Does NASA & SpaceX's Plan with Artemis Make Sense

Tech Level
93 followers
1 Video View·Oct 19, 2022
This video is supported by CuriosityStream.
Hey hey, Marcus House with you here. The journey to Mars. Over the past few decades,
there's been some fascinating proposals to define which method and what associated hardware crew
will use to make this trip. Although each mission profile is seemingly more feasible than the last,
all have been far too expensive and potentially dangerous to justify the risk. That is changing
With the release of NASA's Moon to Mars strategy, we finally have a proposal
that inches us ever closer. Of course, SpaceX's Starship is set to lower the cost of mass to
orbit by orders of magnitude, giving these proposals a real chance to be implemented.
In this video, we're going to take a look at what this path to Mars might look like
and how it could evolve. Okay, so let's start by focusing on our hopefully triumphant return
to the moon aboard SpaceX's Human Landing System Starship variant. This is to be the first crewed
flight destined for the moon's surface for over 50 years. There have only ever been 24 humans who
have been to the moon, with only 12 of them making it to the surface, and this was all between 1968
and 1972. As the moon is the closest world on which we can inhabit, it'll provide us with
invaluable experiences that will lay the groundwork and the infrastructure needed to further space
exploration out to Mars and beyond. We already have the data from those original Saturn V
launchers, the American Super Heavy Lift launch vehicle that was developed under NASA's Apollo
program, and with the new current surge of space commercialization spearheaded by SpaceX,
there is no doubt that the initial lunar return missions are already well within reach. But there
are some significant differences between the Apollo Saturn lunar rockets and the Starship
Super Heavy stack. It is important to understand these differences as the number of full orbital
launchers with Starship needed to make a single human landing system or HLS mission to the moon
occur makes the system look somewhat inefficient at first glance. But it is these extra refilling
launchers that are the main difference between launching disposable rockets versus launching
reusable ones, which is what is going to be required to sustain long-term space travel.
Now, if the intent was to create a handful of moon landings like those achieved during the
space race, well, then quite frankly, the complexity of a next generation moon mission
may look kind of daunting. However, there is one major point that needs to be stressed.
After an Apollo mission, NASA was left back at square one as they would always need to manufacture
another complete rocket for each flight. With SpaceX's Starship designed to be rapidly reusable,
once the first mission is over, all that is required is for Starship to refill with propellant
and off it goes to the next destination. Or at least that is the goal, right?
Now there is an old rocketry saying, getting to low earth orbit, or LEO, is getting halfway to
anywhere. That saying makes reference to the fact that by the time a spacecraft gets off the planet's
surface, accelerates through the atmosphere, achieves enough horizontal velocity to clear
the planet's curvature and achieve orbit, the velocity change experienced would already have
been more than would be needed to get to so many locations in the solar system from this point on.
Now just to be clear, you do sometimes need to use multiple time-consuming gravity assists from
various planets of the solar system to literally get to many places, so not ideal for most crewed
missions. But you get the idea though. Refilling in low earth orbit means that you can drastically
increase a mission's range. Now with that said, we'll need to take a look at the refilling depot
which has been shown in diagrams recently. Although we don't know a lot about it, we know
enough to speculate. Once a Starship gets to orbit with its payload, there is very little propellant
remaining. Now for individual missions to low earth orbit, that isn't a big problem as you
only need a tiny amount of delta-v to maneuver in orbit or to de-orbit entirely. Now for many
standard missions such as Starlink 2 delivery, SpaceX's groundbreaking satellite internet
constellation, there would typically be a little extra propellant left over as a safety margin.
Could this be transferred into a propellant depot before returning to earth? Regular Starlink
missions could over time be helping to top up this depot alongside dedicated Starship tanker
missions. These are vehicles sent purely for the purpose of delivering propellant for the depot
as its cargo. Now at first it sounds like a lot of extra steps right? But if you think about it,
it is the one thing that we have been missing this entire time. When we have a surplus amount
of propellant in low earth orbit, I believe our mentality will shift away from the current focus
of how many tankers it takes to fill the depot and instead focusing on what we can achieve with
all of this capability. Now as the propellant depots are anticipated to be larger than your
usual Starship, we can assume that there is more than enough commodities available here
to comfortably refill any other Starship variant able to rendezvous with it. So with a full depot
at the ready, you might think that we can launch crew in a Starship, have it refilled in low earth
orbit and then dock with the human landing system right? Well not quite. Crew rating certifies that
a spacecraft or launch vehicle is capable of safely transporting humans. Starship will initially
not be crew rated for launching and landing on earth so it will take time to go through the many
stages of evaluation. Not only for the Starship itself, but the booster as well. Because there
is a lack of an abort system, it means that crew rating may only occur once reliability is well
proven after many uncrewed flights. So as a result, the first HLS mission will require an interim
spacecraft and that is why we still need the Space Launch System with Orion on top. Now NASA
granted 2.9 billion dollars for the SpaceX Lunar Starship in April of 2021. This is currently the
selected vehicle to take astronauts from the gateway down to the lunar surface and then back
up to the gateway again. And they are looking to have this crew rated to this degree as early as
2023. Now it is pretty safe to assume that this date has slipped at this point, but it is
only going to be crew rated for 4 astronauts. Why is that? Well the initial launches will be
supported by the SLS and Orion and the number of astronauts is defined by Orion. So Orion will only
be carrying 4 astronauts to the moon during Artemis 3. Now although this SLS Orion system
is considered by many to be too late and too expensive, one could argue that the timing
couldn't be better as this system essentially comes out of the box crew rated. I mean let's
it, you would expect so at over 4 billion dollars a pop right? Anyway this means that while the
Starship is gaining credibility through successful Starlink satellite launches and filling orbital
depots, the only option for crew to interact with Starship in orbit will be with another spacecraft.
So now that I've covered some of the groundwork, let's take a closer look at NASA's plan for Artemis
3, our first crewed lunar landing in over 50 years. Now we'll take the SLS's wet dress rehearsal
delays here into account, but aside from this we'll optimistically assume that NASA's dates
will remain roughly as we see them currently. Now imagine if you will an exciting few years
of progress ahead. The year is 2026. The first two Artemis missions were a success
and have paved the way back to the moon by testing all of the primary architecture
and associated systems needed to ensure Artemis 3 is just as successful. Along with a handful of
pre-filled propellant depots already in orbit, this is the potential order of operations for a
round-trip mission. Firstly the Starship or HLS launches without crew on board, more than likely
from the Kennedy Space Center. Once in a low earth orbit it will rendezvous with a propellant depot
and refill. After undocking it awaits the time to perform the burn to launch out into a near
rectilinear halo orbit or NRHO around the moon. This magic orbit that we've been talking about
with NASA's Capstone mission. Once the HLS is in this stable orbit ready to go,
the Space Launch System launches with Orion on top containing our four crew members on board.
This will be the first mission destined for the moon in over half a century. Orion with the help
of the interim cryogenic propulsion stage burning for around 20 minutes will send the crew out to
the moon where it will dock with the HLS. Now it is worth mentioning here that the first couple of
modules for the Deep Space Gateway or DSG could have been launched in 2024. These are the powered
and propulsion element and the habitation and logistics outpost. If these are operational at
this time it would provide a habitat and research platform for the two crew that remain on Orion's
DSG complex. Based on this plan for the first crewed mission we would expect the process to
look something like this. HLS undocks from DSG with two crew on board and proceeds to land on
the moon. Now an important note here is that an existing HLS vehicle may already be on the lunar
surface left over from the HLS lander test. This would have been done in tandem with Artemis 2 and
this could carry not only extra provisions but also potentially provide a redundant return vehicle for
this mission or any following mission. I just think that is a neat little thing to consider.
So after this mission is complete the now globally recognized astronauts launch back off the moon
surface in the HLS and head back to return to Orion and the DSG. The crew of four now reunited
departs from DSG aboard Orion and performs a lunar departure burn and returns to earth.
Now let's just take stock here. An Apollo mission would be over at this point having discarded the
vast majority of all of the rocket but we now still have all of the super heavy boosters used
to get that master orbit standing by to launch again. We also have an Orion capsule to be
refurbished and reused again too. Then we also have a fully working HLS in lunar orbit. It's just
empty. Now could this be refilled with tankers which themselves were refilled in low earth orbit?
Well yes this is possible but it would be very very inefficient. In the short term it would
probably make more sense to keep the idle HLS here as an expansion module to the deep space gateway.
There's a lot of space in this beast. So what about the requirements for the spacesuits for this
mission? I'll jump into that problem and others in just a moment but real quick a massive thank you
to CuriosityStream for sponsoring this week's video and as you can see it just fits beautifully
with the topics that we discuss. We are talking loads today about the moon and how we could set
up the infrastructure for the first sustainable colonies. Well take this great documentary here
called the moon our gateway to the universe. There has been a lot of debate about whether we should
directly visit Mars or use the moon as a gateway. There is a load of good reasons to invest in the
moon first. It's a quick three-day journey and we can practice and invent the technology needed to
live off world. Last time we visited there was no internet. Computers were primitive and much
too heavy to put anything substantial on a vehicle like Apollo. In the coming years privately funded
companies along with the historic space agencies are going to change everything. It is a marvelous
eye-opening video for sure and there is just so much more here on CuriosityStream too. It could
be terrific documentaries from bodies of our solar system such as Mars, Saturn, Jupiter or Pluto or
maybe you would actually like to know a little more about how all of this came to be in the first
place. CuriosityStream's service covers a massive range of subjects and common interests from across
the globe so if you would like to help support me and you'd like to give it a try head to
curiositystream.com and with that you can sign up for access for under $15 for the entire year. Yep,
the entire year. That is just amazing. You'll find that link in the description below. Thank you
CuriosityStream. So what about the spacesuits? And I don't mean pressurized flight suits either.
I mean the bulkier ones used for spacewalks and moonwalks. The development of NASA's next
Generation X EMU spacesuit seems to have halted over the past few years but recently production
was awarded to Axiom Space and Collins Aerospace with the hope that these two companies will
provide spacesuits capable of traversing lunar and martian surfaces. Though it may seem odd that NASA
is having trouble recreating something that they initially created. Unlike the original Apollo
suits these need to be even more robust and will need to be tailored for a whole new set of use.
The most abused suits were those from Apollo 17. They were on the lunar surface for about 75 hours
and the astronauts spent just over 22 hours outside of the vehicle in their suits which,
believe it or not, was really pushing their usable lifespan. Now that seems unintuitive right? 22
hours is not long compared to the total time accumulated by the suits worn for the spacewalks
on the International Space Station as an example. On the lunar surface though there is a major
irritant in the form of the lunar dust that acts as a very aggressive abrasive. As Artemis 3's
mission is to start the setup of a moon colony it is the perfect time to field test these new
spacesuits. That's going to be really exciting so I can't wait to find out more information on the
new suits as it comes to light. But what else I find exciting is the technology that we need around
transportation. Cast your thoughts back to Apollo 15. The very first mission to include a rover. I
can't imagine a much more appropriate mission goal than to land on a new planet and just drive around
can you? That is human ingenuity right there. But when could we see the next generation of rovers?
Well let's continue jumping right ahead to the launch of Artemis 8. At this point the deep space
gateway has been fleshed right out with an additional habitat module, an airlock module,
and a robotic arm. It can now comfortably sustain crew for longer duration expeditions.
The Commercial Lunar Payload Services or CLPS experiments will by now be surrounding the lunar
landing zone with additional cargo. With growing confidence payloads are starting to include
in-situ resource utilization experiments to extract usable water from the lunar subsurface.
Now that can be used not only for consumption but can also be used to generate propellant
for test vehicles. If you are a fan of for all mankind like I am think of the lunar surface
access module which is essentially a reusable crewed lunar lander. This will be far down the
track but you can see the direction that we need to head. Traveling large distances on the moon
becomes simple when you can just refill, travel to orbit and back again, or just hop to another
base on the surface. In-situ resource utilization is absolutely key and what an incredible opportunity
to develop and test this technology. Along with these initial experiments we have building
materials being created from regolith all supported by a load of robotic reconnaissance
rovers. At this point the method to get crew to the moon will remain the same and it will still
only consist of four crew members. This time though we can afford to commit to a 30-day stay
on the lunar surface. Time spent here will almost exclusively I suspect be spent in the rover and
on board HLS. Their spacesuits I suspect will be used only during emergencies and crucial
maintenance tasks similar to what we see with the ISS today. Now the suits may also be required for
the crew to move from HLS to the rover and back again but the hope is that there will be a way
for the astronauts to transfer to the rover via a pressurized tunnel at this point. Further down
the timeline this will certainly be the case. Now here is what we are not so sure of though.
How will HLS be refilled? This is where the question of sustainability comes in.
Sending a brand new spacecraft for every mission is not ideal and even using Raptor vacuum engines
to ferry propellants to the deep space gateway is very inefficient. I wonder if at this point
we could be at a stage where ion engines can be used as the depot's main engines. This would allow
a feasible way of resupplying transfer vehicles such as HLS in lunar orbit. It would of course
still involve a lot of launches in the supply chain to fulfill the propellant requirement
and it would also add extra complexity with the use of a third propellant source for the
ion engines. The thing is though such propulsion is around 10 to 12 times more efficient than
chemical engines so even if it takes a long time to move the vehicle this would provide a level of
sustainability we've never seen in space before. Now the energy requirements of this of course I
could do an entire video about so I do realize we are talking about technology here that doesn't
really exist yet. Now let me know if you would like me to do a video about
such high efficiency options and their requirements I think that that would be a
fun one to dive into and hey remember to subscribe and perhaps even join the mailing
list so you don't miss out on these midweek videos that fall out of my typical published
time on Saturdays. So many people tell me that they've missed these ones so yes that helps us
reach you much easier thank you. Okay so at this stage we now have that sustainability factor right
well we are getting there but we are still throwing away the space launch system every time.
Starship must be able to launch humans to really accelerate our progress so from this point it
becomes more and more essential for Starship to receive a crew rating. Once these steps are
achieved we hit that pivotal moment where our lunar presence becomes a viable route to Mars.
So if our aim is to colonize Mars you may ask why invest so heavily in the moon missions and
infrastructure. Well Mars may seem more like Earth than the moon but as far as our survivability is
concerned there is actually not that much difference. The moon missions coming first has
a few big benefits. The moon is only three days away. Mars at least six months or so. The simple
fact is that the moon is a much safer target to aim for while developing the needed technology.
In the event of any problems the crew can return home in just days. Just think about Apollo 13. If
such an event happened on the way to Mars the outcome would be obvious. We aim instead now
to colonize both. So taking this path is a way to have our cake and eat it too. From my perspective
I'd rather see loads of missions building upon each other than one colossal Mars mission using
much less tested technology. I personally think the direction that NASA is planning here is a good
one albeit a little slow. So how do we then transition to that epoch-defining event? The
first human missions to Mars. Let's fast forward again to the year 2033. A small permanent habitat
now exists on the moon and the crew of Artemis 12 is now currently down on the surface conducting
their exploration mission. The technology is now well vetted after a very busy set of moon missions.
The location for the first Mars base has now been selected and the main pre-supplies containing
supporting hardware for the first crewed Mars landing is about to arrive on Mars. NASA is
sending Boeing-produced landing pods and separate ascent vehicles intended to be the primary method
to shuttle crew to and from the surface of the red planet. Various uncrewed Starships at this
point have already made their way to the surface of Mars too providing an extended base of operations
and providing redundant launch systems. The only thing yet to be prepared is the vehicle that will
now shuttle the crew from Earth to Mars. Now personally I am hopeful that Starship will be in
a position to fulfill this role but it seems that we are spoiled for choice as NASA now has a
proposal of their own. They plan to launch a Mars transit habitat integrated with a hybrid propulsion
stage to form a deep space transportation system. An exclusive platform dedicated to ferrying crew
through space. A very similar idea to the Hermes spacecraft in the Martian but much much smaller.
That thing was just stupidly massive for cinematic purposes. So whether the plan ends up being a
short or a long stay Martian mission the only change really involves taking different trajectories
to achieve the desired short or long term stay mission. But aside from this the overall mission
plan remains the same. Once arriving on Mars the crew will explore its surface largely from within
the environmentally controlled rovers. The astronauts will have much of the same equipment
used on the moon including those same spacesuits and robotic tools. All of the preparation coupled
with the actual tasks of going to the moon and studying its surface has been a very good dress
rehearsal for the first Mars mission and no matter how this plan evolves after enough lunar
experience we will be ready. Ready to take the most dangerous and challenging journey ever attempted.
So yes that's the current proposal and much of this information comes of course from NASA's
Moon to Mars objectives released just weeks ago in May. Now there is a lot of information just
glossed over in this video in regards to the rocket science involved and I'm also working on
future episodes to come that will expand on all of this. So thanks a heap for supporting what I do
here as a subscriber or even direct supporters and also for watching all the way through this video.
I'll of course be back on Saturday with the next video covering all of the great stuff going on
right now. So grateful to all of you amazing patrons and YouTube members right here. You
blow my mind every week. If you would like to help support the Patreon link is right here. The
merch link is also below if you would like to pick up some new gear like this Mars here we come shirt
and all of the stuff that goes with it. If you enjoyed this video here are some other deeper dive
ones if you haven't seen them. They aren't part of the news cycle so these continue to be very
relevant. Thanks again for watching and I'll see you all in the next video.
