again.
Now it's April 1943 when German forces entered the ghetto to begin deporting the remaining
inhabitants. In response, Jewish resistance fighters fought back in what is known as the
ghetto uprising. So tell us about what happened to you and your family. You had the chance to
say a little bit about the work that was going on underground, literally, to prepare for the
resistance. What did this mean for you and your family, your mother, your father, your sister,
and you? Events erupted with Nazi columns marching into the ghetto with armored cars,
armored cars, and tanks, and bomber planes over above us. And we had a
bunker, as I mentioned. So we opened the trap door, the secret trap door, stepped down
the flimsy ladder into the bunker, pulled the trap door down. I felt banished.
This is not a photograph of your bunker, but tell us about this.
Well, the ceiling pressed down on me. The damp walls closed me in. The flickering of the
carbide light was our substitute for the sun. The ticking of the clock was our only clue when
morning was rising and night was setting. The few people who shared the bunker with us was my whole
nation. How I miss the open horizon, the blue crispness of day. And while we were in this
netherworld, fighting broke out in the streets, facing a 20th century army, armed from head to
toe, facing armored cars and tanks and bomber planes was a handful of poorly clad, poorly fed,
poorly armed freedom fighters. They climbed out from the tunnels, climbed up on rooftops in front
of open windows, in front of tanks and molotov cocktails and whatever else they had, very little
of course. It is noteworthy that it took that handful of freedom fighters longer to battle
than it took for Poland or for France to capitulate. Estelle, as you've described,
this poorly armed, poorly clad, poorly fed, as you said, group of resistance fighters held off
the German army for nearly a month. But eventually, of course, the Germans began to
accelerate their efforts and began to destroy the ghetto, literally building by building,
and eventually they got to your building. What happened to you? Well, at some point,
a grenade was thrown into our bunker and there was not a corner to hide anymore.
In an instant, a horde of barbarians were upon us and they chased us out into the street.
The ground beneath us trembled. The air thundered with detonations, flames, enormous
bomber planes, warplanes were dropping incendiary bombs, flames, enormous tons of flames
were licking the sky and painting it in otherworldly colors of iridescence.
And they marched as our lips were parched from thirst and dust and people in congealed blood
amazing how much suffering human beings can take and remain human and compassionate.
And they marched us to my to freight to the deportation station. Estelle, tell us about
your arrival at Majdanek and and what that meant. When we arrived at Majdanek, they separated women,
men, and children. There were very few children. The children were isolated in a barbed wire
area and they like they yammered mama that I was so afraid that because children under 14
were contraband and I was 13 that they would separate me from my mother and sister.
So the women were seated together on the ground waiting for orders. We expected the next order
would be to go to the showers and the men were sitting across in a group across across from the
women and there was a small space where the guards were marching back and forth and keeping us in
fear. My father wiggled his way to sit in the first row and locked eyes with us. His eyes,
I was so used to looking into his eyes for comfort and reassurance. They were so full of suffering
I could hardly bear it. When the guard wasn't looking, I dashed across that divide and knelt
in front of my father and I said, Tata, don't worry about me. They won't get me. I turned the
lapel of my jacket and showed them that we had cyanide stones in our lapels as a last resort
and I said, Tata, remember I have cyanide. He looked at me and he said, no, you must live,
and I lived. Still, that was the last time you saw your father. That was the last time I saw my
father, but he lives in me. The voice, his voice, he left in me. It's an eternal
voice of goodness and kindness and that too was a way of holding on to our humanity.
It's the faith that there is good and kind.
Estelle, if you don't mind, you had a photograph of your father after he was gone.
Tell us what happened to that photograph.
I had a photograph of my father. My father was extremely dear to me and so I hid the photograph.
The only thing I held on was between under the lining of my shoe where that little lining that
covers the sole of the shoe. So, I put it under that lining and so the soldier stopped me and he
said, what are you hiding? I said, I'm not hiding anything. He says, you're lying. I know
you're hiding something. So, I thought the picture is meaningless to him. I might as well tell him
that's all I have and I showed him the photograph. I said, yes, I have, all I have is a photograph
of my father. So, he snapped it away from me.
Just for the sheer act of the brutality of taking that from you. Estelle, with your father gone,
now it's you, your mother and your sister Frida and you were selected for forced labor.
Once that happened, what was the daily life like for you and your mother and your sister?
We worked from pre-dawn to late night. We worked in an ammunition factory.
We were starving. There was a small distinction between slave labor camps and extermination
camps. Majdanek was an extermination camp, which was purely a killing factor in the 20th century.
And a slave labor camp, the camp too, was enclosed by electrified barbed wire fences.
The electrified barbed wire fence was the end of our horizon, except there was not a crematorium,
but they worked us nearly to death. We didn't, we completely isolated. The camp was surrounded by
a vast no man's land, so we were completely isolated. It was impossible to imagine
that only a few rabbit hops away from us, people sailed on silver lakes and children sat around
dinner tables with families as children should. We had no idea if the allies were winning or losing.
So, the only thing that stands out in my mind, like a breath of air, was when we were marched
at gunpoint from the factory to the barracks was a patch of sky. The patch of sky was our only
contact with humanity, not really, but with freedom, light. Still, after you'd been in Majdanek for
three months, there was an incident with your sister, and tell us about that, how you were
able to stay together. The incident with my sister was kind of complicated, and I'll point
out that more of it is in the book that I wrote, Transcending Darkness. It was a very
interesting and horrid situation, but something led my sister to be placed on a list that was
made public, put on the wall. We were absolutely sure that everyone who was placed on the list
was designated for the guest chamber. My mother, sister, and I had a pact that if one of us is sent
to the guest chambers, we'll all go. So, the only logical thing for my mother and me to do
was to trade places with two other women who also were on the list and who hoped to see
another sunrise. So, the following day, when the next three names were called, there were more
people, but the three names, my sister and the two women's names that we traded place with,
were called, we reported. Absolutely sure, beyond any grain of doubt, that we were being
marched to the crematorium. Instead, they marched us to a train and they took us to
the camp in Skarzysko. What were the conditions like for you in Skarzysko?
We worked from early morning to late. In Majdanek, there was no, and I may have
not followed, or in Majdanek, we did slave work. We just dug up turf from one place
and replaced it in another place. Completely meaningless work. Sadistic, meaningless work.
In Skarzysko, as I pointed out, we worked in a ammunition factory from sunrise to sunset,
and as I described, there was also an electrified barbed wire fence and towers with
sentries who were marching with beams of light every step we went. And we slept
in barracks on one plank, maybe 20 or more women squished together like sardines.
We had no blankets, no mattresses. We were covered with lice. I don't believe,
I don't remember having a comb or a towel. Estelle, from Skarzysko, you were forced to
move again in the summer of 1944 to another labor camp at Czestochowa, and from there you would
end up being liberated in January 1945. Tell us about the night that you were liberated.
So, one night, a miracle happens. We hear a bombardment, and this was January 1945,
and from September 1945, 1939 to January 1945, we were so completely isolated
and had no idea whether allies are winning or losing. And then we hear that rumble of
detonations and heavy artillery, and every time the bombardment paused, we said,
oh, please don't stop. Dying by allied bombs would be such a dignified death. And that night,
we were liberated. Our euphoria and our fear and our helplessness, we were liberated by the
Russian army are indescribable. This was January 1945.
Bitterly cold. Bitterly cold, yep.
Yeah, Poland is very cold. The ground is covered with snow and ice. All we had on is a loose
caftan, no underwear, no stockings, no scarves, just a caftan and wooden clogs
covered with lice and mange, looking so dreadful. And we were so afraid. We wanted to run.
This was the front line. What if the Germans
come back? We wanted to run, but we just couldn't. We just shuffled out of the camp
and afraid. In fact, we thought maybe it's a ruse. We couldn't believe it.
The thought of this being a ruse was ridiculous, but we were so afraid to believe it.
And so we went through the, shuffled through the no man's land that encircled the camp.
And then we hear Russian voices. And we hear tanks and Russian voices. So we rushed to them
as though we see Messiah. And we said, oh, do you know how long we've been waiting for you?
Oh, with such gratitude. And they held up a hand and they said, sorry, we still have a war to fight.
And indeed they did. The war didn't stop, wasn't over till May. And they looked at their watches
and they told us that we, that it's still war and that there's the curfew is still in effect
and that we better find a place before nightfall. I don't know if I was more afraid of dying of
cold in the street than being arrested for breaking the curfew and being thrown into jail.
So we shuffled forward, no place to go, not a panic, not a home to return to. Warsaw was
completely destroyed. Homeless, penniless and stateless. And we shuffled like that and
nobody, and people look at us and they draw away from us. So nobody wanted to have anything to do
with the Jews from concentration camp. And yes, I'm sorry.
And Estelle, I know we're now going to have to, we're going to skip over so much more than
you endured with your mother and your sister, although fortunately we were able to stay
together following your liberation. The three of you together would make your way
in an incredible journey through Poland, Czechoslovakia and Germany. And eventually
were able to immigrate to the United States in 1947. These were your documents that you
came with to the United States. And we have one more after this one, just to show our audience.
Estelle, I have one more question for you in the time that we have left.
In the face of rising global antisemitism, please tell us why you continue to share
your firsthand account of what you experienced during the Holocaust, knowing how painful this is.
I am sharing my experiences with the hope that it will serve as a reminder
of the consequences to us and to humanity when we accommodate ourselves to tyrants,
how it corrupts the conscience of a nation, what it does to love, what it does to trust.
The purpose here is not to curse the darkness of the past, but to illuminate the future.
I would like to add that we survived with love for humanity and compassion and joy of life. Life
should be lived joyfully. Without that, survival would be hardly meaningful.
And I think everybody viewing today knows that you've just stated what you are, who you are,
and what an honor for us to have you with us today.
