The Great Persian Army That Vanished The Lost Army Of King Cambyses Odyssey

History on Edge
51 followers
67 Video Views·Oct 18, 2022
The Great Persian Army That Vanished The Lost Army Of King Cambyses Odyssey
Six centuries before Christ,
the inhabitants of the Egyptian oasis of Siwa
looked out at the Sahara and held their breaths.
At the heart of the oasis
was one of the most powerful propaganda weapons
of the ancient world, the Oracle of Amon.
Just days away was a mighty Persian army
on a mission to destroy it.
The army never arrived.
Engulfed by a sandstorm,
they were said to have been lost without trace.
But is it just legend or terrible truth?
Geologist Tom Bowne dreams of solving the mystery
of the fate of the army and has a startling new theory.
Well, you told me that you found human souls.
Archaeologist Gail MacKinnon
hopes to find warriors entombed in the sand.
And desert guide Walid Ramadan
is the man they'll depend on to keep them alive
amidst the dangers of Egypt's great sand sea.
Generations of adventurers have unsuccessfully
scoured the desert for the remains of the lost army.
Amongst them, Count Laszlo Almaschi,
the model for the so-called English patient.
But this expedition has a dramatic new discovery
to investigate.
Published in a Cairo newspaper,
this photograph of ancient arrowheads
has reignited the hunt for the lost army,
suggesting that legend might, after all, be fact.
People were struck by the find in the tomb of King Tut.
He was one king.
Can you imagine five or 10,000 soldiers?
Bronze armor, weapons, skulls, skeletons,
possibly chariots.
Everything you can think of.
It's a huge treasure if you can think of it that way.
It would be the archeological find
of not the end of the century,
but of several centuries.
In 539 BC, Cyrus, King of Persia, defeated Babylon,
founding the largest empire the world had ever seen.
When his son Cambyses went on to conquer Egypt in 525 BC,
he sent an army to attack a small oasis.
The rest is history, or a tall story.
The Greek writer Herodotus was the most famous historian
of the ancient world.
A single paragraph he wrote reads like fiction,
but may be the only evidence
for the hideous fate of Cambyses' army.
Cambyses detached a body of 50,000 men
with orders to attack the Ammonians,
reduce them to slavery, and burn the oracle.
The force started from Thebes
and may be traced as far as the town of Oasis,
seven days' journey across the sand.
General report has it that when the army had left Oasis
and in their march across the desert
had reached a point about midway,
a southerly wind of extreme violence
drove the sand in heaps over them
as they were taking their midday meal,
so that they disappeared forever.
I think if Cambyses' army were to be found in the desert,
I think it would spell the end
of one of the longstanding mysteries in ancient history,
what happened to Cambyses' army
is Herodotus' account really true.
Tom Barne has been obsessed
with the mystery of Cambyses' lost army for decades.
He's one of many whose imagination has been fired
by the lurid tale told by Herodotus.
Novelists have borrowed the plot.
Adventurers have used the history as inspiration.
Laszlo Almaschi, the explorer immortalized
as the English patient,
spent years searching the Egyptian desert
for the lost army.
Just before he died in 1951,
he told a friend he was on the verge of finding it.
He said that he had a pretty good idea
of where it might be.
And he also said that he had found certain artifacts.
He never actually indicated on the map to any of us
where exactly he thought this might be.
He was very, very willing to talk about it,
but not very willing to tell us exactly where to look.
If Almaschi did find the lost army,
he took the secret of its location to his grave.
Half a century on, a Cairo newspaper
reported a sensational discovery in the Western desert.
The paper said that the army of King Cambyses
had been found at last by a geologist, Dr. Ali Barakat.
To archaeologists, the claim was highly controversial,
but in the coffee shops of Cairo, they spoke of little else.
So this is an arrowhead, is there?
Yeah, I think it's an arrowhead.
The expedition's guide, Walid Ramadan,
translates the article for archaeologist Gail MacKinnon.
Who is this guy here?
That's Dr. Ali Barakat.
He was the boss of this expedition.
So he actually took these photographs that we're seeing
and identified this area on the map?
Yeah.
Okay.
What do you think about this story?
Do you really believe it?
I believe what I see by my own eyes.
So you're not quite sure?
We have to go and see.
Going to see will mean a dangerous journey
deep into the Sahara.
The dry sands of the desert can preserve bodies
and relics for thousands of years,
so it's perfectly possible that the shifting sands
could have revealed Kambisi's army.
Tom and Gail's expedition will not be the first
to try to reach the remote site
where Dr. Ali Barakat made his discoveries.
Egypt's Supreme Council of Antiquities,
despite being publicly skeptical about a geologist's claims,
sent archaeologists into the desert to investigate.
Dr. Barakat was not invited to join them.
Before long, the archaeologist vehicles
became irredeemably bogged down.
Dr. Barakat's site remained tantalizingly out of reach
and the mystery unresolved.
A fellow geologist, Tom Baum has worked with Ali before.
He has faith in his judgment
and is convinced his claims should be followed up.
So Tom, what's Ali's background?
Is he an archaeologist or a historian?
No, he's a geologist, but he's very widely read.
So to him, I can imagine him thinking that
peace coming up with what appears to be weaponry
and bodies in this area where other people have looked
and other people have thought might be the hiding place
for the residue of Kambisi's army,
then I think his views are sincere.
I think that he believes that he has found
part of a lost army.
It makes sense in this area,
he's talking about it could be one of the areas.
Exactly.
It's all very interesting.
It'll be wonderful to see Ali's photographs
and hear his story.
Yeah, I'm still imbued with a little skepticism
about the whole thing, quite frankly.
I'm not really sure what to think about it.
The team visit Dr. Barakat at his inner city home in Cairo
to hear the full story of his discovery.
Ali, the finds that you've made are truly remarkable,
there's no question, and looks like arrow points,
possibly a spear point, a dagger,
and lots and lots of human bones.
Gail, what does that look like to you,
a lance pointer, a knife, a blade?
I can't see it too well from here.
It looks like the socket of a spearhead,
but I can't read, there's no scale,
so I don't really know.
Were there a lot of bones when you got out?
Yes.
After we find this, we found many bones on the ground.
Do you think that the whole army is out there,
or do you believe that you found some of the army?
It turns out Ali's finds were made by chance
on a brief geological field trip.
There wasn't time for a full search of the area.
He's confident another expedition will confirm
that the lost army really has been found at last.
And probably from here we may find the whole army,
probably from this area.
300 miles up the Nile from Cairo was ancient Thebes.
It was from here that Cambyses launched his desert campaign
after his conquest of Egypt in 525 BC.
Unfortunately, Dr. Barakat is unable
to join the expedition.
Much of the western desert of Egypt
is a restricted military zone,
and he's not been granted a permit
to revisit the site of his discoveries.
But he has provided Tom and Gail with his photographs
and told them exactly where to look.
On the western bank of the Nile,
the team's vehicles, drivers, and supplies are waiting.
This is the backup, and this is the one who will drive.
Hossam is the cook.
He's the most important man here.
Exactly.
The journey to the edge of the desert
traces a caravan route that would have been old
when the Persians marched down it
2,500 years ago.
The Persian army was generally composed
of a whole number of different ethnic contingents.
The later accounts of the Persian invasion of Greece
say that all the peoples of Asia were represented.
So it would have been a very dazzling, exciting sight
if you were not on the wrong side of it.
The Persian army, from descriptions we have
in other contexts, tended not to travel light.
The Persian expedition to Greece had a huge baggage train.
They even brought concubines with them
as well as camel trains full of provisions.
It was said in that case that the Persians
drank all the rivers in Greece dry.
Kambysis had angered the Egyptian priests
by his overthrow of the pharaoh.
And as his army set off on the long
and dangerous journey to Siwa,
they may have faced not just
the vast waterless expanse of the Western Desert,
but also the wrath of the Oracle of Siwa.
The priests were immensely powerful in Egypt, you see.
If you got on the wrong side of the priests,
you were in trouble.
And of course, many of the oracles
said what the priests wanted them to say.
And it is possible that the Oracle of Siwa
predicted doom for this interloper, doom and death.
Kambysis' troops thought they'd left
the Nile Valley on a routine mission.
They knew that hundreds of miles
of terrifyingly waterless desert
lay between them and their goal,
was that they wouldn't be coming back.
To follow in the footsteps of King Kambysis' lost army,
the expedition must first visit Kaga,
which the historian Herodotus called Oasis.
It was the last place where he said they were seen alive.
The force which was sent against the Ammonians
started from Thebes and may be traced
as far as the town of Oasis,
seven days' journey across the sand.
The approach is still dominated by a mudbrick fortress
that was already ancient when the Persian invaders
appeared out of the desert.
Well, the fort was certainly here in Persian times,
so therefore it was quite likely that it was garrisoned.
So perhaps the first thing that the Persians had to do
was they burst into Kaga Oasis, was reduce this fort.
It's certainly a commanding view of the entire Oasis
and a commanding position.
Herodotus states that the army took a week
to cover the 130 miles from the Nile Valley to Kaga.
If they managed to keep up this rate of 18 miles a day
on foot, without any shade, in blistering temperatures,
it would have taken them more than three weeks
to cross the desert to Siwa.
And that's assuming they marched in a dead straight line.
In fact, Tom is sure that the need to find water
would have made the journey even longer.
So the Persians started here in Luxor
and crossed 130 miles of open desert
to get here to Kaga Oasis.
And their general track, regardless of how they went,
was to the northwest.
Siwa would be clear off the map way up here,
405 miles away.
So what they would do, almost certainly,
would be to go to the last water before the open desert.
And the last water before the open desert
in any direction that they would take from here
would be Ain Amur.
The tiny Oasis of Ain Amur is an easy drive away.
But for the Persian foot soldiers,
the slog through the unforgiving desert
would have been a taste of things to come.
When they started out, they might have been fairly cocky
because they had a force that they knew
would be able to overthrow any tiny Oasis village,
of which they must have captured hundreds
in the establishment of the Persian empire.
And so this would be nothing more than a raid
or a routine mission for them.
But they had no idea what they were up against
and what they were going to face.
The western desert of Egypt is dry,
even by the standards of the Sahara.
In summer, temperatures can soar above 50 degrees centigrade.
This is no place to be far from home.
After three days on the march,
the Persians would have been exhausted.
I'm sure that even between Cargo Oasis and this point,
the water was already being rationed.
They're beginning to realize that water is running out.
A few palm trees and a hole with some water in it.
It must have looked very, very good
to thirsty soldiers having marched
the 80 kilometers from Cargo.
If the Persian army did stop at Ayn Amur,
there's every chance they'd have left something behind.
We've collected a number of pottery sherds
laying around on the surface
of the landscape around the Oasis.
And these represent different types of cooking pots,
water jars, carrying vessels for food,
stone in some cases, painted pottery, glazed pottery.
And these represent different periods
from the pharaonic really through to contemporary times
to modern day.
It's very hard to say if they stayed here.
I mean, they may have just watered,
not even camped overnight, or if they did,
you'd probably need to excavate this area
to be able to tell for sure.
Tom has worked out the logistics of the army's stay here.
To be a viable source of water for such a large force,
I believe that the spring must have been larger
to really attract them,
unless they were prepared to stay here for several days
and make the best use of the water supply they could,
fill everything up to the outset,
give everyone a good rest,
let everybody tank up on water
before the march started again.
If they did stop at this watering hole,
it may well have been the last water
that the Persians saw at all.
From Ayn Amur onwards,
all food and water has to be transported.
For the Persians, this must have been a huge burden.
The logistics make it virtually certain
that Kambaisi's army could not have been as vast
as Herodotus said.
50,000 is a great many people to take on
what in effect was desert travel
from one oasis to another,
because apart from watering the soldiers,
you've got to water all the pack animals as well.
With decades of experience in the desert,
Tom Barne has calculated
that a minimum of 3,000 tons of food and water
would have been needed for 50,000 men
to survive the march to Siwa.
As with most such figures that we get in ancient sources,
we have to be fairly skeptical.
It's often said that one should take off at zero or two
before one actually gets to the accurate figure.
And that's particularly true of Persian armies,
which are always exaggerated in terms of their size.
It's said in other cases that millions of men
took part in Persian expeditions.
The army was probably at the most 5,000 strong.
Tom Barne has a new theory
which has the soldiers running out of luck and water
in a place where no one has looked before.
He believes the Persians' lack of understanding
of the local geography led them far to the south
of their intended destination,
directly into the Great Sand Sea.
I suspect that the Persian army setting out into the desert
would not really have known what was there.
They were at the far extreme of their empire here.
They didn't have a very developed sense of space,
didn't have three-dimensional maps.
And I think they probably would have had little idea
of what they were finding at the other end.
The Great Sand Sea stretches over 100,000 square miles
with dunes up to 500 feet high.
It's one of the least known
and most treacherous places on Earth.
One of the few to have experienced it
is oil prospector Mike Rundell.
It's like being in a raging ocean.
There is no way out.
There's no civilization.
There's absolutely no way to go.
And if you're stuck, you don't survive.
It's as simple as that.
You can survive for two days or three days
and then you don't.
That's it, you're finished.
Gerhard Rolfs in 1874 was the first Western explorer
to survive the journey through the dune field.
By the 1930s, motor cars were making
the first tentative forays into the Great Sand Sea.
The most celebrated of the explorers
was the real English patient, Count Laszlo Almaschi.
He went through the Great Sand Sea,
I think three or four times.
And he knew the Libyan desert and the Sahara,
parts of the Sahara and the Egyptian desert.
I mean, probably better than anybody.
The Arabs, they called him the father of the sands.
Many of the driving techniques
still used by desert drivers today
were pioneered by Almaschi,
such as reducing tire pressure
to increase traction in the soft sand.
In the flat corridors between the dunes,
high speeds could be achieved.
But crossing the soft sand of the dunes themselves
created huge problems for even the most expert drivers.
In the 1930s, Rupert Harding Newman was one of them.
I'm one appalling occasion in 35,
when we got into a belt of dunes,
it took us all day to do 10 miles.
You got to be careful that you don't deliver the top
before you know what the other side is like,
because you could have got into a sort of
sand pit of loose sand,
which you wouldn't have got the car out of.
But going down, you want to keep a car very straight.
And then just as you get near the bottom,
you accelerate and with luck, get out.
Tom and Gail are beginning to realize
the expedition is going to be even tougher
than they imagined.
But hard as it is in four wheel drives,
on foot, the 400 mile journey to Siwa
must have been a nightmare for the Persians.
Could Cambyses really have risked losing an army
just to attack a small oasis and its oracle?
It seems a crazy decision.
Cambyses has the reputation in Herodotus' account
of not only being a stereotypical tyrant,
but also being drunk and mad.
He even tells a story,
which I think we have to take with a pinch of salt,
which is that the Persians, when they're making decisions,
have to think something is a good idea
both when they're drunk and when they're sober.
I suppose in the Greeks' eyes,
you could say that Cambyses' attack on Siwa
was a decision that he only thought was a good idea
when he was drunk.
Perhaps he ought to wait until the morning.
Whatever Cambyses' reasoning,
he sent his men to their deaths.
The early explorers gave the name
The Church of the Spirits of the Lost Persian Army
to this rock.
When the wind blew,
the explorers fancied they heard it keen a lament,
bemoaning the folly of sending out men
into the land of the dead.
As they retreat further and further from water,
I'm sure that the will of the men was beginning to break.
What were once men who would march and step and fife
and play drums and sing and talk,
after a few days, they'd be muted
and they'd realize the grim circumstance.
No more jollity.
And they're going also into an area
that's reputed to be full of ghosts.
As the Persians headed west into the unknown
and a certain death,
the scribes of conquered Egypt invoked the gods
in all their elemental power.
Open are the double doors of the horizon.
Unlocked are its bolts.
Clouds darken the sky.
The stars rain down.
The constellations stagger.
The bones of the hellhounds tremble.
This is the place that King Cambyses' army never reached,
the lovely oasis of Siwa.
Where they thought it should be,
they found instead an ocean of sand.
According to Tom Barne,
the Persians had got their geography wrong.
When they set out on this expedition,
they'd been in Egypt maybe a year
and they were probably unfamiliar
with the country geographically.
This is what got them into trouble
because any map that they would try to follow
would lead them to disaster.
Tom believes the Persians' inability
to calculate longitude was their undoing.
The modern map has Siwa far to the northwest of Karga Oasis
on a bearing of 310 degrees.
But in Cambyses' time,
Siwa was thought to be on the much more southerly bearing
of 289 degrees.
Slap bang in the middle, in fact,
of the great sand sea.
The team has picked up Salah Zidan, a Bedouin guide,
to help them find their way through the dunes.
The seemingly gentle landscape, he warns,
can change in an instant once a sandstorm begins to blow.
His advice is to camp in the sheltering lee
of a rocky outcrop or butte.
We're in this area here,
which is an area of alternating longitudinal dunes.
Tom has worked out a plan
for searching his chosen area for the remains of the army.
The 289-degree bearing coming up from Karga Oasis
enters the dunes right here at this point,
or enters the sand sea right here at this point.
And if the Persians actually made it to this point
and believe they should continue on
a little bit further along that bearing,
that would put them in this quadrangle.
And this quadrangle is sort of a natural cul-de-sac.
It would draw them deeper and deeper into the sand sea
without them really knowing it.
How do you intend to do it, Tom?
I mean, how do you see us systematically doing it?
is to roar down the dune corridors
and do essentially what is butte hopping,
go from butte to butte, circle the butte,
looking for pottery remains
or other alachlanous fragments that people have brought in.
And whenever we find something,
get out and take a look at them.
I don't think that the army died in one big plop
in one area with just piles of bodies
and everything that was left.
What we're more likely to find than anything
in the time that we have
are places that they stopped en route
where they camped briefly.
Wally, we want to circle those buttes over there.
It is beautiful, isn't it?
Isolated hills.
Tom is sure that Kambaisi's army,
like the team themselves,
would have camped or rested in the shelter of the buttes.
You always want to know where you've come from
and where you're going.
This is something to me that's very human.
And so buttes would be a natural place
to hole up for your morning drink of water
or your campsite at night.
Not only because they offer shade
and shelter from the wind,
but also because there's something more homey
about a butte than there is about some barren flap
that's radiating heat waves.
One of the things Tom hopes to find
are the remains of water jars
that Kambaisi's soldiers would have carried.
I imagine most of their water was carried in gerbas,
which are water skins.
They would also have a tremendous amount
of crockery with them.
And if any of this was used for carrying water,
it would be discarded as the water was exhausted.
In the 1930s,
Almaschi hoped that this pile of ancient water jars
found beside a butte
would prove that Kambaisi's army passed this way.
But analysis of them proved inconclusive.
One of the fascinating things about desert
is that when something is dropped,
it just stays there forever
because life, A, it's very dry.
There's no one particularly to pick it up
and carry it away
because the first person who went there
is probably, you're probably the second person
since he was there.
And things just are frozen in time.
In the vastness of the Western desert,
even huge objects can lie undiscovered for years
despite intensive searches.
The US bomber, the Lady Be Good, crashed here in 1943.
It took 15 years to find her.
When search parties eventually arrived,
they found the wreck remarkably well preserved.
So too, many miles away were the bodies of the crew.
They died with their boots on, just like the Persians.
Perhaps one of the most frightening things
regarding the forced march on foot
for the common soldier would be that
they never knew where they were going.
They never knew how far it was to their objective.
And that must be very frightening.
Well, as they're starting to run out of water,
they're becoming more and more apprehensive.
The apprehension turning to alarm,
that turning to fear and finally panic.
You can picture extreme cases of what might happen.
Men might be slaughtered
so that people would drink their blood
or cut open their bladders and drink their urine.
Anything to get any moisture as the end comes.
Madness would take over.
Urine might help them for a while,
but the blood would be deadly because it's so saline.
I can easily imagine this happening.
With the army already weakened by thirst,
the great sandstorm described by Herodotus
could have been the last straw.
When the men had left Oasis
and in their march across the desert
had reached a point about midway,
a southerly wind of extreme violence
drove the sand in heaps over
as they were taking their midday meal
so that they disappeared forever.
In ancient times,
cataclysmic weather was seen as the work of the gods.
The Oracle of Siwa was reputed to house a sacred stone
which when touched by the priests
would unleash a sandstorm against its enemies.
Prime amongst them, the army of King Cambyses.
Cambyses is notorious for his supposed acts of sacrilege,
his violence against temples in Egypt.
And that is seen in the sources very clearly.
As being a pattern of crime that has to be punished.
And I think the sandstorm is being implicitly seen
as divine retribution.
Attacks on the Oracle get met with this kind of response.
If you've never been in the desert in the sandstorm,
it's very difficult to imagine what it's like.
You can't see, you can't breathe,
and there's a hell of a wind.
And you know that if you stay still,
you will be buried.
In a very, very short space of time.
You're being sandblasted.
If you look what sandblasting does to a bridge
and paintwork, it does that to you
and your face and your eyes.
And you can't really breathe.
You feel you're being drowned.
And if you lie down, the sand piles up against you.
And if a sandstorm goes on as it can do
for two or three days, you're dead and buried.
I mean, it's a very, very quick,
not particularly pleasant way to go.
I think it's perfectly possible
that an army could be wiped out by a sandstorm.
Comparative material suggests
that these are fairly terrifying events
and it gets to a great temperature in the desert
in those kinds of circumstances
with the south wind blowing.
So it's by no means impossible.
Once covered by sand, it's possible for bodies
to survive well-preserved for centuries,
indeed millennia.
This is the perfect environment for preservation
of organic and inorganic material,
merely because it's so hot and dry.
The body, for example, the drain of fluid fairly rapidly
and become naturally mummified.
If we happen to find the army or part of the army,
there could very well be preservation of bodies.
In the 1930s, Rupert Harding Newman's expedition
uncovered a well-preserved skeleton.
Not evidence of Cambyses' army, it turned out,
but the even more ancient body of a woman,
perhaps 5,000 years old.
So it had left excavated.
She had ostrich-shell necklace on her wrists
and on her ankles and on her tummy she had a complete belt.
We eventually found she'd had eight and a half pound weight
of ostrich-shell beads on her.
After a day and a half of fruitless search,
Tom and Gail stumble upon their first bones.
It's a camel.
He's saying it's around more than 100 years.
More than 200 years.
200 years?
From 100 to 200 years.
How could he know that?
From experience.
How long do you think it is?
Well, it's very difficult to tell how long it's been out here.
Depends on the weather conditions
and the environment at the time.
Yeah, but he's used for seeing such things
from different areas.
Yeah, but he might be used to seeing such things,
but you can't say it's one or 200 years old
because it's older than he is.
I just don't think that you can look at the bones
and say, give a chronological age,
merely because it does depend on the weather.
So let's drive to the front, maybe find the rider.
Okay, let's do that.
It's funny, sometimes you go long stretches
without finding any bones or anything.
Even geologists, which I am,
go long stretches without finding any fossils.
But, and then sometimes you have a bonus of them.
And who knows, on walking back to the car,
we might spy something.
You can never tell.
A full search of even this small part
of the Great Sand Sea would take months.
Running low on time,
and with only a dead camel to show for their efforts,
the team retreat to the nearest oasis.
For the time being,
Tom's search area is keeping its secrets.
The team turned their thoughts to the move north
towards the hidden valley where Dr. Barakat
uncovered the arrowheads, daggers, and human bones,
which he thinks are the remains of Kambisi's army.
I'm not sure about Ali's location.
I've got no idea what to expect.
The photographs we saw in Cairo
were very tantalizing, I think.
Just the word I would use.
It's actually something tangible,
something that has been found.
Whatever he's found, it's of interest.
It may be an Islamic cemetery from the Middle Ages.
It may be a garrison of Roman soldiers,
or it may be a remnant of the Persian army.
There's just no way to tell
until we're actually at the spot.
If Dr. Barakat really has found the army,
then it seems the Persians
didn't get their geography wrong after all.
The place where they perished
would show that they were on the right route to Siwa,
but poignantly died just short of safety.
Dr. Barakat's discovery places Kambisi's warriors
amongst almost impassable dunes.
Even today, only the most powerful vehicles
stand a chance of penetrating them.
The Egyptian archaeological expedition failed to get through.
Tom and Gail may be the first to find the extra evidence
that could prove Dr. Barakat's sensational claims.
Cracks, gullies.
We're headed straight in the direction
that's supposed to be 370 meters ahead of us.
It should be just right over this hill, 160.
That's a short nine iron.
There it is.
Yep, this is it.
This is it, this is the very same place.
Yep, yep.
That looks like his photograph, doesn't it?
It looks very much like his photograph.
Right on it.
Tom and Gail must compare the landscape
with the photographs given them by Dr. Barakat
in order to locate the exact spot of his discoveries.
Now, this is the place, all right.
There's a huge boss of rock there
that sticks out, sort of an eye in the middle of it.
Ali Barakat probably took his photograph
from almost exactly where I'm standing.
He specifically pointed out this undercutting ledge
as a place where they found a great amount of material.
And he described it to me as millions of bones
that he thought were all of animal origin
until he started finding human skulls.
Instead of mounds of human skulls, however,
the team finds an ancient pot.
Gail is intrigued by the discovery,
but there's not much to go on.
And there's a small piece of black paint here,
remnants of a design on the side.
But the pot is not distinctive enough
to be dated on the spot.
So we still have our work cut out for us,
but it is interesting that we found something
in Ali's area fairly rapidly.
Clearly, somebody was here with a pot
either full of something or emptied of something.
Wind is beginning to pick up.
Salah is anxious that a storm is brewing.
There's only just time for Gail to identify
where the arrowheads were found.
Yeah, there are the stones there in the first grasp.
See the size of the hole,
by the size of the metal detector.
The arrowhead's obviously not here anymore.
And I believe that it's gone off to Cairo, hasn't it?
All the objects in the first grasp.
So essentially that's their first pit.
There are only animal bones to be seen.
There's no sign of the piles of human bones and skulls
as described by Dr. Barakat.
So do you think a sandstorm's coming, Tom?
Look at the horizon.
No.
Okay.
As the wind increases in intensity,
the team heads back to the relative safety of the campsite.
It was near here in 1935 that Laslo Al-Mashi,
the real English patient,
nearly died of thirst when trapped by a sandstorm
that raged for eight days and nights.
Hello, this is for Ali Barakat.
Ali Barakat?
Yeah, Ali Barakat.
Tom is anxious to call Dr. Barakat.
As his claim that he found human bones is now in doubt.
Hello, Ali?
This is Tom.
How are you?
I'm fine, thank you.
We're in the middle of a sandstorm.
Yeah.
You told me that you found human skulls.
Yes.
Where did they come from?
To the northwest of the first site.
Of the first site?
Look for the higher area.
You will find bones, great, great number of bones.
Great numbers of bones.
As night falls and conditions deteriorate,
the team speculates whether it was a storm like this
that did for the army.
I'm not sure that 5,000 men
could be completely covered in sand.
I'm still not convinced of it.
I don't believe your word.
I believe that they come to this area perhaps
and they're hit by a very violent sandstorm.
God knows how many of them were left.
I can see a sandstorm of that magnitude
on exhausted men who are dying of thirst,
breaking them up into groups, disorienting them,
and eventually not burying them all in a huge sandstorm.
No, that's too apocalyptic,
but certainly playing a major role in the destruction of them.
I still want to go back to Ali's site.
Oh, I do too, tomorrow morning.
Yeah.
By morning, the sandstorm has blown itself out.
They return to the site of Ali's discoveries
with his new directions.
They locate some bones straight away, and they are human.
Well, I've got two fragments of two long bones,
the thigh bone and a bone of the lower leg, essentially,
along with a piece of occipital over there,
and there's a piece of the jaw bone.
So essentially, this body is not in situ.
I don't think it's a burial.
Could it be someone who crawled under here and died here?
No, I don't believe it to be that,
merely because I'm just too suspicious
of the runoff here from the upper area.
Gail believes the bones have merely been washed down
under the ledge from a burial above.
But Tom is not convinced.
I'm kind of a romantic.
I'd like to believe that this is a Persian soldier,
some poor soul who crawled under here
to get his last bit of shade before expiring.
The team splits up to look for the great numbers
of human bones described by Dr. Barakat.
Tom is quite keen for it to be a soldier
from the Persian army, but it could possibly be a Bedouin.
It could possibly be modern.
No bone out here that is identified as human
is necessarily the Persian army.
On a last look round,
Tom has made a new and exciting discovery.
It's like another piece of skull, a couple of pieces.
It's obviously been out here a long time
because you can see the surface of the skull
is starting to erode and crack and weather away.
Oh, Tom, we've got another one over here.
Further fragments of bone and skull are scattered all around.
It's not an army, but it might be a group of stragglers.
We've got skull scatter here over the hill
and there's stuff under the rock cut ledge.
So it doesn't make any sense to me at the moment.
Gail still doubts
whether the discoveries have much significance,
but Tom is far more confident
that their finds vindicate Dr. Barakat
and that this is the last resting place
of King Kambisi's army.
If indeed we have found some tiny remnant of that army,
and that is proven,
I think it would be a phenomenally interesting contribution
to ancient history.
I think if evidence were found
that confirmed Herodotus' story,
it would be one extra little brick in the wall
to prove that he was in fact quite reliable
and that his sources weren't just any old hearsay.
One extra little brick in the wall
to support Herodotus' credibility
and his reputation as the father of history.
The weapons, which could be the first concrete evidence
that the tale of Kambisi's lost army is true,
are now in Cairo.
Apparently, Dr. Barakat handed them over
for expert scrutiny
at the headquarters of Egypt's Supreme Council of Antiquities.
Ever since then, official silence has reigned.
To try to find out what's going on,
Tom and Gail head to the Ministry of Culture.
The minister's archaeological advisor
says the finds must be somewhere in the system,
but his first reaction is to be doubtful
about their significance.
This looks like a knife or a dagger,
and this looks like an arrowhead.
Okay, they could be from the army of Kambisi,
they could be from any army,
beginning from the most ancient,
from the Bronze Ages, if you like,
until, let's say, 300, 300, 400 years ago.
So you cannot really judge,
judge these things without having the context.
Regardless of their lack of context,
it would be possible for someone
who is an expert in Persian weaponry
to look at the objects and determine
whether or not they are of Persian origin.
They might be 100% Persian,
but even though I find they are Persian,
I still have no question marks.
How did they come?
What are they a part of?
What's the context they were found?
There's so many questions you can ask,
and I'm afraid the answers will be just mere conjecture.
The British Museum in London
houses a world-famous collection
of ancient Persian weaponry.
As a result, perhaps nobody is in a better position
to assess Dr. Barakat's discoveries
than curator Dr. John Curtis.
He examines the photograph of the dagger first.
It's in rather bad condition, I'm afraid.
It's heavily corroded.
I think it is possible that it could be
a short sword of Persian date.
To really be conclusive about this,
I'd need to actually have the piece in my hands
and be able to examine it.
Now, these bronze arrowheads are extremely interesting.
They're of a type that we call three-winged,
and arrowheads like this actually are very common
in the Persian period,
and indeed, they were probably standard issue
to the Persian army.
I've got some examples here,
absolutely the type that we would expect
the army of Khambaises to be using,
and they're exactly the same as the ones in the photograph.
Is one of the greatest mysteries of the ancient world,
which has inspired generations of desert explorers
on the verge of being solved at last.
We have the most promising new leads
to come about in a century
in terms of looking for the lost army,
and I think that Ali's find
should definitely be followed up on.
Somebody needs to mount an expedition,
go back to the sites, do some excavations.
There is something there.
