Scanning Negatives

Tech Lover
46 followers
3 Video Views·Oct 21, 2022
Hey everybody, my name is Ted Forbes and welcome back to another episode of The Art of Photography.
We're going to do a couple episodes now on process. I want to take you through the process
of taking a negative and bringing it to life as a print. There's obviously two ways you
can do this. I want to explore both. I want to look at the differences in them. I think
this is something that I've hinted at and people have asked me about. I think it would
be really cool to cover both these processes. What we're going to do is two things. We're
going to do one tract, which is a darkroom print. What we're going to do is use the enlarger,
the mobile darkroom, all those things. We're going to enlarge these negatives. The other
process that I want to look at is the digital process. We're going to scan the negatives
and we're going to see what the differences are and compare the final results. What is
the difference of being able to bring an image into Photoshop and manipulate it or Lightroom
or whatever your software of choice is versus doing this the traditional way in the darkroom
as a print. We'll compare those and we'll talk about them some.
Just to give you a little hint of where we started on this, I've talked about this a
lot in the last two episodes. We did one on medium format and we did another one on
toning. In the toning episode, you saw that I used these little tiny prints. I will talk
about the idea behind these. Initially, what I wanted to do was do a series of botanicals
or flowers that were shot basically on a white background to create a sense of simplicity,
sense of minimalism, a sense of beauty, and really be able to play with the tonality that
comes out in the flower. Originally, the idea is that I was just going to do contact prints
and they would be these little tiny prints that I would work with. I would like to explore
the possibility of blowing these up and working with them and manipulating them and maybe
enhancing them somewhat. That's what we're going to be working with.
I shot these obviously on a white background. The process that went into these is literally
I did use a flash with an umbrella just to give it a nice diffuse look. I used my Hasselblad
camera on this. The reason was I wanted something where I could really control the exposure
well because I think it's important to retain some of the texture and some of the tonality
that you have within the flower against this white background. I also wanted the sharpness
that it gives you. Anyway, one of the things I did on here is I used a close-up filter.
The reason I used a close-up filter was not for a macro thing, but I just needed the flower
to fill more of the frame. I'm working with medium format, so if you don't have a way
to do that, it's not as big of an issue because you can enlarge bigger than you can with 35
mil, but that's what I went with on that. Now, the other thing I used, as I mentioned,
we used just a white sheet of artboard on the back. It's a non-reflective, but it's
a board that's stable, and so I put that behind the image, measured the exposure off
because I wanted that to go ahead and go white so that can blow out. Really, the important
part was the flower that I was shooting. I used a flash for this, and I used a sync cable
because this is rather old-school technology. Now, the reason I'm telling you this is I
made a pretty big mistake when I was shooting. There is a little switch on here for the flash
sync, and this is a very old lens that's on here. These older lenses offered two options
for flash syncing. One of them is still usable today with the modern technology that we have,
and the other was designed for older flashbulb types of things. With flashbulbs, because
they were so bright and rather unruly, the camera was basically designed to, when the
shutter went off, was just to delay just a little bit, to not get the intensity of the
light when it first came out, and to kind of operate off of once the bulb starts cooling
down and when the light goes down a little bit. Unfortunately, on this lens, the little
indicators of what setting you're on have pretty much rubbed off, and so I shot the
first roll of film on the wrong flash setting. So I was using this older flashbulb setting,
and my pictures came out too dark. Now, the reason I'm telling you this is, obviously,
you make the correction, shoot another roll of film, which I did, so the second one came
out correctly. But when I made a contact sheet of the first one, there was some pretty interesting
stuff that came up, and I think I have some images that are actually, they have a different
feel than what I intended them to be originally, but I think they're workable, and I want to
use those to try to get something out of it, and I'll show you those when we get to it.
And I think that's kind of cool, because what we can do is hopefully take a mistake and
turn it into something that was unintentional, but still interesting, based on a mistake
that I made, essentially. And so what we're going to do is, we're going to do two tracks
on this. We're going to deal with the analog side and the digital side, and what I want
to talk about today is, we're going to scan these into the computer, and I'm going to
show you my process on that, and then I'm also going to show you how to make the contact
sheet in the darkroom. And then what we'll do is, we're going to spread this out, so
the next couple shows, what we're going to do is explore both those tracks. So when you're
enlarging in the darkroom, what kinds of tools, what kinds of options do you have? And then
also on the computer side, what are your options? And we'll compare the prints when we're done.
So anyway, let's get started right now. So come on over to the computer, and let's talk
about scanning images. Okay, so any time you're dealing with negatives, and this holds true
whether you're on the enlarger or whether you're working digitally, is dust tends to
be, they're just kind of magnets for it. And so the first thing I do is, I get these just
dry dust wipes, and I will go ahead and clean everything I've got, even if it appears clean.
And the reason is, is because all it takes is one or two specks of dust, and then you
have to spend time cloning those out, or using a healing tool in Photoshop, or something
like that. So the first thing I will do is, clean both the carrier, and go ahead and open
up the scanner, and I will clean that out too. I will probably also hit it with some
air. You can buy cans of air, and just make sure all the dust is off. And you know, sometimes
it's not always easy to see. But it's, you know, like I said, you can clean them up later,
but it's just very time consuming. You'll still have to clean them up. Dust will inevitably
make its way on there. But that's the first thing I do before I start scanning. Okay,
so when everything's clean, it's really quite easy. What you're going to do is simply put
your film into the negative carrier, into the holder, and go ahead and put that on the
scanner. We're going to close the lid, and we're ready to go here. Okay, the scanner
that I'm using on this is actually an Epson 4870, which is not current by any stretch
of the imagination. There are better scanners you can get now. But I've noticed that even
for what I do, this is still good enough. It gets enough tonality, it's sharp enough.
It depends on what you're doing. Now we are talking about medium format film and up, and
I think for 35mm, it's a little bit different. I think you would notice a difference in the
quality of a scanner in that level. But you know, what it does is essentially the Epson
software, which is pretty crude as well, and we're just trying to get this good enough
to deal with. I typically turn off all the auto functions. I turn off sharpening. I want
to be able to do most of this in post. I just need a clean scan to start with, and I think
that's fairly important. So what we're going to do is I just scanned what was on the bed.
This makes a contact sheet, and we're simply going to draw a little box around here to
get our scan. And sometimes I go ahead and make these a little bit bigger than the image
and bring some of the black in as well. And you're going to notice on here, and depending
on what software, what scanner, all that you're using, the auto functions are usually pretty
bad on here. And it also depends on the quality of your negative. So the first thing I'm going
to do is I'm going to go ahead and bring up the levels here, and I'm going to go ahead
and play with these. Now what I want to do is I'm going to bring the highlights back
a little bit, or you can bring them up in this case. I want to bring the shadows back
because what it's looking for is black blacks, white whites, and for whatever reason, this
software just does a really weird, janky job of this. And so you'll notice too that
the scanner really picks up a lot of tonality here because I am getting some shadows back
here on this background. But I think this is probably just about where I want it. I
can manipulate those more when we get into Photoshop or Lightroom. And I'm going to go
ahead and close that, and I'm going to set the DPI on this. I'm going to scan it in grayscale.
And the DPI, I'm going to use 2400 on here. This will give me a big enough print to work
with what we're doing. Obviously, if you're going to go really, really, really big and
test the limits of the resolution, you would go higher. But I think 2400 dots per inch
is fine in this case. I'm going to go ahead and say scan. And we're going to put this
on the desktop. Let's save it. Rename it a little bit. And we'll save it as a TIFF file.
I'm going to say OK. And it's going to go ahead and work its magic. And we'll bring
that scan open as soon as it's done.
OK. So before we get cooking here on post-production, I want to talk a little bit about my philosophy.
Disclaimer right up front, this is my personal feeling and opinion. And it is not right for
everyone, I understand. And people like to work differently. But personally, the things
that make a photograph beautiful to me are the moment of the capture. We talk about the
decisive moment, especially when you're shooting people. In this case, it was flowers. But
what I was going for was something organic, something very pure, something very beautiful,
minimalist background. I wanted this organic S-shape in here. And I want the tones of this
lily to speak. And so generally speaking, I don't like to do a ton of post-production.
Post-production for me is not the time to whip out a paintbrush and wake up and be an
artist. It's the time to just come in and figure out what you need to do to enhance
this, to get it ready for print, basically, and what you want it to look like in the end.
So I did mention earlier that I did scan this a little bit flat. And I always do that because
it's easier just to add that back in post. And so what we will do is do that. And I'm
going to create a new adjustment layer over here on the Layers palette. Basic stuff. I'm
going to add a Curves layer. If you've never worked with a Curves layer before, basically
what this does is it affects the tones on the layers underneath. This is an adjustment
layer here. So when you open it up, you're given a histogram. And then you have this
diagonal line that runs the length of the histogram. Pretty easy to note that down here,
if I move this point, this is affecting the lows. So if I look at the shadows, they start
getting darker and darker. And this is kind of some interesting look going on in here,
although it gets really pixely and eventually goes to a silhouette. And then the same with
the highlights up here, where if I just move this point, of course you can move it anywhere
in this box. Keeping it on the top line, I'm moving it and I blow out my highlights until
it becomes a white image. So what you can do is you can add points by clicking in this
line. If I just click a line in the middle and drag, it adds a point. And it brings the
mid-tones down to where they're darker, or I can raise the mid-tones to where they're
brighter. So what I'm going to do here is I'm going to show you how to do what's called
an S-curve. And if I take this point, I'm going to make it the upper mids to highs.
I'm going to bring that up just a little bit. I'm going to add a second point by clicking
on this line. And we're going to drag that down. And so what you end up with, let's exaggerate
so you can see, something that looks like the letter S, basically. An S-curve is typically
what this is called. It adds contrast to the image. So I'm going to bring this down
at my low lows in there and kind of move this around and dial it in visually. And you can
start to see that I am, indeed, affecting the tonality of the lily in the middle because
this is where the large, vast majority of our gray tones are. It looks pretty good.
I like that. And if I click the layer on and off, you can see that we went from something
very flat to something that was high contrast. Consequently, you can do the opposite of an
S-curve or you can do reverse S-curve, and it makes things more flat. And I'll just simulate
that for you there. And look, we lost all the mid-tones. And it really is kind of dull
in there. So let's go back to the S-curve. And I feel really good about those being pretty
low and these being in the middle a little bit. And so we start to get a little bit of
life and a little bit of contrast going and really bringing out some of the tones inside
the lily here. The other thing I might do, just to make sure that when this prints, this
white background is white-white, I'm just going to bring my highs over just a little
bit to ensure that they're blown out. And do that. Didn't change the look too much.
And that's kind of what I was going for with this. You know, something that almost had
kind of a mechanical quality to it that you don't see in real life. I mean, that kind
of contrast, but that's what I wanted to get. Another thing you can do on this, let's zoom
in here. And I'm going to show you the technique I like to use for burning and dodging. And
it's really easy. You can use the burn and dodge tool. They're there. But let me show
you what I like to do. I used to like to use the paintbrush tool. I'm going to create a
new layer. We're simply going to grab the brush tool here. And so I can paint, right?
So if I start painting, it spray paints black across the middle of the image. Let's undo
that. What I'm going to do is on this layer, I'm going to create an adjustment, or we're
going to actually come in and knock this out. So we are going to change the way this layer
behaves from normal to soft light. Now watch what happens when I paint with the black.
Just watch in these mid-tones. What this starts doing is it starts affecting the darker areas.
But notice that it didn't bleed into the white. And it's not like, and I want to use an adjustment
layer like this, it's not like when I'm painting over the top. So what I'm effectively doing
is burning in some of these darker areas. If I switch over to the color white and paint,
you'll notice that I start affecting the lighter areas and the way the light hits it. Now,
let me undo some of those. It probably is best to do two different layers for this because
you'll want to be able to massage them on and off. But anyway, that is indeed how this
works. And if I turn that on and off, you can see that I really brought out probably
too intensely some of the shadows in here. The other thing you could do too is, let's
say that's just too intense, you can dial back the opacity on that somewhat too. So
I can just kind of sit somewhere in the middle and make it a very subtle effect. So anyway,
so here's our beginning image. And I just went from that to just bringing it out a little
bit. And that's what we're going for. So that's basically what I'm going to do on that first
image. Now the second image probably is going to require a little more finesse and a little
more work. And the reason is, the first thing I'm going to do is hit that curves layer.
But this white flower is a little dull. And I want to bring that out. And there's a couple
ways we can do that. So the first thing let's do is let's hit the curves layer. And let's
go ahead and bring up the highs a little bit. And we'll do the S curve once again. Actually,
that didn't look too bad. So we're bringing out some of that contrast. This is the same
S curve I had before. And I don't really care about the whites being perfectly white. I
don't want to blow them out too much. That's why I'm not doing auto on any of these. You
could also bring the shadows in to intensify them. And I really don't like that. So we
don't have any pure blacks. It's not the end of the world. That's a little bit better start
on this image. I think the second thing I might do is we could actually light this flower
in the middle. So I'm going to show you a little dirty trick that I use sometimes. Let's
create a selection around that white flower there. And what I'm going to do is create
a new layer. And we're going to do a solid fill of white there. Let's deselect it. Bear
with me here. I'm going to go to the blur tool. This is the same thing basically as
dodging for this. And we're going to have to remember this when we do the physical print.
Let's go to the blur and let's say Gaussian blur. I'm going to blur this out quite a bit
here. There we go. Big blur. Now what I'm going to do is change this layer behavior
from normal to soft light. And there we have a brighter flower. And I may bring that down
a little bit. So there's on and off and you can see that we did in fact brighten that
up. This would have been the equivalent of dodging or keeping light from hitting a print.
Other thing that's bothering me about this composition and this is my mistake is I used
a piece of art board for the white background and I somehow got this black shape down in
here. It doesn't completely bother me. I don't think it disturbs the image. It's just a little
on its own. So the other thing you might consider doing is something like this. Let's
go ahead and I'm going to grab the lasso tool and we're going to do something kind of free
form here. Bear with me here. We're going to kind of select the area in the middle here.
This would be the equivalent of just burning in these sides. Now what I'm going to do is
go up to the select menu and I'm going to inverse that selection. So it's going to be
opposite of what I actually selected. Now you can see it's these sides here. Let's create
another new layer and I'm going to color that in solid black and by hitting command
and delete. Let's deselect it. Let's blur that out as well. So let's go back to the
Gaussian blur. So now you can see that it's just starting to shadow that and then I will
change the layer behavior from normal to soft light once again. And then let's dial this
way back on the opacity. And you're going to start to see here that we are more or less
creating a vignette but it helps balance out this thing that I don't like down here.
So we'll remember that when we're actually working on this that we may end up doing some
boxing into the shadows. And this is better. It's not perfect. I may actually want to crop
to get some more of that out because it is an awfully heavy vignette but it doesn't bother
me too much. I think it kind of works. I might pull the opacity back just a little more.
But essentially what we're doing is framing that in a little further and not worrying
about this just being a distraction out there on its own. And at this point I'm starting
to feel better about this image. I might want to continue to tweak it just a little more.
But as you can see in both of these examples that I didn't do anything that was just heavy
Photoshop where I'm starting to paint all of a sudden or clone or change the composition.
And like I said this is a personal opinion. Other people think differently on this and
it's okay. It doesn't make anyone right or wrong. It's just my style personally is to
let the image speak for itself and breathe and just be beautiful on its own. Again we
will compare this with the darker print. I'm not sure just because this ended up being
experimental. I messed the roll of film up because I had a setting wrong on the camera.
But this other image is closer to what I had in mind. And you can see how much easier this
was to achieve too because I think I was working from you know having being ready to do specific
things to this image and I knew how to get it. And that's based on experience.
One final note on these that I want to share with you too is that in the next episode we're
going to be dealing with doing darkroom equivalents of these. And just so we have a point of
reference where we can compare a little bit and talk about them. I'm going to have these
printed and you can certainly do this on an inkjet printer if you want. I'm actually going
to show you how to do this. I'm going to use Adorama's service which is adoramapix.com.
They're actually a very great service and I've done stuff through them before and they
generally look really good. If you go to photo prints at the top I'm going to show you exactly
what it is I'm going to order here and I'm going to go ahead and order this. I'll have
those in the next episode. Down at the bottom there's prices. Here's Kodak professional
glossy Kodak professional luster and professional metallic. Metallic is a very special use kind
of deal and it's not it's it's outside the scope of this comparison that we're doing
here. Glossy personally I just don't care for. I don't like the light to reflect off
of the surface of the image. It doesn't do much for me. So I'm going to stick here with
professional luster. We're going to do just two 8x10 prints $1.49 each. That's pretty
reasonable. I think the prices are very reasonable on a lot of things. They have an FTP site
once you create your account you can upload your images and then select what you want
printed the quantity and all that. Just to let you know that's what I'm going to do.
If you have an inkjet print you obviously have more choices in paper. I've talked about
those in episodes past and that's the optimal way to go but I just want to let you know
for all intents and purposes that's what I will be doing with these. Now the other thing
I want to talk about real quick before we finish up here is I want to talk about prepping
these just a little bit for printing and what sizes dimensions because that becomes confusing
to people. What you want to do is make sure you understand the service that you're using
and what they will deal with or if you're using your own printer what it will deal with
in Adorama's case I know that there are RGB images in fact they are sRGB in the end. But
that's not something to worry about. I'm just going to save them full size as if I'm going
to the web with them and that's what they're going to be working with. The other thing
you want to be able to do is under image let's go to image size and we're going to
be dealing with image size now. So what you can see here is actually if I were just to
print this right now it is optimized to do a 2 inch by 2 inch image. It is optimized
to do a 2 inch by 2 inch image at 2400 pixels per inch because that was the size of the
negative that I scanned. So I'm going to change this around a little bit to get it to fit
onto an 8 by 10. Now obviously this is a square both of these are and so I just want
it it's going to be the shorter of the two dimensions on 8 by 10. It will sit in the
middle and I can trim it or frame it however I want. What I'm going to do is turn resample
image off and what I'm going to do is I'm going to change the resolution down to 300
and you can see right there that what happened is now I have a 17 by 18 inch image. It's
I can go pretty large with this scan is what I'm saying and just to give you a little note
here when you are printing generally speaking 300 is optimal 300 pixels per inch. You can
get away with 150 if you're using a high quality enough printer any less than that and it starts
to degrade and there are people who will argue with me on that and I would not go 150 I mean
go 600 if you can you want the maximum resolution just know that 150 is the lowest you can possibly
deal with. So if you're not able to get the right size out of this you need to actually
go in and resample or actually rescan your image. Don't resample it doesn't work. Rescan
the image at a higher pixel depth. Anyway so what I'm going to do here is for the width
and the height I'm going to change the largest one of these to let's just say 7.5 because
it's an 8 by 10 image but there will be a little bit of a border on that. My resolution
is coming out 725.733. Remember you have resample image off. Let's go ahead and say okay and
I'm done. I'm ready to save this out and get it ready for print. Anyway I'm going to go
ahead and print these and in the next episode we'll have those when they come back. Okay
so this has been part one in this series of process of taking an image and working with
it into getting a final print. We talked about the digital side of things and we've talked
briefly about contact sheets and how that works and what we're going to do in the next
show is we're going to dig a little deeper and we're going to hit the enlarger and we're
going to talk about what kinds of options you have in terms of burning and dodging and
working with a print. Now we have remember two prints that we're dealing with or two
negatives that we're dealing with. One of these is going to be fairly easy to work with because
it was shot correctly and how I intended. The other one was not so it'll be interesting
to see how difficult that becomes to actually get something that's usable in the final image.
So anyway I know I've referred back to a lot of older episodes here from time to time and
we will continue to do that because I don't want to bog down with talking about developing
film and working on a print. So I will keep links to other shows that we've done on these
so if you're interested in filling gaps in knowledge potentially on that you can check
them out. So you can find the show notes and all our previous episodes on our website which
is theartofphotography.tv and that's about it for today. We will see you next time. So
thank you once again for watching and catch you in the next show.
